Microsoft Admits to Disabling Third-Party Antivirus Code

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
Responding to Kaspersky’s accusations that antivirus programs are being mistreated on Windows, Microsoft acknowledges that their OS does disable third-party AV – but it is strictly for compatibility, not competitive, reasons. Based on what Windows and Devices’ director of security had to say, it seems that the fault lies with AV makers if their solutions get flagged: when third-party code expires or becomes outdated, Redmond’s security software will kick in.

“Microsoft’s application compatibility teams found that roughly 95 per cent of Windows 10 PCs had an antivirus application installed that was already compatible with Windows 10 Creators Update,” said Rob Lefferts, director of security in the Windows and Devices group. “For the small number of applications that still needed updating, we built a feature just for AV apps that would prompt the customer to install a new version of their AV app right after the update completed. To do this, we first temporarily disabled some parts of the AV software when the update began.”
 
I've had to roll back the creators update strictly for compatibility reasons. Mainly remote desktop doesn't work to non creators update pcs.
 
I've had to roll back the creators update strictly for compatibility reasons. Mainly remote desktop doesn't work to non creators update pcs.
Well yeah, having that feature is "not compatible" with their latest license revenue model.
 
I've had to roll back the creators update strictly for compatibility reasons. Mainly remote desktop doesn't work to non creators update pcs.

That is odd, I have not run into that problem, yet. Good to know though, thanks.
 
Sounds like Kaspersky should have gotten their shit together sooner? If the other major virus players weren't affected, they likely had support in place ahead of time.

I have seen Kaspersky slow an otherwise fast machine to a crawl. Not always, mind you, but probably a compatibility issue or something.
 
MS should never disable a 3rd party AV unless that AV is breaking something. It should only notify the user of a problem and *perhaps* activate an additional layer of MS-provided AV protection.

Anti-competitive, period.
 
Yet one more way that Microsoft is taking away more of what little control it's users had over their OS. What AV that is used should be up to the customer not MS.
 
Fairness maybe 3-4 times, and I should have said major updates. And strangely never the same thing

Can you name something specifically? This can happen, I've seen it happen once myself with CPU-Z with the AU update last year. Since then though I've not seen this once across a very large library of software including tons of open source stuff that never had a problem.
 
Anti-competitive, period.
Who, microsoft???

Nah, you are lying fam!!

Joke aside, since they started with the misleading configurations screens on windows 8, (making the creation of a microsoft account looking like the only option to create an account for the computer) to the GWX fiasco(malware tactics if you ask me) to the barrage of ads in W10, even after removing them and disabling the option, this type of crap just doesnt surprise me anymore.
 
MS should never disable a 3rd party AV unless that AV is breaking something. It should only notify the user of a problem and *perhaps* activate an additional layer of MS-provided AV protection.

Anti-competitive, period.

Yet one more way that Microsoft is taking away more of what little control it's users had over their OS. What AV that is used should be up to the customer not MS.

Perhaps you should try reading and researching the issue. Microsoft only disables AV software (~5% of the time) that is not compatible (and therefore not working anymore) or is not up to date (and therefore is not providing the proper protection anymore) and then it installs Windows Defender to help keep the person safer until they install a replacement or update the AV software. I don't see the issue here. Seems like MS is going out of their way to help the consumer, not be anti-competitive.
 
Perhaps you should try reading and researching the issue. Microsoft only disables AV software (~5% of the time) that is not compatible (and therefore not working anymore) or is not up to date (and therefore is not providing the proper protection anymore) and then it installs Windows Defender to help keep the person safer until they install a replacement or update the AV software. I don't see the issue here. Seems like MS is going out of their way to help the consumer, not be anti-competitive.

They never bothered to ask if their help was wanted. I can only speak for myself but I want to have full control over my OS including choices of what gets disabled or not. An OS is there to serve me not the other way around. Microsoft needs to back the fuck up and leave the user be but they won't do that.
 
They never bothered to ask if their help was wanted. I can only speak for myself but I want to have full control over my OS including choices of what gets disabled or not. An OS is there to serve me not the other way around. Microsoft needs to back the fuck up and leave the user be but they won't do that.

And yet Microsoft gets blamed every time there is some new virus developed for it that infects someone's computer.... Every decision they make is not going to be perfect, they have no way of making a perfect decision, just one that is best for the largest base of their consumers and for the health of their product overall, which this is. People are terrible about updating their AV, they get viruses, they perpetuate viruses. Why should Microsoft not do something to prevent it?

You want to control your system yourself? Good, when an update comes, you can check what happens and change it. They aren't 'forcing' you to not use AV software or Defender. You can install software that is up to date and works. If you don't like the decision, there are other options out there that might be preferable to you. But for the majority of people this is a better solution.
 
