I don't think this game is trash but I think it failed to make it's core audience happy because of how it was managed. I would say the first signs of a problem was when GTA 5 had it's DLC cancelled in order to make more money from the online community. This clearly went against the principles that the Houser brothers had back in the 90's that founded Rockstar's foundation. The second sign was when Dan Houser, Lazlo and many of the development team walked on the company. Leslie B was also kicked out shortly after. The third sign was that Rockstar failed to show what the game was actually about leading up to it's release. The fourth sign was when all media gave it a perfect 10 score. There are a bunch of different types of people with different expectations and it's a red flag when they all give a game a perfect 10. Even more strange was that mainstream media was trying to fan the flames of hype instead of the usual moral outrage towards the game. Even the feminists were strangely quiet leading up to the game launch. This only happens when people were paid off or threatened to be black listed. The fifth and final sign was the social media reaction after having played the game.

I think the game engine is great, the graphics are great, the soundtrack is awesome, the animations are solid. On the other hand, the gameplay regarding combat is outdated, the gameplay was dumbed down to the point of it being on permanent story mode, the game's humor was less edgy, and the soul of the game was altered from being an apathetic, power hungry swamp of free form chaos into that of a mature TV crime drama with cringy socialite archetypes that dominate modern mainstream media.

My opinion is that the development team was hired based on sexist and racist hiring practices which led to a much more diverse team that made a game for a much more diverse audience. If the Houser's had stuck with their original principles and made the game for the core audience then this wouldn't have happened.

That being said, this development team didn't go out of it's way to troll the core audience leading up to release. The game didn't have intentionally uglified characters, it didn't force the gamer to roleplay a homo sexual nor did it market the game at an imaginary audience. For these reasons, I don't hate the game I just think it failed to be as good as it could have been. I think it disappointed a large part of the core audience because of how watered down it is and all of the non traditional, tame elements that naturally stem from the development team who were not there to make a frat boy fantasy game like the previous games were. When half of your development team is comprised of adult women, you are not going to get a game like GTA 5. This is common sense. They should only hire people that are best for the job and that means focusing on your core audience and who can best serve them. This means the team should not be diverse nor should it be shamed for not being so. It's ok to make products aimed at specific demographics.

The final question is, will a new audience replace the core audience that Rockstar sold out? The pre orders mean that this game is successful but I could see the next game losing money if they spend 10 years and billions of dollars producing a product that has half the pre orders that this one did. It really comes down to weather or not Rockstar gained more fans than it lost with this outing. The pre order success of GTA 6 just means that fans of the series had faith in Rockstar based on their previous games and that their faith was misplaced.
 
Last edited:
I tried GTA 5 on my PC. First ever playing anything GTA, and I wasn't real happy with it. Not sure I am going to continue playing.
It doesn’t hold up well IMO outside of the story/characters. Although I’d still enjoy the shit out of it of if I never played it before.
 
IMO it’s the worst GTA game I’ve ever played. It’s an impressive game outside that though, and I think that’s the issue.

I truly don’t understand the 10/10 reviews. It’s a very high rating I think for the technical reasons, the absolutely massive handcrafted map that will take months for a player to go fully explore, the interaction with the environment, etc. It’s also remarkably polished at release and bug free
I'm pretty sure all games journalists are scared to death to give it anything less than a perfect score, far beyond the usual shill mentality. Rockstar probably has the pull to get them fired, instead of only cutting them off.
for what has to be the most complex game ever made.
I'm curious what makes it more complex than say GTA V?
 
30fps is a literatally dumb (htf do you spell dumbing????) down of society. sub 30 because it's so progressive if you will...

*horse with blinders
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure all games journalists are scared to death to give it anything less than a perfect score, far beyond the usual shill mentality. Rockstar probably has the pull to get them fired, instead of only cutting them off.

I'm curious what makes it more complex than say GTA V?
GTA5s map is basically the size of just the urban area of 6, and 5 generally was far less dense and basically just has clear areas dropped for each major location. 6 is not only huge, but feels like a real area. There are way more interactions and things to do in 6 as well. You really have to play the game to appreciate what they’re doing here at a technical level. Nothing comes close, not cyberpunk, or anything else. For me it feels as big of a deal as to when I first played GTA3 or Skyrim, and it’s far more impressive than GTA5 when it released since GTA5 really wasn’t a huge leap over GTA4 in all reality.

It will be very, very difficult playing open world games after this game as I don’t see anyone putting anything out like this for some years that isn’t just AI slop.

But again, all of that is unfortunately let down by a poor GTA single player story mission experience which is unfortunate. This is why it’s very clear the game was made for GTA online, and they have an impressive framework that will last a long time here for it.
 
