Three Problems Computers Can Never Solve

Can a computer figure out if there is a God? What is life? Can God make a rock so big that God can't even lift it? (I heard this first from George Carlin in the 70s). OK, I used God twice so perhaps not fair. Is there life after death? Predict the future with super high probability? Where is Malaysia Airlines Flight 370? Count to infinity? I guess computers can't, at least for the foreseeable future, answer philosophical type questions.
 
Maybe it's just me, but they could have made the video a lot shorter by just saying "Computers can't solve infinite equations".
 
Can a computer figure out if there is a God? What is life? Can God make a rock so big that God can't even lift it? (I heard this first from George Carlin in the 70s). OK, I used God twice so perhaps not fair. Is there life after death? Predict the future with super high probability? Where is Malaysia Airlines Flight 370? Count to infinity? I guess computers can't, at least for the foreseeable future, answer philosophical type questions.

They stated they didn't mean these types of problems...
 
Maybe it's just me, but they could have made the video a lot shorter by just saying "Computers can't solve infinite equations".

what is an infinite equation? an equation with infinity in it? or ininitely long? there are cases of both that can be solved.
 
Can a computer figure out if there is a God?

What are you talking about? I AM GOD HERE!!!!1

IAMGODHERE.jpg
 
what is an infinite equation? an equation with infinity in it? or ininitely long? there are cases of both that can be solved.

Infinity isn't a number so you don't have to worry about something having infinity in it ... if something is infinitely long then there is technically no end to it so you can't ever solve it (although once you get out to that 10 billionth significant digit I am not sure how important the numbers are anymore :D ) ... interestingly, solving the unsolvable irrational numbers (like pi, e, etc) was where they discovered patterns and messages (in the book Contact)
 
Can a computer figure out if there is a God? What is life? Can God make a rock so big that God can't even lift it? (I heard this first from George Carlin in the 70s). OK, I used God twice so perhaps not fair. Is there life after death? Predict the future with super high probability? Where is Malaysia Airlines Flight 370? Count to infinity? I guess computers can't, at least for the foreseeable future, answer philosophical type questions.

It took some time, but the answer is 42
 
man watching that video with no sound and relying on youtube's captioning to "see" what was said just made me feel a bit ... dumb.

So what I got was a computer couldn't know if it would go forever?
A computer couldn't know how small a compression is the smallest you can have?
A computer couldn't decipher an infinite number of colored tiles or something?
 
There are simpler things that computers can never solve. For example computers can't fix idiots, they just empower them to spread their stupidity.
 
Infinity isn't a number so you don't have to worry about something having infinity in it ... if something is infinitely long then there is technically no end to it so you can't ever solve it (although once you get out to that 10 billionth significant digit I am not sure how important the numbers are anymore :D ) ... interestingly, solving the unsolvable irrational numbers (like pi, e, etc) was where they discovered patterns and messages (in the book Contact)

you can solve infinitely long equations (by applying methods to reduce them to finitely long ones) and even though infinity is not defined, you'll have to deal with infinity a lot when calculating limits. you encounter both things mentioned above in 1st semester maths so the statement "Computers can't solve infinite equations" (whatever infinite equations means exactly) is not true.
 
Computers have the capacity to think just like humans, its merely a software issue. Like in the movie transcendence, the easiest solution may be to simply emulate the human brain, but then have all the horsepower and limitless memory potential of a networked machine.
 
This isn't true.

Depends on how literal you want to be ... you can reach a point where a further solution serves no more than an academic purpose ... however, if something is infinitely long there is no end to it so you could have computers solving it for a googleplex years and never ever reach an end ... as I said, this was the point of Contact the book ... the irrational numbers had patterns in them that didn't show up until a society had the technology to solve them down to unimaginable levels :cool:
 
Back
Top