VR Devs Pull Support For Oculus Rift Until Palmer Luckey Steps Down

I am sorry, what goal posts did I move? I haven't moved any goal posts. You are the one that was insinuating their was illegal discrimination in the case and therefore it was different. However, there was not. I am talking about decisions to refuse service. Discrimination comes in all forms, if you choose not to do business with a company based on their CEOs personal beliefs, that is still discrimination. However, it is not illegal discrimination. So really, the only one shifting anything is you.

You edited your post after I already quoted and responded to it...

First off, in your first reply you mentioned NOTHING about the baker incident. I replied to that assuming you were referring to that and other similar incidents. But you later used the exact phrase "Private businesses have the right to refuse service" (which you edited out after the fact). That is only true in certain circumstances, which is what I pointed out. Then you continued to ONLY refer to the baker incident, despite it not even being brought up specifically after I called out your previous claim. You are twisting your own words around after the fact to create a narrative that you think works.
 
I think your logic doesn't really hold up here. It might be easier if you look at it in the abstract:

You are against policy X. A CEO of company Y funds political organizations to make policy X a reality. Company Y has nothing to do with policy X, nor do its employees, however, it is safe to assume that by soliciting company Y, some of your money is going towards bankrolling policy X. Therefore, you decide to boycott company Y, because you don't want your money funding policy X. This seems like a logically consistent standpoint to me, I'm not sure what the hypocrisy is.

Exactly, don't see why that is that hard to grasp that logic there.
 
Do either of you know what hypocrisy is?

I don't like these dev's voting with their wallets so I am going to show them by voting with my wallet!

They are attempting to financially impact Oculus over politics and I don't like that, so I am going to financially impact them over politics. This makes sense to me.
 
I don't like these dev's voting with their wallets so I am going to show them by voting with my wallet!

They are attempting to financially impact Oculus over politics and I don't like that, so I am going to financially impact them over politics. This makes sense to me.

It's not hypocrisy, it's a combination of a free market mixed with the freedom of speech and opinion. It really doesn't matter how full circle it comes (which is circumstantial mind you), unless you're one of those types who prefer a dictatorship that makes finding both facts and affiliations irrelevant?

I'm sure you're not. It's just only good when it aligns with your political views.

This is by far just another example that further backs my opinion that having what amounts to a two party system with two sides of players as flawed. No matter what side you support, even if they were to win the elections and control the government, the other side will simply play upon that and rile up their base and eventually regain control. Creating a circle of malignant life that is our government system. ww
 
Do either of you know what hypocrisy is?

lol I'd like you to explain to me.

I don't like these dev's voting with their walletss [playing politics and trying to strong arm a company because they don't like the personal opinion of an employee] so I am going to show them by voting with my wallet!

FTFY

fuck those devs



imo of course.... and this is coming from someone who detests occulus/facebook and has a Vive sitting on my desk
 
Incorrect. Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Americans with Disabilities Act.
The Civil Rights Act of 1964 only makes illegal discrimination based on race, color, religion and national origin. It says nothing about gender-based discrimination or political leanings. Title II, Sec. 201 (a): "...without discrimination or segregation on the ground of race, color, religion, or national origin." If you're going to sue for discrimination you have to prove it was based on one of those four reasons if you're going to invoke the Civil Rights Act.

I'm being pedantic, here. I'm well aware that several states have drafted laws that extend the definition of rights to all people in establishments offering services to the public.
 
The Civil Rights Act of 1964 only makes illegal discrimination based on race, color, religion and national origin. It says nothing about gender-based discrimination or political leanings. Title II, Sec. 201 (a): "...without discrimination or segregation on the ground of race, color, religion, or national origin." If you're going to sue for discrimination you have to prove it was based on one of those four reasons if you're going to invoke the Civil Rights Act.

I'm being pedantic, here. I'm well aware that several states have drafted laws that extend the definition of rights to all people in establishments offering services to the public.

I realize that. If you read what I quoted, he edited his post after the fact to specify gender. I was speaking generally, as was the quote.
 
Why? Because it doesn't fit your personal political views?

Please explain why it's not okay for independent game developers to choose not to put in THEIR OWN time and money to develop for a certain company, REGARDLESS of the reason.

I don't have a problem with the choice not to do business. Fine, don't do business and be done with it.

I DO have a problem with them choosing go after an individual who simply exercised his right to an opinion. Essentially DEMANDING that this person "step down". It's not enough that they simply disagree with this person. No, they have to attempt to ruin them in their career.

Simply for having an opinion.

It's bullshit. First to last. And I'd be saying the same thing if it were a bunch of Trumpies going after a Hillary supporter in the same way.
 
You edited your post after I already quoted and responded to it...

First off, in your first reply you mentioned NOTHING about the baker incident. I replied to that assuming you were referring to that and other similar incidents. But you later used the exact phrase "Private businesses have the right to refuse service" (which you edited out after the fact). That is only true in certain circumstances, which is what I pointed out. Then you continued to ONLY refer to the baker incident, despite it not even being brought up specifically after I called out your previous claim. You are twisting your own words around after the fact to create a narrative that you think works.

Your right, I did edit my post, silly me for expounding on the topic that you obviously needed expounding upon. The whole debate between liberals and conservatives about refusing service exploded over the baker incident. So yes of course that is the one I am referring to. Not sure why that wouldn't come to mind as it was the one that made the most headlines and national news stations... And my references aren't just limited to the baker incident, but that is a tangible case that can be brought to light. Why are you grasping at straws here? You keep showing how you are the one moving the goal posts.
 
I think your logic doesn't really hold up here. It might be easier if you look at it in the abstract:

You are against policy X. A CEO of company Y funds political organizations to make policy X a reality. Company Y has nothing to do with policy X, nor do its employees, however, it is safe to assume that by soliciting company Y, some of your money is going towards bankrolling policy X. Therefore, you decide to boycott company Y, because you don't want your money funding policy X. This seems like a logically consistent standpoint to me, I'm not sure what the hypocrisy is.

The thing that makes this so much worse is the utterly disproportionate pay that CEO's earn compared to any average worker at the company. So it's not just a small chunk that's going towards that cause, it's a huge chunk. You're literally pumping a percentage of your money into the hands of lobbyists and whatnot.
 
I think your logic doesn't really hold up here. It might be easier if you look at it in the abstract:

You are against policy X. A CEO of company Y funds political organizations to make policy X a reality. Company Y has nothing to do with policy X, nor do its employees, however, it is safe to assume that by soliciting company Y, some of your money is going towards bankrolling policy X. Therefore, you decide to boycott company Y, because you don't want your money funding policy X. This seems like a logically consistent standpoint to me, I'm not sure what the hypocrisy is.

First if you are going to mention hypocrisy, then quote it within the context that I used it. Also, which logic in particular are you referring to? Hypocrisy wasn't just about boycotting a company because what the CEO does, it was about saying it is okay for devs not to provide service to a company based on an individuals beliefs while saying a privately owned business denying service to someone based on personal beliefs is not okay.

In your scenario above you are missing the fact that money paid to the company is not directly going to fund political organizations. Personal money from the CEO was going to pay for that. So while true the CEO makes a large chunk of money from the company. the rest of the worker also make money from the company, and most of the money from the company goes to the larger staff than the CEO. Also most of the money Luckey has came from the sale of the company to Facebook. So should the devs boycott Facebook as well for acquiring a company whose CEO has such beliefs? After all, they gave him the lion share of the cash he now holds...
 
Last edited:
I don't have a problem with the choice not to do business. Fine, don't do business and be done with it.

I DO have a problem with them choosing go after an individual who simply exercised his right to an opinion. Essentially DEMANDING that this person "step down". It's not enough that they simply disagree with this person. No, they have to attempt to ruin them in their career.

Simply for having an opinion.

It's bullshit. First to last. And I'd be saying the same thing if it were a bunch of Trumpies going after a Hillary supporter in the same way.

First off, no one is demanding anything. The only thing ever stated, was that they refused to develop for Oculus if Palmer was employed there/in charge. That is in no way a demand that he be removed, it's a statement that if he remains they will just choose not to do business with them.

Second, dumping millions into a shitposting internet troll brigade is not "simply having an opinion". If all he said is "I like Trump" I doubt this would have even made the news.

I agree with you that if it were reversed, and he was funding shitposters for anti-Trump ads, I would still think it was bullshit. The whole thing is just sleazy as fuck. I can't really fault developer for not wanting to do business with such an individual.

The only things I agree are bullshit are the family attacks/doxxing/whatever. There is no excuse for that.
 
In your scenario above you are missing the fact that money paid to the company is not directly going to fund political organizations. Personal money from the CEO was going to pay for that. So while true the CEO makes a large chunk of money from the company. the rest of the worker also make money from the company, and most of the money from the company goes to the larger staff than the CEO. Also most of the money Luckey has came from the sale of the company to Facebook. So should the devs boycott Facebook as well for acquiring a company whose CEO has such beliefs? After all, they gave him the lion share of the cash he now holds...
How much of the money is supporting the cause you dislike is almost irrelevant if you don't want ANY of your money supporting it if you can avoid it. Plus, when it comes to CEOs, it's symbolic also. If the head of a company is endorsing certain political views, that's a symbol that by supporting the company he is in charge of, you're also indirectly supporting the cause you don't like. Plus it's unknown how much his own political views affect the company culture. It could be almost none at all, or could be substantial. Either way, supporting the company continues to enable his behavior that you don't want and can be symbolically seen as endorsing it. Meanwhile, if Bob in accounting financially supports a view you don't like, Bob has no influence as to the direction the company takes, so in that case supporting the company is divorced from how it influences the policy you don't want to support. Suzy in Human Resources could have the exact opposite view as Bob, but like him, has no influence as to what direction the company takes. The CEO however, does.

As for your Facebook scenario, you could argue that either way. If the main person the boycotter is protesting against is Palmer Luckey, you could conceivably still support Facebook because money it receives wouldn't continue to go to him; that would come from Oculus. Alternately, you could argue Facebook is still an enabler of him, so you could justify boycotting them also as a way to further cut him off.
 
How much of the money is supporting the cause you dislike is almost irrelevant if you don't want ANY of your money supporting it if you can avoid it. Plus, when it comes to CEOs, it's symbolic also. If the head of a company is endorsing certain political views, that's a symbol that by supporting the company he is in charge of, you're also indirectly supporting the cause you don't like. Plus it's unknown how much his own political views affect the company culture. It could be almost none at all, or could be substantial. Either way, supporting the company continues to enable his behavior that you don't want and can be symbolically seen as endorsing it. Meanwhile, if Bob in accounting financially supports a view you don't like, Bob has no influence as to the direction the company takes, so in that case supporting the company is divorced from how it influences the policy you don't want to support. Suzy in Human Resources could have the exact opposite view as Bob, but like him, has no influence as to what direction the company takes. The CEO however, does.

First, you keep insinuating the company is engaging in this behavior. That isn't true, the CEO is privately engaging in the behavior. Nor has the CEO influenced the company to promote the behavior. The devs won't be seen as supporting that cause simply because they decide to design something for the company. Only if the company's stance was to support a particular cause, would your statement be accurate.

It is near impossible to find a company that has individuals who do not support something you oppose. It is even harder to find a sizeable company that does not employ a mixture of employees with assorted beliefs who will unwittingly suffer from a boycott. But my point about hypocrisy had nothing to do with the financial decision to support or not support a company. That is purely up to the individual. I support any individual's right to vote with their wallet, and I support just about any company's right to vote with their wallet as well. I may not agree with them, but that does not mean I will not support their right.

As for your Facebook scenario, you could argue that either way. If the main person the boycotter is protesting against is Palmer Luckey, you could conceivably still support Facebook because money it receives wouldn't continue to go to him; that would come from Oculus. Alternately, you could argue Facebook is still an enabler of him, so you could justify boycotting them also as a way to further cut him off.

I am not sure how you can separate Palmer Luckey from Facebook at this point. If you are going to link him to OR and say it should be boycotted because of him, then how can you separate the company that owns OR from that as well?

First off, no one is demanding anything. The only thing ever stated, was that they refused to develop for Oculus if Palmer was employed there/in charge. That is in no way a demand that he be removed, it's a statement that if he remains they will just choose not to do business with them.

I am confused how is saying:

Hey @oculus, @PalmerLuckey's actions are unacceptable. NewtonVR will not be supporting the Oculus Touch as long as he is employed there.

Not a demand? You can't honestly say that refusing to support a company until an individual is removed is not a demand.
 
I am confused how is saying:

Hey @oculus, @PalmerLuckey's actions are unacceptable. NewtonVR will not be supporting the Oculus Touch as long as he is employed there.

Not a demand? You can't honestly say that refusing to support a company until an individual is removed is not a demand.

Are you? Because I don't see the demand for him to be removed, at all. I see someone stating that they will not support Oculus if he's employed there.

If I say, "I won't buy an iPhone because Tim Cook is employed there / CEO", you really think that is a demand for him to be removed?

A demand would be, "Tim Cook needs to be fired, immediately!"
 
First off, no one is demanding anything.

"We refuse to work with you." That's not a demand.

"We refuse to work with you UNLESS you do *INSERT ACTION*." Is, intrinsically, a demand. Try again.


Second, dumping millions into a shitposting internet troll brigade is not "simply having an opinion". If all he said is "I like Trump" I doubt this would have even made the news.

So, having "the "wrong" opinion" is grounds for losing your job nowadays?

Sorry but FUCK THAT. People in this country are too fucking caught up in trying to define what you CAN'T say when they forget that their opinions on "acceptable" speech are worth exactly NOTHING.

And you're acting as if the alt-right movement were ONLY an "internet shitposting troll brigade". Just like the various "media" sites are desperate to label it, uniformly, "racist, misogynist, bigoted, etc, etc"

And if you're looking no further than that, you're missing all the important things that are (and need to be) said. Simply because some of the stuff being said makes you angry or uncomfortable.

And, instead of DEBATING, and proving that your ideas are better, you simply attack the person saying these words.

Not okay. NEVER okay.
 
First, you keep insinuating the company is engaging in this behavior. That isn't true, the CEO is privately engaging in the behavior.
Considering in my abstract example, I flat out said company Y has nothing to do with policy X, I think you're reading stuff that isn't there. The point is the CEO continues to get his money directly from the company. If he received NO financial compensation from the company he runs, then your point would hold up. As long as the company continues to fund him, it makes sense for someone to boycott them if they disagree with his views.

Nor has the CEO influenced the company to promote the behavior.
That's an assumption, we don't know that. Maybe he has, maybe he hasn't. Maybe there's a subtlety to the hiring process based on their views. Maybe there have been internal fundraiser emails for a political organization. Maybe nothing. What we do know is the CEO runs company Y, and publicly endorses policy X.

The devs won't be seen as supporting that cause simply because they decide to design something for the company. Only if the company's stance was to support a particular cause, would your statement be accurate.
Again, since the head of the company draws income from said company, if consumers give money to that company, they can be seen as indirectly supporting it financially, regardless of their intent.

It is near impossible to find a company that has individuals who do not support something you oppose. It is even harder to find a sizeable company that does not employ a mixture of employees with assorted beliefs who will unwittingly suffer from a boycott.
It is NOT hard to find a company that has a CEO directly funding organizations you may oppose however, regardless of what the actual workers think. As for whether the employees have a harder based on a boycott, I don't see that as the consumer's responsibility. Pretty much any boycott over anything could be considered unethical then, which I think is a little insane.
 
Considering in my abstract example, I flat out said company Y has nothing to do with policy X, I think you're reading stuff that isn't there. The point is the CEO continues to get his money directly from the company. If he received NO financial compensation from the company he runs, then your point would hold up. As long as the company continues to fund him, it makes sense for someone to boycott them if they disagree with his views.

Considering this direct quote from you:

How much of the money is supporting the cause you dislike is almost irrelevant if you don't want ANY of your money supporting it if you can avoid it. Plus, when it comes to CEOs, it's symbolic also. If the head of a company is endorsing certain political views, that's a symbol that by supporting the company he is in charge of, you're also indirectly supporting the cause you don't like.

It is not so abstract. You are clearly insinuating that because a CEO supports a cause, the company symbolically also supports it. That isn't true.

That's an assumption, we don't know that. Maybe he has, maybe he hasn't. Maybe there's a subtlety to the hiring process based on their views. Maybe there have been internal fundraiser emails for a political organization. Maybe nothing. What we do know is the CEO runs company Y, and publicly endorses policy X.

I am sorry, but your entire comments are based on pure assumption. Excuse me if I use the same level of assumptions as rebuttal. Especially since I cannot find anywhere on OR site, or in conjunction with any of their dealings that they in some way support a particular candidate. I would say my assumption is based on far more facts than yours.

Again, since the head of the company draws income from said company, if consumers give money to that company, they can be seen as indirectly supporting it financially, regardless of their intent.

Facebook also draws money from the company, as do all of the companies employees, and shareholders. Since they all get money from it, shouldn't we also be factoring them in? You are going down a very slippery slope with that stance.

It is NOT hard to find a company that has a CEO directly funding organizations you may oppose however, regardless of what the actual workers think.

CEO yes, what about the board, shareholders, executives all of which derive large income segments from the company, not to mention the workforce, which in most sizeable companies still derives the most income from the company.

As for whether the employees have a harder based on a boycott, I don't see that as the consumer's responsibility. Pretty much any boycott over anything could be considered unethical then, which I think is a little insane.

You are making a massive leap there with that claim. We all make decisions every day that affect someone's livelihood, that does not make are decisions unethical. However, it should make one stop and consider how they are spending their money. Again, this is exactly what the Devs are thinking, where are they spending their resources and support? They are well within their right there. I just don't agree with the ultimate outcome of that blanket decision based on this circumstance.
 
Are you? Because I don't see the demand for him to be removed, at all. I see someone stating that they will not support Oculus if he's employed there.

Dude, the demand is clear as day. How is saying you will not work with a company until someone is removed, not a demand to remove them?

If I say, "I won't buy an iPhone because Tim Cook is employed there / CEO", you really think that is a demand for him to be removed?

Absolutely.

A demand would be, "Tim Cook needs to be fired, immediately!"

That is what you are directly insinuating when you say you will not buy products unless he is removed.
 
That is what you are directly insinuating when you say you will not buy products unless he is removed.

No, it really is not. What you are saying is that you aren't going to give them your money unless he is removed. They don't HAVE to get your money. It's completely their choice, no one is demanding anything.

Look up the definition of "demand". Here, I will do it:

de·mand
dəˈmand/
noun
  1. 1.
    an insistent and peremptory request, made as if by right.
verb
  1. 1.
    ask authoritatively or brusquely.

None of what was said fits that description. It was never asked that he be removed, nor was it commanded or even requested. Really it was more of a stipulation, but not even that because an agreement was never made.
 
"We refuse to work with you." That's not a demand.

"We refuse to work with you UNLESS you do *INSERT ACTION*." Is, intrinsically, a demand. Try again.

You guys need to work on your semantics. Look at my post above.

So, having "the "wrong" opinion" is grounds for losing your job nowadays?

You aren't even listening, are you? You quoted my post but you didn't actually read it.
 
And you're acting as if the alt-right movement were ONLY an "internet shitposting troll brigade". Just like the various "media" sites are desperate to label it, uniformly, "racist, misogynist, bigoted, etc, etc"

What is the alt-right then?
 
Last edited:
You guys need to work on your semantics. Look at my post above.

Qualifying their association in such a way is an implicit demand. You know it. You're the one attempting to hide behind semantics here. And you know it.

You aren't even listening, are you? You quoted my post but you didn't actually read it.

I am listening. As soon as you actually make a cogent argument, rather than regurgitate this nasty crybully mentality, we can actually have an adult discussion.


What is the alt-right then?

You're looking for a "sound byte" version of what it is. I can't provide that for you. Because it isn't any one thing, no matter how hard some people try to label and malign it as such.
 
It is amazing that so many have forgot the three that died related to the clintons woes and the two banks that when down because of the clintons. 16 years ago it was all over the tv. Then all of a sudden it got pulled. Just to come back on the BBC where they didn't have the power to stop them from broadcasting it. If could of seen the future back then I would of save all that news.

Actually, when you do the full tally of people who died under mysterious circumstances while connected to the Clintons or in some way tied to testifying against them, the body count is up to about 50 now...
 
What is the alt-right then?

What does it matter to someone who only eats, breathes, and shits what the main stream media tells them to think, despite WikiLeaks having emails showing that 5 of the 6 major media outlets are actively colluding with the DNC in a form of state-sponsored media on the level of China?

And yes, its the same WikiLeaks that used to be the darlings of the liberal media for calling out Bush and his WMD bullshit - funny, I never heard about them being connected to Russia or any of the other bullshit until they started releasing information about Hillary.

I mean the nerve, what do they think they are, an unbiased whistleblower organization that doesn't take sides? :confused:
 
Qualifying their association in such a way is an implicit demand. You know it. You're the one attempting to hide behind semantics here. And you know it.

It really is not, but I don't see the point in arguing it further.

I am listening. As soon as you actually make a cogent argument, rather than regurgitate this nasty crybully mentality, we can actually have an adult discussion.

No, you are not. I stated it's more than an "opinion" when you bankroll an operation like this. You are being intentionally thick for the purpose of going on a tirade about some perceived injustice.

"Crybully"...LOL, you think Oculus, the gigantic corporation, is being abused here? Again, as I stated before, these developers have ZERO OBLIGATION to develop for Oculus. It doesn't even matter why, they can do it for whatever reason they want.

It's like you want to force them to spend their own time and money developing for a company they disagree with because you don't agree with their opinion about Palmer. That is some fucked-up shit my friend.
 
While I don't agree with Palmer's political stance, it's his right to do whatever he wants to do. The thing I am most getting tired of is how you have to walk some kind of tight rope to do anything anymore. Social media has basically brought back the Salem witch trials, but you can be faceless now.

The leader of the free world told all black people they must vote for Hillary or else he would be personally insulted.

When the representative of the country often thought to be the symbol of personal freedom tells who you are allowed to vote for, it's probably not very far from the end.
 
I still haven't had the chance to try VR yet. Wait, what were we talking about again? :cautious:
 
You're looking for a "sound byte" version of what it is. I can't provide that for you. Because it isn't any one thing, no matter how hard some people try to label and malign it as such.

More talking about what it isn't. It's almost as if it doesn't know what it is.

What does it matter to someone who only eats, breathes, and shits what the main stream media tells them to think, despite WikiLeaks having emails showing that 5 of the 6 major media outlets are actively colluding with the DNC in a form of state-sponsored media on the level of China?

And yes, its the same WikiLeaks that used to be the darlings of the liberal media for calling out Bush and his WMD bullshit - funny, I never heard about them being connected to Russia or any of the other bullshit until they started releasing information about Hillary.

I mean the nerve, what do they think they are, an unbiased whistleblower organization that doesn't take sides? :confused:

Lots of hand-waving and look-over-there and doing anything but talking about what the alt-right is. Why can't you do that?
 
It's like you want to force them to spend their own time and money developing for a company they disagree with because you don't agree with their opinion about Palmer. That is some fucked-up shit my friend.

No. I honestly don't give a shit how the spend their dev dollars or who they spend it with.

The only thing I take issue with is the whole "Unless this person goes away" caveat.

That's it, a simple, finite point. IMNSHO, attacking someone this way over their political leanings is disgusting.

End of story.

I'm not suggesting any "remedy" or "fix" for this. Just noting I dislike this nasty behavior.

If you can't accept my opinion on that as, exactly, my opinion, move along. Or try to get me fired somehow, like a good like a good little SJW.
 
More talking about what it isn't. It's almost as if it doesn't know what it is.



Lots of hand-waving and look-over-there and doing anything but talking about what the alt-right is. Why can't you do that?


Put it this way. Pretty much every social group you point out is going to have racist, sexist, bigoted people in it. The left does. The right does. The alt right does.

But what you're trying to do is pigeon-hole an entire group of people simply by the bad actors in their midst.
 
I still haven't had the chance to try VR yet. Wait, what were we talking about again? :cautious:

Getting skull fucked through your eye sockets by pictures on redit, facebook and billboards. Don't try to break up that discussion with talks about something meaningful.
 
