Apple WWDC14 Streaming Live

Tim Cook bought up the subject of Windows 8 at his own developers conference.

Oh sure, blame Tim Cook for your being obsessed instead of taking responsibility for your problems and going out to seek help. That's what's wrong with late middle-aged guys who say they're programmers that write macros for Excel these days...they never take responsibility for their own actions and that's causing the whole thread to go to hell in a hand basket.
 
Mavericks is a free upgrade. If one is looking maximize the number of existing customers on the latest versions of their software, make the upgrades free. I don't think there's much mystery surrounding this subject. Of the economics of that is a different matter.
I never said there was a mystery. One might expect that cost would have a significantly inverted effect on adoption rates, and the data seems to be in line with that. Your comment here about the predictability is irrelevant.


When comparing OS X and Windows were talking about groups of such vastly different size and audience that yes, the adoption rate is pretty pointless..
It's only pointless if you choose to ignore all the useful applications, which you seem to be doing. I provided several examples of where this data might be useful, as well highlighted the fact that this is a very prolific metric in software companies, all of which you just seem to have ignored.
 
It's fine that you think user adoption rates are pointless, but literally the rest of the industry doesn't.
 
It's only pointless if you choose to ignore all the useful applications, which you seem to be doing. I provided several examples of where this data might be useful, as well highlighted the fact that this is a very prolific metric in software companies, all of which you just seem to have ignored.

I'm not ignoring what you said. Just wondering what is the meaning of comparing two percentages of adoption rates for two completely different operating systems with vastly different user base sizes and significantly different audiences. Even if Mavericks had 100% of the OS X there'd still twice as many Windows 8.x users.
 
I'm not ignoring what you said. Just wondering what is the meaning of comparing two percentages of adoption rates for two completely different operating systems with vastly different user base sizes and significantly different audiences. Even if Mavericks had 100% of the OS X there'd still twice as many Windows 8.x users.
because, as we've repeated ad nauseum the numbers are comparing OS X Mavericks to past versions of OS X and Windows 8 to past versions of Windows. Not, as you seem to be stuck on, the difference between OS X and Windows.
 
Just wondering what is the meaning of comparing two percentages of adoption rates for two completely different operating systems with vastly different user base sizes and significantly different audiences.
My examples covered a variety of scenarios for comparing adoption rates where the absolute market sizes were of limited importance. You are either ignoring my points or do not understand them.

Even if Mavericks had 100% of the OS X there'd still twice as many Windows 8.x users.
We get it - sometimes we are not interested in the absolute number of users. You can usefully compare things other than total number of users. That is what was done here.
 
because, as we've repeated ad nauseum the numbers are comparing OS X Mavericks to past versions of OS X and Windows 8 to past versions of Windows. Not, as you seem to be stuck on, the difference between OS X and Windows.

There's been a number of blogs and Twitter discussions over this subject and that's not at all what that pie chart was about since it was comparing the adoption rates of Mavericks to Windows 8. Sure, Windows 8's adoption rate is much lower than 7. And sure Mavericks' adoption rate is the best of an OS X version ever and few will debate these points because they are straightforward facts with readily attainable numbers to back up them points. But comparing them is where the problem is and that's what Apple did.
 
All those statistics presented in the presentation are prime examples of skewing statistics, for ones gain (very common attribute in marketing).

Yes those tabulations are probably on point for both OSX and W7/8. However a true comparison would be Comparing the adoption rates for W8-->8.1 vs OSX--->Mavericks.

Anyways debate on till the sun goes down. This always leads to interesting posts
 
Yes those tabulations are probably on point for both OSX and W7/8. However a true comparison would be Comparing the adoption rates for W8-->8.1 vs OSX--->Mavericks.
:confused: how does this even make sense to you?
 
There's been a number of blogs and Twitter discussions over this subject and that's not at all what that pie chart was about since it was comparing the adoption rates of Mavericks to Windows 8. Sure, Windows 8's adoption rate is much lower than 7. And sure Mavericks' adoption rate is the best of an OS X version ever and few will debate these points because they are straightforward facts with readily attainable numbers to back up them points. But comparing them is where the problem is and that's what Apple did.
try watching the actual broadcast instead of reading blogs about it

the windows comparison is at 10 minutes in and the android comparison is at 48 minutes. Cook is talking about fragmentation, as Apple does every single year at WWDC, and what every developer is primarily concerned about for reasons that multiple people have listed out for you over the past few days you've been banging your head against the wall trying to understand this.
 
