NSA Can Resume Bulk Data Collection

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Well it sure didn't take long for this to happen.

The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court ruled late Monday that the National Security Agency may temporarily resume its once-secret program that systematically collects records of Americans’ domestic phone calls in bulk.
 
Of course they haven't stopped, why would they actually follow the Constitution when all three branches regularly ignore it.
 
I'm still trying to understand what it is that ordinary, everyday people say on the phone that they think is so incredibly vital that the government would want to know about it...;) There's nothing that I can think of that they might say the government would have the slightest interest in knowing. OTOH, there is plenty of reason not to publicize what your methods are to kooks, nuts, unibombers, terrorists, and the like. That's why we have "secret" in the first place, the residue of two world wars, etc. Unfortunately, it's a proven fact that some crazies dislike America so much that they wouldn't hesitate murdering those same everyday people just to promote some vastly warped point. I'm glad that we have folks at least trying to stop that kind of thing before it starts--"an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure," etc.
 
I like how they have a budget that allows them to spy on 300 million people for no gain, but somehow can't secure the federal employee database, which has opened us up to potentially having 4 million people being blackmailed into becoming ACTUAL national security threats.
 
I'm still trying to understand what it is that ordinary, everyday people say on the phone that they think is so incredibly vital that the government would want to know about it...;) There's nothing that I can think of that they might say the government would have the slightest interest in knowing. OTOH, there is plenty of reason not to publicize what your methods are to kooks, nuts, unibombers, terrorists, and the like. That's why we have "secret" in the first place, the residue of two world wars, etc. Unfortunately, it's a proven fact that some crazies dislike America so much that they wouldn't hesitate murdering those same everyday people just to promote some vastly warped point. I'm glad that we have folks at least trying to stop that kind of thing before it starts--"an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure," etc.

”Those Who Sacrifice Liberty For Security Deserve Neither.”

I know that's a fairly common quote to throw out in this sort of discussion. But think about the potential consequences for a moment. I have no doubt the program has ultimately been helpful in stopping certain terrorist acts and saving lives but that's not the point, at least in my opinion. The point is not that the majority of people have anything to hide, but that the FISA courts and several branches of our government manipulate or even outright ignore the Constitution to their own ends, in the name of "Security." I have less of a problem with these sort of programs if there is more accountability to the people they claim to be protecting.

This court, and this "tech" was created supposedly to fight terrorism as part of the Patriot Act, but is now used to police citizens of the United States. The FISA courts have been noted several times granting secret warrants for monitoring of suspected drug ring leaders and other criminals. Now that may not be a bad thing in and of itself, however when the NSA has the capability to monitor ALL of the citizens of the US, it is not a stretch to believe, and almost seems inevitable that it can and will be used to more nefarious ends.

I like to quote this section from the second amendment:

"..when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government"

Now then consider other governments in certain countries that have less "freedom" than we do, how those governments have literally fought and killed their people to maintain power and prevent revolt. Given what seems like human nature and inclination of those in power, consider what they might be willing to do if or when people in our country decide to revolt in good conscience against a government they believe has consistently eroded the freedoms and ideals this country was founded on. I'm not saying that the government or the police are going to outright kill people to protect their political holdings. However, if they believe sending riot police with sniper rifles and throwing tear gas and smoke grenades at mostly peaceful protesters is justifiable (i.e. during some of the Occupy Wall Street protests because they were blocking the entrance to a bank), well then we have bigger problems.

That said, I believe it is the peoples right protest even revolt when they feel government isn't acting in the best interest of its people. What the patriot act, the NSA, and these FISA courts have the capability to do, and have proven willing to do, with little to no oversight and almost completely in secret, blatantly contradicts any accountability that OUR government is supposed to have for our people to that end. And I have no doubt they would use it to its fullest extent to keep the powers they have gained.

I don't know, maybe I'm just paranoid. I have lost my trust in the morals of our leaders, and I am absolutely certain I am not the only one. For those at the NSA reading this post, dont worry about me, I am not going to be doing anything crazy lol! I will fight with my vote and my voice, but tread lightly, I have noticed a lot of people lately getting a LOT more worked up about this!
 
