Why Microsoft's Windows 8 Gamble Didn't Pay Off

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
ZDNet thinks they know why Microsoft's Windows 8 "gamble" didn't pay off. Let's hear what you think.

"On a sales and penetration basis, Windows 8 is not going to be seen as a historic high for Microsoft, it will be more in the Vista category than the [Windows] 7 category simply because people haven't taken to it. The bottom line with OS upgrades is in the numbers."
 
I think their idea behind the 8 platform and the unification of mobile to one device (including the xbox) can be seen as a failure.

The idea was there, but the implementation was a bit poor.
 
It didn't pay off because Metro caused almost complete alienation of their enterprise segment customers and most consumer segment customers without a touchscreen x86-based computing device.

Touchscreen = Windows 8 is pretty damn good
Keyboard and Mouse Only = Teh Suck
 
Wow, I guess ZDNet's news must be slow. Either that or they like beating a dead horse over and over. :D
 
It was a bad decision to try and unify the various platforms by dumbing down the desktop GUI.
Bringing everything down to the lowest common denominator is never a good idea.
 
Wow, I guess ZDNet's news must be slow. Either that or they like beating a dead horse over and over. :D

Didn't you know, ZDNet has a new business philosophy.

58a.jpg
 
It was a bad decision to try and unify the various platforms by dumbing down the desktop GUI.
Bringing everything down to the lowest common denominator is never a good idea.

agree unification of a platform doesn't mean everything has to be exactly the same. Just cohesive enough to do the basic tasks on any device.

Hey on my tablet I go to apps and open the store... On a PC you could be able to open apps and open the store too.

Both don't have to be the exact same tile size/shape etc but a similar enough so a user can switch devices and be pretty confident in major functions...
 
Firstly the idea to bridge tablets and desktop PCs was just a terrible idea and poorly executed. The desktop PC has been refined with decades worth of work, and you think a touchscreen could just replace that? Touchscreens aren't new technology, and if it could be done it would have been done years ago. On top of that they had two UI's mashed together in one OS. Both work completely different from each other.

Then there was the push. Microsoft didn't take no for an answer. You had to get Windows 8 and you were going to like it's new UI, and Microsoft will do it or die trying. Never EVER try to get people to like something they obviously don't. Products aren't made to be accepted, but made to what consumers accept. What do you expect when Microsoft Windows is the only consumer OS besides Mac OS X. Which BTW might have aided in Apples sales cause they didn't force their consumers into anything.
 
If I want a smartphone or tablet OS, I would have bought a smartphone or tablet using it. Daaaa.....

I've stirred everyone asking me for desktop computer advice to avoid a brand that required they have Win8 on it.
 
I'm still amazed Windows 8 was so far off the mark in terms of usability on launch. I mean it really feels like they did zero research on how average people would react to it. I'm impressed a company worth billions thinks that's fine.
 
For once an article that was worth the read instead of clickbait and IMO is pretty much right on the money in its analysis.
 
Apple gets it, Microsoft didn't.

iOS and Mac OS have many things in common, but neither tries to force parts of itself on the other that don't make sense in context.
 
Apple gets it, Microsoft didn't.

iOS and Mac OS have many things in common, but neither tries to force parts of itself on the other that don't make sense in context.

Except the flat look that many are raging about. :D (Raging, not raving.)
 
I'm still amazed Windows 8 was so far off the mark in terms of usability on launch. I mean it really feels like they did zero research on how average people would react to it. I'm impressed a company worth billions thinks that's fine.

Oh they knew. Hopefully Windows 8 was just a failed experiment as opposed to them being arrogant and just not listening to us at all. If not for Classic Shell I would not be using Win 8.1 right now.
 
Touchscreen = Windows 8 is pretty damn good
Keyboard and Mouse Only = Teh Suck

And to clarify...

Touchscreen = Teh Suck
Keyboard and Mouse Only = Far superior input method.

