GOG Refusing To Distribute Hatred?

I think it's bullshit that nudity is more of a trigger than violence for people 90% of the time. This is the first game we've had in a long time that's actually been garnering a large amount of disapproval.

I think it's bullshit, too, but that doesn't mean I think anything goes in any venue.
 
I think it's bullshit, too, but that doesn't mean I think anything goes in any venue.

I just think companies are being giant hypocrits choosing what to censor. If all violence is bad then why can I shoot up people in an airport or pick up a prostitute then run her over? Oh wait, I forgot those games are sending a message/sattire.
 
I just think companies are being giant hypocrits choosing what to censor. If all violence is bad then why can I shoot up people in an airport or pick up a prostitute then run her over? Oh wait, I forgot those games are sending a message/sattire.

Sure, sure. Being a hypocrite isn't a crime or even wrong however.
 
Censorship. Sometimes I feel like technology takes us 1 step forward and 2 steps backward (intellectually).

Yes and no.

I feel that our awareness of events around us has increased hundreds-fold so things may appear worse because in comparison to 50 years ago, you had no idea what was going on in the world.

I think 'intellectually' technology has progressed us a bit more but our 'tastes' might have gone down but may not even be related to tech, could just be our (evolution) of society?

What we think has gone too far gets lesser and lesser, yes this game might be too far for some folks but not long ago even showing a gun or above a woman's knees on tv was way too far.
 
Not sure of anyone's age here but who remembers the first GTA (the top down version) and the controversy that game unleashed?
 
Comparing Postal to this game is pretty silly. This game is sick and encourages the murder of woman and children in great graphic detail. Not understanding the difference from members on this forum doesn't surprise me.

Here are some screenshots for comparison:

Postal - http://cdn.akamai.steamstatic.com/s...d13003223808620c95f9.600x338.jpg?t=1414690150

Postal 2 - http://cdn.akamai.steamstatic.com/s...723365e7965c9accf117.600x338.jpg?t=1429307161

Hatred - https://ggtriple.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/hatred-gore-gameplay2.gif?w=700

I'm still sure you won't get it.

What the fuck.

You can't kill children and It doesn't encourage shit unless you actually enjoy being a psycho path in the first place.

I don't know, playing a game in which you are pointlessly and realistically enjoying running around killing/raping innocents would seem to fit the definition of "enjoying being a psycho."

Censorship. Sometimes I feel like technology takes us 1 step forward and 2 steps backward (intellectually).

I don't think it should be censored by the government. But I would absolute judge any company that carried it or person who played it. I've been a gamer my whole life, but sometimes I see the internet enables sick fucks to get off too much, and sadly someone who, before the internet, may have not met other sick people and thus sought to change their ways, now can find the other .000001% of the population who may share the same depravity and thus feel OK continuing it. See: cannibal porn, etc.
 
What the fuck.



I don't know, playing a game in which you are pointlessly and realistically enjoying running around killing/raping innocents would seem to fit the definition of "enjoying being a psycho."



I don't think it should be censored by the government. But I would absolute judge any company that carried it or person who played it. I've been a gamer my whole life, but sometimes I see the internet enables sick fucks to get off too much, and sadly someone who, before the internet, may have not met other sick people and thus sought to change their ways, now can find the other .000001% of the population who may share the same depravity and thus feel OK continuing it. See: cannibal porn, etc.

Agree 100%. I don't mind high levels of violence in an "action" context, sci-fi context, horror (not pointless hack/slash, but real horror) context, etc. but this is a bunch of shit, and there is no legitimate purpose for it to exist. It's sick. This is of course my opinion, and everyone has their own, but I don't mind making mine known on this subject.

I'm glad GOG doesn't want to carry this shit. I agree that it's pretty hypocritical that they do carry Postal (and I wouldn't play that shit either) but whatever.
 
