Attack Code For 'Unpatchable' USB Flaw Released

Just keep it straight huh, two guys release the vulnerability, they let the industry know there was a problem.

Then two other guys decided to play techno-terrorists and release attack code that they wrote in order to force the industry to hurry up their response to the vulnerability. The damage they have done will probably cause magnitudes more damage then what would have been caused had they not taken it upon themselves to save us all. These two you can shoot, I'm good with it.
 
so the answer is to shoot the messenger...right
Between Assange and Snowden it appears to be how the Fourth Reich deals with that pesky Constitution.

To the previous poster, what exactly would be the charge against these two guys? Giving a free heads-up to the world that every PC with an enabled USB port is completely defenseless against these exploits? Even more astonishing imo, you defend hackers and our NSA knowing and using these hacks, but not the American people?

I honestly don't get the logic.
 
So help me out here - how does this work? )

Here's how it works: The chip on the malicious drive tells the computer "I'm a keyboard". Then, pretending it's a keyboard, it sends a series of keystrokes to the computer to, say, open up a command prompt with Administrator privileges. At this point, it has complete control over your computer.

Another variant is a USB device that pretends it's a USB-to-Ethernet adapter, and then forges the DHCP response, so that your computer uses dns.badguys.com instead of your ISP's DNS. Then, when you think you're going to yourbank.com, you're actually getting served a page from bank.reallybadguys.com, and they grab your banking login.

The problem is that there's no way for the OS to know whether the USB device is compromised. It can't read the firmware, and even if it could, the malicious code on the USB device could respond with the non-malicious firmware, while hiding itself.

Anyone remember Stuxnet? It used some similar techniques, only they applied to the control systems of the centrifuges.
 
These two you can shoot, I'm good with it.

yes Icpiper

We are quite aware of your fascist proclivities as you have gone to some lengths to illustrate them in the past.

Now run along, the adults are trying to have a conversation.
 
Anyone remember Stuxnet? It used some similar techniques, only they applied to the control systems of the centrifuges.

I was thinking the same thing. Just because you're not plugging said compromised USB into your own personal computer doesn't mean this vulnerability won't be exploited.

Sure, with the vulnerability being announced someone somewhere was certainly working on exploiting it. Though now that the code has been posted on github anyone anywhere has access to it. Take the number of incidents that may have happened and multiply that by 1,000
 
I was thinking the same thing. Just because you're not plugging said compromised USB into your own personal computer doesn't mean this vulnerability won't be exploited.

Sure, with the vulnerability being announced someone somewhere was certainly working on exploiting it. Though now that the code has been posted on github anyone anywhere has access to it. Take the number of incidents that may have happened and multiply that by 1,000

I'm sure the NSA and CIA classified this USB exploit they used for themselves as "Unlikely to be used or discovered by others."
 
Is this flaw limited, at least theoretically, to USB controller firmware? What prevents the same exploit with other host firmwares, e.g. Firewire etc?
 
Between Assange and Snowden it appears to be how the Fourth Reich deals with that pesky Constitution.

To the previous poster, what exactly would be the charge against these two guys? Giving a free heads-up to the world that every PC with an enabled USB port is completely defenseless against these exploits? Even more astonishing imo, you defend hackers and our NSA knowing and using these hacks, but not the American people?

I honestly don't get the logic.

Assange is not a US Citizen so the US Constitution doesn't have a whole lot to do with him. As for good old Ed, the traitor can go fuck himself.
 
Between Assange and Snowden it appears to be how the Fourth Reich deals with that pesky Constitution.

To the previous poster, what exactly would be the charge against these two guys? Giving a free heads-up to the world that every PC with an enabled USB port is completely defenseless against these exploits? Even more astonishing imo, you defend hackers and our NSA knowing and using these hacks, but not the American people?

I honestly don't get the logic.

You don't get the logic?

Read again please, two guys already previously warned us. So these two new guys who wrote and release attack code did not warn us of anything at all. they only did the leg work for other people who will use their work to attack others and if that isn't worthy of a charges of computer crime then wtf is.
 
if that isn't worthy of a charges of computer crime then wtf is.
If you want to know what constitutes a computer crime and what does not, I suggest reading the Computer Fraud and Abuse act. I think you'll find that this isn't one.
 
And this would be the offense to charge them with.

18 U.S. Code § 1030

(5)
(A) knowingly causes the transmission of a program, information, code, or command, and as a result of such conduct, intentionally causes damage without authorization, to a protected computer;
(B) intentionally accesses a protected computer without authorization, and as a result of such conduct, recklessly causes damage; or
(C) intentionally accesses a protected computer without authorization, and as a result of such conduct, causes damage and loss.

I prefer option 5-B myself.

http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1030
 
That's the same as saying, "Put the secrets to a nuclear bomb out there including the implosion design. I mean someone is going to work on it right?"

I don't agree, different levels entirely. A nuke is not easy to develop, even if you have all the knowledge of how to do it. Hence so few countries having them. If it was easy and didn't take time everyone would have them.

Taking apart computer devices and programs in comparison is extremely simple. It took these guys a couple months, less than a year at most. There is no reason the bad guys can't do the same. The only difference is the bad guys won't tell you they found the flaw because they want time to screw people over with it.

Putting the information out there brings it to the forefront of peoples awareness which should ideally mean the problem being addressed more quickly. Otherwise you get things like Microsoft knowing about a flaw for months in advance but only patching when it gets exploited and becomes a real and not a theoretical problem.
 
Or you have 7-C below;

(7) with intent to extort from any person any money or other thing of value, transmits in interstate or foreign commerce any communication containing any—
(A) threat to cause damage to a protected computer;
(B) threat to obtain information from a protected computer without authorization or in excess of authorization or to impair the confidentiality of information obtained from a protected computer without authorization or by exceeding authorized access; or
(C) demand or request for money or other thing of value in relation to damage to a protected computer, where such damage was caused to facilitate the extortion;
 
By writing the attack code and publishing it, they have made themselves conspirators. Saying that someone else may have already done it or will likely do the same does not absolve them of their actions. The wrote, published it, and it is completely reasonable that a criminal will make use of it and others will be damaged because of their actions.

This altruistic response to look at these asshats as good guys has got to stop. They did nothing good, they didn't provided anything new, the industry already knew of the problem. Attempting to force the industry to change their door locks by making copies of their keys and handing them out to criminals on the street is not the way to do things.
 
This altruistic response to look at these asshats as good guys has got to stop. They did nothing good, they didn't provided anything new, the industry already knew of the problem. Attempting to force the industry to change their door locks by making copies of their keys and handing them out to criminals on the street is not the way to do things.

To them, they saved the world. It's the same with ecoterrorists and other activists that cause harm. They are doing it for the good of the people.

The flaw was known. It wasn't fixed. These two released the code that other hackers can manipulate and use to cause damage.

Using the same nuke analogy, the information that nukes are possible and prove it is the first two guys sharing the info. The second two guys are the ones that leak detailed plans on how to create a nuke. The hackers out there can't really use the first bit of info to create a bomb without a lot of knowledge and trying. The second - just follow the directions, and you're good to go.

I'm all for sharing exploits to get them fixed. But, share them with the right people. If you just share them with the world, you're just as bad as the people you're trying to fix the exploits from (the hackers).
 
Taking apart computer devices and programs in comparison is extremely simple. It took these guys a couple months, less than a year at most. There is no reason the bad guys can't do the same. The only difference is the bad guys won't tell you they found the flaw because they want time to screw people over with it.

But not mafia and script kiddies have access. And how responsible are they?

There is NO fix for this flaw. NONE.

That means any web exploit can now target USB devices once they gain control of the computer and download onto the USB device which now can NOT be disinfected.

All the USB device has to do it redirect itself to a malicious command and control server to receive updated instructions as time progresses.

This is a DOOMSDAY Weapon. Iran took over a year last I heard to remove all the infections it was so nasty...and with the help of the best security teams they could hire. (Not that Iran didn't deserve what was coming to them) What chance does the average user have.

Use your fucking head for once.
 
But now mafia and script kiddies have access. And how responsible are they?

There is NO fix for this flaw. NONE.

That means any web exploit can now target USB devices. Once they gain control of the computer and download onto the USB device firmware, there is no safe escape for that computer because the USB device can NOT be disinfected.

All the USB device has to do at that point is redirect itself to a malicious command and control server to receive updated instructions as time progresses.

This is a DOOMSDAY Weapon as there is no fix. What happens to power stations, labs, health facilities, communications facilities, defense contractors etc. that use computers and get hit with this?

Iran took over a year last I heard to remove all the infections it was so nasty... It took the best security teams they could hire and a good deal of scrapped hardware.. (Not that Iran didn't deserve what was coming to them)

What chance does the average user have when new variants can now be written daily and installed with a simple exploit? Remember there is no fix for existing devices due to a flaw in the base standard. It's not the device mfg's fault, but the USB spec's fault.

Use your fucking head for once.
 
You don't get the logic?

Read again please, two guys already previously warned us. So these two new guys who wrote and release attack code did not warn us of anything at all. they only did the leg work for other people who will use their work to attack others and if that isn't worthy of a charges of computer crime then wtf is.
So the alternative is to stick our heads in the sand, pretend the problem doesn't exist and prosecute individuals for what amounts to either a USB spec or implementation problem. Brilliant.
 
The device can pretend to be a keyboard, open a command window and shutdown anti-virus and/or download malicious code form the internet. If you're looking you might see a cmd window for an instant.

When's the last time you got a UAC prompt for installing drivers when you plugged in a mouse?
That is EXACTLY how this works.
 

While a fix might not exist, it seems like this should be easily preventing by minding what device you stick in your ports, and what ports you stick your device in.

Pretty good advice at the best of times, though I suppose it may come more naturally to some.
 
My dick analogy gave me an idea; a device that plugs into a known good USB port; and acts as an intermediary between the port and any device. Writes to firmware are not permitted, could even contain updatable detection software to lets users know something's up. A USB condom as it were. Someone will make millions.
 
While a fix might not exist, it seems like this should be easily preventing by minding what device you stick in your ports, and what ports you stick your device in.

Pretty good advice at the best of times, though I suppose it may come more naturally to some.
30 years ago it was known as "Don't accept floppies from geeks." Same problem and cause.
 
Meh. The sky isn't falling. If the means to inject malicious code exists in the firmware of existing devices then that same code path can be used to patch the firmware. LOL decade.

Source: Engineer who writes embedded firmware for USB host controllers

Exactly, this is kind of reminding me of the Y2K scare.
 
Exactly, this is kind of reminding me of the Y2K scare.
I'm not sure how this suggestion could work. It doesn't matter how an existing firmware is patched, malware can simply replace the entire thing. Also device intermediaries would have the exact same inability as the OS to recognize malware before it does its damage.

One solution might be for OS's to (as ridiculous as it sounds) whitelist USB firmwares, and limit operation of the bus to those firmwares/devices. Absolute nightmare to maintain because of the number of USB types and devices, but so far I can't think of anything else.
 
My dick analogy gave me an idea; a device that plugs into a known good USB port; and acts as an intermediary between the port and any device. Writes to firmware are not permitted, could even contain updatable detection software to lets users know something's up. A USB condom as it were. Someone will make millions.

I love the USB condom idea. I'll take a box
 
yes Icpiper

We are quite aware of your fascist proclivities as you have gone to some lengths to illustrate them in the past.

Now run along, the adults are trying to have a conversation.

Fascist, that's a new one.

A new achievement unlocked.

I'll run another analogy past you, see if you get the point.

Two months ago some researchers released information about a flaw in ATM Machine code.

Two months ago. A major problem, a serious potential vulnerability. A problem what would take the industry a little time to get figured out, probably a little more then two months.

Now, two months later, these other two researchers decide to reverse engineer the vulnerability and wrote an attack code and published that code online for anyone to grab. Now all anyone needs is a magnetic swipe-card writer, some blank cards, and this code, and they can steal a bunch of money from your bank accounts and make purchases against your accounts.

And you don't think that their actions are illegal. You don't think that they actively took actions that compromised the integrity of systems world wide.
 
I'm sure the NSA and CIA classified this USB exploit they used for themselves as "Unlikely to be used or discovered by others."

You do realize that from the point of the first release of info at BlackHat 2014 only two months have gone by?

Why is it you think the NSA used this vulnerability? I am not saying they haven't, just asking why you say they have.

CIA has nothing to do with it, CYBERCOM would, but not the CIA.
 
You do realize that from the point of the first release of info at BlackHat 2014 only two months have gone by?

Why is it you think the NSA used this vulnerability? I am not saying they haven't, just asking why you say they have.

CIA has nothing to do with it, CYBERCOM would, but not the CIA.
Read the referenced articles in the original post. That's why.

You really need to grow a pair imo and stop blaming individuals for exposing a generic USB specification (or implementation, or both) problem. USB sticks can't be trusted now, period, regardless of how many people we throw in jail.

Good grief.
 
I'm not sure how this suggestion could work. It doesn't matter how an existing firmware is patched, malware can simply replace the entire thing. Also device intermediaries would have the exact same inability as the OS to recognize malware before it does its damage.

One solution might be for OS's to (as ridiculous as it sounds) whitelist USB firmwares, and limit operation of the bus to those firmwares/devices. Absolute nightmare to maintain because of the number of USB types and devices, but so far I can't think of anything else.

