Debunking Myths About Video Game Developers

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
While I am not sure who actually believes any of these myths are true, the responses from the developers definitely make this article worth reading.

What’s more, a lot of what people think they know about game development is actually misconception. We spoke to a number of game developers who told us about the biggest things people get wrong about game development, and below is where, in their own words, these developers debunk common myths.
 
DLC providing job security, is not my fucking problem.

So don't buy it ... DLC is actually a good thing for gaming (yes I know that sounds blasphemous coming from a gamer) ... before DLC we only got expansions (expensive and time consuming add ons) or nothing ... there was little incentive for most developers (besides companies like Blizzard) to continue to provide lots of content for nothing

With the modern development environment a lot of companies lay their teams off once a game is finished and hire them back (or hire new teams) when they are ready to start a new project ... DLC does provide a nice bridge to keep the teams intact and producing content for a game until the next version of it can be developed ... although a few companies abuse DLC, the majority of companies who use it do so responsibly and in ways that enhance game play and allow game customization the way the users want it
 
So don't buy it ... DLC is actually a good thing for gaming (yes I know that sounds blasphemous coming from a gamer) ... before DLC we only got expansions (expensive and time consuming add ons) or nothing ... there was little incentive for most developers (besides companies like Blizzard) to continue to provide lots of content for nothing

With the modern development environment a lot of companies lay their teams off once a game is finished and hire them back (or hire new teams) when they are ready to start a new project ... DLC does provide a nice bridge to keep the teams intact and producing content for a game until the next version of it can be developed ... although a few companies abuse DLC, the majority of companies who use it do so responsibly and in ways that enhance game play and allow game customization the way the users want it

DLC Done RIGHT is a good thing. Now we RARELY get expansions (which I prefer more than tiny bits), instead, we get a game with 40% of its on-disk content locked off behind a paywall. That is not 'DLC' because there is no 'DL' involved. its just 'C', and before, we got all of the 'C' by purchasing the game once. Now we pay for it twice, thrice or however many times the publisher decided to chop it up.
 
So don't buy it ... DLC is actually a good thing for gaming (yes I know that sounds blasphemous coming from a gamer) ... before DLC we only got expansions (expensive and time consuming add ons) or nothing ...
And now we don't get expansions. It can vary a lot on the game, but DLC is the equivalent of Cheetos, whereas expansions were a full-course meal. A good expansion can be as good as the original game. A good DLC still feels short and almost always feels like something that shoould have just been in the original game, or added in an expansion. I like playing a full game, not 10% of one, which is what DLC usually is.

Plus, everyone loves seeing messages saying "buy more shit!" inside your game that you've already bought, right? That totally doesn't cheapen the experience at all. The companies that sell DLC are not barely scraping buy, they're powerhouses that are extracting maximum cash. The fact that they treat developers slightly less like garbage when they're selling DLC isn't a good argument for the gamer. Their game still gets cheapened by sliced up bits that in the past would have added up to something cohesive.



[/QUOTE]
 
So don't buy it ... DLC is actually a good thing for gaming (yes I know that sounds blasphemous coming from a gamer) ... before DLC we only got expansions (expensive and time consuming add ons) or nothing ... there was little incentive for most developers (besides companies like Blizzard) to continue to provide lots of content for nothing

With the modern development environment a lot of companies lay their teams off once a game is finished and hire them back (or hire new teams) when they are ready to start a new project ... DLC does provide a nice bridge to keep the teams intact and producing content for a game until the next version of it can be developed ... although a few companies abuse DLC, the majority of companies who use it do so responsibly and in ways that enhance game play and allow game customization the way the users want it

This is like one huge strawman argument. Is there anyone who thinks that profit from DLC doesn't benefit the publishers/game developers? No. It may in fact do exactly what you say it does. But that's not the problem with DLC. DLC more often than not is developed at the same time as the "core" product. It's often released at the same time. And when it comes to testing and validation this means that the DLC content is really apart of the core game just behind another paywall which really wasn't there before. It means that before, a game cost 50 bucks or so at launch, but in order to get the entire game you are in reality likely paying closer to 70 bucks for the complete game. It's an artificial increase in game pricing more often than not.

Now there are some development studios that do DLC well enough that the additional cost is worth it, but lets not fool ourselves in believing that easter eggs, different color costumes (Street Fighter anyone?) or one special level was something that didn't exist before DLC.
 
On a fundamental level this is the age of not questioning, not thinking, and believing nice little fantasies. There's no place for mythbusters in this world.
 
On a fundamental level this is the age of not questioning, not thinking, and believing nice little fantasies.
4743204-9985367102-4QmbI.gif


Whoa. Deep man.
 
This is like one huge strawman argument. Is there anyone who thinks that profit from DLC doesn't benefit the publishers/game developers? No. It may in fact do exactly what you say it does. But that's not the problem with DLC. DLC more often than not is developed at the same time as the "core" product. It's often released at the same time. And when it comes to testing and validation this means that the DLC content is really apart of the core game just behind another paywall which really wasn't there before. It means that before, a game cost 50 bucks or so at launch, but in order to get the entire game you are in reality likely paying closer to 70 bucks for the complete game. It's an artificial increase in game pricing more often than not.

