Well to be completely honest I don't know the XClio, especially because I'm not american, so I've never seen that brand before, so sorry for my mistake! :)
@OP
I love the MX518, definitely go for it!
Personally I'm not a huge fan of the G15, I've had it for a month and I didn't like it all...
This is what I would change:
Get a good PSU, it's worth it to spend a few extra bucks for quality when it comes to PSUs. Thermaltake is a goo bang for the buck in my opinion, at $60 AR
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16817153028
why would get such expensive RAM...
This is not HOT, but it's definitely a decent deal, especially for those who don't like rebates and want a good budget DDR2 800 kit.
http://www.newegg.com/product/product.asp?item=N82E16820231098
Now that I think about it I agree that he should not take the Asus board. A $100 board that reaches 350FSB will be more than enough for him for at least 1-2 years (9x350 = 3.15Ghz).
However I stand against the 8800GTS.
The 7900gs is definitely not as good, but it's still a very good card...
Because the E4300 has a 9x multi and 800Mhz FSB! If you get any crappy board that can reach 300mhz, you can easily have it up to 9x300 = 2.7Ghz!
Well as you could see it was only on a few benchmarks, so maybe those specif tests took more advantage of the conroe's bigger cache. Anyway it was...
I think you get more value for your money going for an E4300, or at least waiting for the E6420. I wouldn't buy the E6400 right now.
Mobo- I would go with the Asus P5N-E SLI, it's cheaper, showed good performance on many reviews and supports SLI/quad core
Ram- There are cheaper options...
Well if you're buying NOW, the E4300 is stil better because even though the CPU difference is only $10, you can save $100 or so buying cheaper ram and a cheaper mobo, but still getting an excelent performance
I can't understand why he would go for the Gigabyte instead of the Asus.
The Asus is SLI compatible, even if you never use it;
The Asus supports quad core CPUs
The Asus is only $7 more expensive!
Also, I think that the E4300 is a smarter buy, because of the 9x multi, meaning that he...