Intel's Diversity Goals Face Many Challenges

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It's only been a few days since Intel announced its diversity initiative and we are already questioning whether it will succeed or not.

"It will be hard. I think it's going to be like what we do every two years -- invent Moore's Law," Krzanich said in an interview Wednesday, referring to the company's overarching goal of doubling computer chips' processing power every other year. "We don't know how we're going to do it. We go and put in the engineering effort and do what it takes. We'll do the same thing here."
 
Pointless waste of resources to put on a dog and pony show.
 
...referring to the company's overarching goal of doubling computer chips' processing power every other year.
How can I trust what the rest of the article has to say when the author doesn't understand such a basic concept as Moore's Law?

Gordon Moore said:
The number of transistors and resistors on a chip doubles every 18 months.
 
Diversity goals are pretty stupid when well over 90% of your applicants are white men or Asian men. You either have to get profoundly lucky with your applicants that aren't either of those or your standards have to take at least a bit of a hit to hit those goals.
 
Glad I'm not a manager there. What a stupid thing to have your salary tied to. Now if the applicants don't match the prescribed pattern, the manager will have to find diversity matches of lower skill at job agencies? Or the pool widens because people realize their "diversity" means more than their skill?
 
Diversity goals are pretty stupid when well over 90% of your applicants are white men or Asian men. You either have to get profoundly lucky with your applicants that aren't either of those or your standards have to take at least a bit of a hit to hit those goals.

You may be right. I don't know how many are getting degrees in Math, Engineering, CS and other applicable fields, but as I recall, the issue goes well beyond technical workers. I'll also add, that there are plenty of minorities with these degrees and like most people I've worked with, they're bright, hard working and very capable of handling most tasks.

The reality is when you start hiring minorities and they are put into positions of power, other minorities will apply, because they feel they have a shot of going somewhere. I know someone who's not in a tech field who is leaving her job, because she's the top performer in her group and is being passed over by guys who started 3 months ago.

If you don't think there are super bright women and minorities capable of these jobs, then you're just wrong. Virtually every woman I've worked with in the last 20 years was talented and I know one who was exceptional had to go to HR just to get a promotion (one she should have gotten a decade earlier). I knew guys who were no more capable and were certainly lazier who got promoted much faster (within 2 or 3 years of starting vs 13).

I have another friend who was fired from a job basically because her boss didn't like female engineers. And you can say, "Oh that's just a BS excuse," but she's works for the top animation house in the U.S.

If you look for them, you'll find lots of great women, hispanics and african american (to name but 3 groups they're trying to hire) candidates for most positions in tech companies. And if you hire them, more will follow.
 
You may be right. I don't know how many are getting degrees in Math, Engineering, CS and other applicable fields, but as I recall, the issue goes well beyond technical workers. I'll also add, that there are plenty of minorities with these degrees and like most people I've worked with, they're bright, hard working and very capable of handling most tasks.

The reality is when you start hiring minorities and they are put into positions of power, other minorities will apply, because they feel they have a shot of going somewhere. I know someone who's not in a tech field who is leaving her job, because she's the top performer in her group and is being passed over by guys who started 3 months ago.

If you don't think there are super bright women and minorities capable of these jobs, then you're just wrong. Virtually every woman I've worked with in the last 20 years was talented and I know one who was exceptional had to go to HR just to get a promotion (one she should have gotten a decade earlier). I knew guys who were no more capable and were certainly lazier who got promoted much faster (within 2 or 3 years of starting vs 13).

I have another friend who was fired from a job basically because her boss didn't like female engineers. And you can say, "Oh that's just a BS excuse," but she's works for the top animation house in the U.S.

If you look for them, you'll find lots of great women, hispanics and african american (to name but 3 groups they're trying to hire) candidates for most positions in tech companies. And if you hire them, more will follow.

Thanks for kicking some real truth in here. My friend is from India and his dad was one of the biggest names behind Volvo India when it started. His dad started other ventures and business because he said he knew they were going to replace him with a white man. Sure enough it happened last year. How did he know this? Well by watching what was happening to the others around him
 
Thanks for kicking some real truth in here. My friend is from India and his dad was one of the biggest names behind Volvo India when it started. His dad started other ventures and business because he said he knew they were going to replace him with a white man. Sure enough it happened last year. How did he know this? Well by watching what was happening to the others around him

Thank goodness for the anecdotes that "prove" what a problem this is, and that there are just tons of qualified minority IT professionals who are applying for these positions but just not getting the jobs because businesses would rather hire less qualified white males, even if it means they're businesses will suffer, they won't meet "diversity" goals, and will likely be sued into oblivion for discrimination.

