T-Mobile Wants To Stop Network Abusers

So having it writing that I get 7GB tethering a month (per device for me so 14GB total between my phone and the wife's) isn't clear enough? I find 7GB pretty reasonable as I still have Internet at home too.

Unlimited mobile data is not there to replace your home Internet connection like some of these people are doing.

Not to mention let's not ignore the fact that these people abusing the system signed a ToS in good faith to NOT do stuff like this. I love how that's glossed over by so many people who jump on the bandwagon and say "data is data no matter what". That's fine believe in what you believe in but don't sign that ToS and then say well I don't agree with that so I'll do it my way.

Personally, I'm still trying to wrap my head about the whole 2TB of data in a month. The average 2 hour movie 1080p in mp4 format is roughly 2GB. That means 200GB for 100 movies. That's still a far cry from 2TB. So honestly WTF is that person doing and why are people defending them?

If the terms say 7GB then all well and good as long as they don't dictate "how" that data can be consumed, it's not their business how, that 7gb's already been paid for, that's all I'm arguing here. They can't turn around and say "oh, and if you wanna tether that 7gb then pay extra" because they are not providing any extra service for that feature, it's just an artificial distinction.
 
T-Mobile's service is fast as hell in my area, and more reliable than Comcast imo.

Yeah, checking speedtest (while flawed I'm sure) I get 45Mbps from my house, unfortunately I don't have a need to have an unlimited plan at LTE speeds, but I like the fact that if I do exceed an allotment it simply goes slower, and I don't get some mystery bill that says I owe $13000 because I went over my data during the solstice in the airport of a foreign country, etc etc etc.
 
And you do have unlimited data, the fact someone used 2TB of data in a month kind of shows that, however they do say you only get X amount of 4G LTE speeds via tethering, you still get unlimited data just at slower speeds if you exceed that amount while tethering.

For some of you bitching and moaning about "it's my data how I use it..." geezus, you must be some of the people they're talking about in the article who willfully hide the fact you're tethering in order to get around the known policies, and yes they obviously are known since you're fucking circumventing it, so don't give me this "well they say unlimited" garbage.

It's called false advertising or misrepresentation of services offered. Don't call something unlimited that has clear limits.
 
If I visit a webpage on my phone that's OK, but if I tether my phone to my laptop and then visit the same webpage on the laptop then I need to pay extra for that? It's the same data. How can you steal data that you've already paid for? The carriers are the ones stealing... stealing money from people who pay extra for tethering.

It has always been like that. It doesn't apply to most plans that operate with a bucket of data (say 3 GB), but if you have unlimited data it's unlimited for you phone. Without hacking, it will likely be unlimited if the tethered device is a tablet.

The reason it's limited, is because wireless bandwidth is far more limited than your home connection. There's a reason why data cards for laptops/pcs cost more/month and almost always have a data cap.

I'd be shocked if anyone on here has a contract that doesn't say something about tethering. My flip phone contract from 11 years ago had it, but I can't imagine tethering at 1x.
 
If the terms say 7GB then all well and good as long as they don't dictate "how" that data can be consumed, it's not their business how, that 7gb's already been paid for, that's all I'm arguing here. They can't turn around and say "oh, and if you wanna tether that 7gb then pay extra" because they are not providing any extra service for that feature, it's just an artificial distinction.

For T-Mobile's Unlimited data plan, it's unlimited for smartphones, and includes a 7GB bucket for Wifi/USB/Bluetooth tethering, after you've consumed that 7GB, bandwidth drops to 128kbps while tethering.

When just using your phone, you still get full LTE speeds (until you routinely hit 21+GB in an area with a lot of LTE users, then your data is 'deprioritized').

I had my laptop tethered to my phone a while back, and I got the message that I had already exhausted my 7GB bucket. Come to find out, it downloaded everything needed to upgrade to Win10 without even notifying me that it was doing so.

The problem is that people are changing things to make it like they are using a phone/tablet. There's a thread over at XDA that details how to do so.

Yes, I have tethering set up that way, but I'll never go so far as burning up more than 25-30GB.
 
This, they can Fuck right of with their here is your data cap but you have to pay extra to use that same data on other devices. I'm not stealing anything, I'm just not willing to double pay for the same data. Now if they want to start offering unlimited plans again excluding tethering then they have an argument. Only want to give be a few measly gb, then I use it how I want.