That's a good point regarding GTA online. This game world is very well built and will work well for an online playing field, unrivaled by others. While it may be disappointing for core players of the single player campaign, it's understandable that Rockstar had to make sacrifices in order to ensure their own survival given the current corruption spreading from the World Economic Forum. It's obvious that Rockstar's investment in the online version of GTA was successful and that is probably the current focus going forward for the studio's survival. Watering down the controversial edges of the IP and pushing a new, addictive form of online entertainment that doesn't require anything but the most neutral position in order to prioritize maximum mass market penetration, seems to be the goal.

As an old school GTA fan, I find the single player campaign is still a decent game on it's own but probably not worth the current asking price. It certainly isn't the Rockstar of old and I find it less satisfying than Cyberpunk 2077. I'm not an online multiplayer type of gamer so it's a step down for me but I can't say I'm shocked by their current direction and I can still find things to enjoy in the base game.
 
Last edited:
I can't remember the last time I played a game without a difficulty setting. Trying to make a one-size-fits-all approach for all gamers today seems impossible. Especially with the popularity of Soulslike games, a lot of people today want borderline impossible difficulty.
there are settings to make it easier if you want. it's under gameplay/accessibility. You can have enemies with less health and you take less damage. you can also make it easier to hotwire cars.
 
So... is this game woke? Did they go broke?

I'll likely pick up this game like I did GTA V, when it's out on Steam for cheap, or even free. It's just my usual policy, I don't buy games at launch. Who wants to pay to playtest bugs? From videos I've been watching, it does look nice. Hopefully it can go at least 60FPS when it launches on PC.
 
So... is this game woke? Did they go broke?

I'll likely pick up this game like I did GTA V, when it's out on Steam for cheap, or even free. It's just my usual policy, I don't buy games at launch. Who wants to pay to playtest bugs? From videos I've been watching, it does look nice. Hopefully it can go at least 60FPS when it launches on PC.
it’s woke, but they already made $3.8+ Billion
 
It's obvious that Rockstar's investment in the online version of GTA was successful and that is probably the current focus going forward for the studio's survival. Watering down the controversial edges of the IP and pushing a new, addictive form of online entertainment that doesn't require anything but the most neutral position in order to prioritize maximum mass market penetration, seems to be the goal.
GTA online makes good money: https://en.gamegpu.com/news/igry/dokhody-gta-online-za-vse-gody-prevysili-5-milliardov-dollarov

If you look at it like they're going to try to make something more like an MMO out of it a lot of the stupid stuff makes sense. Lots of MMOs have idle clicker mini-games, like mining or farming. Those aren't there because people really think they're fun. They're there to give your fingers something to do while you're hanging out talking to your friends.

Same goes for discouraging crime, especially violent crime. If you're running an MMO you really don't want all your players constantly trying to kill each other. You might even want to get rid of the ones that are just there to look for PvP action. MMOs are inherently social, and it's the social aspect that keeps people coming back year after year. Get a bunch of players running around just trying to kill everyone they can and they'll chase off a lot of noobs. Griefers are expensive. Every noob they chase off reduces revenue. In a GTA MMO you'd want players forming gangs and working together on heists, etc. And sure occasionally have a beef or turf war with another gang and get in a fight. A GTA MMO wouldn't be right without PvP, but PvP shouldn't be the focus either. It should be about players teaming up for "profitable criminal activity".

Also seems like they're trying to make it more female friendly. I get that from an economic perspective. When I was a kid video games were for boys. I'm 50. That was the 80s. Now there are a ton of women gamers. Not just girl gamers, women. And my 73yo father still plays games. He plays more than I do! Go figure, he's retired and has more time. OG GTA back in the '90s was sold to a boys club. Not anymore. A game that's only attractive to guys is almost "niche".

At least they didn't totally puss out on the edgy stuff. Like I hear there's a nudist resort in the game full of naked retirees & you can go to a strip club. And no, haven't played it. PC or bust.
 
Unfortunately, I agree with you. It's just the way these things go when you reach the top. Big props to Dan Houser and the crew who had the integrity to leave before it went off the cliff. Hopefully some new dev teams will make real GTA style games in the future while Rockstar does it's thing with it's GTA IP online. Cyberpunk is proof that other game developers are capable of making large open world cities with their own style and gameplay to propel gaming into the future.

I do think this type of thinking has put most AAA game developers out of business so it's not going to be common in the future but Rockstar might have reached the WOW level of MMO style success that many game developers chase and never achieve.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like a lot of reports on crimson desert in terms of the size of the world and graphics and interactivity but less depth on quests and characters?
 
My guess: They probably never will. Now that the cat is out of the bag, sales will go flat. Just like TLOU2.

