Is this power supply fake?

vividshock

Weaksauce
Joined
May 31, 2014
Messages
127
So I bought the Antec EarthWatts Green EA-380D on Amazon for 25$ shipped which was weird considering they usually sell for 40~45. Anyways I got the package and what first struck me odd was the EU flag right on top. Once I saw that I quickly searched for passive PFC switch on the power supply as the box did not indicate it had active PFC, although this model should. Should I just test it out on my old computer or is this something I shouldn't do?

Edit: The box on the left is the one I bought.

66b38c082b.jpg
 
Last edited:
If i recall correctly all PSU'en in the EU must be active PFC. so maybe because you got an EU model/packaging it doesn't say so, because its irrelevant information.

There is nothing that really shines in my eyes telling me it should be fake. But yeah the packaging is different.

Maybe its cheap because they got them from a greek out of business sale :D
 
Mhmmm. It booted up into ubuntu fine.... When I shut down it doesn't even get into the bios anymore. No time take out my main rig's PSU to check :/
 
EarthWatts is now a fairly old brand (7+ years), so it wouldn't surprise me if they had packaging revisions here and there.
 
I pulled one of these PSUs out of a business video server, they're junk units.

Like with most Antec designs, the fan doesn't run fast enough so the PSU runs much hotter than it should. It also has junk OST/Teapo capacitors which fail, and much sooner from the increased heat.
 
I pulled one of these PSUs out of a business video server, they're junk units.

Like with most Antec designs, the fan doesn't run fast enough so the PSU runs much hotter than it should. It also has junk OST/Teapo capacitors which fail, and much sooner from the increased heat.

Wait, are you telling me that all the fairly high reputation they garnered way back when this line was released has now gone into the shitter with cheaper components?

I'm a sad panda!
 
I also have an EA380D Green PSU inside my i5 system with a GTX 750 Ti GPU. I will be replacing it shortly before I send it to a new home. I just don't know what to replace it with. Maybe a Corsair CX430(M)?
 
Read reviews on Corsair low end power supplies. Last I knew Corsair was/are cheaping out on their capacitor choices.
EA380D were Delta power supplies, and good quality/reputation, I still know of old ones running. Server might be hotter than home units.
jonnyguru website still has some old reviews I think. Teapo were considered passable, not sure if reputation has changed.
I was going with Rosewill Capstone (on sale)[Fortress and Tachyon were better more expensive] but Rosewill has released a new set power supplies to confuse price/quality.
XFX is currently getting good reviews. Sigh, I am not building much, using what I bought on sale in the past, so not keeping up.
Units based on Seasonic G are usually very good.

Probably an EA380D at $25 is as good as you will get under $60.
 
I also have an EA380D Green PSU inside my i5 system with a GTX 750 Ti GPU. I will be replacing it shortly before I send it to a new home. I just don't know what to replace it with. Maybe a Corsair CX430(M)?

Don't get the CX430. I had one and it died off after 3 months. That was the reason why I bought this psu.
 
You get what you pay for, if you spent more on a quality power supply, like say a seasonic, then you wouldn't have to worry about components that may or may not be questionable/durable.
 
Don't get the CX430. I had one and it died off after 3 months. That was the reason why I bought this psu.

I've had a CX430 powering my 24/7 HTPC for 2.5 years now without any issues at all. It's even powering a GTX 980 now without a single issue. For the first year I had it I was folding on it 24/7 as well w/ dual core pentium processor and various second hand GPUs ranging from a 470 GTX to a 570 GTX.

Just because you had one die within' 3 months doesn't mean they're bad designs or that all of them are bad. Sometimes things happen.
 
Which version did you have? last I remember the first version was very good, and the second version was questionable because of cheaper components.
 
Well I might have the first version then. I bought it in 2012.
 
Don't get the CX430. I had one and it died off after 3 months. That was the reason why I bought this psu.

I was responding to a response from GiGaByTe, who has been pushing a PSU line that has been known to fail to reliably produce or handle anywhere close to the overinflated power output ratings of the various models in that line. (Yes, I'm talking about the Thermaltake TR2 line whose currently available "430W" model is really only a below-mediocre-quality 350W unit.)
 
Last edited:
I was responding to a response from GiGaByTe, who has been pushing a PSU line that has been known to fail to reliably produce or handle anywhere close to the overinflated power output ratings of the various models in that line. (Yes, I'm talking about the Thermaltake TR2 line whose currently available "430W" model is really only a below-mediocre-quality 350W unit.)