I like how they have a budget that allows them to spy on 300 million people for no gain, but somehow can't secure the federal employee database, which has opened us up to potentially having 4 million people being blackmailed into becoming ACTUAL national security threats.

What is even funnier is that MOST Senators and Congresspeople and their staffers do not:

-encrypt their office phone lines
-encrypt their email
-use HTTPS for their official government domains

The chair of Cybersecurity Appropriations has said on record to reporters and I quote, "I don't understand any of this stuff".
 
I would love to see their back-end algorithms, had to be done high end shit.
 
547775.jpg
 
”Those Who Sacrifice Liberty For Security Deserve Neither.”

I know that's a fairly common quote to throw out in this sort of discussion. But think about the potential consequences for a moment. I have no doubt the program has ultimately been helpful in stopping certain terrorist acts and saving lives but that's not the point, at least in my opinion. The point is not that the majority of people have anything to hide, but that the FISA courts and several branches of our government manipulate or even outright ignore the Constitution to their own ends, in the name of "Security." I have less of a problem with these sort of programs if there is more accountability to the people they claim to be protecting.

This court, and this "tech" was created supposedly to fight terrorism as part of the Patriot Act, but is now used to police citizens of the United States. The FISA courts have been noted several times granting secret warrants for monitoring of suspected drug ring leaders and other criminals. Now that may not be a bad thing in and of itself, however when the NSA has the capability to monitor ALL of the citizens of the US, it is not a stretch to believe, and almost seems inevitable that it can and will be used to more nefarious ends.

I like to quote this section from the second amendment:

"..when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government"

Now then consider other governments in certain countries that have less "freedom" than we do, how those governments have literally fought and killed their people to maintain power and prevent revolt. Given what seems like human nature and inclination of those in power, consider what they might be willing to do if or when people in our country decide to revolt in good conscience against a government they believe has consistently eroded the freedoms and ideals this country was founded on. I'm not saying that the government or the police are going to outright kill people to protect their political holdings. However, if they believe sending riot police with sniper rifles and throwing tear gas and smoke grenades at mostly peaceful protesters is justifiable (i.e. during some of the Occupy Wall Street protests because they were blocking the entrance to a bank), well then we have bigger problems.

That said, I believe it is the peoples right protest even revolt when they feel government isn't acting in the best interest of its people. What the patriot act, the NSA, and these FISA courts have the capability to do, and have proven willing to do, with little to no oversight and almost completely in secret, blatantly contradicts any accountability that OUR government is supposed to have for our people to that end. And I have no doubt they would use it to its fullest extent to keep the powers they have gained.

I don't know, maybe I'm just paranoid. I have lost my trust in the morals of our leaders, and I am absolutely certain I am not the only one. For those at the NSA reading this post, dont worry about me, I am not going to be doing anything crazy lol! I will fight with my vote and my voice, but tread lightly, I have noticed a lot of people lately getting a LOT more worked up about this!

You got that quote a little wrong tho, you left out the word "essential", it's a qualifier, a distinction. See, just as WaltC mistakenly thinks this program colects the contents of calls, your own interpretation of this quote assumes that this database of call meta-data is a threat to "essential" liberty.

You idea that the FISA court was created to combat terrorism is also completely wrong as the FISA Court "is a U.S. federal court established and authorized under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 (FISA) to oversee requests for surveillance warrants against foreign spies inside the United States by federal law ..."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Foreign_Intelligence_Surveillance_Court
yup, the FISA court has been around for over 35 years.

This "tech" isn't being used to police our citizens, it's being used to connect known bad guys with unknown bad guys here in the US. Too much of a reach for you, I know.

Anyway, enough. I'm happy enough it's getting a closer look even if many people don't want to listen to facts that don't allign with their mistaken beliefs.
 
Holy crap, who gives a damn. I for one have nothing to hide from the NSA and they can data mine all the information they like to acquire from me.

Too many paranoid retards out there and think that with the NSA having access to META-DATA or other data is going to harm them in any way or considered policing society.

If you're a threat to National Security or committing fraudulent business practices then you deserve what you get.

The United States Government has every legal right to collect META-DATA from each and every citizen is likes, nor can be considered an "invasion" of privacy. META-DATA is META-DATA... all it is in time, gps coordinates, call duration, and phone number. Also the GOV doesn't give two shits about what you text or say over the phone unless it were an issue with national security.

