Windows 9 Will Kill Microsoft's Awkward Charms Menu

Are people really this clueless? Metro introduced a flat UI design language, which was then copied by Android for ICS, and now Apple in iOS and in OSX, as well as tons of websites, mobile apps etc.

Its trendy to 'hate' Metro and foam at the mouth, the fact that everyone else is copying it proves its the right idea.
 
They're blending the two. Whether or not they give the "aero" and "classic" options is not known.

http://www.neowin.net/news/microsoft-shows-off-the-start-menu-that-is-coming-to-windows-81

^^ Screen shots of the mashup.

That was for a later 8.1 update, not win 9. It also caught quite a bit of backlash and is what I referred to. It isn't a start menu, that is just the shitty start screen attached to the start button.

It is possible that is what we will end up with, and if so MS is going to find out that trying to force something that people have flatly stated they don't want won't work for them.
 
I hated the charms bar among many other aspects of 8, seeing it go is a relief.
No need to drag on over a dud, just glad they're moving forward.
 
I really have no interest in Windows 8 or 9.....

Still using Windows 7, who's with me?:cool:
 
Are people really this clueless? Metro introduced a flat UI design language, which was then copied by Android for ICS, and now Apple in iOS and in OSX, as well as tons of websites, mobile apps etc.

Its trendy to 'hate' Metro and foam at the mouth, the fact that everyone else is copying it proves its the right idea.

This has nothing to do with the thread topic. But as long as you bring it up, I hate to burst your bubble but Microsoft didn't "introduce" shit. Web designers and marketers have been using flat / international style for more than a decade.

Maybe start by reading up on International Style aka Swiss Style. Goes back as far as 1896.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Typographic_Style
 
This has nothing to do with the thread topic. But as long as you bring it up, I hate to burst your bubble but Microsoft didn't "introduce" shit. Web designers and marketers have been using flat / international style for more than a decade.

Maybe start by reading up on International Style aka Swiss Style. Goes back as far as 1896.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Typographic_Style

If you read any material on Microsoft's rationale for their implementation of modern design, they never claimed to have invented the concept. Indeed the term "metro" comes from the fact that some of these design principles have been used in metropolitan transportation systems for many years. However Microsoft did introduce these concepts in to their products more fully and earlier than Apple or Google, Microsoft didn't get the idea from those two.
 
The charms bar is probably the single reason I avoided Windows 8. The moment I saw it and what MS was doing, I just abandoned it out of principle. There is absolutely nothing intuitive about having to mouse all the way over to the corner of the fucking screen (making sure not to go too far, especially in RDP windows), then the bar pops up and now you scroll fucking DOWN to click on something like search, type in your query, then scroll all the way to the fucking OPPOSITE SIDE OF THE GODDAMN SCREEN to click something. It's like my hand gets tired just launching one app and I've traveled the distance of a square foot across my desk. Jesus.
 
I think it's funny that people want Aero back....

Back when Vista came out (hell, even XP for that matter), all us hardcore gamers would completely disable everything related to making Windows pretty because it eats up resources.

Must be metrosexual feminist creep... infecting everything! :eek:
 
Still using Windows 7, who's with me?:cool:

I'd be all for a new version of Windows that was just the same Win 7 GUI with all of the current security, power management, performance, etc. improvements implemented.
 
Back when Vista came out (hell, even XP for that matter), all us hardcore gamers would completely disable everything related to making Windows pretty because it eats up resources.

Now, we have enough resources to run the OS several times over (VM's) without much of a decrease in performance. I think we're fine as far as resources go. We're not hurting.

If you are finding you need to disable things these days to get your game to run better, you're running old hardware or a very underpowered machine. Disable services, stop things from running at boot (I do this, because I like a lean machine), or going with a "classic" style UI is not gaining much at all. At least as far as gaming goes. Less than a percent, and that's well within a margin of error.
 
That was for a later 8.1 update, not win 9. It also caught quite a bit of backlash and is what I referred to. It isn't a start menu, that is just the shitty start screen attached to the start button.

It is possible that is what we will end up with, and if so MS is going to find out that trying to force something that people have flatly stated they don't want won't work for them.

I know, my friend is already complaining but I just tell him, remove them if he does not want them. Otherwise, it is just whining for the sake of whining.
 
This has nothing to do with the thread topic. But as long as you bring it up, I hate to burst your bubble but Microsoft didn't "introduce" shit. Web designers and marketers have been using flat / international style for more than a decade.