But comparing them is where the problem is and that's what Apple did.
There's no problem here. The numbers were (presumably) not falsified, and adoption rates are something which are of interest to people. It is not a problem to compare them.
 
:confused: how does this even make sense to you?

Windows 8.1 is an incremental update to the Windows 8 Platform.

OS X Yosemite or 10.10 is an incremental update to the Mac OS X platform.

Are the updated feature list different (simply stated: # of extra features): Yes

Simplified version
In statistical analysis, the idea is to compare trends. Now a unbias or neutral comparison will compare two specific trend date based on all factors consistent. Ideally possible, however in reality two problems:

1) Data variables are going to be different for each trend. You can attempt to eliminate this problem, but never truly

2) Presentation and Purpose of trend analysis. Purpose, what is this data going to be used for and how is going to be presented. Is the person undertaking the analysis presenting this in an academic sphere or for marketing standpoints. Most times skewing data involves comparing two trends to make it seem as though the trend is in favor of one group of people.

Hence my comments above initially. If you wanted facts and figure that are a true analysis of whats actually happening

You need to see adoption rates of ONLY Window 8-->8.1 and Mavericks OSX-> Yosemite (for future success) or Moutain Lion to Maverick.
 
Windows 8.1 is an incremental update to the Windows 8 Platform.

OS X Yosemite or 10.10 is an incremental update to the Mac OS X platform.

Damn, you missed his point entirely. OSX -> Mavericks =/= 8 -> 8.1

I think you meant Mountain Lion -> Mavericks.
 
In statistical analysis, the idea is to compare trends. Now a unbias or neutral comparison will compare two specific trend date based on all factors consistent.
Just from reading this I am quite certain you don't do any statistical analysis.
 
Windows 8.1 is an incremental update to the Windows 8 Platform.

OS X Yosemite or 10.10 is an incremental update to the Mac OS X platform.
No, this is false. 10.10 is a major revision in OS X.

10.6 Snow Leopard > XP
10.7 Lion > Vista
10.8 Mountain Lion > Windows 7
10.9 Mavericks > Windows 8
10.10 Yosemite > Windows 9

All of the OS X major releases had minor revision updates between major OS releases.
The reason they revision it this way is because they decided to call their OS platform "OS EX" (some call it OS ten) similar to how Microsoft decided to call their platform "Windows"

Current Mavericks is at 10.9.3. Before that it had 10.9.2 and 10.9.1 and 10.9.0, which are all equivalent to the minor revisions Microsoft has deployed for Windows 8.
 
Just from reading this I am quite certain you don't do any statistical analysis.

I can send you my presentation I`m working on if you`d like. But I'm guessing you have a rebuttal planned for this comment as well right?;)

Anyways apparently the stat fact finders with an itch published some articles that are a read:

http://blogs.computerworld.com/wind...hingly-misleading-claims-about-windows-8-wwdc
http://www.geekwire.com/2014/apples-tim-cook-digs-windows-statistical-stretch/
http://www.tekrevue.com/windows-8-outpaces-os-x-mavericks/

Overall WWDC was a out of the ordinary and really a dev. conference, not the usual dog and pony hardware update show overshadowing the real drivers of growth; Developers
 
...the real drivers of growth; Developers

Actually, marketing and consumer interest drives growth. If marketing wasn't super-duper-the-most-important-and-crucial-thing-ever-in-sales, Apple wouldn't be as mega-profitable as it was under Jobsariffic.
 
try watching the actual broadcast instead of reading blogs about it

the windows comparison is at 10 minutes in and the android comparison is at 48 minutes. Cook is talking about fragmentation, as Apple does every single year at WWDC, and what every developer is primarily concerned about for reasons that multiple people have listed out for you over the past few days you've been banging your head against the wall trying to understand this.

I understand the point about fragmentation, I've mentioned that before. So Windows is more fragmented than OS X. Ok, fair enough. But XP, 7 and 8.x each by themselves has more users than all other non-Windows desktop OSes combined.
 