Obviously the majority of United States citizens have no idea what National Security is, or what it entails.

What people OUGHT to be concerned about is Google, Apple, Microsoft, and others invading your privacy and using your personal information against you. These corporations have more information about your personal life than what they are legally entitled to and no one is doing a damn thing about it, rather you bitch and grip about the NSA sifting through literally useless information.
 
I hate the 'nothing to hide' argument. There are lots of good articles out there debunking that one.

Justification by saying that 'corporations do it also' is just as bad. We should be getting laws passed that makes it illegal for companies to collect that information, not using it as some sort of excuse for our government doing it also. It's even worse when factoring in all the data breaches happening in companies and government.
 
Holy crap, who gives a damn. I for one have nothing to hide from the NSA and they can data mine all the information they like to acquire from me.

Too many paranoid retards out there and think that with the NSA having access to META-DATA or other data is going to harm them in any way or considered policing society.

If you're a threat to National Security or committing fraudulent business practices then you deserve what you get.

The United States Government has every legal right to collect META-DATA from each and every citizen is likes, nor can be considered an "invasion" of privacy. META-DATA is META-DATA... all it is in time, gps coordinates, call duration, and phone number. Also the GOV doesn't give two shits about what you text or say over the phone unless it were an issue with national security.

Obviously the majority of United States citizens have no idea what National Security is, or what it entails.

What people OUGHT to be concerned about is Google, Apple, Microsoft, and others invading your privacy and using your personal information against you. These corporations have more information about your personal life than what they are legally entitled to and no one is doing a damn thing about it, rather you bitch and grip about the NSA sifting through literally useless information.

Can I get you some knee pads?
 
Just remember, what they tell you they are doing is probably 10% of what they are actually doing, if nothing else people should've learnt this by now.

I'm amazed how some people think its ok for a govt agency to have complete access to every persons complete life, with no warrant or cause, and to top it all, they can do it in secret, lie about it and face no consequences.
 
I like a how people argue that NSA keeps us safe. The reason nothing every happens is because not everyone is a crazy terrorist. They have to keep the "client base" alive as some boogey monster but if the NSA just disappeared I think we would all not notice anything!
 
Meh, I know I'm being watch.

I emailed Ted Cruz and told him to go back to Canada. So, yeah, I'm on a list and being collected on.
 
Where are all the people that deify Snowden right now? Their silence is deafening...

He's a hero for changing what, exactly?

:confused::confused::confused::confused::confused:
 
Obviously you're 1 of the billions of people that wear a tin hat twenty-four seven.

Can I get your source on him being one of a billion people not okay with this?

The United States Government has every legal right to collect META-DATA from each and every citizen is likes, nor can be considered an "invasion" of privacy. META-DATA is META-DATA... all it is in time, gps coordinates, call duration, and phone number. Also the GOV doesn't give two shits about what you text or say over the phone unless it were an issue with national security.
META-DATA is literally everything of importance. It shows them EVERYTHING they desire to know. It's clearly a violation of privacy (unreasonable search and seizure). The actual text is near irrelevant and they get that, too. Anyone believing they can't or don't is the real retard present, period. They also write their own laws and pass them regardless of what the masses want.

Legal != Moral/right/just
 
META-DATA is literally everything of importance. It shows them EVERYTHING they desire to know. It's clearly a violation of privacy (unreasonable search and seizure). The actual text is near irrelevant and they get that, too. Anyone believing they can't or don't is the real retard present, period. They also write their own laws and pass them regardless of what the masses want.

Legal != Moral/right/just

READ: METADATA

METADATA is NOT "everything" ... besides no sane individual cares what the Government collects, when in fact that information will never be used against them, especially by the NSA. The only people that do care are those wrongfully committing crimes and wearing tin hats. Fact.

There is a FINE LINE between "Privacy" laws between what the Government CAN DO and what Business CANNOT DO! Businesses have ZERO right to invade United States citizens PRIVACY, PERIOD. Yet businesses do it on a daily basis illegally and get away with it, because of morons like yourself allowing them to. Government has every legal right to collect METADATA in terms of protecting the countries self-interests and it's citizens worldwide.