Unless we're talking about cell phones and tablets (which often require a keyboard for lots of typing, in which case a laptop is superior). But my desktop and laptop (yes, it has touch)? Mouse/keyboard are superior. If Microsoft believes people are going to throw away their laptops and desktops and go to cell phones for everything they're mistaken. Although that seems to be their line of thought...
 
It didn't pay off because Metro caused almost complete alienation of their enterprise segment customers and most consumer segment customers without a touchscreen x86-based computing device.

Touchscreen = Windows 8 is pretty damn good
Keyboard and Mouse Only = Teh Suck

I disagree. I have a Surface Pro, and Windows 8 was horrible even on a touch interface. The start menu was about as close as you could get to being useless either way. I just replaced it with the classic start menu at some point.

The problem for touchscreens is that they didn't go nearly far enough. Instead of just making this wholly disconnected and nearly unrelated touchscreen layer, they should have done various enhancements to make the power user's experience easier on a touchscreen. But they didn't.

On the other hand, with the classic UI tweak Windows 8 is really no worse than 7 (performance wise actually better). So, no, the keyboard and mouse users--or at least the power users--didn't really suffer much.

Frankly the OS was just horribly planned out. Windows Vista at least looked good while being bloated (which later on that actually got a lot better. I know as a user); it also lead to Windows 7 visually. Windows 8? I don't know what the heck it was trying to accomplish. I can see what the RT version did, kind of. But the desktop edition? I don't think it really accomplished anything besides being better performance wise. Instead of developing a brand new interface they could have just made a touch mode that tweaked various aspects of the core OS. That would have been much more worthwhile as a desktop OS.

At least it's pretty stable. As a user of it on both of my computers, I rarely have any issues, and games work fine on it now; in fact they work better than they did on W7. That's something.
 
It was quite jarring at first, but I got used to the Start Screen even on my desktop in about 1-2 months after 8 first came out, sue me.

I actually have to admire MS for at least trying something bold and dynamic unlike Apple and OSX. Flame away haters.

The only thing I thought was a stupid idea was Windows RT, especially with making it look just like its x86 counterpart and the confusion that would follow among the general public. They should have made an entirely different UI just as Apple did with iOS and OSX.
 
Vista did better than 8.x is doing in corporate market share. Comparing 8's failure in that and several other senses is unfair to Vista. IOW, there are degrees of failure and in this case, 8 is a bigger failure than Vista.
 
It was quite jarring at first, but I got used to the Start Screen even on my desktop in about 1-2 months after 8 first came out, sue me.

I actually have to admire MS for at least trying something bold and dynamic unlike Apple and OSX. Flame away haters.

The only thing I thought was a stupid idea was Windows RT, especially with making it look just like its x86 counterpart and the confusion that would follow among the general public. They should have made an entirely different UI just as Apple did with iOS and OSX.

They failed because they forced a terrible desktop interface on their customers.

It's like getting "used to" your own crap. It doesn't stink...to you.
 
It didn't pay off because Metro caused almost complete alienation of their enterprise segment customers and most consumer segment customers without a touchscreen x86-based computing device.

Touchscreen = Windows 8 is pretty damn good
Keyboard and Mouse Only = Teh Suck

You'd think he read the forums here since we've said that same exact thing over and over for 2 years now.
 
Vista did better than 8.x is doing in corporate market share. Comparing 8's failure in that and several other senses is unfair to Vista. IOW, there are degrees of failure and in this case, 8 is a bigger failure than Vista.

Vista definitely did better than 8! Too bad poor driver support at launch for Vista, otherwise its a good OS!
 
I think the problem is simple: desktops/laptops and tablets/phones are different tools that serve different purposes. My desktops and laptops are used for production, while my tablets and phones are used for consumption. Windows 8 is great on my Lumia Icon - I like it just as much as iOS. But Windows 8 is vastly inferior to Windows 7 when I need to get work done on my desktops/laptops. As pxc said above, Windows 8 is a worse failure than Vista was, at least in the corporate space.
 
