Game Dev Explains Why He Doesn't Like "Let's Play" Videos

And your assumption there would be 100% wrong. Which is why you shouldn't assume everyone only does or thinks the way you do. Had I not found a video posted the day the game was released for me to watch all 4 or 5 hours of the story I would have been at the store the next day to buy the game.

I have purchased every MK game for nothing more than the single player story. I even preordered the last two non fighting game editions to the story line. So I wasn't even thinking of not buying it even being an option till I saw the video looking for a few videos of normal fights from the game and found that instead.

So yes, I would have bought the game at full price for no other reason than to play through the single player mode but that person's video resulted in me not needed to. So they went from being able to make profit from a new release sell to making $1.
You can say that now... but there was a LP and you did buy it at a low price. On top of that, you could always be the outlier. Most people I know aren't satisfied with just watching an LP, especially on games like a fighting or ones that usually is focused on gameplay.

Personally I don't get the people who watch non-commentary play throughs, especially of linear story focused games like this, or Soma, or Gone Home, etc.

I do, ... I watch non commentary gameplay for games I've played and like the story of. In fact, before LPs even started, I had HD vids of the Soul Reaver games cutscenes purely for the story.

That said, I do get the movie argument, but with that in mind, these walking simulator games seemed, to me, that they should've just been movies.
 
Last edited:
It's called Fair Use. Adding commentary or critique to something marks it as Fair Use, or transformative. Whether or not you enjoy them is entirely irreverent, they are legal under the basis of the Fair Use laws. People make money off of other people's stuff all the time too. It's really no different than what singers like Weird Al or the few hundred parody music channels on Youtube do. Same with the thousands of musicians that make money by doing covers. Let's Players are doing nothing wrong and if they make money doing something they enjoy, so be it. Being pissy or jealous that people can make money playing games is rather petty.
I'm not so sure that publishing entire walktroughs of story driven games can fit into fair use. It's like uploading a whole movie. No matter how you stretch it, that won't fit into critique and commentary. You don't need to publish the entire story to be able to form a criticism. I'm sorry but I have to agree that let's plays that include the entire game is more of a negative influence on sales for a few hours long story driven games.

But for games where gameplay is more important than the story, it's actually good advertisement. I purchased xcom2 after watching let's plays of it.
 
You can say that now... but there was a LP and you did buy it at a low price. On top of that, you could always be the outlier. Most people I know aren't satisfied with just watching an LP, especially on games like a fighting or ones that usually is focused on gameplay.



I do, ... I watch non commentary gameplay for games I've played and like the story of. In fact, before LPs even started, I had HD vids of the Soul Reaver games cutscenes purely for the story.

That said, I do get the movie argument, but with that in mind, these walking simulator games seemed, to me, that they should've just been movies.


I understand watching cutscenes, or watching the stories of older games to catch up (I Did the same for Mass Effect when ME3 came out, or Metal gear solid when MGSV came out) but I am talking about watching new games that you haven't played and watch an entire lp of it instead of playing it yourself.

You mean Soul Reaver, would you have enjoyed simply watching someone play it and never playing it yourself?

Also "walking simulator" games have been around a while, many classic adventure games are the same way. The interactivity of them make them more than a movie and provide things a movie can not. Playing Gone Home is not the same as watching it.
 
How is this even a discussion? The basis of the defense is the these types of games are more like movies? That completely undermines the entire notion that streaming them with no or minimal commentary should be considered fair use. Last time I checked, YouTube doesn't allow people to stream movies so I don't understand how some of you think you're making a point in your favor when you argue that these Lets Plays are streaming games that are more like movies.
 
How is this even a discussion? The basis of the defense is the these types of games are more like movies? That completely undermines the entire notion that streaming them with no or minimal commentary should be considered fair use. Last time I checked, YouTube doesn't allow people to stream movies so I don't understand how some of you think you're making a point in your favor when you argue that these Lets Plays are streaming games that are more like movies.

Is it a game or a movie? We can't have developers intentionally confusing consumers and the law here.
 
What ever happened to demo's?

I mean, if you want to sell a game and you don't want someone else to influence your game, make a freaking demo of it then. People can watch if they want but they can also try the demo and see if it is worth purchasing. Not having a demo or a way to try the game to see if it even fits your taste in a game, well.... if you arn't sure about a game that you want to buy you just might watch a lets play or a stream on twitch or whatever before making that decision and then you are at the whim of the person that is showing off your game.
 
