Windows 8 Gaining Market Share

Win8 hate, mostly justified, hardly rectified.
I thought it was great on phones and tablets but wanted to throw my 8 laptop out of the window which got me using linux on it instead becuse linux felt more like windows than windows did...
Boom! Minds blown, just as fast as the opportunity to make an OS that was an impovement on 7.
 
Is installing Classic Shell really that hard ? :rolleyes:

For a single system? No.

Now tell an IT department that they have yet ANOTHER piece of software to add to a standard image. And that there are STILL retraining costs, regardless...

Yeah, most IT departments are gonna be going "Fuck that noise, Go Win7!".

And that's pretty much EXACTLY what's happened.
 
Windows 8 is a great OS. Fast and responsive. Breathes new life to older laptops. Anyone that complains about W8 on a desktop environment should just shut up and install either Classicshell or Start8.

:rolleyes:

Windows 8 is a great OS. It has a sucky UI that destroys productivity and offloads expensive retraining costs to the parent organization. Anyone that complains about those with legitimate concerns about the Metro/Modern UI should just shut up and get on with their single machine support experience instead of yapping on something they don't know about.
 
:rolleyes:

Windows 8 is a great OS. It has a sucky UI that destroys productivity and offloads expensive retraining costs to the parent organization. Anyone that complains about those with legitimate concerns about the Metro/Modern UI should just shut up and get on with their single machine support experience instead of yapping on something they don't know about.

How does it destroy productivity praytell? It has a more efficient work flow than windows 7 could ever dream. Metro is 100% optional. My wife hasn't seen metro on her laptop in almost 2 yeara, no classic she'll or 3rd party software required.
 
I'm Director of IT at a Southeastern Corporation. If an applicant starts bad-mouthing Windows 8 in an interview I immediately cross him off the list. A tech's job is to make things work and not to make judgements. In my opinion the difference between Windows 7 and 8 is really insignificant.

No opinions allowed at your corporation? Does your boss know you are scratching people with brains off the list?
 
Then you're a terrible IT director. They removed a lot of the great network functionality for enterprises when they created Windows 8. One of the biggest is managing network start menus. Google it.
You realize you can enforce a start screen via group policy, right?

That functionality was added back ages ago when 8.1 dropped.
 
I'm Director of IT at a Southeastern Corporation. If an applicant starts bad-mouthing Windows 8 in an interview I immediately cross him off the list. A tech's job is to make things work and not to make judgements. In my opinion the difference between Windows 7 and 8 is really insignificant.

Sounds pretty judgmental and opinionated to me. "I'm right and everyone who doesn't agree with me is wrong!". :D

I was explaining to a friend the "Pro-Microsoft At Any Costs IT World circle jerk" earlier and that example fits in perfectly.
 
this exactly.

give it 10 years where the same people will be kicking and complaining when MS takes it away.

To be fair, do you think anyone will put up a stink when they take Vista away? Wait, have they taken vista away yet?
 
What's the diffetence between Win8 and Atari's E.T. game?
You bury both in a landfill and people will actually try to dig it up 30 years later.....:D
 
What's the diffetence between Win8 and Atari's E.T. game?
You bury both in a landfill and people will actually try to dig it up 30 years later.....:D

You bury both and people will actually try to dig up E.T. 30 years later.
Damn mobile posting, I've gotta start using the preview button more when I'm typing on my phone!
 
Then you're a terrible IT director. They removed a lot of the great network functionality for enterprises when they created Windows 8. One of the biggest is managing network start menus. Google it.

No, you don't go into such things with entrenched views and opinions.

If you walk in to an interview saying "I don't like this or that!" then that tells me you don't have an open mind and may not offer the correct solution for the issue at hand.

You rollout the best fit for the job whether its Linux/Windows or whatever. Not what you personally prefer. That's one of the biggest mistakes IT people make by pushing THEIR preferred solution rather then the solution that's best for the customer.
 
If you walk in to an interview saying "I don't like this or that!" then that tells me you don't have an open mind and may not offer the correct solution for the issue at hand.

You rollout the best fit for the job whether its Linux/Windows or whatever. Not what you personally prefer. That's one of the biggest mistakes IT people make by pushing THEIR preferred solution rather then the solution that's best for the customer.

I don't like a lot of things that we deploy. I still do it, and we make it work. I don't have to like them to make them effective. Now, if I didn't like them and refused to work with it, that's a whole different story. But, I'd hire someone if they didn't like something because of x and y, but knew enough to know about x and y and how to work around it. No product will be great, some will have flaws. Some won't be liked. But, liking or disliking something doesn't mean they don't know it or won't use it.

I don't like Lotus Notes, but that's what we used (went to Outlook/Office 365 recently). Same with Blackberry (recently went to Apple or Windows Phone).
 