Perhaps the designers should have thought about this when they created USB.
Serial and 5-pin DIN ftw! :D
 
So the alternative is to stick our heads in the sand, pretend the problem doesn't exist and prosecute individuals for what amounts to either a USB spec or implementation problem. Brilliant.

Exactly. Let's throw the authors of Metasploit, Kali Linux, etc. in jail too while we're at it.
 
I'm sure the NSA and CIA classified this USB exploit they used for themselves as "Unlikely to be used or discovered by others."
I don't believe Stuxnet used this particular exploit, but it *did* use a zero-day autorun exploit in Windows. On top of that, it targeted a specific application--the one Iranian engineers used to create the programs that ran on the VFD controllers for the centrifuges. It would modify the program files created by that application. The modified programs got uploaded onto the VFD controllers. From that point, whenever the Iranian engineers would upload a new program, the malicious program would modify the newly-uploaded program. So even if the engineers cleaned up the originally-infected computer and uploaded a clean program to the VFD controller, the VFD controller would remain infected. And to make things even better, when engineers would download the program *from* the VFD controller to verify whether it was infected, the malicious program would return a *clean* copy of what had earlier been uploaded.

That's not all of it, either--Stuxnet had to cross an air gap in order to get into the facility as well. And the list goes on. From an engineering/design perspective, Stuxnet was/is a truly impressive piece of work.
 
By Ur_Mom;
The flaw was known. It wasn't fixed. These two released the code that other hackers can manipulate and use to cause damage.

You expected a fix to the USB standard in 2 months time? To something that's actually a low risk problem and requires physical access to attack. Wow, you don't expect much do you.
 
There is NO fix for this flaw. NONE.

That means any web exploit can now target USB devices. Once they gain control of the computer and download onto the USB device firmware, there is no safe escape for that computer because the USB device can NOT be disinfected.

All the USB device has to do at that point is redirect itself to a malicious command and control server to receive updated instructions as time progresses.


Wow wow wow, slow down a little DigitalGriffin, it's not that easy. It's one thing for a flash update to look for and find USB hardware that it is written for. It's another thing entirely for the flash to access a device that it has to guess at. Let's use your standard 101 keyboard. Maybe the eprom for it is very generic, it has a Standard Windows Driver so the eprom code is also probably very generic and standard. Maybe a given OS will identify a Standard 101 Keyboard the same or maybe it won't. You can't address something you don't know the address of. So now the code has to find the address from your OS, more code. Go to the Device Manager, take a look at the Device ID Code for your Keyboard, record the ID Number. Now plug that keyboard into another computer and conversely check a new programmable keyboard in both computers as well. See how Windows or whatever OS you use labels and IDs this hardware.

I am not saying there isn't a risk, I am just saying that it might not be as easy as it initially sounds.
 
The problem is that there's no way for the OS to know whether the USB device is compromised. It can't read the firmware, and even if it could, the malicious code on the USB device could respond with the non-malicious firmware, while hiding itself.

Not entirely. The OS could "test" for known expected responses. Now I know you are saying that the bad code could be written to return "valid" responses to the test but this doesn't happen without a cost. USB Device EPROMs do not have unlimited space for code. Now your EPROM must hold the "payload" and the "camouflage". Not impossible but it starts to become device dependent. Say, you could do this with a Laser Printer but not a standard USB mouse as an example.
 
Read the referenced articles in the original post. That's why.

You really need to grow a pair imo and stop blaming individuals for exposing a generic USB specification (or implementation, or both) problem. USB sticks can't be trusted now, period, regardless of how many people we throw in jail.

Good grief.

JeffDC, my "pair" is big enough not to have any problems standing up to people who spout bullshit about things they don't know anything about. I didn't blame anyone for releasing information about the existence of the vulnerability. I blame the creators of the attack code for releasing that attack code to the entire internet. Two months was no where near enough time for industry to react to this problem. I'll tell you why these two asshats released this attack code, they wanted to make a splash during this years BlackHat conference. They wanted to get known and don't try and sell some bullshit like they were trying to force the industry to save us all, you can believe that if you want, I don't. If their intentions were so selfless and noble why in hell didn't they just notify the industry first and warn them? Were they afraid that the industry would blow them off?

Think about it. There is a simple fix, costly, but simple. A new hardened USB Standard. Call it USBH1.0 if you want. All the USB devices in the world and you don't think the industry would welcome the opportunity to resell all of them? OMG, think of the surge in sales, manufacturing, jobs, etc. Everyone has to replace all their shit with new shit, whooahh!.
 
Back
Top