I'd certainly believe it could simply be bad board but my friend must be quite unlucky as he's RMA'd the board once already. he'll probably try to RMA it one more time before just eating it and buying a different board.
If you take a look around these forums, I'm not the first one to have a few issues, in fact there's a 13 page thread on the subject.
And I'm not so concerned about troubleshooting this board, just lookin for alternate board recommendations
He flashed bios to 1007, the new tester PSU was an Antec 550 SLI, the original was PC Power & Cooling Turbo Cool 510 SLI, the OS was Windows XP Pro, but we were having reboot issues outside the OS (I had it flip off on me while browsing bios menus).
Edit: We've flashed to the 1009, no better.
Posting for my friend who's been through hell with his new rig. Its an Asus a8n-SLI Premium with 2x 6800GTs, a X2 4800+ Toledo, and 4gb of Corsair XMS PC3200? He's getting spontaneous reboots or BSODs whenever you tax the system at all, and sometimes they even happen in posting phases, before we...