I don't like a lot of things that we deploy. I still do it, and we make it work. I don't have to like them to make them effective. Now, if I didn't like them and refused to work with it, that's a whole different story. But, I'd hire someone if they didn't like something because of x and y, but knew enough to know about x and y and how to work around it. No product will be great, some will have flaws. Some won't be liked. But, liking or disliking something doesn't mean they don't know it or won't use it.

I don't like Lotus Notes, but that's what we used (went to Outlook/Office 365 recently). Same with Blackberry (recently went to Apple or Windows Phone).

What your saying I think is different than what other posters were implying. If you have a solid reason for disliking a product then i absolutely agree that it shouldnt remove them from consideration. But that is given they absolutely have enough background knowledge to draw a legitimate conclusion as to why it isn't a good solution in many cases.

That would actually show 2 things, analysis technique/abilities, and just a technical understanding which i think both are desirable for IT jobs
 
What your saying I think is different than what other posters were implying. If you have a solid reason for disliking a product then i absolutely agree that it shouldnt remove them from consideration. But that is given they absolutely have enough background knowledge to draw a legitimate conclusion as to why it isn't a good solution in many cases.

That would actually show 2 things, analysis technique/abilities, and just a technical understanding which i think both are desirable for IT jobs

However if its just blind hatred for a product with know background information then i wouldnt consider that candidate either.
 
You realize you can enforce a start screen via group policy, right?

That functionality was added back ages ago when 8.1 dropped.

You aren't seriously suggesting that GP start screens are as effective and easily managed as ABE redirected start menus? Have you ever sat down to make a GP start screen? Now multiply that by 22 x 6 user groups.
 
You aren't seriously suggesting that GP start screens are as effective and easily managed as ABE redirected start menus? Have you ever sat down to make a GP start screen? Now multiply that by 22 x 6 user groups.
Redirection still works, just like it always has, for managing the "All apps" section of the Start Screen.

Not seeing the problem here...
 
I do IT and moved my boxes to 8 and then 8.1 because, simply put, using a new OS is the easiest way to become familiar with it and I couldn't afford to be ignorant of the changes in 8 and 8.1, regardless of how much I wanted to stay on 7.

After having used 8 and 8.1 on my system for a long time now, I've got it to a very usable state. I still don't feel it's a functional improvement over 7 in any way aside from maybe the new Task Manager and how it handles multiple simultaneous file transfers (along with ability to pause).

A lot of the features I was really looking forward to turned out to just be exaggerated BS that never actually materialized. Windows 8 was supposed to automatically load-balance when you had multiple network connections on the same network. It does come with integrated teaming, but nothing better than what has already been possible via Intel PROSet for the last 10+ years. Windows 8 was supposed to re-introduce hardware audio acceleration (EAX has been unsupported since XP), yet that seems to have evaporated.
 
User wise 8.1 is a step forward.

However, support wise Windows 8.1 is a big step backwards. Windows update is unreliable. The 8.1 update was a huge mistake (building a machine twice). The License keys in the BIOS doesn't work very well. Secure boot is a waste of time.

In actual fact for grassroots support folks to rebuild a Windows 8.1 machine is almost financially non-viable with regards to the time it takes.
 
I don't like a lot of things that we deploy. I still do it, and we make it work. I don't have to like them to make them effective. Now, if I didn't like them and refused to work with it, that's a whole different story. But, I'd hire someone if they didn't like something because of x and y, but knew enough to know about x and y and how to work around it. No product will be great, some will have flaws. Some won't be liked. But, liking or disliking something doesn't mean they don't know it or won't use it.

I don't like Lotus Notes, but that's what we used (went to Outlook/Office 365 recently). Same with Blackberry (recently went to Apple or Windows Phone).

I was going to post the same thing. There are plenty of products that I've come to hate over the years, but that doesn't mean the job doesn't get done. Hire people for their skills and work ethic, not their personal preferences.
 
I was going to post the same thing. There are plenty of products that I've come to hate over the years, but that doesn't mean the job doesn't get done. Hire people for their skills and work ethic, not their personal preferences.

that being said you shouldnt be answering interview questions like this based on your personal preference either. You answer it in a professional manor and that includes the ability to make things work as opposed to writing off a potential solution
 
that being said you shouldnt be answering interview questions like this based on your personal preference either. You answer it in a professional manor and that includes the ability to make things work as opposed to writing off a potential solution

Depends on the question. If they ask how I feel about a product, I'll give an honest answer. But, I will let it be known that if it's the available solution, it'll be used. I know about products that I don't like (some of them I don't like because I do know about the details), but when it comes down to business - it doesn't matter what I like or don't like - that's what's being used and needs supported.
 
Back
Top