Google Pixel Has Best Smartphone Camera Ever Tested

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
I’m still on the fence due to the Pixel’s premium cost but (arguably) less-than-premium design, but it may actually be worth the asking price when you figure in its optics, which have gotten a glowing review at DxOMark. Indoor shooters may be particularly pleased, as it is reported to have great low-light performance.

With an overall DxOMark Mobile score of 89, pixel, the latest Google smartphone, is the highest-rated smartphone camera we have ever tested. Its image quality scores are impressive across the board, but it is particularly strong in providing a very high level of detail from its 12.3MP camera, with relatively low levels of noise for every tested lighting condition. It also provides accurate exposures with very good contrast and white balance, as well as fast autofocus. The Pixel’s strong scores under a wide range of conditions make it an excellent choice for almost any kind of photography.
 
I thought I read that DxOMark worked with Google to make the camera better. So, if that's true, it should score well.
 
I'm glad the Google iPhone 6 has a good camera

Heh, I don't care what it's similar to so long as it's better. There isn't a whole lot of difference between a Mercedes and a BMW in the same price bracket. From what I can tell, Google assistant is in a completely different league then Siri though. If I were to buy a pixel it would be for project fi though. I use under 2gb a month on average of data due to constant wifi (and access to xfinity wifi) the difference in price between Project Fi and my current plan would pay for the phone in less than 2 years. Only thing holding me back right now is the 128gb version of the XL is sold out in all colors.
 
But it's still $650 minimum... The fact that Google has effectively abandoned the affordably-minded Nexus crowd better mean the phone is good. Project Fi could potentially make the higher price worth it.
 
You can just see the excitement on their faces.




Flash-photos__920.png
 
I preordered the XL, on Project Fi already, an upgrade to my 5x. I love the 5x but the camera is not so great. Before that I had a G3 with a pretty good camera and image stabilization. Hope the Pixel lives up to the hype.

Ohh also I get a free Daydream VR, curious about that. Don't expect it to compete with my Vive tho...
 
This news is a week old. French don't get excited, hence the moody photo above.
 
Could be, but I remember the HTC UltraPixel that produced only 4MP images. That did not go well. I believe that 12MP is the current standard. When some will push it to 24MP or more (say Samsung or Apple) all will follow.
 
Could be, but I remember the HTC UltraPixel that produced only 4MP images. That did not go well. I believe that 12MP is the current standard. When some will push it to 24MP or more (say Samsung or Apple) all will follow.

Thing is, when you up the pixel density you have to deal with higher noise levels and thus the image quality doesn't really go up.

Once you get past a certain pixel density, the sensor is unable to separate the different colors/light levels between the pixels.

That is why image quality goes like this Large Format > Medium Format > Full Frame > (regular) Crop Frame > Point & Shoot > phone.

Compare that phone camera to a real camera and you will see that the phone camera is STILL complete crap comparatively.

The other reason is that the lenses can only resolve so much. Past a certain amount, the lenses become very expensive.
 
we need more megapixels. That way, when the ladies take nude selfies, they're 4k wallpaper size
 
  • Like
Reactions: Droc
like this
^ A 4K image is only about 8MP(?) or so. Those nudies are already being shot in 4K and above. Maybe not by the time it's been run through this-or-that app and resized

In other words, you want best quality, better have access to the source camera ;)
 
^ A 4K image is only about 8MP(?) or so. Those nudies are already being shot in 4K and above. Maybe not by the time it's been run through this-or-that app and resized

In other words, you want best quality, better have access to the source camera ;)

Actually, you want access to a camera that takes RAW images, not one that just spits out crappy jpegs.
 
having the best sensor with the worst optics will result in a shitty image. Phone optics are shitty. Pixel count means fucking squat. You can take an old 4MP DSLR and take incredible photos compared to a 24MP phone.
 
we need more megapixels. That way, when the ladies take nude selfies, they're 4k wallpaper size

Given equal sensor area, higher the pixel count usually means crappier image (low dynamic range, noise, horrible low light performance, etc).
 
But...?

Exposure-and-Contrast-90-__002__920.png


Pixel is exposing for wrong area here. S7 still is the best imo.

Color-85-__002__920.png


Is it me or did they just screw up the Pixel test in this pic so you can't quite compare them because the framing is obviously off.
 