Yup, was going to say the EA series is quite good quality for the price. I still have an 6 year old 500w model handling my HTPC without issue.
 
Wait, are you telling me that all the fairly high reputation they garnered way back when this line was released has now gone into the shitter with cheaper components?

I'm a sad panda!

I've never known Antec to be a reputable brand. I replace/repair so many dead Antec units of all kinds that it's not funny. I currently have 4 Antec units that I've recapped, with one of them having a fan mod done on it as well.

The most common is shitty caps exacerbated by their "quiet fan control" technology.

If you want a reliable unit, get something else. Antec units can be modified by replacing the caps and changing the fan circuitry, but it takes time and money that are better spent on a more reputable PSU.

I was responding to a response from GiGaByTe, who has been pushing a PSU line that has been known to fail to reliably produce or handle anywhere close to the overinflated power output ratings of the various models in that line. (Yes, I'm talking about the Thermaltake TR2 line whose currently available "430W" model is really only a below-mediocre-quality 350W unit.)

More like you've created a really bad straw man fallacy and are perpetuating things that never happened. I assume you're talking about this thread where you make a quip at the end:

http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1868928

Would you show me where I try and push a TR2 onto someone? You can't because I never did. I asked why everyone hated them and talked about my experiences with them.
 
More like you've created a really bad straw man fallacy and are perpetuating things that never happened. I assume you're talking about this thread where you make a quip at the end:

http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1868928

Would you show me where I try and push a TR2 onto someone? You can't because I never did. I asked why everyone hated them and talked about my experiences with them.

I was under the (mistaken) impression that you were recommending the TR2 PSUs when you really weren't. ;)

What I read that came up with my statements about the TR2 line are several professional reviews that showed that they couldn't handle anywhere close to their advertised wattage ratings in realistic operating conditions, plus user reviews that gave the individual models in that line one or two stars (out of five) that count for a very large percentage of total reviews of such units. (I will pull some examples of those whenever I have a lot of time.)

By the way, none of the three TR2 PSUs that you listed in that thread are capable of handling even 70% of their advertised wattage ratings. In fact, the TR2 420W is based on the CWT PUF platform - one of the shittiest platforms that CWT has ever produced. And even the 600W and 850W units are realistically capable of outputting only 400W and 550W, respectively. (Now I know why: Their ratings are at an actual inside-the-PSU operating temperature of an unrealistically low 25°C - but most PSUs actually operate at 40 to 50°C. So obviously, realistic power output capacity degrades with such a rise in inside-the-PSU operating temperatures.)

And you may be right in that although Antec's PSUs are based on solid PSU platforms (for the most part), the company has consistently specified lesser-quality components in most of its lower-to-mid-level lines.

EDIT: I had temporarily suspended posting further in this thread, until I realized that GiGaBiTe's posts did have some merit to them.
 
Last edited:
I've had a handful of EarthWatts PSUs that have been deployed in office PCs for years. In my experience they seem to hold up well enough. They are far from stressed in their present environments and this may skew the results, but I trust them enough to keep using them. I bet this was just an example of a packaging redesign at some point along the way, since they have been selling these units for years now.
 
By the way, none of the three TR2 PSUs that you listed in that thread are capable of handling even 70% of their advertised wattage ratings. In fact, the TR2 420W is based on the CWT PUF platform - one of the shittiest platforms that CWT has ever produced. And even the 600W and 850W units are realistically capable of outputting only 400W and 550W, respectively.

I've read the reviews on the 420, 600 and 850W units so I know the questionable quality that they supposedly have. I've not had them fail on me though, even under a moderate to heavy load. So again, I'm not going to stop using them just because people say bad things about them.

(Now I know why: Their ratings are at an actual inside-the-PSU operating temperature of an unrealistically low 25°C - but most PSUs actually operate at 40 to 50°C. So obviously, realistic power output capacity degrades with such a rise in inside-the-PSU operating temperatures.)

This is because of the garbage 80PLUS rating. PSU manufacturers want to get an 80PLUS rating slapped on their units for laymen who don't know any better and buy just because of that rating.

According to the most recent version of the 80PLUS test, the ambient temperature in the testing room is 23C +/- 5C, so between 18 and 28C. If their PSU works in that environment, many don't care if it performs like crap in a realistic environment.