I'm not saying the game is awesome or anything, but it's still art. And art doesn't always portray happy rainbows and sunshine. It'd suck if it did. Should we start banning books that describe terrible murders too? Or should book sellers stop selling them? Should they also sell something else that's similar but not another?

I'm not one to dictate what a company should sell, but I don't enjoy the hypocrisy.

Also, I don't think you rape in Hatred. At least I never heard much on that. I also, don't really care much about Hatred.
 
I am a free market kinda guy, GoG is free to sell or not sell what ever they want.

That said, there is nothing new or unique about this games violence that has not been done in other games -- including Postal which they are still selling. So it come off as bandwagoning IMHO.

So the "story" reason is bad that makes the violence less acceptable? Serious? Less acceptable than banging a hooker and killing her for the money back?

I don't get the kerfuffle over the game, but GoG is free to sell whatever they want to whomever they want -- as long as it isn't cake or pizza, that shit hast to be sold to everyone all the time no matter what :D
 
I am a free market kinda guy, GoG is free to sell or not sell what ever they want.

That said, there is nothing new or unique about this games violence that has not been done in other games -- including Postal which they are still selling. So it come off as bandwagoning IMHO.

So the "story" reason is bad that makes the violence less acceptable? Serious? Less acceptable than banging a hooker and killing her for the money back?

I don't get the kerfuffle over the game, but GoG is free to sell whatever they want to whomever they want -- as long as it isn't cake or pizza, that shit hast to be sold to everyone all the time no matter what :D

The way I see it is that the sole point of this game is to do horrible things. Postal is similar, and I'd group it the same, but I can also see how someone would draw a line in a slightly different position on this one. Not my taste at all, but I could see it. With something like GTA, yes, you CAN do bad things, but that's not the ENTIRE intent of the game. I bought several GTA games, but you know what? I just steal cars and cause general mayhem, jump them off of things, etc. Never once have I killed a hooker. (unless maybe I inadvertently ran one over. Let's call that gross digital negligence though rather than murder. :D I view GTA more as a sandbox simulator that also let's you commit a lot of crime. I'd still put it more in an action/heist movie category like the movie Heat though.

Everyone is going to draw their lines in different places. I get it, but there are some extreme examples, like Hatred, that I personally just think are trash, serve no good purpose. I'm not going to say it should be outright banned, but I fully support a store that decides they don't want to carry it. That's their right, and if it aligns somewhat with my opinion, bonus points I guess?
 
The way I see it is that the sole point of this game is to do horrible things. Postal is similar, and I'd group it the same, but I can also see how someone would draw a line in a slightly different position on this one. Not my taste at all, but I could see it. With something like GTA, yes, you CAN do bad things, but that's not the ENTIRE intent of the game. I bought several GTA games, but you know what? I just steal cars and cause general mayhem, jump them off of things, etc. Never once have I killed a hooker. (unless maybe I inadvertently ran one over. Let's call that gross digital negligence though rather than murder. :D I view GTA more as a sandbox simulator that also let's you commit a lot of crime. I'd still put it more in an action/heist movie category like the movie Heat though.

Everyone is going to draw their lines in different places. I get it, but there are some extreme examples, like Hatred, that I personally just think are trash, serve no good purpose. I'm not going to say it should be outright banned, but I fully support a store that decides they don't want to carry it. That's their right, and if it aligns somewhat with my opinion, bonus points I guess?

I get it, Hatred is not my kinda game (Neither is Postal or GTA). But loved me some Insta-gib matches in Unreal Tournament back in the day, and as such I don't see much moral difference in the "kill in an arena for the Landri Corp for fame and money" and "I'm gonna kill them all because I hate them all"

I mean if the story opener is a little different, the lead character in Hatred was holding up a bank and it went sidways, now the cops show up and he has to kill his way across town to freedom -- with the exact same gameplay and graphics -- it wold be ok?
 