If they didn't claim it was a game and instead called it an interactive movie, they could (maybe should) have a stronger copyright claim, imho.
 
well having two family members that have had cancer I think id rather give my money to the Macmillan nurses than this game dev.
 
Honestly given how linear and how little interaction there is then i would guess that it is overreaching to call it a game, and after understanding that then it doesn't surprise me at all that it sold poorly.

Most surely whoever watched the LP didn't do it specifically because it was that game but because of the LPer. So, these developers get no sympathy from me, yes it took work on your part, but what you did doesn't qualify as a game to me and thus you should have adjusted your expectations to the fact that it was a non game!

And that is without entering in the subject matter, as i think that most of us have had someone close die to cancer at this point in time, sometimes fast, sometimes slow, but at least in my case, it isn't something i would like to dwell about actively.
 
Totall bullshit, I know that myself and just about everyone at work will watch letsplays' to see if a game looks interesting, to see how the interface runs, to see if it is easily understandable and you can navigate efficiently. Im not even sure people watch letsplays just for the sake of watching them (unless they don't have money in the first place to buy it)

|This developer needs to stop spreading his cancer (Pun)

Side note, his game looks like shit.
 
I'm not so sure that publishing entire walktroughs of story driven games can fit into fair use. It's like uploading a whole movie. No matter how you stretch it, that won't fit into critique and commentary. You don't need to publish the entire story to be able to form a criticism. I'm sorry but I have to agree that let's plays that include the entire game is more of a negative influence on sales for a few hours long story driven games.

But for games where gameplay is more important than the story, it's actually good advertisement. I purchased xcom2 after watching let's plays of it.

It depends entirely upon the game. This games was never going to sell well. The art style is incredibly weird and off putting to a lot of people. The subject matter turns people away quickly. Combined with the general stigma attached to "Walking Simulators" it was doomed from the start. There are thousands of LPs out there for other "Walking Simulators" and yet some of them sell pretty well. Dear Ester, Firewatch, Vanishing of Ethan Carter, Gone Home, etc have all sold rather well despite tons of Let's Plays. Then there are the myriad of adventure games these days. Despite Let's Plays a lot of them sell well. Let's Plays expose more people to games then it turns away. Even if someone goes looking for a Let's Play to help decide if they want to buy a game, I'd argue that even if the LP turns them away they probably wouldn't have bought it in the first place so no sale is lost. The reality of game development is: Most games will fail. For some reason they simply don't manage to capture a big enough audience. There can be any number of reasons why, but there is never only one reason. The video game market is pretty much a free market, it's all up to the customers to decide what does and does not succeed. Unless it's one of the handful of major franchises in a genre there is absolutely zero guarantee of success. The developer is looking for something to blame instead of reflecting on why the game never managed to capture the audience that loves these types of games that are all about the "experience".
 
I understand watching cutscenes, or watching the stories of older games to catch up (I Did the same for Mass Effect when ME3 came out, or Metal gear solid when MGSV came out) but I am talking about watching new games that you haven't played and watch an entire lp of it instead of playing it yourself.

You mean Soul Reaver, would you have enjoyed simply watching someone play it and never playing it yourself?

Also "walking simulator" games have been around a while, many classic adventure games are the same way. The interactivity of them make them more than a movie and provide things a movie can not. Playing Gone Home is not the same as watching it.
Honestly, I don't think so. But that was just my reasoning on it. Actually, no. I tried to watch the Blood Omen 2 playthrough and I could not do so without constantly skipping and ultimately missing most of the story.

I disagree about the walking simulator statement though. Do correct me, if I'm wrong here, but Gone Home and such has no failure state right? No way to "lose"? Because that is the difference for me. Take the king quest games for example. You can royally fuck yourself if you didn't collect things an hour earlier.
 
It's like how some game dev/pub don't want to release demos of their games because they want you to get suckered into buying it first to find out how shitty it is.
 
Honestly, I don't think so. But that was just my reasoning on it. Actually, no. I tried to watch the Blood Omen 2 playthrough and I could not do so without constantly skipping and ultimately missing most of the story.

I disagree about the walking simulator statement though. Do correct me, if I'm wrong here, but Gone Home and such has no failure state right? No way to "lose"? Because that is the difference for me. Take the king quest games for example. You can royally fuck yourself if you didn't collect things an hour earlier.