They never bothered to ask if their help was wanted. I can only speak for myself but I want to have full control over my OS including choices of what gets disabled or not. An OS is there to serve me not the other way around. Microsoft needs to back the fuck up and leave the user be but they won't do that.

And then be blamed when everything goes bad and complain why MS has done nothing about this.
 
And yet Microsoft gets blamed every time there is some new virus developed for it that infects someone's computer.... Every decision they make is not going to be perfect, they have no way of making a perfect decision, just one that is best for the largest base of their consumers and for the health of their product overall, which this is. People are terrible about updating their AV, they get viruses, they perpetuate viruses. Why should Microsoft not do something to prevent it?

You want to control your system yourself? Good, when an update comes, you can check what happens and change it. They aren't 'forcing' you to not use AV software or Defender. You can install software that is up to date and works. If you don't like the decision, there are other options out there that might be preferable to you. But for the majority of people this is a better solution.

The majority of people are retards who get viruses regardless of what AV is on there so that's a moot point about blame. I fix computers for a living and the majority of the average shock me by being smart enought to even breathe. Idiocracy isn't the future, it's here and now. So really it's lose lose as them being retards cause my freedom to take a hit. I don't even want Defender on my OS at all but it's not like uninstalling it is an option for the public. Microsoft would do well to have a version of Windows giving full control to the users but that doesn't jive with their goals.
 
It could be for compatibility reasons. A few weeks back I made the mistake of updating a relatives PC with Windows 10 Creators Update. The laptop had xfinity's version of norton 360 installed. After the update Norton would not start even after uninstalling and reinstalling. After playing with this for an hour I used the option to revert to the previous windows only to have an unbootable system (windows at boot would say attempting repairs only to fail and not be able to continue) after the rollback. I ended up having to do a reinstall keeping your files option which took 2 hours on a ~6 month old AMD A10 laptop (no SSD). This was a very frustrating experience especially since this was the morning I was supposed to drive back 350 miles with my wife and in-laws. If my sister in-law had pressed the same button on the popup as I there would have been no hope for recovery. I expect she would have had to take the system to Best Buy and paid to fix it.
 
Who, microsoft???

Nah, you are lying fam!!

Joke aside, since they started with the misleading configurations screens on windows 8, (making the creation of a microsoft account looking like the only option to create an account for the computer) to the GWX fiasco(malware tactics if you ask me) to the barrage of ads in W10, even after removing them and disabling the option, this type of crap just doesnt surprise me anymore.

What i find interesting is MS tested that 'hide the local account' option on GFWL. I found it right away but most people didn't and were stuck with it for their gamesaves and such. I ended up having to use it because if i played GTA IV on PC, it would kick my wife off of Netflix on the Xbox360. That was an early strong lesson in how hard MS will go in making sure one account=one person and how bad of an idea it is.
 
NEVER have had to reinstall anything with an update, nor has anything stopped working... I use Norton 360 from Comcrap and have had no trouble...

But if MS is disabling third party vendors then they are in the wrong..
 
Some of our AVG installs got disabled after the creators update, but that was strictly because they were on an old version, the users who had updated their installs had no issues. Out of curiosity we re enabled one of the old AVG installs after the update and Network connectivity and the windows firewall just went completely south, so did domain access permissions for some reason. Either way I was silently thanking MS because having your AV shut down on you until you do your updates on it is a far better alternative to the system failing half way through and spending god only knows how many hours trying to roll back updates instead.
 
Really sad how the local MS cheerleaders fail to see that you are losing control of your system, release by release.

They get blamed for bad shit? yes.
Unfounded? no, their code just fucking sucks.
Ok for them to start disabling shit without telling the computer owner? no, I paid for this damn computer and software, At the very least, give me some info, before you think that I am a moron.

If I want a dumb device like this, I would just get an ipad and be done with it.
 
They never bothered to ask if their help was wanted. I can only speak for myself but I want to have full control over my OS including choices of what gets disabled or not. An OS is there to serve me not the other way around. Microsoft needs to back the fuck up and leave the user be but they won't do that.

If you want full control over your OS, I suppose you could install LFS. If you want to use something that someone else produced, you are already surrendering full control. The maker of the product is going to want to have some control over the product, usually relative to how much the maker wants to be responsible when something goes wrong.

In addition, people need to chill out with the MS hate. An OS is a tool to get a job done. If my old table saw breaks, and I have to purchase a new one, I am not going to go into rage mode because that model saw and the features I liked about it aren't available anymore. I'll just get the closest thing I can find to do the job, and get back to work.
 
The majority of people are retards who get viruses regardless of what AV is on there so that's a moot point about blame. I fix computers for a living and the majority of the average shock me by being smart enought to even breathe. Idiocracy isn't the future, it's here and now. So really it's lose lose as them being retards cause my freedom to take a hit. I don't even want Defender on my OS at all but it's not like uninstalling it is an option for the public. Microsoft would do well to have a version of Windows giving full control to the users but that doesn't jive with their goals.