I get it, Hatred is not my kinda game (Neither is Postal or GTA). But loved me some Insta-gib matches in Unreal Tournament back in the day, and as such I don't see much moral difference in the "kill in an arena for the Landri Corp for fame and money" and "I'm gonna kill them all because I hate them all"

I mean if the story opener is a little different, the lead character in Hatred was holding up a bank and it went sidways, now the cops show up and he has to kill his way across town to freedom -- with the exact same gameplay and graphics -- it wold be ok?

I personally would make a distinction. For me context is 87.5% of whether or not I'm ok with something. Well, sort of. I'm not really ok with violence in general in real life (other than maybe martial arts types of things) but in games/movies, yes, I make a determination for myself based on the situation/context/taste/etc.

In real life, no, there wouldn't be much difference. However, a heist gone sideways (in an entertainment context) is still different in my opinion. If I was playing a character in this situation I'd probably kill some opposition, but I wouldn't be slaughtering bystanders and random strangers just for the hell of it. Minimum collateral damage.

In the Liandri Coporation example, the participants are willing contestants in a blood sport. Once again, fine. They chose to do it. They aren't dumping innocent children into the arenas, and saying kill them for fun. They're dropping you in with other willing opponents.

I would hope others made similar distinctions, but everyone is different. There's no denying that this is my own personal take on all of this.
 
So the big issue for most people here is choice. Hatred seems like a game where the objective is to kill the innocent which brings back MW2 airport scene memories. While a game like GTA gives you the choice either for fun or to aid you in the situation. It's ok if the game gives you the opportunity to slaughter innocent people but when it's forced then it suddenly becomes controversial. This simple answer here seems to be to not buy the game.
 
So the big issue for most people here is choice. Hatred seems like a game where the objective is to kill the innocent which brings back MW2 airport scene memories. While a game like GTA gives you the choice either for fun or to aid you in the situation. It's ok if the game gives you the opportunity to slaughter innocent people but when it's forced then it suddenly becomes controversial. This simple answer here seems to be to not buy the game.

No one's forcing anyone to buy it. How then can you force a private company like Twitch to display it?
 
Comparing Postal to this game is pretty silly. This game is sick and encourages the murder of woman and children in great graphic detail. Not understanding the difference from members on this forum doesn't surprise me.

Here are some screenshots for comparison:

Postal - http://cdn.akamai.steamstatic.com/s...d13003223808620c95f9.600x338.jpg?t=1414690150

Postal 2 - http://cdn.akamai.steamstatic.com/s...723365e7965c9accf117.600x338.jpg?t=1429307161

Hatred - https://ggtriple.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/hatred-gore-gameplay2.gif?w=700

I'm still sure you won't get it.

The feminism is strong in this one, yet he forgets men are killed all the time in video games in graphic detail.
 
I am a free market kinda guy, GoG is free to sell or not sell what ever they want.

That said, there is nothing new or unique about this games violence that has not been done in other games -- including Postal which they are still selling. So it come off as bandwagoning IMHO.

So the "story" reason is bad that makes the violence less acceptable? Serious? Less acceptable than banging a hooker and killing her for the money back?

I don't get the kerfuffle over the game, but GoG is free to sell whatever they want to whomever they want -- as long as it isn't cake or pizza, that shit hast to be sold to everyone all the time no matter what :D

Well, I personally dislike games that force you to be a psychopath for no real reason other than "kill 'em all!" I don't think there's a moral argument to be made either way, really. If I owned a game store, o wouldn't go out of my way to sell Hatred. And if I owned a movie store, I wouldn't go out of my way to sell Human Centipede. Shock for the sake of shock is usually never entertaining. But that's me.

Either way, their just pixels on a screen, who cares who's banging or killing who
 
Human Centipede was great IMO. I watched it with my mom, who also enjoyed it.

If Hatred goes to any length to explore the mind of a psychopath/suicidal I can see it being good. Anyone know if the game requires you to kill women and children, or is that merely an option like in other games?
 
People like to point out that none of the comparable games like Postal or Manhunt were as realistic or detailed as Hatred is, completely forgetting that at the time, those games were considered very realistic.

Recall the controversy around Doom and Wolfenstein. People were up in arms over the realism of those games, while today we view them as simplistic. Back then, those games were thought to have graphical detail akin to real life.
 
All of these games were released. Nobody censored them. There's not even an issue here.
 
No one is even comparing all the sick horror games that have come out recently to this game.
Why was there no out cry for games like The Evil Within? Just because you don't play the psycho doesn't mean the game is not fucked up.
 
No one is even comparing all the sick horror games that have come out recently to this game.
Why was there no out cry for games like The Evil Within? Just because you don't play the psycho doesn't mean the game is not fucked up.

There are plenty of fucked up games, and a good portion of them I won't play. That doesn't mean I'm setting out to tell others not to. Personally, I would hope that some people would have at least some line they won't cross with some of it. Like I said before though, it's all about context. Sometimes I like to provoke myself a little bit, and play something a little outside what I'm normally into. That's where things like the Doom series come in, or things like Dead Space. Sure there are some fairly nasty things in them, but there's more to it than just killing innocents for fun. The Evil Within was a bit much in some places, and I actually didn't finish playing it, but it also had some very good mechanics to it in some ways, and some of the actual horror elements were good. I could have easily done without some of the straight-up chainsaw gore though. I'm totally not into that, and it did wear on my after a while, which is part of the reason I lost interest.

I have a lot of very fine lines in my sense of taste. Some of it may even seem to border on hypocrisy at times, because some things that bother me in some cases don't bother me in others. Just my wiring I suppose. I just find some things tasteless while I tolerate something similar somewhere else because of the context. **shrug**

If someone wants to play hatred, I'll definitely judge them for it, but I'm not going to stop them from doing it. I'm open to the same criticism for some of the things that I like the might bother others too. Whatever.

For me though the whole concept of Hatred is distasteful, a bit repulsive, and I won't bat an eyelash over someone not wanting to carry the game.
 
Yes, and you're completely missing my point.

People are saying Hatred is different then other comparable games due to it's graphical fidelity and realism, ignoring the fact that those other games were thought to be extremely realistic and almost life-like at the time they were released.

Wolfenstein and Doom's detractors pointed to those game's realistic graphics as a reason to ban and censor them and Hatred's opponents are doing the same thing. Ten years from now, when VR and 4K are the norm, people will look back on this particular isometric shooter with the same attitude and brush it off as simplistic and not very realistic.

We can post screenshots and YouTube videos of low-poly NPCs and poorly textured gore from games past and say, "See, these games were nothing like Hatred, they're such low detail and the humans consist of 25 polygons" but that's being disingenuous. All of those games were considered to be breathtakingly real at the time.


tl;dr Graphical fidelity and realism are relative to the time period in which the game was developed. Therefore, comparing the fidelity of Hatred to Postal or Doom is irrelevant.
 
Yes, and you're completely missing my point.

People are saying Hatred is different then other comparable games due to it's graphical fidelity and realism, ignoring the fact that those other games were thought to be extremely realistic and almost life-like at the time they were released.

Wolfenstein and Doom's detractors pointed to those game's realistic graphics as a reason to ban and censor them and Hatred's opponents are doing the same thing. Ten years from now, when VR and 4K are the norm, people will look back on this particular isometric shooter with the same attitude and brush it off as simplistic and not very realistic.

We can post screenshots and YouTube videos of low-poly NPCs and poorly textured gore from games past and say, "See, these games were nothing like Hatred, they're such low detail and the humans consist of 25 polygons" but that's being disingenuous. All of those games were considered to be breathtakingly real at the time.


tl;dr Graphical fidelity and realism are relative to the time period in which the game was developed. Therefore, comparing the fidelity of Hatred to Postal or Doom is irrelevant.

Minor edit, I meant "wasn't"

Manhunt is still pretty brutal and graphic by todays standards. Some of the ways you kill people is just borderline terrorist beheading quality. It doesn't take high res graphics to trigger someone, it's your imagination that really brings it to life.
 
Graphical fidelity plays a part in my decision making for how much gore I can handle. Less realistic, I can handle it more. More realistic, maybe somewhat less so. Once it hits a certain point, I may not even want to continue playing some of the series that I don't mind as much currently. However, that's one of the least significant parts in a case like this.

For me, the theme of the game, the things it wants the player to do, and in the context (or lack of as the case may be) are the main factors. Going on a killing spree of innocent civilian people is not what I call entertainment. And maybe some of the things that I do find entertaining (going on killing sprees against competitors in blood sports, aliens, demons, Nazis, etc.) isn't what someone else finds entertaining either.

I still think most critical thinkers could draw some lines between the two. At least I would hope so. If not, what're you gonna do? Let em seek it out and play it, and just hope they don't have some looming psychological disorder (beyond IMO wanting to play something like this in the first place...)
 
Graphical fidelity plays a part in my decision making for how much gore I can handle. Less realistic, I can handle it more. More realistic, maybe somewhat less so. Once it hits a certain point, I may not even want to continue playing some of the series that I don't mind as much currently. However, that's one of the least significant parts in a case like this.

For me, the theme of the game, the things it wants the player to do, and in the context (or lack of as the case may be) are the main factors. Going on a killing spree of innocent civilian people is not what I call entertainment. And maybe some of the things that I do find entertaining (going on killing sprees against competitors in blood sports, aliens, demons, Nazis, etc.) isn't what someone else finds entertaining either.

I still think most critical thinkers could draw some lines between the two. At least I would hope so. If not, what're you gonna do? Let em seek it out and play it, and just hope they don't have some looming psychological disorder (beyond IMO wanting to play something like this in the first place...)

Also, I can handle a lot more gore in things like Alien movies, where yes, the aliens are tearing people to shreds than say people doing it to each other. I also hate torture scenes. Anything where someone is helpless (tied to a chair for example) while someone does horrible things to them. Can't handle it. Someone getting sliced in half in battle by a sword though? Doesn't bother me. Once again, context, value of the story, reason for the violence, etc...
 
Also, I can handle a lot more gore in things like Alien movies, where yes, the aliens are tearing people to shreds than say people doing it to each other. I also hate torture scenes. Anything where someone is helpless (tied to a chair for example) while someone does horrible things to them. Can't handle it. Someone getting sliced in half in battle by a sword though? Doesn't bother me. Once again, context, value of the story, reason for the violence, etc...

Agree I feel similarly.

I do kind of wish games would not be locked to a forward moral compass. Maybe I feel like being a psychopath, I think a good game should allow it but react accordingly.

Why must most games we always have to play the hero?
 
I typically don't really want to play the part of someone like that, but that doesn't also mean that I want to be a hero all the time either. Assassin, hacker, thief, post-apocalyptic bad ass out for himself, etc. are some of my favorites. I like to be more of a subversive type of character. Sometimes yes, even what turns out to be the good guy or hero, but in a fairly renegade or underground fashion. I love gritty settings, especially in the cyberpunk styles. Even some interactions with psychotic or psychopathic characters are nice sometimes, but I typically really don't want to be one. Well, in an arena shooter, I usually don't care too much who I am as long as the character looks cool. :D
 
The feminism is strong in this one, yet he forgets men are killed all the time in video games in graphic detail.

LOL!! I don't even want to respond to this. You may be the biggest tool on the internet (quite the accomplishment) if you don't get the difference. I truly hope you are just an ignorant child and not a grown man, because if you are an adult male (notice I didn't type man) you need serious help. Even those that are defending the game aren't making anything even close to as asinine a comment as what you just tried as an argument. I feel bad for your parents as they did a terrible job. Seriously.
 
