What Snowden Got Wrong About Eavesdropping On Aliens

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
So you mean that stealing documents from the government and releasing them to the public doesn't make you an expert on aliens? That's odd. :p

Snowden went on to suggest that if humans overheard aliens communicating amongst themselves—if humans were to pick up the alien version of a telephone call or television broadcast—it might be so well encrypted that it would be invisible among the radio chatter of the natural universe. But that's not necessarily the case, Shostak said, because even general broadcast signals would have narrow-band components that humans might notice.
 
Well shit. That actually makes sense. Sort of like the ultimate spread-spectrum cordless phone.
 
Except that we are far past this point ourselves already.

See, a good twenty years or more ago, we came up with what was commonly called back then, Frequency-Hopping Radios, radios which were able to rapidly change frequency in order to make it very difficult to intercept them. This wasn't the same as encryption but when combined with encryption you can see the physical and technical issues invovled with trying to capture and understand the signals.

Well, this begs the question, how do you handle the first part, the rapidly switching frequency aspect? I suppose you just grab everything, suck up the entire spectrum and record it all. Then you use other parameters like signal strength, point of origin, crystal count, etc to find the pieces of the puzzle and stick them all together again as if they were one contigeous transmission. Now you only have the encryption to deal with.

So the "ultimate spread spectrum phone" has been around for a long time already, and it's not really any harder to listen too it then any other, just takes the right equipment and a little processing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frequency-hopping_spread_spectrum

http://www.google.com/patents/US20030103589
 
Finally, the guy says something that gives credibility to what I've been saying all along: Snowden is not as smart as he thinks he is, and maybe more importantly, he is not this infallible demigod of a person.


Now, let's say an advanced species was using something like quantum entanglement communication or something, or some other type of technology that is far beyond or capability, and possibly even our basic understanding of things in general - that's very plausible.
 
Let's not forget, even if we did hear and record alien transmissions we would have next to no chance of understanding the language. Without a common root language we would basically have no basis to get started on a translation. In person we could eventually learn to communicate but off of a transmission lacking video? I doubt it.
 
It must suck to be as constantly under attack as Snowden is. I'd say every person on the planet makes an off the cuff remark about something they don't know much about 10+ times a day. This doesn't even warrant an article. I don't think anyone with half a brain seriously thinks they can genuinely understand the motivations of hypothetical aliens that may or may not resemble us in any meaningful way and what technologies they might have.

And no one is as smart as they think they are, especially people commenting on message boards.
 
It must suck to be as constantly under attack as Snowden is. I'd say every person on the planet makes an off the cuff remark about something they don't know much about 10+ times a day. This doesn't even warrant an article. I don't think anyone with half a brain seriously thinks they can genuinely understand the motivations of hypothetical aliens that may or may not resemble us in any meaningful way and what technologies they might have.

And no one is as smart as they think they are, especially people commenting on message boards.

Snowden voluntarily goes on talk shows with high profile people because he's a narcissist. Everyday people who make off the cuff remarks don't have that opportunity.
 
Let's not forget, even if we did hear and record alien transmissions we would have next to no chance of understanding the language. Without a common root language we would basically have no basis to get started on a translation. In person we could eventually learn to communicate but off of a transmission lacking video? I doubt it.

Ummm maybe. I fully understand what you are saying and I agree that you have a valid point, one far more relevent then this crap about encryption being the big roadblock to understanding alien communications or preventing us from even being aware of their presence.

But I would point out that even without a common root language, form follows function. Yes, it is entirely possible that an alien species could rely on a form of communication that is far different from our own. Pheromones ring any bells? Imaging an Alien species whose use of pheromones for communication is as advanced above how Ants use it as our use of spoken language is above Chimps. We still have challenges right here on our own planet, I don't think anyone has come to a complete understanding with how dolphines communicate as in being able to talk to dolpines "like a native speaker".