I love the fact that you idiots cry that we "needed" it and demanded the United States government put the bill into play after 911, but now that it's been over a decade you cry about how devastating it is, when it's not, for the NSA to snoop on completely worthless METADATA that Joe Blow knows nothing about the specifics of what that data really is. The complete TEXT/SMS message is NOT "METADATA." Period, end of story.

LEGAL != Does NOT mean moral/right/just!

Moral / Right / Just is subjective! The Directive Form is NOT!
 
...Actually the USA is a republic. But do go on about the government who's structure you cannot articulate. ;)

I think the point that he was trying to make, which you added nothing to, was that "in May the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, in New York, ruled in a lawsuit brought by the A.C.L.U. that Section 215 of the Patriot Act could not legitimately be interpreted as permitting bulk collection at all."

So a public court, with public record, makes a ruling on a very controversial subject. A secret court, with no public record, then comes behind it and over turns it.

But sure, go on with the semantics.
 
READ: METADATA

METADATA is NOT "everything" ... besides no sane individual cares what the Government collects, when in fact that information will never be used against them, especially by the NSA. The only people that do care are those wrongfully committing crimes and wearing tin hats. Fact.

Just think about WHY the Bill Of Rights exists. Is the First Amendment there to protect people from saying "Good Morning" and "The Sky Is Blue"?

What protects any of us from doing something illegal? What is the mechanism that defines what YOU do as being legal or illegal?

And who is the "government"? Do you want your neighbors collecting data on you? Why is the government different? Are they not your neighbors?
 
Umm, I agree that we must protect our rights, but the issue with the NSA is far and away from what people are making it out to be.

The entire purpose the NSA has with metadata is for national-security and terrorism acts.

The NSA is not your local police department. Local PD's, obviously, are made up of 90% buffoons who have absolutely no knowledge of terminology, sheep to the law, some crooks, lack intelligence, and rarely hold a real formal education. If your local police department had this much power, which they do not, I'd definitely be concerned. The local police departments require a warrant to subpoena such information, even if the local police departments did obtain this type of information they'd have to hire a specialist. The information the National Security Agency is collecting is very trivial and ought to be of very little concern to citizens.

NSA = National Security Agency.


Seriously, people are dumb as rocks, and ought to be placing their concerns towards corporate america, software developers, and social networking sites. They're the ones who are invading our Constitutional Rights and stripping them away, letter by letter.
 
Correct me if I am wrong but has this large scale collecting of data lead to any arrests? Every act that was carried out had the suspects eventually captured through normal means. The fact that things like the Boston marathon happen, the shoe man on the plane, base shootings, etc. seems to speak for itself. Those events that were not carried out again had very specific reasons for the suspect to get caught.

No one should collect any information on you without your consent unless they have a warrant. To include business and government.
 
Most of whatever they may or may not do as a result of their intellience gathering we will never hear about.
 
I'm still trying to understand what it is that ordinary, everyday people say on the phone that they think is so incredibly vital that the government would want to know about it...;) .

As others have said, it's "just" the metadata. The time/date, location, to/from numbers, how long the call lasted, etc.

That being said, if they want it, it is obviously valuable. Think of the data mining possibilities. I still think this all is going to get fed into a central "psuedo-history" style database someday (now?).

Collect every little detail of anonymized data. Sure, you can't tell the individual behind it. But you're not trying to control an individual, you're trying to control large populations.

Send out a news story or article with specific copy. Mine the phone metadata, who calls who, link that back to names via publicly available sources - what, they just take the metadata, they aren't taking the name from your call! But if the name is available via other sources...

Mine Twitter and Facebook. What's the sentiment of certain demographic groups, of the population over all? Is that announcement popular? What words trigger what emotions or actions? How does money start moving there?

Etc, etc, etc.

You can make a giant Pavlovian machine, once those in power, be it commercial or government, start taking all these signals and learn how to make us salivate with ever greater detail.
 
Correct me if I am wrong but has this large scale collecting of data lead to any arrests? Every act that was carried out had the suspects eventually captured through normal means. The fact that things like the Boston marathon happen, the shoe man on the plane, base shootings, etc. seems to speak for itself. Those events that were not carried out again had very specific reasons for the suspect to get caught.