LOL!! I don't even want to respond to this. You may be the biggest tool on the internet (quite the accomplishment) if you don't get the difference. I truly hope you are just an ignorant child and not a grown man, because if you are an adult male (notice I didn't type man) you need serious help. Even those that are defending the game aren't making anything even close to as asinine a comment as what you just tried as an argument. I feel bad for your parents as they did a terrible job. Seriously.

zzZPsw5.gif
 

It's ok man. You are a "strong" man and I'm sure those feminazis are holding you down. Because not wanting to brutally murder woman (in any form even if it is just simulated), who are vulnerable by nature, is a bad thing. Just like in prison when rapists and woman/child murderers are made an example of. I'm sure all of those men are feminists as well!

You just have never felt a vagina and hate woman because they ignore you. There is no other explanation. There are many like you out there, maybe start a club?! One day you will pay for the services and your life will change forever!!

Sarcasm aside, give me a break. How old are you kids?
 
It's ok man. You are a "strong" man and I'm sure those feminazis are holding you down. Because not wanting to brutally murder woman (in any form even if it is just simulated), who are vulnerable by nature, is a bad thing. Just like in prison when rapists and woman/child murderers are made an example of. I'm sure all of those men are feminists as well!

You just have never felt a vagina and hate woman because they ignore you. There is no other explanation. There are many like you out there, maybe start a club?! One day you will pay for the services and your life will change forever!!

Sarcasm aside, give me a break. How old are you kids?

Lol man you need to chill from the boards a bit, you're getting too upset over this. More than half your posts are just insults at this point and not actual discussion.

25
 
Lol man you need to chill from the boards a bit, you're getting too upset over this. More than half your posts are just insults at this point and not actual discussion.

25

What does this not have to do with the discussion? Your retaliation to be called out for no moral standards is to call go down the anti-feminist route and not question the fact someone equated killing woman (/children) to video game violence against men. Violence against woman and children is something that has been considered reprehensible by even the lowest humans for a very long time, hence why there are very few games that portray it... and none until now that glorify it.

I must have hit a nerve.
 
By the way Nick - posting an insult and then responding to an insult by saying too many insults is incredibly hypocritical and short sighted.
 
tl;dr Graphical fidelity and realism are relative to the time period in which the game was developed. Therefore, comparing the fidelity of Hatred to Postal or Doom is irrelevant.

Not entirely. At the time Doom was "violent" for a video game. But Hatred certainly is more violent and realistic looking than any game from the 90s. It does surpass those games. Perhaps it crosses a line for many that previous games did not.

I have to say, it is getting close to crossing a line myself. Mainly because you explicitly target innocents, whereas in games like Sleeping Dogs that is not your primary objective. The animated violence isn't the part that stands out, but who you target and your reasons for doing so does. But I don't have a problem with it being sold. I think it is a crappy game that is trying to make a name for itself by being edgy. Kind of like The Witcher 2, except far more edgy and a whole lot more crappy. :p
 
Not entirely. At the time Doom was "violent" for a video game. But Hatred certainly is more violent and realistic looking than any game from the 90s. It does surpass those games. Perhaps it crosses a line for many that previous games did not.

I have to say, it is getting close to crossing a line myself. Mainly because you explicitly target innocents, whereas in games like Sleeping Dogs that is not your primary objective. The animated violence isn't the part that stands out, but who you target and your reasons for doing so does. But I don't have a problem with it being sold. I think it is a crappy game that is trying to make a name for itself by being edgy. Kind of like The Witcher 2, except far more edgy and a whole lot more crappy. :p

The Witcher isn't even that edgy. Yeah, you have to make choices sometimes that aren't optimal in the sense of your usual "good guy saves everybody and nothing bad happens ever again"-kind of game, but the games are pretty relaxed compared to the books or, say, Game of Thrones.

Things change when the objective of the game is explicitly to target and kill "innocent" people, however. The black and white graphics and overhead view actually tone it down a bit, but the game clearly deserves its AO rating.
 
Back
Top