Windows 8.x obviously wasn't successful by Windows standards in terms of adoption percentages and was overall a PR nightmare. That said there are areas where it did things it needed to do. Windows touch and tablet hardware is for more prevalent, much cheaper and much better than it was two years ago, thanks in part to free Windows licensing for lower end devices. Of course going from at cost to free might be considered a failure of Windows 8, but given the economics of Android devices and Chromebooks, free Windows in there spaces is just a reality of the market.
 
But Windows 8 is vastly inferior to Windows 7 when I need to get work done on my desktops/laptops.

Vastly inferior or pretty much the same when using desktop software depending on who you talk to. Of course there are differences between 7 and 8 on the desktop but the place where productive work is done, in desktop applications hasn't changed at all.
 
Yada, Yada, Windows 8 sucks, no it doesn't, touch screens suck, no you suck! ;) :D On and on and on and on and on. No one is going to convince the other of their point of view so give it up everyone. Oh, and I am typing this on my desktop with full screen IE at home in Windows 8.1 Pro. (Works great and does not have a touch screen.)
 
Oh, and I am really looking forward to the release of Windows 10. Not because it has a start menu because personally, I could care less about it. (For personal use that is.) Nope, the real reason I cannot wait for it is because it is going to make the company I work for a lot of money. :D
 
I see the fan boys are here in full force...keep saying they can't change anybody's mind but they'll keep trying and posting and trying and posting and trying and posting, etc...etc...give it a freaking rest already.
 
I see the fan boys are here in full force...keep saying they can't change anybody's mind but they'll keep trying and posting and trying and posting and trying and posting, etc...etc...give it a freaking rest already.

No I can't change anyone's mind. But telling me that using desktop apps on Windows 8.1 is vastly inferior to Windows 7 and makes getting the same tasks done much harder with exactly the same desktop applications makes no sense to someone like me that uses the 8.1 UI daily on desktops and laptops. How is writing code or a working on a Word document or Excel spreadsheet of PDF document using the same software that works the same any harder between 7 and 8.1?
 
I see the fan boys are here in full force...keep saying they can't change anybody's mind but they'll keep trying and posting and trying and posting and trying and posting, etc...etc...give it a freaking rest already.

Why, we really do think alike, that was what I was thinking of the haters as well. :D
 
No I can't change anyone's mind. But telling me that using desktop apps on Windows 8.1 is vastly inferior to Windows 7 and makes getting the same tasks done much harder with exactly the same desktop applications makes no sense to someone like me that uses the 8.1 UI daily on desktops and laptops. How is writing code or a working on a Word document or Excel spreadsheet of PDF document using the same software that works the same any harder between 7 and 8.1?

Just as a thumbs up, I do appreciate many of the things you have shared over the last couple of years, thanks. That said, I figure if they want to limit themselves and their knowledge, let them, more customers for us. :)
 
I'm still amazed Windows 8 was so far off the mark in terms of usability on launch. I mean it really feels like they did zero research on how average people would react to it. I'm impressed a company worth billions thinks that's fine.
They don't sell directly to consumers for one, they sell to PC makers and IT departments.

They also are more focused on what the board thinks than actual moves to maintain/improve sales.

It was not a bad idea to bring mobile devices and PCs together. But they should be a compliment and not a mimic of each other. But a successful compliment would take a little genuine vision and be hard to convince a Board when you have it right. A mimic is easy to explain and pitch. It has the plus of saying you'll save development costs by unifying the platform and its easy to demonstrate when you've achieved a mimic. Plays well for the Board.
 