There are plenty of classic point and click adventure games that have no fail state at all. The main example being probably the most famous and most influential classic adventure game series, Myst.

It's pretty much like any "walking simulator" as people refer to them these days, only it was much muuuuuuuch harder and contained more use of puzzles to piece things together. It was still all about you walking around, exploring, and figuring things out for yourself.
 
Isn't Myst a puzzle game? I wouldn't put those in the same category. Where as, from what I've heard, Gone Home and the like lacks any of that.
 
Gone Home isn't heavily puzzle based no, but others are.

The Vanishing of Ethan Carter had puzzles and things to overcome.

Even with a lack of traditional puzzles in Gone Home there are "secrets" and hidden things that you will miss and not get if you aren't paying attention or don't "figure" it out by thinking and using your brain. Like the secret diary, the story about the uncle, hidden areas, etc.
 
If Ethan Carter had puzzles, then it wouldn't be one I was including. From what hear, your interactions in Gone Home doesn't change anything except from furthering the story... like pressing play.
 
If Ethan Carter had puzzles, then it wouldn't be one I was including. From what hear, your interactions in Gone Home doesn't change anything except from furthering the story... like pressing play.

It's not like pressing "play," you have to piece together secrets and find hidden things to uncover the full story, some of which you can outright miss and still "complete" the game.
 
I just think we'll find out that, according to developers, no game sucks anymore.. If a game doesn't make a ton of money it's because it was Lets Played or pirated. The game was great but we were ripped off!
 
Caveat to that is that, their games doesn't suck, and it was due to piracy/LPs. :D
 
I view let's plays as the modern demo and they have gotten me to buy games that I would not have had much interest in just from written reviews or your standard PR info/game trailer. A lot of dev's should be very thankful for video reviews/let's plays and cheaper games via online distribution like steam sales to get as many sales as they now do.

Totalbiscuit has a decent take on this situation in a video about it. He favors better controls for defining what is copyright violation by creators via youtube for things like music content. That is about the only legit complaint this dev makes in my opinion. As a cancer survivor (a minor form thankfully) I don't care to play this type of game. I might watch a video of someone playing it but probably not. I'm sure as heck not going to pay $15 for it, especially if it is a game type I don't enjoy and is only 2 hours long.
 
Is it really too much to ask for the Let's Play people to put a link to the developer's site on the comment block? Or to mention how to purchase it in the video? That's all the guy is asking.

It doesn't matter if it's a "shit game", only two hours long, you hate cancer games, or whatever else you can dream up to disagree with someone trying to make a dollar. IMHO - it should be common courtesy to link back to the online store.
 
Is it really too much to ask for the Let's Play people to put a link to the developer's site on the comment block? Or to mention how to purchase it in the video? That's all the guy is asking.

It doesn't matter if it's a "shit game", only two hours long, you hate cancer games, or whatever else you can dream up to disagree with someone trying to make a dollar. IMHO - it should be common courtesy to link back to the online store.

A link to a website or saying "buy this game if you like it" won't do shit for sales. If a person wants a game after looking at it, the five seconds it takes to find where to purchase it won't make a difference and neither will it make any difference to people that aren't interested in the game.
 
A link to a website or saying "buy this game if you like it" won't do shit for sales. If a person wants a game after looking at it, the five seconds it takes to find where to purchase it won't make a difference and neither will it make any difference to people that aren't interested in the game.
While I agree with you, it does streamline the process...

And a link would, if they track it can help show people the numbers. But no, it really won't actually help with sales is my belief.
 
While I agree with you, it does streamline the process...

And a link would, if they track it can help show people the numbers. But no, it really won't actually help with sales is my belief.

I can see an argument for linking if, say, the game is only sold on the developer's own website or some more obscure digital platform. Now if a LPer or streamer gets an early key or is given a key from a developer or publisher then I'd say they should, at least, put a link to the game's website in the description of the video or stream. In general, I think a simple rule to follow with this stuff is "Don't be a dick".
 
Is it really too much to ask for the Let's Play people to put a link to the developer's site on the comment block? Or to mention how to purchase it in the video? That's all the guy is asking.

It doesn't matter if it's a "shit game", only two hours long, you hate cancer games, or whatever else you can dream up to disagree with someone trying to make a dollar. IMHO - it should be common courtesy to link back to the online store.

A link to a website or saying "buy this game if you like it" won't do shit for sales. If a person wants a game after looking at it, the five seconds it takes to find where to purchase it won't make a difference and neither will it make any difference to people that aren't interested in the game.