Maybe start by reading up on International Style aka Swiss Style. Goes back as far as 1896.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Typographic_Style

They had websites in 1896? Cool. :D
 
The charms bar is probably the single reason I avoided Windows 8. The moment I saw it and what MS was doing, I just abandoned it out of principle. There is absolutely nothing intuitive about having to mouse all the way over to the corner of the fucking screen (making sure not to go too far, especially in RDP windows), then the bar pops up and now you scroll fucking DOWN to click on something like search, type in your query, then scroll all the way to the fucking OPPOSITE SIDE OF THE GODDAMN SCREEN to click something. It's like my hand gets tired just launching one app and I've traveled the distance of a square foot across my desk. Jesus.

FUD and exaggerate much? In fact, how about being flat out wrong and lying?:rolleyes:
 
I think it's funny that people want Aero back....

Back when Vista came out (hell, even XP for that matter), all us hardcore gamers would completely disable everything related to making Windows pretty because it eats up resources.

Must be metrosexual feminist creep... infecting every thing! :eek:

Or computers are significantly more powerful now than when vista came out.
 
I actually kinda like Windows 8 now...but that bar is garbage. It's like a bastardized control panel.

It took me a while to find it when i used win8 for the first time, i knew the start button was gone but where the hell was the control panel.
 
I think it's funny that people want Aero back....

Back when Vista came out (hell, even XP for that matter), all us hardcore gamers would completely disable everything related to making Windows pretty because it eats up resources.

Must be metrosexual feminist creep... infecting everything! :eek:

Not sure why its "funny", or what the correlation is. Disabling all the eye candy back when games used more resources than the hardware could often handle had a practical point to it. These days CPU's and GPU's are at a point - and have been for a while - that there tends to be free resources and performance to spare.

People just like options, same as they always have. Microsoft only got rid of Aero because of Sinofsky's insistence that uglying up the desktop as part of the plan of slowly moving everyone away from it was the way to go. Didn't work. Spectacularly so.
 
Yay, Microsoft finally listened to their customers.
Let's have a party. -_-
 
I love the stupid corners are going away I use start8 to remove them and every update it gets broken and I generally have to re-install start8.

What is funny is that saying virtual windows is new. The logon logoff screen is virtual desktop, windows 7 has a virtual desktop built in, MS just used to expect the low end consumers to pay for virtual pc.
 
I love the stupid corners are going away I use start8 to remove them and every update it gets broken and I generally have to re-install start8.

What is funny is that saying virtual windows is new. The logon logoff screen is virtual desktop, windows 7 has a virtual desktop built in, MS just used to expect the low end consumers to pay for virtual pc.

Thankfully, I will be able to enable them so I do not have to use a Windows 7 experience anymore. Also, having gadgets on the desktop is nearly worthless if you have a lot of programs running for obvious reasons.
 
I love the stupid corners are going away I use start8 to remove them and every update it gets broken and I generally have to re-install start8.

What is funny is that saying virtual windows is new. The logon logoff screen is virtual desktop, windows 7 has a virtual desktop built in, MS just used to expect the low end consumers to pay for virtual pc.

You can just disable charms in taskbar settings.
 
Chares are ok for a pure tablet experience, a freaking nightmare for mouse use.
 
I doubt that. More like they couldn't BS their shareholders about the fall off of sales anylonger.

Thing is Windows licensing sales haven't done badly even in a declining PC market. There's nothing really new here as we know about the good release/bad release cycle of Windows. Windows 8 is a major technical advancement for Windows as it does now allow a single OS run on a more devices than any other OS out there. Getting all the pieces in place is a lot of work and while things could have been better on the desktop side with 8, the essence of the core of 8 looks like it will still be there, a hybrid OS. But the UI elements will be better designed to work better with keyboard and mouse.
 
Chares are ok for a pure tablet experience, a freaking nightmare for mouse use.

They aren't bad on single screen but as others have noted they are a kludge with multiple screens. It's not clear yet if they'll even remain on touch devices, according to Mary Jo Foley Charms will be gone for all UIs including tablets.
 
The people who want Aero back should just buy a Mac.

Great solution, well thought out.

I already use Aero, theres no need for a shift to a none MS compatible OS.
Decent gaming support is a requirement.
It would be nice to have Aero on the latest OS that doesnt suck, then I could show my support for it.
For now Win 7 is very good, when something better is released I'll get it.
 
I use Windows 8 too. My only complaint with it is things that make it Windows 8

"I like Windows 8 just fine but"...

