Windows 9 Will Kill Microsoft's Awkward Charms Menu

Has nothing to do with "can't cope with change". Different just for the sake of being different is poor design.

There is a reason steering wheels have stuck around for 90+ years. Sometimes the design/invention IS that good.

There's more to it than that; that's what I thought at first, too.
Microsoft really wanted to push their app store, and rather than easing into it, they literally threw it into everyone's faces.

I suppose they do have to make money, but those apps will never stick around, and will eventually have the same demise as the Gadgets on Windows Vista/7; they went from being awesome tech to a "security risk". (really, Microsoft?)
Oh well, it's not like the software and OS industry hasn't been like this since the early 80's, it's just that now we have the technology to actually back these types of business models, good or bad as they may be.
 
Unfortunately, because of Microsoft's poor choices in these areas, Windows 8 is going to be regarded through history as the next ME/Vista, even though it is far more deserving than that.
You know this is bad when the [H]ard Linux Shill is starting to defend Windows 8. :eek:

Public regard can be fickle. Sure Vista was a flop, but most of the major changes that Vista bought are still in 8. 7 was successful with pretty much everything Vista had, just better implemented.

There's more to it than that; that's what I thought at first, too.
Microsoft really wanted to push their app store, and rather than easing into it, they literally threw it into everyone's faces.

I suppose they do have to make money, but those apps will never stick around, and will eventually have the same demise as the Gadgets on Windows Vista/7; they went from being awesome tech to a "security risk". (really, Microsoft?)
Oh well, it's not like the software and OS industry hasn't been like this since the early 80's, it's just that now we have the technology to actually back these types of business models, good or bad as they may be.

The Windows Store its apps aren't going anywhere. There are some very nice apps now and with modern apps running in a window on the desktop there won't be any need to ease anyone into anything, modern apps will be like anything else on the desktop.
 
You'd think that with Vista, nobody liked the side bar then either that they kept it out of 7 and made gadgets capable of being anywhere on the desktop, only to bring back the side bar (via Charms) in Windows 8 and killing off gadgets unless you get third party hacks.

I love Windows 8, but like most of you, I also find the Charms bar annoying. It's always in the way when I move my cursor out of the way to the side of the screen, or sometimes when closing a window or program hitting the red X at the top right corner. Right-clicking the start icon gets me most of the admin function I need 99.9% of the time.

On my Surface Pro however, I like the Charms bar just fine.
 
Has nothing to do with "can't cope with change". Different just for the sake of being different is poor design.

There is a reason steering wheels have stuck around for 90+ years. Sometimes the design/invention IS that good.

Yet, the start menu is NOT a steering wheel. It is more like the turn signal stalk on a car. Thankfully, 10 years from now, I will no longer have to deal with this start menu on new operating systems anymore.
 
Public regard can be fickle. Sure Vista was a flop, but most of the major changes that Vista bought are still in 8. 7 was successful with pretty much everything Vista had, just better implemented.

Hopefully enough fixes and polish will be made to Windows 9 for it to be the next 7 or XP.

The Windows Store its apps aren't going anywhere. There are some very nice apps now and with modern apps running in a window on the desktop there won't be any need to ease anyone into anything, modern apps will be like anything else on the desktop.
We'll see.
I'm not saying you're wrong, but I've seen a trend in software and platforms since the 90's where people and companies both say "this is here to stay" and yet, a few years later, everything is gone and none of it is supported on any platform.

Blackberry apps, PDA apps, Windows Vista/7 gadgets, etc.
I would actually like it if Microsoft proved me wrong; it's not like I like abandonware or anything. :(
 
Hope they bring back Media Center out of box too. I thought it stupid as hell that we're charged extra for what's essentially a full-screen Windows Media Player. They need to bring back Media Center and incorporate it as a tile system like Start Screen and X-box One's GUI.
 
Blackberry apps, PDA apps, Windows Vista/7 gadgets, etc.
I would actually like it if Microsoft proved me wrong; it's not like I like abandonware or anything. :(

There's really no comparison between Windows Store/Windows RT apps and gadgets. Windows RT is the foundation for all of Microsoft's tablet and phone offerings. Even if those products are successful today, I don't see how Microsoft could drop the 1/2 million apps that are now using this API on Windows phones, tablets and PCs. With the introduction of Universal Apps Microsoft is expanding the reach of Windows RT, even onto the Xbox. I know that people love to talk about all of the stuff that Microsoft abandons but there's a an awful lot that they have stuck with for years and years while offering industry leading backwards compatibility.
 
Hope they bring back Media Center out of box too. I thought it stupid as hell that we're charged extra for what's essentially a full-screen Windows Media Player. They need to bring back Media Center and incorporate it as a tile system like Start Screen and X-box One's GUI.

That would be great but Media Center is a very niche market. I'm more concerned about have the option at all, even it is an at cost add-on.
 
Hope they bring back Media Center out of box too. I thought it stupid as hell that we're charged extra for what's essentially a full-screen Windows Media Player. They need to bring back Media Center and incorporate it as a tile system like Start Screen and X-box One's GUI.

Add a fan of WMC, saddens me to say it will never be brought back.
 
I know that people love to talk about all of the stuff that Microsoft abandons but there's a an awful lot that they have stuck with for years and years while offering industry leading backwards compatibility.

Uh huh. Tell that to all the WP7 users that MS just abandoned by dropping Skype on that platform. Some of whom have only had the phone for 2yrs. Meanwhile Skype still supported on Android phones that are over 4 years old.

In any case desktop users are going to continue to ignore metro apps in Win9 since they're functionally stripped down web widgets that are pointless next to desktop equivalents.
 
Uh huh. Tell that to all the WP7 users that MS just abandoned by dropping Skype on that platform. Some of whom have only had the phone for 2yrs. Meanwhile Skype still supported on Android phones that are over 4 years old.

Only 2 years? That's a pretty long time when it comes to phones these days. And while the Windows Phone market is small, the adoption rate of Windows Phone 8 was extremely high, there just aren't that many Windows Phone 7 users around.

In any case desktop users are going to continue to ignore metro apps in Win9 since they're functionally stripped down web widgets that are pointless next to desktop equivalents.

This isn't at all what the more interesting Windows Store apps are. Sure there's a lot og junk there like all of the app stores. And while there aren't currently any top line productivity modern apps (Office is coming one day), there are a number of good casual games, digital media apps, social media apps, e-readers, reference and educational apps, etc. that work very on the desktop that are better than their web counterparts and sometimes even their desktop counterparts if those even exist.
 
As with every Windows 8 thread, there's a lot of whining and weh. You bunch of bloody manchildren.

The only thing I did dislike however was the charms bar, a bit of a pain with dual monitors, plus not really intuitive. I hope they bring back Aero too - don't really like the flat coloured look to everything.
 
I also like Win8, and think that bar was worthless for desktop.
I barely go to the start screen either.
I press my search button on the mouse (or win+q/s), and win+x to shotdown/restart/control panel etc.
 
Back
Top