Now there are some development studios that do DLC well enough that the additional cost is worth it, but lets not fool ourselves in believing that easter eggs, different color costumes (Street Fighter anyone?) or one special level was something that didn't exist before DLC.

Who's using the strawman now ... as I said there are clearly some violators ... but since PC games have essentially remained fixed in price since the early 2000's you can't blame developers from trying to make a little extra income ... we still have companies like Blizzard who do full out expansions (and people scream like bloody murder about the price and features) ... we have companies like Bethesda that offer DLC over the course of a year or more so they were clearly not included in the original game (and some of them, like changing the ending to Fallout, are a response to user inputs) ... PC gaming is always experiencing more downward pressure in pricing (even while development costs are soaring) so I don't begrudge a good developer who comes up with decent DLC the opportunity to make their development profitable ... but I also agree that we should call out the bad ones who use the money grab but don't offer any true value
 
I wouldn't say the myth of DLC is busted at all. This can be beat til we're red in the faces, but I don't recall games back in the 90's announce Expansion Packs well before the game ever shipped. No, that would be stupid as it would be considered back then because of the very reasons that are often brought to the debate with DLC. People don't want to feel as though the product they are spending massive dollars on is somehow being intentionally crippled to release it as a separate add-on. If this is a complete illusion and we all have this ass backwards, then it's the gaming industries fault for causing this misconception, NOT the consumer.

At least with Expansion Packs of old we got often times 25-50% or more new content for a not too bad of a price. Can't tell you how many times you see simple skin packs costing $5 or more. Simple cosmetic items that require next to no testing or development outside of the artists time. They are making boat loads of money for doing literally nothing and have got away with it (for the most part) because it hasn't affected actual gameplay. The minute it starts altering the game it becomes a problem (look at Payday 2 recently). Game Developers know EXACTLY how to squeeze consumers these days. They learn from those around them what works and what doesn't and every now and then they'll go all EA on your ass and just make it so you need DLC if you want to continue having a multiplayer experience.
 
DLC providing job security, is not my fucking problem.

Today's DLC is the 90's WC Secret Missions Disk (which between WC and WC2 there was at least 3 of them) as well as an add on that added voices.

I don't think I bought the latter, but I was more than willing to by the former.

Game Developers Don’t Care About Bugs

I've never thought that. My gut says games ship with bugs, because bean counters want the game out now, even though they know about the bugs. I've seen this in the Corporate world where doing so meant months of pain for the development teams, support groups and up to a million customers. Why? Because all but the support groups are on salary so the pushing dev teams 60-80 hours a week for a few months (after launch) doesn't cost them money (until the help quits).
 
The first one already is a big minefield. When educated gamers refer to developers as being lazy, they doesn't actually mean they dip out of work, or whistle with their legs on the desk. Lazy in this case means cutting corners, doing it quick and dirty instead, of right.

After reading forward, I must reiterate. THEY ARE LAZY. 40 hours of work per week is the norm, for most people, not a crunch. The crunch is when you don't see your family for weeks, and only go home to shower once or twice a week, that's a crunch, not lousy 40 hours/week. I know he said well over 40 hours, but that can mean anything. He was cautious for a reason. If fhe could honestly say they put in 60-80 hours of work / week he'd have said that without a heartbeat, and not this 40+ hours bs.

Misconception: Game Development Is Easy

Easy means nothing, easy compared to what? I do think it's easy compared to working in a coal mine, or in construction in Quatar.

You can't just copy&paste completed building blocks either. The fact of the matter is that game development is easy, compared to most physical jobs.

A Good Idea Is All a Game Needs

Said noone ever. Except developers when defending themselves.

DLC Is Evil

Said noone ever, again. Pay to win, and day0 DLCs are.

I thought we were looking at things from the customers standpoint. What do I get out of Day0 DLCs? And saying it's not something cut from the original game is just a lie. How many times during development do you think the following sentence is uttered "That's a good idea, let's save it for a DLC"? Again "cut from the main game" doesn't neccessarily mean it was finished and ready to ship then cut from the game. It just means they witheld some features or content as DLC. But of course there are the cases when it's actually finished and on the freaking game disk, but you still have to pay to unlock it.

All Game Developers Are Rich

Never heard this one either. Many senior developers are well paid, but not rich. But rich is again a relative word. Compared to who?

Realistic Graphics Mean a Better Game

If you have two identical games, and one has better graphics, then which is the better game I ask? Hint: not the one with worse graphics.

You can't neglect any part of the game, gameplay for graphics, or graphics for gameplay either. But when you start showing off your game, the first thing potential buyers see is the graphics. So don't expect to get much hype with shitty graphics.