I mean, we wouldn't want to muddy the waters with facts or logic, like, what are the numbers of qualified graduates, by race and sex, in these fields. Much better to enrage certain groups by suggesting they're being fired and replaced with white men.
 
Wait, wait, wait. I thought all of these jobs were being replaced by robots. Unless of course these were racist white robots.
 
Thank goodness for the anecdotes that "prove" what a problem this is, and that there are just tons of qualified minority IT professionals who are applying for these positions but just not getting the jobs because businesses would rather hire less qualified white males, even if it means they're businesses will suffer, they won't meet "diversity" goals, and will likely be sued into oblivion for discrimination.

I mean, we wouldn't want to muddy the waters with facts or logic, like, what are the numbers of qualified graduates, by race and sex, in these fields. Much better to enrage certain groups by suggesting they're being fired and replaced with white men.

If it ain't white it ain't right!
 
I think the longer term approach to diversity in hiring will be to encourage more diversity at the Universities ... the tech companies should offer scholarships for diversity candidates (especially women) to get engineering or technical degrees (they could also offer some interactive scholarships that involve internships and mentoring) ... they can also target their normal internships and co-op activities towards diversity candidates ... they could also increase the number of female and diversity managers (since the managers don't always need to be as technically trained ... the best manager I had when I worked at Intel was a Psych major, the worst was a promoted engineer)
 
Thanks for kicking some real truth in here. My friend is from India and his dad was one of the biggest names behind Volvo India when it started. His dad started other ventures and business because he said he knew they were going to replace him with a white man. Sure enough it happened last year. How did he know this? Well by watching what was happening to the others around him

Kind of ironic they replaced an Indian man with a white man in India. But in America, they would have replaced the white man with an outsourced Indian man . :D
 
Thank goodness for the anecdotes that "prove" what a problem this is, and that there are just tons of qualified minority IT professionals who are applying for these positions but just not getting the jobs because businesses would rather hire less qualified white males, even if it means they're businesses will suffer, they won't meet "diversity" goals, and will likely be sued into oblivion for discrimination.

I mean, we wouldn't want to muddy the waters with facts or logic, like, what are the numbers of qualified graduates, by race and sex, in these fields. Much better to enrage certain groups by suggesting they're being fired and replaced with white men.

My anecdotal evidence (across multiple companies in multiple states using various minorities) trumps your it's not true statement. Besides, my statement was that if you hire minorities more will follow. Why are so many minorities in sports? Because they saw others that look like them succeed in those fields.

Actively recruiting minorities will get you more applicants and will ultimately lead to more minorities going into these fields. Pretending there is no problem, or that there's no way to fix it, is part of the problem.
 
I think the longer term approach to diversity in hiring will be to encourage more diversity at the Universities ... the tech companies should offer scholarships for diversity candidates (especially women) to get engineering or technical degrees (they could also offer some interactive scholarships that involve internships and mentoring) ... they can also target their normal internships and co-op activities towards diversity candidates ... they could also increase the number of female and diversity managers (since the managers don't always need to be as technically trained ... the best manager I had when I worked at Intel was a Psych major, the worst was a promoted engineer)

I think it'll take more than the university level. By then, in some respects, it's probably too late. You have to start no later than high school. If you want to target less affluent kids, then they'd probably have to start at grade school.
 
Kind of ironic they replaced an Indian man with a white man in India. But in America, they would have replaced the white man with an outsourced Indian man . :D

I generally find that outsourced workers are brought in as subject matter experts. There are some exceptions, but they've been the exception. Now there are Indian workers, but they generally have a Masters are better and are here on an H1 and working towards a green card and/or citizenship. I can promise you that nobody I went to school with worked on the cheap. Most of them are multimillionaires. My selection is small, but it's not like we went to an elite college...Indians that can get into an elite engineering grade program probably go the the top India school.
 
Back
Top