- Joined
- Oct 12, 2020
- Messages
- 1,388
That's an interesting way to interpret this. 12VHPWR has been around for 1 gen. So in 2 years you have 4% failure. 6-pin and later, 8-pin started what....20 years ago? Not a great rate in 2 years of usage for 12VHPWR. Hardly the same thing and not great looking for 2 years of 12VHPWR vs 20 years of 6-pin and 8-pin PCI-E.Here, let me tl;dr as easily as I can.
View attachment 684244
Still a nothing burger. The same as it was when it was finally discovered that the one thing in common was user error.
Now I will agree with others that this is simply a self-reporting poll, so hardly a real firm scientific statistic. But still.
Also at a certain point a design that makes it too easy to have "user error" is the fault of the design if enough users have issues. As also reported in the video, plenty of the card designs made if incredibly difficult to fully seat the cable within say a recessed plug in the cooler, or other things where verifying it was in all the way was not easy to do. And personally I'd say if you are plugging a cable in and still have to question if its in all the way even though it feels like it is and is even "clicked in" then that's a fault of the design. Now are there genuine user errors of people not using the cable correctly? Absolutely, I won't claim there isn't. Just saying I don't understand the argument it can only be one or the other. It's probably both. A better retention design would eliminate a lot of this "user error".
Last edited: