How Much Power Do Your Electronics Use When They Are ‘Off’?

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
The NYT has an article that may be of interest to the more energy conscious among you. If you think that a device always uses a lot less power when it's off, think again.

My cable box drew 28 watts when it was on and recording a show, and 26W when it was off and not recording anything. Even if I never watched TV, I would still consume about 227 kilowatt-hours annually. To put it in context, that’s more than the average person uses in an entire year in some developing countries, including Kenya and Cambodia, according to World Bank estimates. Always leaving a laptop computer plugged in, even when it’s fully charged, can use a similar quantity — 4.5 kilowatt-hours of electricity in a week, or about 235 kilowatt-hours a year.
 
Yea... cable boxes are some of the most unefficient things in the fucking world when it comes to powerconsumption. But disconnecting them makes you wait like 20 minutes before it's back up when you plug it back in. Virtually everything else is as expected though.
 
We need more regulations to get these things regulated or we could wait until bernie wins the election and cable and electric will be free or wait for hillary to win and civil war to break out so no one will care.
 
Good thing we got this thing called "CA (conditional access) cards" in europe, so you only connect your cable from the cable company/terrestrial or satellite antenna (with the DVB-C/DVB-T or DVB-S signal), plug your CA module in CI slot of your TV and use the TV interface.
 
We need more regulations to get these things regulated or we could wait until bernie wins the election and cable and electric will be free or wait for hillary to win and civil war to break out so no one will care.

Nah we should get rid of all regulations and laws for everything becuase that is definitely a better solution.
 
Personally, I do not care. My electric bill each month is pretty low as it is and yes, I live in my own place, not my parents basement. (Hell, I am 49 after all and besides, my parents live 1200 miles away.)
 
Nah we should get rid of all regulations and laws for everything becuase that is definitely a better solution.

I just think that regulations should have clearly stated goals with a 5-year timeline. If it doesn't meet those goals, then it should be forced to pass the Senate and House again to continue to be on the books. The number of regulations we have on the books is ridiculous, and there's no method for attrition of bad legislation that didn't work but still burden the system.
 
This shows up every few months on one media source or another. Nothing new including the excessive power usage of "off" cable boxes. Sadly, in the OKC area, Cox cable is ending the ability to get any TV via cable without some kind of cable box. They have been running ads warning everyone to get a 'mini box' for every TV in the house that doesn't already have some kind of Cox box. Free for first year, monthly charge per box after that. So now a seldom used TV will have an always on cable box draining both the power grid and the customer's bank account.
 
This shows up every few months on one media source or another. Nothing new including the excessive power usage of "off" cable boxes. Sadly, in the OKC area, Cox cable is ending the ability to get any TV via cable without some kind of cable box. They have been running ads warning everyone to get a 'mini box' for every TV in the house that doesn't already have some kind of Cox box. Free for first year, monthly charge per box after that. So now a seldom used TV will have an always on cable box draining both the power grid and the customer's bank account.

And yet they'll continue to lose customers and wonder why.
 
And yet they'll continue to lose customers and wonder why.

Well this is a little more complex actually. While I'm not a fan of cable companies refusing to just sell cable cards for digital cable, the reason for discontinuing "boxless" cable is actually because of more people just getting Internet access. Why? Cable spectrum. The cable that requires nothing but a TV right now is analogue channels and they take up a lot of spectrum. 6mhz per channel. You get around 150-160 of those 6mhz channels on a modern cable system. Each one can be a single SD analogue TV channel, multiple HD digital channels, or about 38mbps of DOCSIS data. As demand for data is going up, more spectrum for it is needed, and the analogue channels are a good target. Particularly when you talk DOCSIS 3.1, since you are going to potentially want a big range for it that is different form your DOCSIS 3 range. All the analogue channels are already duplicated in the digital range, so it is just a lot of wasted spectrum at the moment. As more people start doing video over the net and wanting faster Internet, that needs more spectrum to deliver.

Now I fully agree that they should sell crypto cards so you don't need to rent a box, but you'd still either need either a TV that could take the card, or a box of your own. Just saying there is a reason for axing analogue service.
 
Well this is a little more complex actually. While I'm not a fan of cable companies refusing to just sell cable cards for digital cable, the reason for discontinuing "boxless" cable is actually because of more people just getting Internet access. Why? Cable spectrum. The cable that requires nothing but a TV right now is analogue channels and they take up a lot of spectrum. 6mhz per channel. You get around 150-160 of those 6mhz channels on a modern cable system. Each one can be a single SD analogue TV channel, multiple HD digital channels, or about 38mbps of DOCSIS data. As demand for data is going up, more spectrum for it is needed, and the analogue channels are a good target. Particularly when you talk DOCSIS 3.1, since you are going to potentially want a big range for it that is different form your DOCSIS 3 range. All the analogue channels are already duplicated in the digital range, so it is just a lot of wasted spectrum at the moment. As more people start doing video over the net and wanting faster Internet, that needs more spectrum to deliver.

Now I fully agree that they should sell crypto cards so you don't need to rent a box, but you'd still either need either a TV that could take the card, or a box of your own. Just saying there is a reason for axing analogue service.

Axing analogue, yes. However, there is ZERO need for the cable companies to require a cable box (or a basic TA) for basic cable channels, etc. Until the FCC gave them permission to FORCE people to switchover to using TA's about 3-4 years back, all of the local cable providers transmitted all the "basic" channels in digital format, using unencrypted QAM ("clear QAM"). This meant that, not box required, almost every HD TV shipped within the last ten years was able to receive basic digital cable broadcasts without the extra power usage of a cable box. They could have easily turned off all analog support and kept Clear QAM, for essentially zero cost and with no wasted bandwidth. Instead, they got permission from the FCC to force everyone to have to have a cable box on EVERY TV they own -- each of which sucks power -- but to give it to customers "for free" for the first two years. After that, they were allowed to start charging us for each TA we have (and they do, and they have already raised the price twice).
 
FQD3HIHGSOEMPFR.MEDIUM.jpg
 
my bedroomr cable bos is set up to go out after 1 hour of not using it
my living room its set for 4 hourss its really annoying there is no steppe betwee n1 har and 4 hours. 2 hours would seem perfect for me. that cover pertty much most movies
I haven measure how much they use though

my wife i horrible bad at turing off the tv when she levaes the living room at it will just sit there and show the directTV logo for 1+ hours for no reason


I've always been focusse on watsed energy. that means energy consumption you can remove without missing any featurs/serivce. so i replaced our buld slowly with LED bulbs instead. and next step is to invest timers on our bathroom fans because e way to often they run the entire day by accidenten because we forget to turn them off.
i really wish there was a bigger er focus on energy consumtion in the genereal consumer market. and an easy way to distings if a product is having a high or low energy consumption
 
Why would anyone be surprised that a DVR uses 28 watts? It's basically a very low end PC. You can also get (at least with comcrap} one of the stand alone converters that don't do on demand or anything and those only use a few watts.
 
Maybe, but some people might be surprised that it is using 26 when it's supposed to be off. 'm not but that's only because I learned this years ago.
 
One of the reasons I ditched all of my cable boxes and went to HDHomerun. Save on the electricity (as well as box rental fees etc....)
All of the devices the HDHomerun served were already plugged in anyway, so 1 less device = less electricty and less wires to boot. Win-win.

Recently moved from that to Sony's Vue service, and got rid of even more wires, and more electricity savings.

I'm down to a 385kWh per month average. (although I've dipped as low as 290, and spiked at 510). And I work from home, TV is on 16 hours a day, mostly for background noise. PC is 24/7
I could cut even more by reducing those.

I tried to get solar, and even they said I already use so little it wouldn't be worth it.
 
The thing to think about is cable tv is sent along lines to be stored locally a head of time, it used to take weeks to stream the show and there was no storage so they simply looped cables at the closer sites, now it takes about two days to stream from the central offices so no one outside of holly wood sees the twist to shows before they go live... people still see stuff a head of time but this limits how much is spoiled since most of their ad dollars are based on saying so many eyes were looking at the screen even if you were in the kitchen making a samich during the commercials.

When I worked for Zoic the head of the studio was trying to get me trained to help his daughter who for all her intelligence could be a complete idiot at times, but that all fell apart when one of the artists found out about and preceded to try and get the interns to wreck the studio. They had to gut most of the staff if I remember correctly while I had to go work on another project.

But it is not the places where they have fast fiber it is places off the beaten path that barely have wires in the ground to them to show their shows in SD... I hope they are mostly upgraded soon, but the point is your cable box is basically an electric transmission line that is never off since it streams power to the box which is used to both confirm that the box is not being tampered with and descrypt the signals and do a bunch of other things.

So those kilowatt hours... I paid about thirty cents a kilowatt hour two hundred times thirty is six thousand or sixty bucks... if you can not afford that you might want to think about about the sixty bucks a month in your cable bill next time.

I am not in favor of wasting power but I do think that this country has cheap power because we use so much of it. If every one only needed say sixty watts a year to turn on your computer or all the lights in your house would cost a thousand dollars... I think it is a hundred pounds of coal is a gigawatt hour or a steady draw of a gigawatt of power and one fuel rod is power for ten years at that rate. Places like las vegas draws about fifty rods a year but las vegas uses the same power for the lights in one month that the rest of the country uses in a year... someone might have to check the numbers the last time I had to look it up was years ago.
 
One of the reasons I ditched all of my cable boxes and went to HDHomerun. Save on the electricity (as well as box rental fees etc....)
All of the devices the HDHomerun served were already plugged in anyway, so 1 less device = less electricty and less wires to boot. Win-win.

Recently moved from that to Sony's Vue service, and got rid of even more wires, and more electricity savings.

I'm down to a 385kWh per month average. (although I've dipped as low as 290, and spiked at 510). And I work from home, TV is on 16 hours a day, mostly for background noise. PC is 24/7
I could cut even more by reducing those.

I tried to get solar, and even they said I already use so little it wouldn't be worth it.


I don't think I've ever seen usage that low even in the smallest house I ever lived in. For my current home, a low usage month is about 1873 kWh (this April - fairly low heating or cooling). My highest usage month is usually July -- which for last July was 3058 kWh. Heating/cooling 4500 sq ft takes quite a bit of juice though. Of course my main desktop, and three HTPC/DVR's use a bit as well. Thankfully, my electricity is cheap at about 8.7 cents/kWh, and I don't think the actual electric part of my utility bill has ever exceeded $300.
 
I don't think I've ever seen usage that low even in the smallest house I ever lived in. For my current home, a low usage month is about 1873 kWh (this April - fairly low heating or cooling). My highest usage month is usually July -- which for last July was 3058 kWh. Heating/cooling 4500 sq ft takes quite a bit of juice though. Of course my main desktop, and three HTPC/DVR's use a bit as well. Thankfully, my electricity is cheap at about 8.7 cents/kWh, and I don't think the actual electric part of my utility bill has ever exceeded $300.

Yeah, I try to keep it low. My house is a 3200 sq ft colonial. According to the monthly reports, I'm the lowest usage in the neighborhood. By far. I think I can cut it down even more, but I have 2 young kids (10 and 11) who constantly forget to shut lights off, leave the TV on, etc....
I have my water bill down to 70-90 quarterly as well, and think I can reduce that too.

:)
 
We need more regulations to get these things regulated or we could wait until bernie wins the election and cable and electric will be free or wait for hillary to win and civil war to break out so no one will care.
Maybe they'll introduce that brand new idea and call it "Energy Star", which currently doesn't exist.
 
Back
Top