Where in the law does it state that the burden of proving consent is on the accused?No, that's an affirmative defense. The accuser admits that they had sex and then has to demonstrate that it was consensual.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Where in the law does it state that the burden of proving consent is on the accused?No, that's an affirmative defense. The accuser admits that they had sex and then has to demonstrate that it was consensual.
Yep the girl may have been going around giving blowjobs she just can't remember a thing next morning. Is it the guys fault then, who she dragged to bed intoxicated? Hell no.
Having said that, there are many cases where people take advantage of girls who passed out. I've seen it happen personally - people stuffed objects into a girls pussy while she was passed out. That constitutes as a rape by itself. It even happened on Big Brother, a guy was fingering a passed out girl right in front of live tv. Both were wasted of course, both didn't understand exactly what they were doing or he wouldn't have done what he did knowing every place is being filmed 24/7.
Burden of proof is not a static concept.Where in the law does it state that the burden of proving consent is on the accused?
I can google too, but you haven't shown me where in the law it shifts the burden of proof.snip
1) Can you quote any law, or cite any case where the accused has to prove consent when there is no forensic evidence? If you google "burden of consent in rape" you can find half a dozen blogs arguing in favor of shifting the burden of proof to the accused, so I'm highly skeptical of this claim.When a woman accuses a man of rape without any other forensic evidence, that's prima facia evidence that the rape occurred. The defendant can either argue that he did not have sex with her (a general denial or normal defense) or he can argue that he did have sex with her but that it was consensual (affirmative defense).
I'm going to try and clarify this for you once again:
None of what you are talking about is relevant because this legislation is directing informal College disciplinary hearings, not criminal cases.
This is simply mandating that disciplinary hearings deciding whether students have violated student conduct codes on campus ask whether and how the accused knew he or she had consent to have sex with the accuser rather than forcing the accuser to prove she said no well good enough to constitute a sufficient NO! to her rapist.
I'm not supportive of these legislative changes.And as it's been shown in the Occidental College case, even if consent has been established by text messages to each other, and other people that they were going to have sex, it's ruled as sexual assault because she was drinking. The fact that he was also drinking does not matter. The fact that she was convinced by a professor that it was rape because he fit a 'rapist demographic' (he's a jock and a valedictorian) nor the fact that it came up a year later matters.
Why? Because when you get down to it, it's because it has the potential of messing with the schools money. If they don't investigate every accusation with a tribunal, the Government has threatened to pull the school's funding.
If all they have is he said, she said, well, what can you do? If you go by sexual history, you can be sure to get called out by for slut shaming if she has a extensive history. And as other cases have shown, if the tribunal calls it consensual well it's worse because they swept it under the rug, and 'no woman would lie about being raped'...
This is why people had had a problem with creating legislation about it. No one is saying it shouldn't be taken seriously but boiling it down to expressed consent, is treating everything as black and white, when it's almost is never that easy.
Good, then google "affirmative consent burden of proof" and read the articles that come up since both supporters and opponents of these kinds of bills agree that it has shifted the burden of proof the accused.I can google too
You are also welcome to cite a case as I previously suggested. The burden of proof for consent (or lack thereof) in absence of "forensic evidence" appears to overwhelmingly fall on the accuser.laws don't specifically state where the burden of proof lies because it's a legal theory and, as I wrote earlier, it's not static.
I'm not under that impression.You seem to be under the incorrect impression that the burden of proof is something that one party has and the other does not.
If you're tired of this conversation you're welcome to leave it.Frankly, I'm tired of explaining to you a concept you apparently don't understand and are more interesting in arguing over rather than learning about it.
Sorry, it's not all about you.If you're tired of this conversation you're welcome to leave it.
If you aren't under the impression that one party has a burden of proof and the other does not, then why do you keep asking for a specific case or law that explains burden of proof?You are also welcome to cite a case as I previously suggested. The burden of proof for consent (or lack thereof) in absence of "forensic evidence" appears to overwhelmingly fall on the accuser.