The other reason is that the lenses can only resolve so much. Past a certain amount, the lenses become very expensive.

Not quite.

Past a certain amount, the lenses will eventually hit something called "diffraction limit", which limits their absolute highest resolution due to the inability of light being ever focused onto a single point due to wave nature of light. IE they become impossible, not just expensive.

Also, Expensive lenses only occur in full sized camera lenses as they more often than not, involve zooming (or at the very least, retractable lens), which involves mechanical components, the lenses themselves must be of a higher quality (they use glass lenses, which by itself are more expensive than the plastic lenses in smartphones, and that's not even counting the more expensive types of glass, such as N > 2 glasses), adjustable aperture size means that they must also use as little vignetting as possible , etc etc.

Plastic lenses in phones are typically a couple of bucks, compared to hundreds, thousands or even 10's of thousands for digital camera lenses.
 
What exactly is it about the pixel that makes it so good, IE the question is, why cant any other company simply buy the same sensor and optics? Is it just that they have first crack at a new sensor which will soon be available in products like the S8?
 
Not quite.

Past a certain amount, the lenses will eventually hit something called "diffraction limit", which limits their absolute highest resolution due to the inability of light being ever focused onto a single point due to wave nature of light. IE they become impossible, not just expensive.

Also, Expensive lenses only occur in full sized camera lenses as they more often than not, involve zooming (or at the very least, retractable lens), which involves mechanical components, the lenses themselves must be of a higher quality (they use glass lenses, which by itself are more expensive than the plastic lenses in smartphones, and that's not even counting the more expensive types of glass, such as N > 2 glasses), adjustable aperture size means that they must also use as little vignetting as possible , etc etc.

Plastic lenses in phones are typically a couple of bucks, compared to hundreds, thousands or even 10's of thousands for digital camera lenses.

How much is the markup on the phone camera lenses?

And I am in no way comparing the super expensive SLR lenses to a phone camera lens. The most "expensive" lens I have would have cost less than $500 when new. Past that, you are just getting into crazy expensive territory. The most I have ever spent on a single lens
was $225.

I have a couple Pentax DSLR cameras and for absolutely ANY type of photography, I will choose either one over absolutely any phone camera every single time.

Even a "crappy" 18-55mm kit lens is light years ahead of ANY phone camera lens. I put crappy in quotes because the newest iteration of the 18-55 kit lens is a pretty good lens.

DXOMARK has lost pretty much any credibility that it had with me as it is saying a phone camera is good for pretty much any type of photography.
 
Not to be 'that guy' but is it really a giant leap to be "best smartphone camera tested"? I mean next years models will then also get the title right? And then each one after that? I really don't expect it to be worse than my S7 because my phone came out before pixel...

Cell cameras will never top dslr. This is a pointless argument because they are also evolving each iteration and the price is much higher. I use my cell for most photos as it is easier to have as an EDC than my giant nikon.
 
No idea on the markup, but if we go by gross profits of lens maker companies, one such company based in Taiwan makes about 50% gross profit (a little over 40% net), so the margin can be quite high if we look only at phone lenses.

Volume accounts for a lot of it though, each individual lens doesn't cost all that much. The company mentioned above ships 10's of millions of lenses per month.

How much is the markup on the phone camera lenses?

And I am in no way comparing the super expensive SLR lenses to a phone camera lens. The most "expensive" lens I have would have cost less than $500 when new. Past that, you are just getting into crazy expensive territory. The most I have ever spent on a single lens
was $225.

I have a couple Pentax DSLR cameras and for absolutely ANY type of photography, I will choose either one over absolutely any phone camera every single time.

Even a "crappy" 18-55mm kit lens is light years ahead of ANY phone camera lens. I put crappy in quotes because the newest iteration of the 18-55 kit lens is a pretty good lens.

DXOMARK has lost pretty much any credibility that it had with me as it is saying a phone camera is good for pretty much any type of photography.
 
Why is every good phone a 12MP one? Still in love with my Lumia 1020.
Because anything past the is pointless for phones as the optic is so small and crappy. My DSLR "only" has 12mp and it can take better pictures than any other phone out there. Also the resolution of 12mp is 4000x3000 so its not really that bad.
 
Back
Top