It's like the people who liked TV shows that everybody else knew were terrible...but years later they're too embarrassed to admit they once liked them.

W8...it's like being in a cartoon dream that you can't awaken.
 
They aren't bad on single screen but as others have noted they are a kludge with multiple screens. It's not clear yet if they'll even remain on touch devices, according to Mary Jo Foley Charms will be gone for all UIs including tablets.

That would be stupid. The charms bar is easy to use with a mouse or touch. The only thing they needed to fix was RDP access.
 
"I like Windows 8 just fine but"...

It's like the people who liked TV shows that everybody else knew were terrible...but years later they're too embarrassed to admit they once liked them.

W8...it's like being in a cartoon dream that you can't awaken.

No buts, I like win 8 and te steady improvements have made it better. I usually do not go along with the crowd though.
 
Oh...is that what that is? I thought it was some JUNK POS that Toshiba installed on my laptop that i couldn't uninstall. :cool:
 
That would be stupid. The charms bar is easy to use with a mouse or touch. The only thing they needed to fix was RDP access.

Winbeta suggested that Microsoft might eliminate the Charms Bar for desktop users, not tablet users. But my sources say the Charms Bar will be going away completely for all desktop, laptop and tablet users with Threshold.

http://www.zdnet.com/microsofts-win...-add-virtual-desktops-drop-charms-7000032401/

Just conveying what I've read. I think the Charms are fine with touch. I think no one here would call me a Windows 8 hater but I don't think they work well with keyboard and mouse beyond a single screen. And even on a single screen it's just not as fluid as I'd like. I've grown accustomed to them on multiple monitor systems and they aren't anywhere the end of time like many make them out to be. That's how I've viewed Windows 8 in general. Microsoft made it's mistakes particularly on the desktop but these mistakes are far, far from fatal and unfixable and there's absolutely no need to throw away the modern UI and by simply integrating the modern UI better into the desktop the major issues of Windows 8 are resolved. Windows 8 needs refinement, not a complete redefinition.

Of course when Windows 9 functionally does everything and more Windows 8 does, Windows Store, tiles, etc. but simply better implemented for keyboard and mouse, some will proclaim how Microsoft totally abandoned Windows 8. Or they call Windows 9 Windows 8.x SP 1.
 
I knew windows 8 sucked the moment I clicked on one of those new tiles (Games for example) and saw this full screen green icon destroy my eyes prior to it loading up.
 
Yay, Microsoft finally listened to their customers.
Let's have a party. -_-

Really more dragged away kicking and screaming than "listening" but if the end point is the same I guess it doesn't matter, except ofcourse for the three or four years MS lost with it's grand experiment.
 
They're blending the two. Whether or not they give the "aero" and "classic" options is not known.

http://www.neowin.net/news/microsoft-shows-off-the-start-menu-that-is-coming-to-windows-81

^^ Screen shots of the mashup.

so what they should have done in the first place... whatever classic shell has filled my start button needs for years now

metro should have always been an option not forced.

The masses cant cope with change that is why vista failed and 8 flopped about.
 
so what they should have done in the first place... whatever classic shell has filled my start button needs for years now

metro should have always been an option not forced.

The masses cant cope with change that is why vista failed and 8 flopped about.

Has nothing to do with "can't cope with change". Different just for the sake of being different is poor design.

There is a reason steering wheels have stuck around for 90+ years. Sometimes the design/invention IS that good.
 
Thing is Windows licensing sales haven't done badly even in a declining PC market. There's nothing really new here as we know about the good release/bad release cycle of Windows. Windows 8 is a major technical advancement for Windows as it does now allow a single OS run on a more devices than any other OS out there. Getting all the pieces in place is a lot of work and while things could have been better on the desktop side with 8, the essence of the core of 8 looks like it will still be there, a hybrid OS. But the UI elements will be better designed to work better with keyboard and mouse.

Those were, and still are, the two major issues with Windows 8.
What sucks about it, is that 8 is actually a good OS, and better than 7 in many ways.

The only major flaw was the lack of out-of-the-box options to change the GUI and/or hardware environment, i.e. desktop or tablet, w/ or w/out touchscreen, etc.
I do think that they can improve these functions with Windows 9, and look forward to them doing so.

Unfortunately, because of Microsoft's poor choices in these areas, Windows 8 is going to be regarded through history as the next ME/Vista, even though it is far more deserving than that.
You know this is bad when the [H]ard Linux Shill is starting to defend Windows 8. :eek:
 
Back
Top