Fiber is a coming.

tunatime

Well...OK
Joined
Sep 15, 2011
Messages
7,514
Fiber is rolling out in my neighborhood and il probably go with the 2gb plan and my old setup (edge router 12) won't be able to handle the speed so looking to replace it. I have one 7 pro ap for WiFi so kinda thinking about going udm pro se/max and adding 1 or 2 cameras while at it. It's a shame they didn't put at least one 2.5gb lan port on it though. I see they have a small UCG-Max that has 2.5gb ports but says it can only do 1.5gb ids. What does that mean for a home network exactly?

Or what are some other options? I looked at best buy and it's nuts the price they are asking for consumer routers now. I don't need wifi just a good router that will handle 2gig and at least one 2.5bg lan link for my PC
 
Used enterprise 10Gb ftw along with a dumb multi-gig switch would be my solution for such a situation. Consumer anything is priced nuts today.
 
Just got to be careful with what the handoff is. Used enterprise 10g usually won't do 2.5 or 5, because those are new standards and enterprise 10g stuff is old. I'm getting fiber finalized hopefully tomorrow; gonna see if it's XGSPON, hopefully with a 10g-baseT handoff, or 1000BASE-LX; they haven't mentioned details yet, but I've got a 10g-base-T port waiting for them. Then it's off to my FreeBSD firewall; not sure how much it can do, but 1G should be easy.

Edit: looks like I got a 1G handoff, sadly. Also, the big storm took down a pole and broke the fiber last week, so they did the home install, but the fiber is still dark. Hopefully they'll get it spliced soon.
 
Last edited:
I am a big fan of used enterprise gear (or pseudo-enterprise if you don't want the big players), you can get it for a song if you know what you are looking for. I'm running a supermicro X10SDV-6C+-TLN4F for my edge device and it can handle snort, pfblockerng and all sorts of other goodies on my fiber connection without hiccup. Same with my Netgear 10GbE core switch, multi-gig PoE+ peripheral switch (for wifi and security items), and multi-gig wifi endpoints. I like that all of this gear can be locally managed/controlled, and it slides into 1U increments and can be hidden in the basement, hah.
 
IMHO, IPS/IDS are largely unnecessary for a home network. I ran Suricata for years with various Proofpoint rulesets and never encountered anything concerning. It's more taxing on your router and in the case of the Ubiquiti thing you're looking at it will cut your Internet speed down from a max of line rate (up to 2.5Gbps) to only 1.5Gbps.

I'm a huge fan of rolling your own router. Use an old PC and slap in a 2 port 2.5GbE NIC or use a new mini PC with 2.5GbE. In this post I outline my virtualized OPNsense instance running under Proxmox. If you wanted to install bare metal without IPS/IDS you definitely don't need something that powerful, something like an N100 barebones with 2x 2.5GbE (one for WAN one for LAN), a single 4 or 8GB DDR5 SO-DIMM, and small TLC NVME SSD should be relatively inexpensive. If you definitely want IPS/IDS you'll want to spec up a bit on the CPU.
 
Yes, use a PC as a router.

You need to confirm what kind of ethernet comes out of your ISP's connection. As mentioned older 10 Gb gear does not do 2.5 and 5.
 
yea I really wish unifi would add 2.5gbe to the udm pro. with POE so ppl with the new 2.5gbe 7 aps would be covered. honestly just go udm pro use 10gb for ont and then wait for info to bring out a cheap 2.5gbe switch with POE. I think it will happen sooner rather than later.
 
I'm in a similar boat, but not very far along homelab-wise. Supposed to be getting fiber in the next month or two but will probably stick with 1Gbps for the near future. In preparation I upgraded my pfsense box to a little HP Elitedesk 705 and added an intel X550T2 which should cover all the way up to 10GB (total cost for the box and nic was just over $200 on ebay). For now this is just connected to a Unifi NVR and AP via some simple switches, but I'd like to add a NAS and PoE switch to feed the unifi cameras as things grow.

I did consider going with a udm/pro instead of building another pfsense box, but I like the options I have with a PC-based router and pfsense/whatever vs the (more expensive) consumer stuff. So, yeah, another vote for building your own router and then adding a PoE switch to that.
 
Yes, use a PC as a router.

You need to confirm what kind of ethernet comes out of your ISP's connection. As mentioned older 10 Gb gear does not do 2.5 and 5.
2.5 /5Gb is just a stop gap money grab anyways for the home market. They could of done 10Gb by now and not be expensive, but they want to keep their business tiers profitable.

Any system that can use 2.5/5Gb bandwidth likely would be better with 10Gb anyways.

unless you have devices that NEED 2.5Gb and it is all they have wired, skip it, get used enterprise gear and now you are set for several years.
 
2.5 /5Gb is just a stop gap money grab anyways for the home market. They could of done 10Gb by now and not be expensive, but they want to keep their business tiers profitable.

Any system that can use 2.5/5Gb bandwidth likely would be better with 10Gb anyways.

unless you have devices that NEED 2.5Gb and it is all they have wired, skip it, get used enterprise gear and now you are set for several years.
mainly it's for APs from unifi that are wifi 7 have 2.5gbe uplink ports
 
mainly it's for APs from unifi that are wifi 7 have 2.5gbe uplink ports
Ya, but will you actually use 2.5Gbe? How many clients are on each AP? and Ubiq isn't known for coming close to the numbers they claim their AP's can handle... So if you have wifi devices that can saturate 1GB and plan to use them to download a lot all the time, sure, get 2.5Gb so you don't saturate an AP, but willing to bet if you look back on your AP stats, seldom will you see much bandwidth used. You could get a newer switch that has 10GB ports and supports 2.5Gb links, but of course you are paying more for that.

I have a single Ubiq AP in wall wifi 6, it serves 3 people - phones, ipads, my iOT devices, my own personal SSID for work devices that I use all day.. and seldom do I ever see more than a couple MB/s used at any burst, has a 1GB link back to my BrocadeICX 6450.
 
Ya, but will you actually use 2.5Gbe? How many clients are on each AP? and Ubiq isn't known for coming close to the numbers they claim their AP's can handle... So if you have wifi devices that can saturate 1GB and plan to use them to download a lot all the time, sure, get 2.5Gb so you don't saturate an AP, but willing to bet if you look back on your AP stats, seldom will you see much bandwidth used. You could get a newer switch that has 10GB ports and supports 2.5Gb links, but of course you are paying more for that.

I have a single Ubiq AP in wall wifi 6, it serves 3 people - phones, ipads, my iOT devices, my own personal SSID for work devices that I use all day.. and seldom do I ever see more than a couple MB/s used at any burst, has a 1GB link back to my BrocadeICX 6450.
internal transfers... wifi 7 can be easily saturated
 
Back
Top