T-Mobile Blog said:
Here’s what’s happening: when customers buy our unlimited 4G LTE plan for their smartphones we include a fixed amount of LTE to be used for tethering....

Unlimited high speed Tethering is clearly not included. In fact, most unlimited plans include no tethering at all.

There's plenty of shitty things telecoms do, but your phone plan is not a home plan. If you want that, you'll play more (much more) http://www.t-mobile.com/cell-phone-plans/mobile-internet.html. The reason they offer unlimited phone data is because most users don't use 2GB of data and heavy users typically use under 5 (on their phone).

If everyone hammered the system, you'd have no coverage. Think of your service when you go to a concert or a basketball game and that's what you'll end up with (i.e. no service)
 
Oh look here we go again realizing that unlimited cannot really be unlimited. I have an idea how about we pay for metered usage. It works perfectly and there is no way to abuse it. Now lets see how many people come in and try to fight me on this again.......
 
They give you 7GB of tethering/month. So actually, you're getting a $50.00 phone plan and they're tossing in a free $50.00 data card plan. That's better than most, if not all, other carriers. Unless sprint has decided to give it away (they didn't in the past), I don't know of any providers that allow tethering for free (this isn't to be confused with the ability to get around being billed).
 

I can't help it if NJ's judge was an idiot. They're not the same. It's true that 4G is as fast, or faster than most wireline Broadband. However, there's not 4G in the U.S., so it really doesn't matter. When we get 100 Mbps wireless with VoLTE calling, then I'll change my tune. AFAIK, Verizon isn't doing that. Again, a bad ruling that has no meaning outside of NJ.
 
snicker the mytouch plans used more bandwidth and were free. the forigne phones do not have limits as only the my tombile app in the phone measures the data so when you play too many games they simply assume that you are using too much "teethering data" and not unlimited or more open bandwidth. personally they really ought to get more plans where if the bandwidth is costing too much just play what the next hop pays since they only pay the data not on their network.
 
I can't help it if NJ's judge was an idiot. They're not the same. It's true that 4G is as fast, or faster than most wireline Broadband. However, there's not 4G in the U.S., so it really doesn't matter. When we get 100 Mbps wireless with VoLTE calling, then I'll change my tune. AFAIK, Verizon isn't doing that. Again, a bad ruling that has no meaning outside of NJ.

They ruled that way because Verizon, themselves, said LTE and landline are the same thing.

Evidently they are only the same thing when it is fiscally convenient for the telecoms.
 
It isn't about tethering. It's about people getting more than what they're paying for.

These guys are paying for the lower level service, 1GB or 2GB, and then cloaking their traffic so that the system doesn't recognize that they've exceeded their cap, and get monstrous amounts more than what they paid for.

It doesn't matter how they've used it. T-mobile allows tethering for free under all their current plans. What matters is that these people are avoiding the throttling, illegally. They're paying for filling up a gas can, and wind up filling up a tanker truck.

Just to clarify, from the blog post:

Here’s what’s happening: when customers buy our unlimited 4G LTE plan for their smartphones we include a fixed amount of LTE to be used for tethering (using the “Smartphone Mobile HotSpot” feature), at no extra cost, for the occasions when broadband may not be convenient or available. If customers hit that high-speed tethering limit, those tethering speeds slow down. If a customer needs more LTE tethering, they can add-on more. Simple.

I'm not trying to quibble, but according to the man himself, they are buying the unlimited LTE plan, not one of the 1gb or 2gb plans. What they are doing is obscuring the fact that they are tethering to get around the caps and making it look like the data usage is coming from the phone itself.
 
snicker the mytouch plans used more bandwidth and were free. the forigne phones do not have limits as only the my tombile app in the phone measures the data so when you play too many games they simply assume that you are using too much "teethering data" and not unlimited or more open bandwidth. personally they really ought to get more plans where if the bandwidth is costing too much just play what the next hop pays since they only pay the data not on their network.

One of the main ways to bypass the 7GB limit for tethering is by just adding the DUN protocol to the fast.t-mobile.com APN. T-Mobile is able to monitor data via the DUN protocol, and with User Agent checks.

People have resorted to VPNs and apps/browser extensions to hide UAs so they aren't throttled/cut off.
 
Who cares if they are? It has no effect on anyone. They can peg their connection 24/7, and it won't have any more effect on congestion during peak hours than anyone else. The vast majority of that 2 TB is consumed during off peak hours where it doesn't matter.

