Corrupt Apple Exec Sentenced To Prison

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A year in prison for this guy and a $4.5 million fine seems pretty light considering he faced up to twenty years. Let the "bad apple" jokes begin.

Paul S. Devine was sentenced in San Jose federal court earlier this week, more than three years after he pleaded guilty to wire fraud, conspiracy and money laundering. The scheme funneled millions in kickbacks to Devine for passing along confidential information to Apple Inc. suppliers and manufacturers who used the secrets to negotiate more favorable deals.
 
Industrial espionage?
So with this character behind bars Apple with quit ripping off other peoples ideas and designs huh?? :D
 
So with this character behind bars Apple with quit ripping off other peoples ideas and designs huh?? :D
Whats their business model then? That only leaves them with patent spamming really generic ideas, like rectangle shapes for phones, and buying up crappy products and marketing them like crazy to get stupid people to pay 300% for mediocre products.
 
What I don't get is an Apple employee commits fraud against Apple and gets jail time but when other Apple employees defraud the public like the Los Angeles school district iPad scandal, collusion to inflate ebook prices, etc. against the public and taxpayers there's no jail time?
 
so he got millions in kickbacks, and only had to pay 4.5mil. That means he got to keep most of his dirty money.

and 1 year in minimum security prison.

WHERE DO I SIGN UP FOR THIS SHIT? I'll do the time for that kind of money.
 
so he got millions in kickbacks, and only had to pay 4.5mil. That means he got to keep most of his dirty money.

and 1 year in minimum security prison.

WHERE DO I SIGN UP FOR THIS SHIT? I'll do the time for that kind of money.

I know, right?

Download a few songs and have your life ruined.

Commit fraud to the tunes of millions and get a slap on the wrist.

The real story here is that the people at the top are probably celebrating this guy while making sure that the lowly peons are kept under their thumb.

It is all about control.
 
They need to start giving these guys 10+ years in real prison with violent offenders after tattooing a derogatory racial remark on their forehead and a set of knockers on their back.
Maybe that would be a better deterrent.
 
so he got millions in kickbacks, and only had to pay 4.5mil. That means he got to keep most of his dirty money.

and 1 year in minimum security prison.

WHERE DO I SIGN UP FOR THIS SHIT? I'll do the time for that kind of money.

Well without knowing how many millions he got it's impossible to know if the fine was a slap on the wrist or not, same with the jail time really, I mean if he made 2-3 million but had a $4.5 million fine plus a year in jail it's not exactly a sweet deal, if he made $10 million from it then it would be a different story.
 
It's really interesting to see how people react to this. Many people here think crimes for hacking are too harsh. Yet most here seem to think this guys punishment was not harsh enough. Lets break it down how exactly were people harmed by this guy? Apple may have lost money in negotiations with suppliers. Apple isn't hurting too bad right now, neither are its share holders. In fact the millions this guy made could have been a fart in a day for steve jobs.

Look what he did wasn't right or anything but neither is stealing from a grocery store. Both of them are unethical but I don't know about 10 years unethical. Every day in this country some one does a similar kick back for lower amounts of money and none of you blink. Your city council owned by Comcast etc... This guy just happened to be lucky / skilled enough to be in a position at one of the worlds largest companies while doing it. If he had been working for a car dealer and disclosed the bigs other janitorial service companies gave for cleaning the rugs should he goto jail for 10 years?
 
It's really interesting to see how people react to this. Many people here think crimes for hacking are too harsh. Yet most here seem to think this guys punishment was not harsh enough. Lets break it down how exactly were people harmed by this guy? Apple may have lost money in negotiations with suppliers. Apple isn't hurting too bad right now, neither are its share holders. In fact the millions this guy made could have been a fart in a day for steve jobs.

Look what he did wasn't right or anything but neither is stealing from a grocery store. Both of them are unethical but I don't know about 10 years unethical. Every day in this country some one does a similar kick back for lower amounts of money and none of you blink. Your city council owned by Comcast etc... This guy just happened to be lucky / skilled enough to be in a position at one of the worlds largest companies while doing it. If he had been working for a car dealer and disclosed the bigs other janitorial service companies gave for cleaning the rugs should he goto jail for 10 years?

Well firstly he betrayed Apple, so many probably think the death penalty should be applied, but also this guy was an executive, and as such class warfare rules dictate he is evil and no punishment is ever harsh enough.
 
This thread is weird. I would have assumed all you Apple haters would have been celebrating the fact that the only victim he harmed was Apple.
 
Shocking how people with loads of $$$$ get away with so much.

Corruption to the core.....
 
This thread is weird. I would have assumed all you Apple haters would have been celebrating the fact that the only victim he harmed was Apple.

Hey man. We use logic instead of emotion like Apple-only fanbois.
 
Hey man. We use logic instead of emotion like Apple-only fanbois.

Oh the irony....

Also, the article didn't really have much information so we can't be sure how much he actually got out of these deals. Maybe it was just $4.5 million, would have been nice to have an article that isn't about 2 paragraphs with almost zero information.
 
Fining on kickbacks is basically saying they are allowed to keep the money, and the Government is taking a cut of it for you to keep it.

The fines for these kickback should be at least the confiscation of all of the kickback money, and THEN a fine on top of that.
 
It's really interesting to see how people react to this. Many people here think crimes for hacking are too harsh. Yet most here seem to think this guys punishment was not harsh enough. Lets break it down how exactly were people harmed by this guy? Apple may have lost money in negotiations with suppliers. Apple isn't hurting too bad right now, neither are its share holders. In fact the millions this guy made could have been a fart in a day for steve jobs.

Look what he did wasn't right or anything but neither is stealing from a grocery store. Both of them are unethical but I don't know about 10 years unethical. Every day in this country some one does a similar kick back for lower amounts of money and none of you blink. Your city council owned by Comcast etc... This guy just happened to be lucky / skilled enough to be in a position at one of the worlds largest companies while doing it. If he had been working for a car dealer and disclosed the bigs other janitorial service companies gave for cleaning the rugs should he goto jail for 10 years?
As for breaking down how people were hurt by this guy, it's a little more meta than that. He committed fraud and money laundering likely to the tune of millions, yet the only prison time is one year. Would YOU risk one year in prison if it mean you could make MILLIONS and maybe get away with it? Would you risk a year in prison for stealing $100? The idea here is the lighter the sentence, the more it sends a message about what a society finds acceptable.

As for the harm, it's not something easily measured, but the more examples there are of someone committing fraud to the tune of millions, the more our society begins to accept it. So even though these millions were coming from Apple and associated companies, maybe the next person is committing fraud to take from pension or retirement funds and gets away with it because of a culture that tolerates this behavior. While in Apple's case, the actual harm is less perceivable, the point is you can only do so much damage via fraud and money laundering for $100, but there's no limit to the number of victims if you're taking millions depending on where it's directed.
 
It's a good thing he wasn't a black guy working at 7-11 when he did this, otherwise he would have to serve the 10 years, or more.
 
Just like any criminal organization. Send a fall guy with no prior convicts in to take the slap on the wrist, continue business as usual.
 
Back
Top