The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt NVIDIA GameWorks Video

How incompetent do you have to be to have hair cause a 40% framerate drop?
 
How incompetent do you have to be to have hair cause a 40% framerate drop?
Incompetent? Um, that hair takes a lot of shaders, so I could see it causing a lot of problems for video cards. It is the same deal with soft shadows. It seems like such a small thing, but it takes a lot of work. Especially if you are smaller studio.
 
Incompetent? Um, that hair takes a lot of shaders, so I could see it causing a lot of problems for video cards. It is the same deal with soft shadows. It seems like such a small thing, but it takes a lot of work. Especially if you are smaller studio.

TressFX does the same thing and it doesn't kill performance in the same manner.

I do happen to know a thing or two about graphics programming and I've already run the game through a graphics 0profiler. Will probably disassemble it later tonight to see what other gems I can find (at least, being x86-64, they can't pull a Skyrim and use x87 floating point instructions but there are plenty of other areas to be incompetent in).
 
Real question is whether or not this will make it into the final release. :rolleyes:
 
TressFX does the same thing and it doesn't kill performance in the same manner.

I do happen to know a thing or two about graphics programming and I've already run the game through a graphics 0profiler. Will probably disassemble it later tonight to see what other gems I can find (at least, being x86-64, they can't pull a Skyrim and use x87 floating point instructions but there are plenty of other areas to be incompetent in).

My experiences with TressFX have been underwhelming at best, even on AMD hardware. The performance drop for a bundles of clipping chunks of hair was not what I expected.

Haven't fired Witcher up yet, but will tonight and it's very possible I'll have the same opinion of Hairworks, but TressFX hasn't exactly caught on (one major title from 2013 as far as I know) and isn't anything to write home about.
 
There's a few benchies already circulating showing a massive performance hit for HairWorks, brutal on 700 series nvidia as well as 200 series AMD
 
There's a few benchies already circulating showing a massive performance hit for HairWorks, brutal on 700 series nvidia as well as 200 series AMD

Hairworks = tesselation heavy. Older Nvidia's and AMD not as efficient at tesselation as latest Maxwells. But simples can't accept that, they insist its a conspiracy or that Nvidia "just didn't bother to optimize for older cards".

In any case, optional graphical settings are optional.
 
Hairworks = tesselation heavy. Older Nvidia's and AMD not as efficient at tesselation as latest Maxwells. But simples can't accept that, they insist its a conspiracy or that Nvidia "just didn't bother to optimize for older cards".

In any case, optional graphical settings are optional.

Why does rolling the driver back give a 20% performance boost for Kepler?
 
The HairWorks in TW3 is almost as blatantly tacked on as PhysX was when it was first introduced.
 
Played last night. I wonder why this version of hairworks is so much more demanding than the one in FC4? In TW3 it cripples my 290x, but simulated fur in FC4 didn't have a huge impact in FPS
 
Too much of a performance hit and not enough of a visual improvement.
 
Why does rolling the driver back give a 20% performance boost for Kepler?

Ask Nvidia. I imagine there's probably something disabled in the older driver that is enabled in the newer; such that even if you enable it in-game its still disabled in the older driver.

Regardless, an underlying technical reason for it is more plausible than "OMG CONSPIRACY"
 
Hairworks = tesselation heavy. Older Nvidia's and AMD not as efficient at tesselation as latest Maxwells. But simples can't accept that, they insist its a conspiracy or that Nvidia "just didn't bother to optimize for older cards".

In any case, optional graphical settings are optional.
Heaven benchmark on "extreme tessellation" settings is higher for the 290x than the GTX 970, sooooooo...
 
That said, its a cool effect, but they really need to tone it down. Everything cloth there looked like there was a tornado with the amount it was flapping, and some of the beasts downright had afros.

Anyone recall how much of a framerate drop they are getting on tressfx in Tomb Raider? For 7950s and newer, I think it was minimal, but not sure for NVidia cards.
 
Heaven benchmark on "extreme tessellation" settings is higher for the 290x than the GTX 970, sooooooo...

"Sooooooooooo" too bad that means fuckall and doesn't translate to most tesselation heavy games. The benchmarks are out there.
 
Pretty funny when you can see the FPS dip even in the promo video. The cut scenes really hurt my performance but other than that the game runs great and I"m enjoying it.
 
I had a chance to play last night for about an hour noticed that having hair effects off actually made my fps worse :confused: Running it on two 780ti. I was a bit surprised by it.
 
Pretty funny when you can see the FPS dip even in the promo video. The cut scenes really hurt my performance but other than that the game runs great and I"m enjoying it.
Yeah I was thinking "Are they serious?" when I saw that.
 
TressFX does the same thing and it doesn't kill performance in the same manner.

I do happen to know a thing or two about graphics programming and I've already run the game through a graphics 0profiler. Will probably disassemble it later tonight to see what other gems I can find (at least, being x86-64, they can't pull a Skyrim and use x87 floating point instructions but there are plenty of other areas to be incompetent in).

While I'm sure it has improved by now: The first use of TressFX in a retail game, Tomb Raider, resulted in like a 40% drop in average framerate. For one single head of hair.
 
Every game that's had Nvidia GameWorks is buggy as hell and performance sucks. Stop making games with GameWorks.
 
Well, from personal experience back on older cards, TressFX caused a massive FPS drop in Tomb Raider and I think it was just Lara that it was used on. In Witcher 3 hard looks really cool, especially when talking to characters and you see it up close. Hair effects are on animals such as your horse and it does look awesome. I haven't tried disabling it to see performance drop but so far game runs great on my system at 1080 maxed out. It looks better than some screen from a few days ago saying it was scaled back massively. It does looks like they scaled some from older videos but not to console level. On ultra it looks great!
 
Back
Top