I don't know why you would presume this to change all of a sudden.
I'm not under that impression.
I wasn't asking you to leave. If you're not enjoying your conversation with me then you might want to disengage from it. I am not tired of it, so I would continue.Sorry, it's not all about you.
I've asked you to provide some citations to support some of your claims because I don't believe they are correct. I don't think asking for evidence is being stubborn.You are wrong and stubborn when you are wrong and I'm not going to continue explaining complex legal concepts to someone like yourself who clearly wants to argue rather than learn.
I wasn't asking for that. I asked for for a "cit[ation] [of] any case where the accused has to prove consent when there is no forensic evidence", because you made that claim. Note the difference.If you aren't under the impression that one party has a burden of proof and the other does not, then why do you keep asking for a specific case or law that explains burden of proof?
I don't think asking for evidence is being stubborn.
Every single case under this lawI wasn't asking for that. I asked for for a "cit[ation] [of] any case where the accused has to prove consent when there is no forensic evidence", because you made that claim. Note the difference.
Now the accused has to demonstrate that the sex was consensual and that the accuser demonstrated an adequate, "yes"
You said something that I didn't believe was correct. Now we're having a conversation about it. I didn't have this conversation with myself for the last couple pages; you were a willing participant. I think this is acceptable for a discussion forum, and I don't think I've been rude about it.What exactly is your point anyway? You seem to really be concerned about it [...]
Since this law is just coming into effect, I suppose that means you cannot cite any case which backs your claim.Every single case under this law![]()
What do you mean "back my claim?"Since this law is just coming into effect, I suppose that means you cannot cite any case which backs your claim.
Let's also note that you made the claim about the historical law here.
Prostitution should definitely be legal. It would cut down on some desperate people doing stupid shit. I say legalize most drugs while we're at it too, minus meth.The answer. Hookers. Much better than a rape charge.
What do you mean "back my claim?"
The law, which you posted the text of so go back and read your own link, states as clearly as possible that the burden of proof for establishing the sex was consensual rests squarely on the accused. The accused must provide evidence that the sex was agreed to affirmatively, he (or she) can not simply rely on the lack of a "no" in order to prove the sex was consensual.
I wrote that in criminal law, lacking forensic evidence, a woman's claim that she has been raped is a prima facia claim that a rape has occurred. She has met her burden of proof for the case to proceed. The burden of proof then shifts to the defense and he (or she) has to then prove the defense.
I'm a professor so it's partly in my nature to explain a difficult concept to someone who wants to learn but you are seriously coming across as simply being stubborn because it really can't be explained much clearer than this. So, while it's fair to ask for resources and evidence and whatever, it's another to completely disregard lengthy responses to your questions that outline how the law works, the theory behind the concept, and then pointing you to the actual text of the law.
You still have to be able to put two and two together on your own even when I give you all the pieces of the puzzle.
Instead of going round and round in circles, if you want me to take your questions seriously explain to me why you think this does not[/i] shift the burden of proof to the accused when he has to tell the hearing's officer that he had consent and then must explain what that consent looked like (other than a simple, you don't believe it).
As in provide references demonstrating that the legal system operates the way you claim (when in dispute). I'm not doing this for the sake of being argumentative.What do you mean "back my claim?"
Instead of going round and round in circles, if you want me to take your questions seriously explain to me why you think this does not[/i] shift the burden of proof to the accused when he has to tell the hearing's officer that he had consent and then must explain what that consent looked like (other than a simple, you don't believe it).
As in provide references demonstrating that the legal system operates the way you claim (when in dispute). I'm not doing this for the sake of being argumentative.
If that's the new procedure then I agree the burden of proof has shifted. Why is consent no longer the default position? Why does the victim no longer have to make a strong case for non-consent?
You said the law I linked stated this clearly. Can you reference that? Again, not doing this to be argumentative.