How exactly do you know that those users aren't a burden on their network our that all that data is consumed on off peak hours? Contrary to belief, wireless bandwidth isn't infinite, and chances are It's not a mobile user so it could impact people in a particular area.
 
They ruled that way because Verizon, themselves, said LTE and landline are the same thing.

Evidently they are only the same thing when it is fiscally convenient for the telecoms.

I understand Verizon's argument. I'm shocked that a judge would agree with that. It's patently false. If everyone in NJ switched to Verizon Wireless for their broadband needs, Verizon's network would not work. And of course there's the cost, which is insanely expensive compared to our already expensive Cable.

As I said before, I don't think much of my industry, but I do not think T-Mobile is doing anything wrong. The only time I do much tethering is if it's for work...and then I get a data card that where all the usage is written off each month.
 
So rooting your phone is hacking now? Well then I must be a good hacker by now.
 
And you do have unlimited data, the fact someone used 2TB of data in a month kind of shows that, however they do say you only get X amount of 4G LTE speeds via tethering, you still get unlimited data just at slower speeds if you exceed that amount while tethering.

For some of you bitching and moaning about "it's my data how I use it..." geezus, you must be some of the people they're talking about in the article who willfully hide the fact you're tethering in order to get around the known policies, and yes they obviously are known since you're fucking circumventing it, so don't give me this "well they say unlimited" garbage.

Look I'm not saying people are being wasteful - I'm simply saying if you don't want it to be unlimited, don't call it unlimited. Does it get any more simple than that?

Put a cap on it. Anything over 6GB is 10$ more per GB. Put a cap on it and say All 4G data will be turned off and you will only have 3G data after xGB is downloaded for that period. It's not hard, and I don't mind either way - I'm simply saying... DO NOT call it unlimited if it is limited. Simple enough? Understand?

I live off a 6gb verizon plan (anything over = extra charge) and I have zero problems with it and I come no where close to it. So this isn't an issue for me, I'm simply saying that as a company you need to live up to what you advertise instead of revoking what people signed up with to begin with.
 
Look I'm not saying people are being wasteful - I'm simply saying if you don't want it to be unlimited, don't call it unlimited. Does it get any more simple than that?

Put a cap on it. Anything over 6GB is 10$ more per GB. Put a cap on it and say All 4G data will be turned off and you will only have 3G data after xGB is downloaded for that period. It's not hard, and I don't mind either way - I'm simply saying... DO NOT call it unlimited if it is limited. Simple enough? Understand?

I live off a 6gb verizon plan (anything over = extra charge) and I have zero problems with it and I come no where close to it. So this isn't an issue for me, I'm simply saying that as a company you need to live up to what you advertise instead of revoking what people signed up with to begin with.

Okay, then what does "Unlimited smartphone LTE data and 7GB for high-speed tethering" entail?
 
So rooting your phone is hacking now? Well then I must be a good hacker by now.

He went a bit overboard on that, but he's right. Hacking is not a bad thing. It's all the folks on XDA do and they're not bad guys.

That said, his point was that the people who were doing it, weren't doing it by accident.

I loe unlimited data, but if this is an issue, going to data buckets is the way to solve the problem. It sucks for everyone that's not abusing the system, because unlimited is better than a bucket, but it's the only full proof way to stop it, AFAIK.
 
Look I'm not saying people are being wasteful - I'm simply saying if you don't want it to be unlimited, don't call it unlimited. Does it get any more simple than that?

Put a cap on it. Anything over 6GB is 10$ more per GB. Put a cap on it and say All 4G data will be turned off and you will only have 3G data after xGB is downloaded for that period. It's not hard, and I don't mind either way - I'm simply saying... DO NOT call it unlimited if it is limited. Simple enough? Understand?

I live off a 6gb verizon plan (anything over = extra charge) and I have zero problems with it and I come no where close to it. So this isn't an issue for me, I'm simply saying that as a company you need to live up to what you advertise instead of revoking what people signed up with to begin with.

So you think the answer is to offer a significantly worse plan? Your plan has less data than T-Mobile has for Tethering and you still get unlimited data for your phone.

I could be wrong, but I really don't think T-Mobile is being unreasonable. I'll just keep saying it: tethering was never included on unlimited data plans...not even when you used a flip phone. 7GB is 7GB more than my employer ever gave for free up until last year when most of the industry converted to data buckets, and eliminated unlimited plans.
 