Put it this way. Pretty much every social group you point out is going to have racist, sexist, bigoted people in it. The left does. The right does. The alt right does.

But what you're trying to do is pigeon-hole an entire group of people simply by the bad actors in their midst.

You were talking about how the alt-right is "not ONLY" those bad actors. In response, I asked: "What is the alt-right?" That's me asking about the entire group.
 
Last edited:
Love watching people try to deflect from the fact that the alt-right is essentially the refined wing of the white supremacist movement. It is a fascist movement through and through.

If you support the alt-right, you literally support fascists. They don't even pretend to be anything other than that.

Now, you can be critical of the source (media matters) but it's plain as day what the alt-right is advocating for here:!
 
NoOther was talking about how the alt-right is "not ONLY" those bad actors. In response, I asked: "What is the alt-right?" That's me asking about the entire group.

In a lot of cases, the "alt-right" gets lumped in with all the social "trash" of the right. White supremacists, blatant misogynists, etc.

The new thing appears to be a group of fairly rabid anti-PC, anti-Social Justice neocons who basically refuse to be cowed into shutting up simply because someone is trying to seize a non-existent "moral high ground".

They seem to be anti-Feminist, at least in terms of third-wave feminism. So they're not raging misogynists who want to beat women back into the kitchen. They just don't think third wave feminism, with all the intersectional politics that go with it, serves a purpose other than to create man-haters.

The whole anti-PC thing comes in at the extreme end as the aforementioned "troll brigade". But, basically it's a refusal to play along with the traditional PC social shaming and subsequent abandonment of an argument. Because PC "feely" argumentative style has essentially become a gigantic appeal to emotion and very Ad Hitlerum.

Because the acceptable thing nowadays is to work a conversation around until you can accuse someone of being a racist/misogynist/sexist/etc/etc. At which point, in our overly sensitive society, most people go "No I'm not! I have black/gay/female/etc friends! And thus the uncomfortable argument of actual facts stops, and it becomes virtue signaling. The alt-right basically either refuses to acknowledge such tactics, or turns them on their heads with humor.

So, yeah, it's easy to see how they can get a bunch of hate. Look at this thread.

Seriously, what does it say when people feel so disenfranchised (even by their own traditional party) that being lumped in with racists and militant misogynists isn't the worst thing in their minds anymore?
 
NoOther was talking about how the alt-right is "not ONLY" those bad actors. In response, I asked: "What is the alt-right?" That's me asking about the entire group.

I am not even sure what the hell you are talking about since I said no such thing?
 
No, it really is not. What you are saying is that you aren't going to give them your money unless he is removed. They don't HAVE to get your money. It's completely their choice, no one is demanding anything.

Look up the definition of "demand". Here, I will do it:



None of what was said fits that description. It was never asked that he be removed, nor was it commanded or even requested. Really it was more of a stipulation, but not even that because an agreement was never made.

We could be here all day listing the various definitions of demand, but you chose only one.


  • CloseStyle: MLA APA Chicago

Full Definition of demand
  1. 1 a : an act of demanding or asking especially with authority <a demand for obedience>b : something claimed as due <a list of demands>

  2. 2 archaic : question

  3. 3 a : willingness and ability to purchase a commodity or service <the demand for quality day care>b : the quantity of a commodity or service wanted at a specified price and time <supply and demand>

  4. 4 a : a seeking or state of being sought after <in great demand as an entertainer>b : urgent need

  5. 5 : the requirement of work or of the expenditure of a resource <equal to the demands of the office> <demands on one's time> <oxygen demand for waste oxidation>
on demand
  1. : upon presentation and request for payment; also : when requested or needed <video on demand>
See demand defined for English-language learners

See demand defined for kids




Examples of demand in a sentence
  1. The committee is considering her demand that she be given more time to complete the study.

  2. The workers said they would not end the strike until their demands were met.

  3. The demand for low-income housing is increasing as the economy gets worse.

  4. We are seeing an increased demand for hospital beds.

  5. The company increased production to meet demand.
Saying you will not do business with someone until someone steps down is a demand, as shown in example sentence 2.
 
LOL...I thought I was the only one that didn't know what the hell "alt right" meant? I guess I'm not up on my slang.
 
Back
Top