Do I NEED M.2 over a 2.5" SSD?

Engr62

Gawd
2FA
Joined
Mar 24, 2015
Messages
719
I'm in the process of upgrading my system. My current system has a 480Gb Intel 2.5" SSD that I've been perfectly happy with. I just keep my OS, MS Office, and one game (Starcraft 2) on the SSD--all other programs/data are kept on my spinner HDDs.

My new motherboard has an M.2 slot, and I was considering replacing the SSD with a 500Gb WD M.2. Would this be a waste of money--I mean, even more money than I'm wasting going from i7-4770K to i7-8700K?

I understand that an M.2 is considerably faster than a SSD, but it's not like I have to wait long for my computer to boot or Office to load.
 
If it's SATA based, it won't make a difference. If it's NVMe based, then yes, big huge difference.

You need to pay attention to the actual interfaces, not just the transfer ones (SATA vs NVMe) but also the interface potentials (m.2 vs mini-PCI-E and whatever else), they're not all just the same things.

If your new motherboard clearly states it supports NVMe-based SSDs then yes, that will get you a massive speed boost compared to SATA which tops out with SATA III meaning about 550MB/s max - NVMe drives typically are 1.2GB/s (that's 1200MB/s) and much higher, some reaching into the 2.5GB/s range these days.

Read the user manual carefully for that motherboard and find out precisely what transfer method(s) that m.2 slot supports and then make a decision.
 
Urrmmm. Difference, yes. Big huge difference, like the difference in going from HDD to sata SSD, no. I have a box here with both SATA and NVMe SSD, and while I can (just barely) tell which one I'm using as I do interactive work, I have to think about it. I/O intensive benchmarks will definitely show the difference, typically to the tune of NVMe being 20-40% faster unless it's many long sequential reads which is generally the best case for displaying NVMe's advantage.
 
If it's SATA based, it won't make a difference. If it's NVMe based, then yes, big huge difference.


On paper, yes. Real-life, not so much. NVMe SSDs have a negligible effect on boot/app launch times and other functions relative to a SATA unit. For gaming, office/productivity, web browsing/typical internet, you're not going to notice any difference and NVMe will not be worth the cost.

If the OP really needed a new SSD (e.g., dying unit, capacity upgrade) and found a good NVMe unit at a good price, then I could see going for it. But given the situation presented, I can't see any justification for the upgrade.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for all of the information. I'll probably hold off for the time-being as I'm perfectly happy with the Intel SSD.

My motherboard (MSI Z370 Gaming Plus) has "NVMe support, up to 32 Gb/s using PCI-Express Gen3 x4, ready for Intel® Optane™ memory." However, it looks like the M.2 drive (WD Blue 3D NAND 500GB PC SSD - SATA III 6 Gb/s M.2 2280 Solid State Drive - WDS500G2B0B) I was looking at is not any faster than my SSD. Thanks again for all of the information.
 
Thanks for all of the information. I'll probably hold off for the time-being as I'm perfectly happy with the Intel SSD.

My motherboard (MSI Z370 Gaming Plus) has "NVMe support, up to 32 Gb/s using PCI-Express Gen3 x4, ready for Intel® Optane™ memory." However, it looks like the M.2 drive (WD Blue 3D NAND 500GB PC SSD - SATA III 6 Gb/s M.2 2280 Solid State Drive - WDS500G2B0B) I was looking at is not any faster than my SSD. Thanks again for all of the information.

Look at this affordable and crazy fast make sure you install in uefi / gpt mode. 3500 mb/s seq read / 2500 mb/s seq write. It's really fast....

https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B07BN217QG/ref=psdcmw_1292116011_t2_B01LXS4TY6?th=1&psc=1
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
The biggest increase in speed from SATA to NVMe would be through getting an Intel 900p or 905p SSD due to its huge difference in Random 4K reads. At least that is what the benchmarks and users of it say.

I have a Samsung 960Pro and although it screams in sequential reads this is not what it is called to do while using windows so the real life benefits are not that big vs a SATA based SSD. If I was moving huge files around all day long then yest it would be crazy fast but the majority of users is not doing this so besides the novelty factor and the less clutter for no cables advantage I don't know if it is worth it vs a larger good SATA SSD.

I upgraded from a Samsung 840 Pro so I felt a difference but I also updated my apps (Adobe Creative Cloud) that are also heavier so you know how it goes.


When the 480GB version of the Intel Optane 905p drops at Samsung Levels I will grab one to test but at current prices I don't really need it.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I own an intel p3700, an intel 1.2tb 750, two 1 tb pm961m's and several sata ssd's. I've also used an intel 900p (280gb) and an hgst 1.6tb sn 260 (in the 8x pci-e adapter format).

If this is all you do "OS, MS Office, and one game (Starcraft 2) on the SSD" then look for budget nvme or decent sata ssd's. Size is more important than most other check boxes.
 
Currently the only NVME drives that are worth it price/perf wise is the 256gb models that are around $85-100. Above that, the cost is not worth it for basic use cases like the OS, games etc.. Even then, with drops in price for sata drives like the Crucial mx500 m.2 sata in 500gb size (down to $92 at Amazon) make it a hard proposition unless you need the sata ports and your mobo can do nvme via pcie bus so you don't lose 2 sata ports. My older Z97 mobo has a 275gb m.2 sata only because it would be sitting there doing nothing otherwise, but I lost two sata ports to use it. A few months ago I put a 256gb WD Black NVME in my Ryzen's mobo. Its neat but meh.
 
Currently the only NVME drives that are worth it price/perf wise is the 256gb models that are around $85-100. Above that, the cost is not worth it for basic use cases like the OS, games etc.. Even then, with drops in price for sata drives like the Crucial mx500 m.2 sata in 500gb size (down to $92 at Amazon) make it a hard proposition unless you need the sata ports and your mobo can do nvme via pcie bus so you don't lose 2 sata ports. My older Z97 mobo has a 275gb m.2 sata only because it would be sitting there doing nothing otherwise, but I lost two sata ports to use it. A few months ago I put a 256gb WD Black NVME in my Ryzen's mobo. Its neat but meh.

I would argue that unless you need m.2 because you don't have any available off-board SATA points, the only good reason for paying for NVMe are the larger sizes, where you can actually get full benefit of what the interface and SSD controller can do. I agree that for general storage you'll be very hard pressed to tell the difference in performance between an MX500 and say a 960 EVO or a Toshiba RD400.

And of course if your m.2 form factor drive is using the SATA interface, it's just another SATA drive and won't go any faster than the SATA interface will let it.

(possibly little-known fun fact: there are PCIe AHCI ssd's as well, in the m.2 form factor. Older (tower) Mac Pro users loved them because they were bootable with the original (4,1) or (5,1) firmware. m.2 pcie/AHCI is apparently as rare as hen's teeth these days, though.)
 
Back
Top