Just as a thumbs up, I do appreciate many of the things you have shared over the last couple of years, thanks. That said, I figure if they want to limit themselves and their knowledge, let them, more customers for us. :)

Thanks and it's nice to see you and others look at it from a more pragmatic angle. Windows 8 obviously has it flaws but it was a first attempt to do something one the very complex side. Many people simply don't believe that a hybrid OS is doable. Windows 8 didn't do it right but the idea is perfectly sound and can enjoy success with good implementation and hardware that fits the concept.

We're pretty close to the hardware getting there. Two years ago if you had told me that decent Windows 8 tablets could be had for $100 or hybrids for less than $200, I wouldn't have believed it. I said from the beginning that Windows 8 was going to need new hardware at lower prices than what we had two years ago to have a chance. As much as we talk about upgrades here the vast majority of copies of Windows come with new hardware.
 
It was a bad decision to try and unify the various platforms by dumbing down the desktop GUI.
Bringing everything down to the lowest common denominator is never a good idea.

I am just goint to say wait and see, because google is going to do this with android and apple will probably at some point too. And if either of them succeeds what will people do? They will start talking about how MS didn't unify the platforms. Its going to be irony at its best.

The mistake MS made was not smoothing users into it over multiple OS iterations. Windows 10 should have been windows 8, and 8.1 should have been 10. Its not that simple but something sort of like that probably would have went over far better. As it is now NO ONE has any motivation to develop for windows RT. And windows 10 is only making that worse.
 
Without a touch screen, metro UI sucks. C'mon - scrolling UP and DOWN on my mouse wheel causes the screen to move LEFT and RIGHT? WTF is that?
 
I'm still amazed Windows 8 was so far off the mark in terms of usability on launch. I mean it really feels like they did zero research on how average people would react to it. I'm impressed a company worth billions thinks that's fine.

They did do research. But none of it mattered to the guy in charge because he thought he knew better, he really believed he was the second coming of Jobs with some grand fischer-price vision of a unified touch-ueber-alles Windows that came to him one night in mushroom hallucination.

microsoft_steven_sinofsky.jpg
 
Without a touch screen, metro UI sucks. C'mon - scrolling UP and DOWN on my mouse wheel causes the screen to move LEFT and RIGHT? WTF is that?


Ya, its crazy how it works perfectly. Oh wait, you are complaining? About the simplest function and most natural feature on the start menu? If that shit confused you can always purchase a Leapfrog tablet... I hear some have built in web browsers now.
 
Without a touch screen, metro UI sucks. C'mon - scrolling UP and DOWN on my mouse wheel causes the screen to move LEFT and RIGHT? WTF is that?

This has really nothing to do with the modern UI. Some of the criticisms of 8 have more to do with fitting in with old habits. Computers have long supported both horizontal and vertical scrolling, it's just that horizontal scrolling has never been done well with most mice and even with track pads where it's a very natural gesture haven't done it well.

On a Surface Pro 3, the situation that you're mentioning doesn't exist as the track pad there recognizes both horizontal and vertical scrolling. Things actually scroll in the plane relative to the gesture. Amazing.
 
Didn't you know, ZDNet has a new business philosophy.

58a.jpg

Damn, even I have to agree at this point.
I think everything that has needed to be said about Windows 8/8.1 has been done at this point.

There are relevant fixes for almost every issue, 3rd party or not, and are all very easy to implement.
Sensational article is sensational. :p
 
Don't like metro because you are a bandwagoning sob? Hey, guess what? Install start8 you moron and stop complaining about issues that don't exist.

That's exactly what I did, except I went with Classic Shell. Metro be gone. The fact I had to install Classic Shell was because of an issue that existed. That one being - why the hell was I not given an option of what type of UI I wanted to use? :rolleyes:

What bothered me was that MS just didn't listen. They flat out ignored our requests to bring back the classic UI. As if they knew better how to increase my productivity on my desktop. It was totally asinine of them. Like I said earlier, I hope they were well aware and just running a (failed) experiment and don't pull this kind of crap again in the future.

(and some version of it is coming back in Windows 10, and Windows 10 will be a hit)
 
Back
Top