Looking for new phone suggestions

Franko

Weaksauce
Joined
Jan 17, 2009
Messages
121
My Nexus 5 is on the way out and I am hoping for a few recommendations for a replacement. I want a phone that uses stock android (and gets the upgrades) like the n5/n6 but is about the same size as the 5. Price isn't really an issue as long as I get my money's worth and the phone works with T-Mobile. What phones should I be looking at?

Thanks for the suggestions in advance.


P.S. The phone only lasted a year and a half of real gentle use (screen starts glitching at random times). Did I just get unlucky or should I steer clear of certain brands if I am hoping to get 2 to 3 years out of a phone?
 
Truly stock Android is hard, but the Moto X would probably do the trick. Motorola's usually good about rolling out updates soon after the Nexus line gets them.

As for your Nexus 5: you got some bad luck. I have one here that's still running properly, and I got it on launch.
 
Bad luck for sure. I know a lot of people who have near release date n5's and they are doing great (with a few battery issues being the only exception). Finding a phone that runs stock android is hard. Your only options are the n6, moto x, g, or e. Since you want a phone that is around the same size, a moto x would realistically be your only good choice. You could always get the Google play edition htc m8 too but those are hard to come by.
 
Sony Z3 or Z3c? It's close to stock, but if you require ONLY stock then you're limiting yourself to the Nexus or playstore varients- I would wait and see if the S6 shows up on there and grab it- no sense buying a year-old model and expecting it to go another three years AND get updates.
 
HTC One M8 I suppose would be your best bet. Close to stock, faster updates than Sony. Moto X 2014 probably a bit too big. If you dont mind an older phone the original Moto X is an awesome phone.
 
I would say Moto is your best bet. There have been some good deals on the MotoX as of late as well. It was almost my next phone, but the camera was not where I wanted it to be. The customization is awesome though.

I want to say the Sony Z3 is just now getting Lollipop. So, the Sony stuff is supported, but its not like the Nexus brand or what Moto has been doing in terms of schedule. I want to say that Moto beat some of the Nexus products in getting the 5.0 update rolled out.

The One Plus One is a bit larger but is a great deal at near nexus pricing. They are getting supported as well currently and with the recent change to their 'Oxygen' OS appears to be a very light touch to Android, but that has just come out, so schedule seems to lag a bit behind as well. Their One Plus Two is rolling out in the coming months.

Not sure what HTCs updates are like, but the M8 might be a good deal for you or even the new M9.
 
unfortunately, your only choice is a nexus 5/6, or an (older) GPE phone or moto X/G/E

do you care about wifi calling/ VoLTE / band 12 LTE?

The One Plus One is a bit larger but is a great deal at near nexus pricing. They are getting supported as well currently and with the recent change to their 'Oxygen' OS appears to be a very light touch to Android, but that has just come out, so schedule seems to lag a bit behind as well. Their One Plus Two is rolling out in the coming months.

I wouldn't put the OPO in the same class as the N5 (in terms of updates)... OPO got backstabbed by CM, their OxygenOS rom is late as well (see other phones getting lollipop before they did). Even if OPO wants to continue updates for the phone, you can see how bad luck/partners can mess that up...



my nexus 5 is still alive and kicking... same battery issues as day 1 (i.e. could last longer), but still get the similar 2-3 hour SOT + 10-24 hour uptime as before. haven't upgraded to lollipop yet, so maybe that's why it's fine, using a custom ROM (slimkat)

I want to say the Sony Z3 is just now getting Lollipop. So, the Sony stuff is supported
sony z1/z2/z3 are getting the lollipop update... but if you have a carrier-specific variant, might be late or never showing up...

the t-mobile Z3 cannot be rooted or bootloader unlocked (still...), so I'd stay away from it (unless I want VoLTE/wifi calling/band 12)
 
Last edited:
I like turtles.

Thanks for reading the thread and giving a well thought out and constructive post.
OP I would see if you can find a Nexus 6 to see if the size is really too big. I thought it would be too until I held one. Since you and a Nexus 5, you know all the good things that you get from having stock phone. Trying to get other phones to work the same way isn't fun at all.
 
I love my original Moto X. It's been going strong for a year and a half now. If it broke today, I'd get another one (but I'd go for a wooden back panel this time). It's nearly stock Android, with a few additional apps co-developed by Motorola and Google during the stint when Google owned them.

I don't like the 2014 version, Motorola clearly dropped the ball after Google wasn't looking after them anymore. Lenovo aren't likely to be better handlers either, so I doubt the Moto X line has any real future, but the 2013 model is the best Android device I've ever used.
 