Look I'm not saying people are being wasteful - I'm simply saying if you don't want it to be unlimited, don't call it unlimited. Does it get any more simple than that?

Put a cap on it. Anything over 6GB is 10$ more per GB. Put a cap on it and say All 4G data will be turned off and you will only have 3G data after xGB is downloaded for that period. It's not hard, and I don't mind either way - I'm simply saying... DO NOT call it unlimited if it is limited. Simple enough? Understand?

I live off a 6gb verizon plan (anything over = extra charge) and I have zero problems with it and I come no where close to it. So this isn't an issue for me, I'm simply saying that as a company you need to live up to what you advertise instead of revoking what people signed up with to begin with.

T-Mobile is living up to what they're advertising. I don't understand your post.
 
Can't edit. Their "Unlimited" plan says:

"UNLIMITED 4G LTE DATA ON-SMARTPHONE ONLY"

The fine print says:
"(Unlimited on-smartphone 4G LTE data option includes 7 GB of tethering);"
 
Okay, then what does "Unlimited smartphone LTE data and 7GB for high-speed tethering" entail?

Well that means then when your using the data natively on the phone its unlimited without being throttled (you are deprioritized at 21gb, but that's only an issue if you are in a crowded area)... But when your using the phone as a modem to connect some 3rd party device you only get 7gb of monthly data..
 
Well that means then when your using the data natively on the phone its unlimited without being throttled (you are deprioritized at 21gb, but that's only an issue if you are in a crowded area)... But when your using the phone as a modem to connect some 3rd party device you only get 7gb of monthly data..

Umm... I know that. Read the post I replied to.
 
How does one "cloak" bandwidth use?
WTF does that even mean? It's not hard to count packets/bytes used and detect what their endpoints were to see if it's not counted against them.
 
lol, smart people are ruining the data scarcity scam. T-Mobile wants $10 for each 2GB of hotspot data bandwidth after the low limits on an unlimited 4G LTE phone.

No sympathy for any user abusing 2TB/month, if that's even true, but I do have sympathy for people paying for a crappy "unlimited" plan and working around very low bandwidth caps included for hotspot data.
 
lol, smart people are ruining the data scarcity scam. T-Mobile wants $10 for each 2GB of hotspot data bandwidth after the low limits on an unlimited 4G LTE phone.

No sympathy for any user abusing 2TB/month, if that's even true, but I do have sympathy for people paying for a crappy "unlimited" plan and working around very low bandwidth caps included for hotspot data.

You have sympathy for people who buy a plan literally advertised as "UNLIMITED 4G LTE DATA ON-SMARTPHONE ONLY" who then use it for full-time tethering?
 
You have sympathy for people who buy a plan literally advertised as "UNLIMITED 4G LTE DATA ON-SMARTPHONE ONLY" who then use it for full-time tethering?
Data is data. If the way tmobile detects this is by looking at user-agent to determine if they're on a computer or not, then the technical means to bypass this is so simple that it's a no brainier to bypass. I heard there's more to it with a time to live for packets where it it's beyond a certain amount they can guess there's some routing involved. I heard that a vpn masks all of this though. When did a vpn start to be considered a hack?
 
You have sympathy for people who buy a plan literally advertised as "UNLIMITED 4G LTE DATA ON-SMARTPHONE ONLY" who then use it for full-time tethering?
Up to a reasonable limit, yes. Nothing stops anyone from "legitimately" doing that if they find degraded speeds acceptable over the low tethering limit. Using different tethering apps just gets around the degraded speed.

The CEO doesn't claim that abuse is hurting the network, only that it could cause problems in the future:

blog post said:
If their activities are left unchecked their actions could eventually have a negative effect on the experience of honest T-Mobile customers.

So yeah, I don't really have sympathy for T-Mobile wanting to rob people $5/GB for bandwidth that costs T-Mobile close to nothing to provide and that isn't hurting other customers.
 
So you think the answer is to offer a significantly worse plan? Your plan has less data than T-Mobile has for Tethering and you still get unlimited data for your phone.

I could be wrong, but I really don't think T-Mobile is being unreasonable. I'll just keep saying it: tethering was never included on unlimited data plans...not even when you used a flip phone. 7GB is 7GB more than my employer ever gave for free up until last year when most of the industry converted to data buckets, and eliminated unlimited plans.

....What I'm saying is DO as you advertised. How is this a hard concept?