80PLUS needs to die and be replaced by a more sane standard where they don't expect you to have an air conditioned computer case.
 
I've read the reviews on the 420, 600 and 850W units so I know the questionable quality that they supposedly have. I've not had them fail on me though, even under a moderate to heavy load. So again, I'm not going to stop using them just because people say bad things about them.

Fair enough. However, I would not recommend using an old-topology PSU on any CPU/motherboard platform that's made within the past two years or so.

This is because of the garbage 80PLUS rating. PSU manufacturers want to get an 80PLUS rating slapped on their units for laymen who don't know any better and buy just because of that rating.

According to the most recent version of the 80PLUS test, the ambient temperature in the testing room is 23C +/- 5C, so between 18 and 28C. If their PSU works in that environment, many don't care if it performs like crap in a realistic environment.

80PLUS needs to die and be replaced by a more sane standard where they don't expect you to have an air conditioned computer case.

I agree that 80Plus is far from perfect. However, your units (except for the 850) are rated at only 70% to 75% maximum efficiency even at an inside-the-PSU operating temperature of 23°C (due to their archaic topologies). That is what makes those particular PSUs (the TR2-420 and TR2-600) so outdated, if not downright lousy.

And my view on those particular TR2 units stands: I would not buy them at their current street prices when they are new. And when acquired used, they are risky buys even when they are free.

Back to the EA-380D Green:

I can't recommend it, either, particularly at its current street price. There are better-quality PSUs out there at or close to that price. I will just have to look for such a unit.
 
(due to their archaic topologies). That is what makes those particular PSUs (the TR2-420 and TR2-600) so outdated, if not downright lousy.

And my view on those particular TR2 units stands: I would not buy them at their current street prices when they are new. And when acquired used, they are risky buys even when they are free.

The way I look at it is:

Buy a used TR2 for $5-10 that probably won't explode.

Or

Buy a new Logisys "480" (more like 188) for $15-20 that will definitely explode.

If you want to talk about ancient topology, Logisys units wouldn't even be considered ATX standard lol. They have more in common with AT power supplies and still have -5v available on the board, even though most of their newer units no longer bring it out to the Minifit Jr. power connector.
 
I wouldn't touch a TT PSU with a 10 foot pole. Or any TT products for that matter. Antec's Delta made units are generally solid though, but for that wattage one of their Green series or a Rosewill Capstone (Excellent SuperFlower model except for the new Capstone G) is probably your best bet.
 
Well yes, don't get cheap as shit units and they won't be cheap as shit. It even has basiq in the name.
 
That unit is $55, I wouldn't exactly call it cheap.

I'm going to recap it and do the fan speed mod at some point since it's mine now.
 
Got another customer in a few days ago with a dead Antec PSU

This time it's an Antec Basiq Power 500W:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817371004

sYS4KgPh.jpg

WpFQnd3h.jpg


This time we have another bad cap brand "Capxon". I can't tell the date of manufacture, but I know it isn't more than 5 years old.

Stay classy Antec.

That EarthWatts 380 Green that I pulled from my i5-2400 system has CapXon caps (I could see a couple of those through the intake grille of that PSU). I replaced it with an Antec High Current Gamer 520W PSU that I pulled from an i7-3770K system (I then purchased an eVGA SuperNOVA 550GS PSU to replace the HCG-520 for that i7-3770K system). I am planning to sell both of those systems with an OEM Windows OS installed; however, I am waiting for one more case part to arrive.
 
That unit is $55, I wouldn't exactly call it cheap.

I'm going to recap it and do the fan speed mod at some point since it's mine now.

It doesn't matter the retail price. It was a cheaply built unit. Some consumers are tricked into thinking spending more is better when it isn't, and some companies do take advantage of that.

Keep buying your Thermaltake PSUs. I will choose a PSU that stays within spec and doesn't destroy my components, regardless of how long it lasts.
 
It doesn't matter the retail price. It was a cheaply built unit. Some consumers are tricked into thinking spending more is better when it isn't, and some companies do take advantage of that.

Cheaply built? No lol.
http://www.hardwaresecrets.com/antec-basiq-bp500u-power-supply-review/

- Has a complete mains filtering stage.
- Uses a bridge rectifier rated for 8A, not four diodes common in shitty Chinese units.
- Has APFC.
- Uses double forward transistors on the primary.
- Schottky transistors on the secondary.
- All of the output wires are 18/16AWG, none of that 20AWG nonsense.