But at the same time, it is no more wild a possability that an alien species could have developed a similar form of language not that different from one of our own. I think that the more in common the envornment the aliens evolved in is with our own, the greater the chance that communication might be similar in function. I would expect them to speak High German, but if they are close to us physically at least a spoken language that is recognizable as such is possible, maybe even probable.
 
It must suck to be as constantly under attack as Snowden is. I'd say every person on the planet makes an off the cuff remark about something they don't know much about 10+ times a day. This doesn't even warrant an article. I don't think anyone with half a brain seriously thinks they can genuinely understand the motivations of hypothetical aliens that may or may not resemble us in any meaningful way and what technologies they might have.

And no one is as smart as they think they are, especially people commenting on message boards.

Ummm, man, professionals in excellent standing take part on messgae boards, forums, world wide. Don't feel sorry for Snowden, there is plenty he has done that he needs to answer for. This article didn't result from an "off the cuff remark". this comment was part of an arguement he is pushing for the wide spread addoption of higher encryption standards free from government control or involvment. He is pushing an agenda where free people have the same level of protection in their communications as our own government/military enjoys. Noble on the one hand, perhaps foolish on the other. Either way, his arguement and reference to aliens has a hole in it the size of Alaska and it is not being cruel or demeaning to point it out.
 
Snowden voluntarily goes on talk shows with high profile people because he's a narcissist. Everyday people who make off the cuff remarks don't have that opportunity.

^This.


The first thing the fanboys want to do is say "poor Snowden, he's a VICTIM" every time someone else wants to paint him in an unfavorable light. He's been the one selling the "victim" angle from day one, and sadly, there is a large group of people that are buying it up like Charlie Sheen at his drug dealer's house.
 
I doubt electromagnetic radiation is being used for communication by any advanced species.

Hell, even we have developed a methodology for producing entangled atoms. An advanced alien race most likely is beyond even this technology.
 
Ummm maybe. I fully understand what you are saying and I agree that you have a valid point, one far more relevent then this crap about encryption being the big roadblock to understanding alien communications or preventing us from even being aware of their presence.

But I would point out that even without a common root language, form follows function. Yes, it is entirely possible that an alien species could rely on a form of communication that is far different from our own. Pheromones ring any bells? Imaging an Alien species whose use of pheromones for communication is as advanced above how Ants use it as our use of spoken language is above Chimps. We still have challenges right here on our own planet, I don't think anyone has come to a complete understanding with how dolphines communicate as in being able to talk to dolpines "like a native speaker".

But at the same time, it is no more wild a possability that an alien species could have developed a similar form of language not that different from one of our own. I think that the more in common the envornment the aliens evolved in is with our own, the greater the chance that communication might be similar in function. I would expect them to speak High German, but if they are close to us physically at least a spoken language that is recognizable as such is possible, maybe even probable.

That's kind of my point. With humans speaking an unknown language we have context and we can make some educated guesses about gestures, body language etc. to determine at least some basic way to communicate. With alien life we literally have no idea. We can't assume anything about how they would communicate. It would take a great deal of observation to even get an idea of where to start. If all we had was an intercepted audio transmission we'd have virtually nothing to go on. Encryption would be the least of our problems. And quite frankly an alien race attempting to communicate with us would probably make it as easy as they could. So I wouldn't worry about encryption.
 
So let's assume a species does advance to something like highly advanced communication imperceptible to humans due to its advanced encryption or whatever. It'd also be fair to assume they didn't just advance from discovering fire to discovering quantum entanglement, they probably progressed, and at some point in their technological progression were broadcasting radio waves out into space that we could pick up. Then at some point that species would "go dark" if they switched over, but we'd still "hear" them at some point in their evolution if we had sensitive enough equipment.
 
Snowden clearly doesn't have the proper hair to be an authority on aliens.
 
Snowden clearly doesn't have the proper hair to be an authority on aliens.



0d087a61048510d127736673e8e21b68b7c51a27ab33d441f7934274fd84caf9.jpg
 
Back
Top