Am an owner of both the MotoX (1st Gen) and (2nd Gen).
I believe that Lenovo has been doing a commendable job taking over the manufacture of the MotoX.
They improved on the MotoX (1st Gen) by giving the (2nd Gen) a larger (5.2 in) and more higher resolution AMOLED display along with a more powerful processor. Not that the (2013) was lacking, but the (2014) is also more solidly contructed with a metal-banded frame.

Lenovo also continued the Motorola tradition of providing an enjoyable-to-use interface. Both the (2013) and (2014) have cameras that can use improvement but for me the user experience more than compensates. I still love the original MotoX but the newer one has won me over.
 
Last edited:
Moto X 2014 for sure.

Not much better than the N5 in specs, but it's pretty much your only option right now if the N6 is too big or expensive for you. I wouldn't get the 1st gen Moto X just because it's already almost 2 years old and the custom X8 chipset in it is keeping it from updated right now.
 
The 2014 version is too large, and the size completely offsets the advantages of the curved back. The 2013 model is an elegant and intelligent piece of design. The 2014 version desperately needed more user testing. The sturdier metal frame is its only redeeming design quality.

If you're considering either variant of the Moto X, make sure you go to a store and try them out. Once you've held both of them in your hands, the choice is apparent.
 
The 2014 version is too large, and the size completely offsets the advantages of the curved back. The 2013 model is an elegant and intelligent piece of design. The 2014 version desperately needed more user testing. The sturdier metal frame is its only redeeming design quality.

If you're considering either variant of the Moto X, make sure you go to a store and try them out. Once you've held both of them in your hands, the choice is apparent.

OP is coming from a Nexus 5, which is only 3mm shorter and narrower than the newer Moto X. Too big is purely subjective and for OP to decide for himself, but I doubt it would be too big for him coming from the N5.

Yes, the original Moto X is more ergonomic and a great phone for its time, but it just doesn't make sense to recommend a phone that is already nearing the end of its life cycle and considerably older/less spec'd than the phone he's replacing, esp. when price isn't really an issue for him as specified in OP.

If you can get by with your gimped N5 for a few more months though, I would try to hold out for the next Moto X due out in mid-late Summer.
 
You want the updates as soon as they come out then you need a nexus or a GPE phone. You want one the same size as the nexus 5, well your shit out of luck on that one unless you buy another nexus 5
 
Thanks to you all for the input it is really appreciated. I have decided to go with a gen 2 moto x. I held the nexus 6 in my hands and I just cant get past the size (its like carrying a paperback novel in the front pocket of my pants...).
 
Am an owner of both the MotoX (1st Gen) and (2nd Gen).
I believe that Lenovo has been doing a commendable job taking over the manufacture of the MotoX.
They improved on the MotoX (1st Gen) by giving the (2nd Gen) a larger (5.2 in) and more higher resolution AMOLED display along with a more powerful processor. Not that the (2013) was lacking, but the (2014) is also more solidly contructed with a metal-banded frame.

Lenovo also continued the Motorola tradition of providing an enjoyable-to-use interface. Both the (2013) and (2014) have cameras that can use improvement but for me the user experience more than compensates. I still love the original MotoX but the newer one has won me over.

Lenovo didn't have anything to do with the development of the 2014 X. The 2014 X was done well before Lenovo took over the mobile operations.
 
Thanks to you all for the input it is really appreciated. I have decided to go with a gen 2 moto x. I held the nexus 6 in my hands and I just cant get past the size (its like carrying a paperback novel in the front pocket of my pants...).

Very good choice. Hopefully you got the $140 off deal they had going.
 
I love my original Moto X. It's been going strong for a year and a half now. If it broke today, I'd get another one (but I'd go for a wooden back panel this time). It's nearly stock Android, with a few additional apps co-developed by Motorola and Google during the stint when Google owned them.

I don't like the 2014 version, Motorola clearly dropped the ball after Google wasn't looking after them anymore. Lenovo aren't likely to be better handlers either, so I doubt the Moto X line has any real future, but the 2013 model is the best Android device I've ever used.

I also have the 2013 Moto X. I have recently ordered the 2014 X for a friend and played with it for some time. Bottom line the 2013 X ergonomics are better, also feels better in hand. The 2014 is just bigger and faster. The original X is a classic.
 
Thanks to you all for the input it is really appreciated. I have decided to go with a gen 2 moto x. I held the nexus 6 in my hands and I just cant get past the size (its like carrying a paperback novel in the front pocket of my pants...).

Good choice. I'm on Verizon so I chose the Droid Turbo, but if that phone weren't available or if I were on a different network I would have certainly chosen the 2014 Moto X. I've had nothing but great luck with Motorola. They have great build quality, customer service, call quality, and IMO some of the best added features available on Android.
 
Back
Top