The only thing wrong with the unit is the shitty choice of caps and the fan controller.

Keep buying your Thermaltake PSUs. I will choose a PSU that stays within spec and doesn't destroy my components, regardless of how long it lasts.

Yep, I'll keep getting ThermalTake PSUs because it seems to wind you up so much. And if you think that higher quality PSUs aren't land mines when they get older, you'd be very wrong. Aged or bad output filtering caps can just as easily destroy parts as a cheaply built PSU can.

There's no ATX PSU on the market that tracks ripple current at the output right after the last filtering capacitors, and there are VERY few that measure the voltage right after the last filtering stage. So if these filtering caps go out, then stuff can still go BANG or get destroyed no matter how good your PSU is.
 
The more you know about power supplies, the fussier you get.
Truth is though when you find something that works well you (I) tend to stick with it till I (we) discover changes.
Corsair CX430 went fro very good to mediocre to " to avoid." Antec Basiq have not that good a reputation, it is sad if the Earthwatts are not the expected quality.

There have been a lot of changes in ten years, and a lot of shell games.

Buying a good expensive power supply is not difficult, they are reviewed, and used hard often enough for reputations to matter.

Low end power supplies, no one enforces standards, changes are made, reviews are less often available. And buyers (dumb buyers?) keep prices low.
 
Cheaply built? No lol.
http://www.hardwaresecrets.com/antec-basiq-bp500u-power-supply-review/

- Has a complete mains filtering stage.
- Uses a bridge rectifier rated for 8A, not four diodes common in shitty Chinese units.
- Has APFC.
- Uses double forward transistors on the primary.
- Schottky transistors on the secondary.
- All of the output wires are 18/16AWG, none of that 20AWG nonsense.

The only thing wrong with the unit is the shitty choice of caps and the fan controller.



Yep, I'll keep getting ThermalTake PSUs because it seems to wind you up so much. And if you think that higher quality PSUs aren't land mines when they get older, you'd be very wrong. Aged or bad output filtering caps can just as easily destroy parts as a cheaply built PSU can.

There's no ATX PSU on the market that tracks ripple current at the output right after the last filtering capacitors, and there are VERY few that measure the voltage right after the last filtering stage. So if these filtering caps go out, then stuff can still go BANG or get destroyed no matter how good your PSU is.

So cheaping out on some components isn't being cheaply made? A chain is only as strong as its weakest link.

I'm not getting wound up by it. I'm just making sure that others that read this thread don't make the decisions you do, and why.

Good thing in quality PSUs something else fails first 99.9% of the time. Or they're replaced before that happens because they last so long.

The more you know about power supplies, the fussier you get.
Truth is though when you find something that works well you (I) tend to stick with it till I (we) discover changes.
Corsair CX430 went fro very good to mediocre to " to avoid." Antec Basiq have not that good a reputation, it is sad if the Earthwatts are not the expected quality.

There have been a lot of changes in ten years, and a lot of shell games.

Buying a good expensive power supply is not difficult, they are reviewed, and used hard often enough for reputations to matter.

Low end power supplies, no one enforces standards, changes are made, reviews are less often available. And buyers (dumb buyers?) keep prices low.

The CX400 was very good. The CX430 was avoid. The CX430 V2 was mediocre, but unbeatable in price/performance with rebates for low end systems.
 
So cheaping out on some components isn't being cheaply made? A chain is only as strong as its weakest link.

You have to give Antec the benefit of the doubt on this model at least. They tried to man up and release a decent product, everything but the capacitors are overspec'd by a good margin. They could have specified X but got Y in regards to capacitors.

Look what happened to Dell and all of those other manufacturers that started using fake Nichicon and Rubycon capacitors during the plague, the supply chain failed them, not the other way around. There were of course OEMs that purposefully used shit capacitors, but that's another story.

I'm not getting wound up by it. I'm just making sure that others that read this thread don't make the decisions you do, and why.

People don't need an internet tough guy to defend them, especially since I haven't recommended a TTake unit to anyone. You've just created this weird logical fallacy that I somehow have.

As I've said for the umpteenth time, I explained why I use them, and it's up to the reader to decide if they want to use them or not. They have the pros and cons and can make an informed decision themselves.
 
Back
Top