You do realize that entire statement is pretty much a reason for Microsoft doing exactly what they are doing right? As far as different versions, Microsoft used to do that and people complained. They still give some different versions, and you still have the ability to change your AV, so I still am not seeing any real point here?
 
You do realize that entire statement is pretty much a reason for Microsoft doing exactly what they are doing right? As far as different versions, Microsoft used to do that and people complained. They still give some different versions, and you still have the ability to change your AV, so I still am not seeing any real point here?

When I am being penalized and having control stripped from me I don't care why they're doing it, just that they are doing it. Oh really, I am able to uninstall Windows Defender ? Cause that's the kind of freedom I want. The ability to install, uninstall what I damn please and to not have the OS move an inch without my say so. No reinstalling Twitter when it feels like it, no resetting my defaults, none of thhat BS.
 
When I am being penalized and having control stripped from me I don't care why they're doing it, just that they are doing it. Oh really, I am able to uninstall Windows Defender ? Cause that's the kind of freedom I want. The ability to install, uninstall what I damn please and to not have the OS move an inch without my say so. No reinstalling Twitter when it feels like it, no resetting my defaults, none of thhat BS.

I guess I don't understand, I do not have Twitter on my system. The last time I needed to uninstall Defender, I did not have a problem. Has it occasionally reset some of my defaults? Yes, but so has every OS I have used, some more often than others. As far as having the OS not move an inch without your say so? Then write your own OS, what kind of bs is that?
 
I guess I don't understand, I do not have Twitter on my system. The last time I needed to uninstall Defender, I did not have a problem. Has it occasionally reset some of my defaults? Yes, but so has every OS I have used, some more often than others. As far as having the OS not move an inch without your say so? Then write your own OS, what kind of bs is that?

Seriously ? Twitter comes preinstalled on 10. You can uninstall it if you want but after the Anniversary update it was right back there on my system again. Same goes for Candy Crush and every other POS app they put on it for you. As for defender if I can uninstall it that's strange. Right click it on the start menu and there's no option for uninstall. Maybe it's on the Apps and Features List ? Nope. Well maybe it's on the add/remove program list in Control Panel ? Nope.

Fucking pathetic how much you people defend this BS.
 
Seriously ? Twitter comes preinstalled on 10. You can uninstall it if you want but after the Anniversary update it was right back there on my system again. Same goes for Candy Crush and every other POS app they put on it for you. As for defender if I can uninstall it that's strange. Right click it on the start menu and there's no option for uninstall. Maybe it's on the Apps and Features List ? Nope. Well maybe it's on the add/remove program list in Control Panel ? Nope.

Fucking pathetic how much you people defend this BS.

I have 10 and I do not have twitter installed, so I don't know what to tell you. I also do not have Candy Crush. Perhaps I am just "lucky" or perhaps I just know how to run my system. There is tons of information out there, I would advise you to avail yourself of it.

As for defending, I am defending the very real legitimate reason Microsoft is doing this. It is meant for the masses. If you are not one of the masses, there are other options as I have clearly stated. I am not going to spend a bunch of time in a thread about the values of what Microsoft is doing here to advertise for other systems. You can clearly see my thoughts in other threads on that topic.
 
Really sad how the local MS cheerleaders fail to see that you are losing control of your system, release by release.

They get blamed for bad shit? yes.
Unfounded? no, their code just fucking sucks.
Ok for them to start disabling shit without telling the computer owner? no, I paid for this damn computer and software, At the very least, give me some info, before you think that I am a moron.

If I want a dumb device like this, I would just get an ipad and be done with it.

So, when are you going to buy that iPad and be done with it?
 
NEVER have had to reinstall anything with an update, nor has anything stopped working... I use Norton 360 from Comcrap and have had no trouble...

But if MS is disabling third party vendors then they are in the wrong..

Interesting, I can log into my computer, Xbox 360 and Xbox One without being kicked off of any of them. Sounds like they fixed the issue which occurred what, 10 years ago?
 
Can you name something specifically? This can happen, I've seen it happen once myself with CPU-Z with the AU update last year. Since then though I've not seen this once across a very large library of software including tons of open source stuff that never had a problem.
Honest I don't remember each case, I just bitch, moan, reinstall, and use the program again. Although I do recall when I first upgrade to Win10, the Master of Orion remake DLC got "uninstalled" because of compatibility issues, but I think it still was actually there it just told me it uninstalled it.
 
I'm mixed. Tired of Microsoft's heavy handed gradual takeaway of our control. But in this case they were avoiding bad publicity that comes with "The creators update broke my system!!!". They had to choose between two evils.
 
Back
Top