If the company says unlimited data - allow the users to have unlimited data. Regardless of how they pull said data, if you said unlimited data - the user is entitled to unlimited data.

If you advertise you have a cap, then you have a cap. Simple as that. Use of the word "unlimited" should not be used in conjunction with these caps. And changing your definition of what "unlimited" entails after people signed contracts for "unlimited" is BS too. If you said unlimited, then you shouldn't get all pissy at your customers that REALLY do use it as you advertised.

You cant say "Try our new Unlimited* plan for just $40/month!"




*Unlimited for the first 5GB and then the speed is capped at 50kb/s
 
....What I'm saying is DO as you advertised.

You seem to be wholly unfamiliar with what they advertise.

They advertise unlimited mobile data on smartphone only, with limited tethering.
 
How exactly do you know that those users aren't a burden on their network our that all that data is consumed on off peak hours? Contrary to belief, wireless bandwidth isn't infinite, and chances are It's not a mobile user so it could impact people in a particular area.

Where did I say bandwidth? Data and bandwidth are NOT the same thing. The only thing that matters is number of active users during peak hours. It doesn't matter how much data a user has consumed over the course of a month. Heavy torrent user guy who kills a TB in a month is going to have the EXACT SAME IMPACT as Joe Blow Netflix guy who just watches a TV show during dinner for an hour, but otherwise doesn't use much. Peaks hours are only a few hours in the evening and maybe a little in the morning. Even if they pegged their LTE connection, they would not consume anywhere near 2 TB during peak hours. It's physically impossible. Therefore, they must have been using data constantly throughout the day, which has NO IMPACT on peak hour usages. Data is not a finite resource. It can be created out of thin air for little more than the cost of electricity, which is stupid cheap. Data caps are 100% about profits and have nothing to do with network congestion.
 
Since no one outside the business world has contracts with the carriers these days there is an easy solution ... let T-Mobile drop whichever customers they find undesirable ... problem solved to everyone's satisfaction ;)
 
If you advertise UNLIMITED DATA... Then guess what? The data amount should be unlimited. No question. No monitoring. Etc...

That's the real problem with most ISP's
If there's a cap, then it's NOT unlimited.
Don't advertise unlimited data, if it's not really unlimited.
 
You seem to be wholly unfamiliar with what they advertise.

They advertise unlimited mobile data on smartphone only, with limited tethering.

As far as I'm concerned, regardless of tethering the data is coming from the Smartphone. I find that to be invalid. Again, do not use the word unlimited unless you're prepared to actually do it.

Unlimited with restrictions != unlimited
 
Data is not a finite resource. It can be created out of thin air for little more than the cost of electricity, which is stupid cheap. Data caps are 100% about profits and have nothing to do with network congestion.

So higher speed routers, additional ports, new fiber runs, etc, don't cost anything?
I suppose all the unicorns do the work for free where you live.
 
As far as I'm concerned, regardless of tethering the data is coming from the Smartphone. I find that to be invalid. Again, do not use the word unlimited unless you're prepared to actually do it.

Unlimited with restrictions != unlimited

So you're literally interpreting "UNLIMITED 4G LTE DATA ON-SMARTPHONE ONLY" as meaning also unlimited tethering.

Yeah. OK.

Look, T-Mobile offers unlimited data on your smartphone and 7 GB per month tethering. Get over it. You sound ridiculous.
 
....What I'm saying is DO as you advertised. How is this a hard concept?

If the company says unlimited data - allow the users to have unlimited data. Regardless of how they pull said data, if you said unlimited data - the user is entitled to unlimited data.

If you advertise you have a cap, then you have a cap. Simple as that. Use of the word "unlimited" should not be used in conjunction with these caps. And changing your definition of what "unlimited" entails after people signed contracts for "unlimited" is BS too. If you said unlimited, then you shouldn't get all pissy at your customers that REALLY do use it as you advertised.

You cant say "Try our new Unlimited* plan for just $40/month!"

.

*Unlimited for the first 5GB and then the speed is capped at 50kb/s


If they tried to pull that crap on me, I'd write $40 on a piecs of paper and mail it to them. If they get to redefine unlimited to mean something else that it's standard English definition, then I get to redefine dollar to what I want
 
If they tried to pull that crap on me, I'd write $40 on a piecs of paper and mail it to them. If they get to redefine unlimited to mean something else that it's standard English definition, then I get to redefine dollar to what I want

tmobile.png
 
Back
Top