I don't think it will go anywhere near as flat as TLOUS2, simply because GTA is so much bigger. Though it is likely it will sell less than GTA5. GTA4 sold less than San Andreas as well, so that is not out of the realm of possibilities even if it was a better game.

Though we'd probably need to wait a bit longer to get a better picture. Game is 80-100 hours long, I think most people who have played it are barely 20 hours in at this point. A lot of gamers aren't reviewing it yet, good or bad because they barely started it.

On the other hand, the gameplay regarding combat is outdated..

To be fair, GTA4 and 5 were quite ancient in terms of the combat. They straight up play like something from the late 90s to early 2000s. I was expecting this to be similar.
 
Last edited:
GTA 4 had the lock on system and GTA 5 added the red dead redemption focus option. I agree that they were both dated but this one does nothing and the game is not challenging either. Niko was a good character but I'm not a huge fan of GTA characters in general so this wasn't a big let down for me in that regard. I think both 5 and 6 would benefit greatly from added depth to the robberies and heist type missions. The gameplay is paper thin with no real options. 6 is especially bad with fetch quests. Honestly, I thought GTA 4 was pretty good because it added Euphoria physics, it had great driving, a good character and the phone was actually used to hang out with people and do things between missions more naturally. It felt like a afterthought after GTA 4 though. GTA 4 also was a big upgrade to graphics and it didn't take 13 years, it also didn't have online stuff that I don't care about.

I honestly don't mind the sim options in GTA 6. They were fine in San Andreas as well but I understand they are not for everyone.
 
Last edited:
Nice insult that some people who don't like the game can't afford it. Absolutely laughable. I used to have little money and tons of time, now with a job and family I have lots of money and little time.

Even if these 33,000 people actually did buy the game, every single one of them posted their ‘score’ so quickly as to make it clear they spent hardly any time playing the game.

You’re defending people who are review bombing a game that they clearly haven’t played and you’re upset that I’m ‘making fun of them’.

I’m not making fun of them. They’re doing that to themselves.

Also, if it wasn’t clear already that most people posting at this forum just despise gaming, period - then it is now.
 
Even if these 33,000 people actually did buy the game, every single one of them posted their ‘score’ so quickly as to make it clear they spent hardly any time playing the game.
I'm sure every 10 of 10 review is honest and legitimate, only "incel review bombers" ever do false reviews.

No one has ever thought of deceptive advertising till now.
 
I have noticed people saying that people giving the game bad reviews haven't played past the first 2 chapters.... Nothing says beat game ever like having to play for a couple hours before the fun kicks in lol.
 
I doubt many pro reviewers fully explored the game or all of it's endings, if they finished it at all. Still, I don't leave reviews on games outside of giving my opinion on forums because I don't care. If game developers piss me off then I simply don't buy their games anymore. I've made it to chapter 4 so far but I don't know how long the game is or how many chapters it has. So far I would give it 7 out 10. GTA 5 was an 8 out 10 for me and GTA 4 was a 9 out 10 for me. The original games were all 9 out 10 based on the time and tech they were built on, each one getting bigger and better despite the PS2 being the system they were all built for.
 
I don't trust the media review scores or user review scores

Media Reviews - incentivized to give games better ratings so they get early access, developer interviews, ad money, etc. It's been like this forever.
User Reviews - botting, fake reviews from people that didn't play the game, actual players review bombing, for pretty much any reason often even if they like the game.
 
GTA5s map is basically the size of just the urban area of 6, and 5 generally was far less dense and basically just has clear areas dropped for each major location. 6 is not only huge, but feels like a real area. There are way more interactions and things to do in 6 as well. You really have to play the game to appreciate what they’re doing here at a technical level. Nothing comes close, not cyberpunk, or anything else. For me it feels as big of a deal as to when I first played GTA3 or Skyrim, and it’s far more impressive than GTA5 when it released since GTA5 really wasn’t a huge leap over GTA4 in all reality.
That's not good news. I had hoped the map would be smaller, not larger than GTAV. Which I already thought was too big for its own good. But this doesn't answer my question. Making it larger does not change complexity. I think GTA4 was peak, GTA5 felt like a downgrade after it. More is not always better. From what I've seen around the net, the random interactions in GTA6 are more annoying than fun, but maybe they didn't show the good ones? Can you confirm if there are actual fun and more importantly funny encounters? Every NPC just seems excessively aggressive and attack you for any reason, while you are punished by the karma system for fighting back. That's not my idea of fun, it seems annoying and frustrating. Not to mention that you are not even allowed to attack certain NPCs. Which seems odd for a GTA game. I've read a poignant comment on this: If some NPCs are not allowed to be hurt for political reasons, does that mean that the rest are politically acceptable to murder? This sends a very concerning message.
It will be very, very difficult playing open world games after this game as I don’t see anyone putting anything out like this for some years that isn’t just AI slop.
I'm more worried about how difficult it would be to play this game. Because the more I learn about it the worse it looks.
But again, all of that is unfortunately let down by a poor GTA single player story mission experience which is unfortunate. This is why it’s very clear the game was made for GTA online, and they have an impressive framework that will last a long time here for it.
But aren't the random interactions specific to the single player? One assumes the multiplayer will have far differently designed interactions that accommodates multiple players.
 