It doesn't matter what you think; this is someone's created content that is more akin to a story than a game, and streaming the entirety of it is detrimental to its sale. You don't get to take someone else's work and not pay for it simply because you don't like it.
 
It doesn't matter what you think; this is someone's created content that is more akin to a story than a game, and streaming the entirety of it is detrimental to its sale. You don't get to take someone else's work and not pay for it simply because you don't like it.

Sure you can, Steam has a two hour return policy which is apparently plenty to "beat" the game and be disappointed.
 
Sure you can, Steam has a two hour return policy which is apparently plenty to "beat" the game and be disappointed.

Let me rephrase. You can return it on your own. But I find it very shitty to stream it to a huge audience, some of whom may have enjoyed it and then not needed to pay. If you didn't like it, whatever, but I feel liking or disliking it does not matter as to whether or not it is right to do a complete playthrough of a primarily story based game.
 
It doesn't matter what you think; this is someone's created content that is more akin to a story than a game, and streaming the entirety of it is detrimental to its sale. You don't get to take someone else's work and not pay for it simply because you don't like it.

Oh no it might convince a handful of people that were on the fence not to buy it. Or, oh my god, it might show that a game sucks and people shouldn't buy it. Of course, on the other hand it could have the exact opposite effect. Most games fail, period. That is all there is to it. The reasons are numerous and it is fucking retarded to point the blame solely at people playing it on Youtube or Twitch. They made a game and for whatever reasons it failed to capture an audience. It happens to most games released. The developer CHOSE to make a walking simulator, a very niche genre that does not have a massive, consistent, player base. They CHOSE to make the game look like it does. Sorry, but that art style seems to be rather unappealing to people. They CHOSE to tell the story they did. Telling people you are going to watch a young child suffer and die from cancer is not exactly material a lot of people will flock to. They CHOSE to make it very short. A lot of people don't like games that short, that is simple fact. They CHOSE to charge $15 for it. Not a terrible price, but combined with everything else it's another nail in the coffin. The game had zero chance of making a big impact, even before it released. The incredibly insignificantly small number of people genuinely turned off by watching someone else play are essentially irrelevant. I would argue that, by and large, LPs and streams HELP a fuck load more games than they hurt. If YT and Twitch didn't exist this game would still sell poorly. They would just need to find a new excuse for it. LPs and streams are FAIR USE. Until such a time that it is challenged in court they are considered legal and protected under Fair Use laws. Whether or not you agree with that is, quite frankly, irrelevant and does not remotely belong in this discussion. Personal feelings on legal matters are useless.
 
LPs and streams are FAIR USE. Until such a time that it is challenged in court they are considered legal and protected under Fair Use laws. Whether or not you agree with that is, quite frankly, irrelevant and does not remotely belong in this discussion. Personal feelings on legal matters are useless.

Totally agree with your final sentence, but I think that a LP/Stream of what is simply a story stretches fair use, just like playing a full movie and making comments throughout.
 
Totally agree with your final sentence, but I think that a LP/Stream of what is simply a story stretches fair use, just like playing a full movie and making comments throughout.

There might be an argument to be made, but at the same time these story or experience only games still do well despite LPs and streams. The Witness, Gone Home, Firewatch, Dear Esther, The Stanley Parable, etc. They've all captured the right audience through a combination of things, including exposure from influential media personalities. Now, there is a crucial difference between those and That Dragon, Cancer. That is the whole idea of mystery and discovery. There really isn't a mystery or anything to discover from this game. They tell you up front what it is and what will happen. I think that might be one of the big things that lead to it's failure. Firewatch is a good example of how to design an experience focused game around several tough subjects. The opening that explains why the main character is there and the way the game presents it's story, the mystery about it, and the interaction with the only other person in the game. The game is entirely linear but you are still asked to decide how the character responds to situations and to figure out what you think he would do after the end of the game.
 
Totally agree with your final sentence, but I think that a LP/Stream of what is simply a story stretches fair use, just like playing a full movie and making comments throughout.
You shouldn't agree with his sentences because he's wrong.

One can not simply claim that *all* Let's Play videos are or are not "fair use."
The specifics of this situation indicate the Let's Play videos were *not* fair use. Specifically, the videos are described violate subsections 3 and 4 of 17 US Code 107 (which governs fair use).
 
Back
Top