No one should collect any information on you without your consent unless they have a warrant. To include business and government.


” The NSA, President Obama, and members of Congress have all said NSA spying programs have thwarted more than 50 terrorist plots.
In all fairness, the article I pulled this quote from claims there is no proof, but we also know that the NSA is not likely to declassify information related to such operations for the common man. Those in Congress who are responsible for oversight of the NSA will be privy to such information, but not you and I, or a reporter for whatever media outlet.

It took this from a fairly decent article on the subject.

Keep in mind, the author goes to great effort to show everything in a light that makes it sound like we are all being lied to about this issue. Keep in mind a couple of things, first, these are not the kinds of questions that are normally asked in an unclassified setting. Normally these issues are discussed in secret with those who are cleared to hear about them.

Second, understand that the NSA is not a Law Enforcement Agency, the NSA conducts operations world wide against almost every country and when it comes to terrorism, many of the foreigners they are watching do come to the US or communicate with people here in the US. Furthermore, if they find that a US Person is doing something illegal, say supporting some terrorists in another country, the case get's turned over to the FBI to deal with so at that point, the NSA really isn't doing anything anymore, the FBI is now involved and as an American, warrants are required for continued surveillance, etc. In short, the whole thing get's much more complex, who is watching who starts changing, and the burden of "proof" changes.
 
As others have said, it's "just" the metadata. The time/date, location, to/from numbers, how long the call lasted, etc.

Ok. We have some of the most powerful computers in the world with some top notch programmers. I am sure they cannot take the metadata and use it along with the shit tons of other data from public sources to figure out who it was, where they were and when, and who they were with. Or, with some not so public but still accessible data.

Take a store, for example. If your phone is on wi-fi, Bluetooth or whatever, they can track it. They really don't have a person associated with it. Until you use your super members reward card. Now, they know where you went in the store, what you stopped to browse, etc., along with what you bought and how you paid for it. Of course, that's stuff you can control.

My point is - once they get that piece of identifiable information, it ties into everything else. Metadata is great. Anonymous. You gather a ton of it, and create a profile, still anonymous. Then, when you get enough, you see that the majority of calls are from 2 places. One, their home; two, their place of employment. Now, you use public information to find out a name. You can find out who they are calling, the various patterns of when and where... Public records can tell you who has a criminal record and for what. It's not difficult. But, it's also not very secret. I'm sure that a person or company or any government agency could all accomplish the same thing. It's all just data. Easily obtained data.

They may not get the details of the conversation, but they can put together a pretty good package of what's going on if they need to. The majority of us on the forum would have no reason or suspicion to have the NSA go that far to use those resources on us. But, it's possible. Legal? Hey, it's just metadata. :D Everything else is public and available (you and I would probably have to pay some fee's to get access to some things).

Even without the metadata, they have a shit ton of information on you. You are not anonymous. To the NSA, though - you're just not important. :D
 
In all fairness, the article I pulled this quote from claims there is no proof, but we also know that the NSA is not likely to declassify information related to such operations for the common man. Those in Congress who are responsible for oversight of the NSA will be privy to such information, but not you and I, or a reporter for whatever media outlet.

It took this from a fairly decent article on the subject.

Keep in mind, the author goes to great effort to show everything in a light that makes it sound like we are all being lied to about this issue. Keep in mind a couple of things, first, these are not the kinds of questions that are normally asked in an unclassified setting. Normally these issues are discussed in secret with those who are cleared to hear about them.

Second, understand that the NSA is not a Law Enforcement Agency, the NSA conducts operations world wide against almost every country and when it comes to terrorism, many of the foreigners they are watching do come to the US or communicate with people here in the US. Furthermore, if they find that a US Person is doing something illegal, say supporting some terrorists in another country, the case get's turned over to the FBI to deal with so at that point, the NSA really isn't doing anything anymore, the FBI is now involved and as an American, warrants are required for continued surveillance, etc. In short, the whole thing get's much more complex, who is watching who starts changing, and the burden of "proof" changes.

+1

Though, metadata has real value to the NSA. They know what they're looking for.
 
Back
Top