(1) An affirmative consent standard in the determination of whether consent was given by both parties to sexual activity. Affirmative consent means affirmative, conscious, and voluntary agreement to engage in sexual activity. It is the responsibility of each person involved in the sexual activity to ensure that he or she has the affirmative consent of the other or others to engage in the sexual activity. Lack of protest or resistance does not mean consent, nor does silence mean consent. Affirmative consent must be ongoing throughout a sexual activity and can be revoked at any time. The existence of a dating relationship between the persons involved, or the fact of past sexual relations between them, should never by itself be assumed to be an indicator of consent.
No disagreement on this definition. It narrows the scope of what constitutes consent.
This does not follow from the definition of affirmative consent. This is a procedural question. What evidence is there that burden to prove consent is now on the accused (vs. the victim proving non-consent)?--
When a dispute arises over whether the accused had consent the onus is on the accused to provide evidence that he or she had consent.
How are you not understanding that when an issue of consent arises in a hearing that the accused is going to have to produce evidence that he or she believed he had consent?No disagreement on this definition. It narrows the scope of what constitutes consent.
Note that this definition makes no reference to legal procedure, or the default presumption of consent.
This does not follow from the definition of affirmative consent. This is a procedural question. What evidence is there that burden to prove consent is now on the accused (vs. the victim proving non-consent)?
so long as you time each thrust between each exclamationSometimes I hear "YES YES YES YES YES" does that count?![]()
I do understand that. That is the same as now. Currently, the accused will defend themselves against claims of non-consent.How are you not understanding that when an issue of consent arises in a hearing that the accused is going to have to produce evidence that he or she believed he had consent?
Agreed the accuser still has to argue non-consent.Obviously the accuser is going to argue that she (or he) did not give consent. What other proof would the hearing officer require?
Consent can only be acquired affirmatively - that does not mean the burden of proving consent moves to the accused. Please note the distinction.I quoted the portion that explicitly states that consent is no longer assumed...it must be gained explicitly. Why would you respond that the quoted section makes not default presumption of consent when it specifically details that consent is not present unless the parties involved obtain it?
Agreed.The state of the law before "affirmative consent" is that consent is present unless it's demonstrated that the victim withdrew it. That's what victims had to overcome during a rape allegation: whether or not they sufficiently demonstrated to their assailants that they were not consenting to the sexual assault!
Because consent ought to be affirmative. How we define consent, and our criteria for criminal guilt (or some lesser guilt), are separate questions.Why do you think institutions have been passing this clarification for the past few years?
What states? For science, and stuff.Hookers are legal in certain states.
The difference is that now the accused has to provide evidence that he or she obtained consent. Before, the accuser had to provide evidence that he or she withdrew consent.It follows that in both "consent" and "affirmative consent" cases:
1) Victim makes an argument for non-consent
2) Accused makes an argument for consent
Why do you think institutions have been passing this clarification for the past few years?
The law is intended to remove the presumption of consent and mandate that all parties must obtain consent. During a dispute over consent, the victim no longer has to prove that she withdrew consent; rather the accused has to prove he obtained consent.
I understand that's your claim, but it could just as well be: victim must show she did not provide consent.The difference is that now the accused has to provide evidence that he or she obtained consent. Before, the accuser had to provide evidence that he or she withdrew consent.
Certainly you're arguing that it is prima facie, but that's not historically the case, and there is nothing explicit in the law that says that would change.The accusation itself is prima facia evidence for lack of consent in an affirmative consent case.
Is there not one damn criminal lawyer on this forum to end this damn discussion already? I mean, to shut someone down ( mope54).
When the victim comes forward and lodges an allegation of rape, there is nothing more for her to claim.I understand that's your claim, but it could just as well be: victim must show she did not provide consent.
The accused could no longer claim passive consent, but the burden of proof would not have shifted.
My claim is that the law doesn't speak to that.