I don't think it will go anywhere near as flat as TLOUS2, simply because GTA is so much bigger. Though it is likely it will sell less than GTA5. GTA4 sold less than San Andreas as well, so that is not out of the realm of possibilities even if it was a better game.

Though we'd probably need to wait a bit longer to get a better picture. Game is 80-100 hours long, I think most people who have played it are barely 20 hours in at this point. A lot of gamers aren't reviewing it yet, good or bad because they barely started it.
Didn't they say the story is 25-30 hours, and the completionist approach is 100 hours?

At the end of the day I care less about how successful or unsuccessful it is, and how others review it. What I care about is if it's any good. And unfortunately the more I see of it, the worse my perception of it gets. Even when I think OK, I've got the gist of the negatives, then I see a new clip that blows my mind, and not in a good way.
 
You can remote play on your PC from your Xbox but you are still limited to using a controller. don't know if it was mentioned in this thread earlier.
Played for a number of hours tonight. Visual quality is lower but still very good, imo.
https://www.xbox.com/remoteplay
1795344088851.png
 
Even if these 33,000 people actually did buy the game, every single one of them posted their ‘score’ so quickly as to make it clear they spent hardly any time playing the game.
It's funny how fast the opinions of those who didn't buy the games are dismissed. When it should be the single most important feedback for publishers and developers. This is direct feedback from the horse's mouth on why the cash machine isn't going ka-ching.

It tells them exactly why they lost these sales. The people who bought it and then leave negative feedback? Who cares they already paid up, but these are literal lost sales, you know the thing they harp on about in context of piracy, that they are now trying desperately to dismiss or ignore.
 
In chapter two now. Picking up and more fun now. Now I’m boosting cars for money and the hospital shootout and chase was a ton of fun. Ch2 feels more open ended in how to move forward and less on rails like the beginning.
 
You can remote play on your PC from your Xbox but you are still limited to using a controller. don't know if it was mentioned in this thread earlier.
Played for a number of hours tonight. Visual quality is lower but still very good, imo.
https://www.xbox.com/remoteplay
View attachment 838605

https://consolemouse.com/en/

I have a PS5 pro but seems to work on xbox.

Downside still 30FPS, but I can actually shoot people. (I hate controllers for shooting)

I rotate between that and smoovplay for 90FPS. If I can't beat a mission with the controller, I switch to consolemouse lol.
 
In chapter two now. Picking up and more fun now. Now I’m boosting cars for money and the hospital shootout and chase was a ton of fun. Ch2 feels more open ended in how to move forward and less on rails like the beginning.
It definitely gets better after chapter 1 which was just a giant tutorial, and yeah that part was pretty solid. I still can’t believe the level of detail on such ancient hardware and how polished this game is.
 
It definitely gets better after chapter 1 which was just a giant tutorial, and yeah that part was pretty solid. I still can’t believe the level of detail on such ancient hardware and how polished this game is.
Yea the tutorial section was too long and honestly not interesting enough to really pull me in.
 
If there was a church, he would complain that you could shoot it up. Which is probably why R* left them out.
With games like this there will always be an endless list of things for people like him to complain about.

Props to him for actually playing the game though, or at least watching someone play.
Im pretty sure there is one, but I don't think you can't go in.

Let me load up the game real quick and ill verify.

EDIT: Looked like one but it's a "Community Center"
1795364775607.png
 
Last edited:
$80 well spent. I mean that. Sometimes you gotta fall for the hype and buy the thing to realize that hype is just hype. At least he's learning when the stakes are low.
Roger that. He bought the PS5 over a year ago literally just to ensure he could play this game at release. Least we get other use out of the PS5 & he did not fall for the preorder. I play Worms with the boys.. with difficulty. I still cannot use the new controllers well.. have not spent any real time on a console since the Sega Genesis and Madden 92 :LOL:

Seen a few vids of this ending
heat rip.jpg


Look familiar to anyone else?

View: https://youtu.be/9vIyuP0GnS4
 
Do you think they will ever take the game offline due to controversy of being way too realistic?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top