Everything a Developer Does Is for Profit

So they're not doing it for profit, they're doing it for return of investment. That's just using a different word for it. :rolleyes:

Game Developers Don’t Care About Bugs

So hundreds of thousands of people are just outliers? It's not that developers don't care about bugs, they don't care about fixing them before release if it means delaying the "return of investment". And they care even less about fixing them after release, they put a skeleton crew on it at most, and you end up waiting weeks or even months for a fix, while you just can't play the game you forked out 60 or more for. Take Mad Max for example.

“Casual” Games Don’t Matter

Casuel games don't matter to gamers. Whining about it doesn't change that. If making casual games is such a great thing, why don't you do that? Oh, so it's not that great after all? Didn't think so for second.

Players Always Know What’s Best for a Game

In the end they're the ones playing it, so they should know what they want in a game. And that's the truth. Of course you can't cater for everyone's wishes, but that doesn't make their wishes any less real.
 
wow, there are ppl who think game dev is easy and game devs are lazy? Sheesh, there's an eye opener for me!
 
I don't mind DLC, I like the added content to the games. I do miss expansions bringing new life into a game. I feel that DLC needs to be faster though, bringing out your first small packs 6months later is too far and the game has been beaten and shelved and not likely to come back off shelf for a $10 DLC pack. I feel all potential DLC should be exhausted by the 6month marker. After that point the game is still at the $60 price point and with DLC already out there, could look more tempting to buy. At 1 year the $60 pack with all DLC should come out. I have no data or reasons, just my personal thoughts.
 
The early ones are clearly myths, but the ones at the end are actually true. For example, "Misconception: Everything a Developer Does Is for Profit" and "Misconception: “Casual” Games Don’t Matter" directly conflict with each other. The author, who is clearly very sympathetic to game developers, wants to have it both ways.
 
Reading it I agree with this article. Sure there are some shady exceptions with DLC and stuff. You’re bound to have some of that. As a whole I think it is pretty right on.
 
Former (burnt-out) game programmer here. Generally, nobody really gave a shit as far as how long you worked, as long as everything got done in a timely manner and it was before the cut-off for that piece of the project (barring bugs and issues of course, which comes later).

To add to that, nobody sits there actually working the full 9 hour (1 hour lunch generally) workday. You probably only do 3-4 hours of real work, where the other 4-5 hours are spent eating, walking around/exercising, goofing off, taking way too many shits, coffee breaks, etc. People in general are lazy, though I've definitely seen it more in the two studios I worked in.

You do what you're told, and that's really it. There is not much room for negotiation when things are already dialed in. Generally, not really the developers fault when the timelines are so constricted and things are missed.
 
The article seems to get derailed at various points. Much of it ceases to be about developers and starts to be about games themselves. I thought this article was "Myths about Game Developers", not "Myths about Games"... or rather, it's not even disproving a myth so much as it is countering an opinion. The most salient example of this is "Misconception: Realistic Graphics Mean a Better Game". What the hell does this have to do with someone's conception of game developers? Rather what does it have to do with debunking myths at all?



Putting that aside, much of the rest is kind of obvious. DLC is again another point that has little to do with game developers as it does with games themselves. I mean, what myth were they trying to debunk? "DLC is Evil" is an opinion. It's not a myth that you can debunk, it's something that you can simply give a different spin to when taken from another's perspective. In this case, that perspective is the game developers. Considering their earnings are likely in some way correlated to what the game itself makes, I don't see who in their right minds would think that game developers would not be better off due to DLC. That's the only myth they could debunk, but it was never a myth and it never needed debunking.



Long story short, this article sucks.
 
wow, there are ppl who think game dev is easy and game devs are lazy? Sheesh, there's an eye opener for me!
Surprisingly I see a lot of people online who think all game development involves is using something like Unreal Editor. Never mind the market research, fleshing out an idea, figuring out how gameplay is going to work, figuring out how to program those ideas so they work on the screen, designing a color scheme and UI that is easy for the majority of the targeted audience to use, researching and designing sound, creating models, animating, etc., etc., etc.,

etc.
etc.
etc.
...
 
I don't mind DLC, I like the added content to the games. I do miss expansions bringing new life into a game. I feel that DLC needs to be faster though, bringing out your first small packs 6months later is too far and the game has been beaten and shelved and not likely to come back off shelf for a $10 DLC pack. I feel all potential DLC should be exhausted by the 6month marker. After that point the game is still at the $60 price point and with DLC already out there, could look more tempting to buy. At 1 year the $60 pack with all DLC should come out. I have no data or reasons, just my personal thoughts.

It depends on the game. In the case of Dragon Age Inquisition I was thrilled to finish just the main game, and no DLC could've convinced me to continue the grind. Actually the first DLC was already out when I finally finished the game.

On the other hand in the case of Mass Effect 2 or Mass Effect 3 for example I wouldn't mind if they were releasing a DLC to this day every 6 months or so. Because the games were so good that I enjoyed starting a new playtrough for each DLC, I finished ME2 at least a dozen times in 3 years.
 
Back
Top