Actually, marketing and consumer interest drives growth. If marketing wasn't super-duper-the-most-important-and-crucial-thing-ever-in-sales, Apple wouldn't be as mega-profitable as it was under Jobsariffic.

Very true, but also without a product having a massive amount of apps, marketability of said product and consumer interest would be nil.

again that falls into the Chicken egg scenario.

But I do agree Marketing and consumer interest is probably high interest
 
Your head must explode when you see the steam hardware survey.

And in that survey, Mavericks has an adoption rate even higher than what Apple presented the other day, nearly 74%. Windows 8.x also has a much higher adoption rate but it's only about 25%. But no one who understands the gaming market thinks that comparing these rates means anything. Because when you look at that absolute numbers, Windows 8.x is used by 10 times more users than Mavericks. This is why you can't ever discount the numbers used to calculate percentages.
 
And in that survey, Mavericks has an adoption rate even higher than what Apple presented the other day, nearly 74%. Windows 8.x also has a much higher adoption rate but it's only about 25%. But no one who understands the gaming market thinks that comparing these rates means anything. Because when you look at that absolute numbers, Windows 8.x is used by 10 times more users than Mavericks. This is why you can't ever discount the numbers used to calculate percentages.

I'm pretty sure that when Apple developers develop something for Apple platforms, the number of Windows 8 or 8.1 computers isn't taken into consideration during the development process.
 
Very true, but also without a product having a massive amount of apps, marketability of said product and consumer interest would be nil.

again that falls into the Chicken egg scenario.

But I do agree Marketing and consumer interest is probably high interest

Yes, you're also right. Application and software functions do drive sales and I'll totally concede that there's really no way to tell if an iPhone would have been what it was if programs weren't available. I guess that all those things have to sort of go hand-in-hand. :)
 
I'm pretty sure that when Apple developers develop something for Apple platforms, the number of Windows 8 or 8.1 computers isn't taken into consideration during the development process.

I completely agree. And likewise the same would be true for Windows developers not considering adoption rates of the latest version of OS X.
 
I completely agree. And likewise the same would be true for Windows developers not considering adoption rates of the latest version of OS X.

Which in turn makes any discussion about the number of Windows 8/8.1 computers in the world as it applies to the percentage of Apple computers running the latest version of OS X in this particular thread pretty meaningless.

Ta da! Let's all go get ice cream and stop worrying about your favorite OS.
 
And in that survey, Mavericks has an adoption rate even higher than what Apple presented the other day, nearly 74%.
And yet you aren't raging against the steam hardware survey.

But no one who understands the gaming market thinks that comparing these rates means anything.
Do you have anything to support this claim, or are you just making it up? If you have any regular communication with game developers you would know that they are very concerned with market fragmentation.


This is why you can't ever discount the numbers used to calculate percentages.
I didn't say they should be discounted. Please don't put words in my mouth.
 
Tempting offer.....only if you promise to correct my mistakes Professor jimmy "Epitatistician" b
Ok sure. I am being 100% serious.

If you're going to coyly suggest you are working on some sort of analysis which would prove you statistical credentials then I am certainly going to ask to see. So yes, please post it or IM me.
 
I completely agree. And likewise the same would be true for Windows developers not considering adoption rates of the latest version of OS X.
Actually they would look at both so they can resource and plan accordingly. This is how businesses operate.
 
And yet you aren't raging against the steam hardware survey.
.



Steam, MS, Apple, any survey have skewed data to favor one party or the other. That`s what they call excellent marketing. This thread is prime example, included with the 100 results you can find when you enter "apple adoption rates" into any major search engine. That`s the point of statistics in marketing demos.
 
Actually they would look at both so they can resource and plan accordingly. This is how businesses operate.

They would look at their actual customer base and plan according to that. Why would OS X adoption rates matter to companies that have little or no investment in OS X products? And likewise why would Windows adoption rates matter to companies that have little or no investment in Windows products? The adoption rate of Mavericks among OS X gamers is sky high according to Steam's hardware survey. You'd still probably need far more resources dedicated to Windows 8.x simply because that sky high OS X adoption rate is only 1/10th the actual number of Windows 8.x users.
 
They would look at their actual customer base and plan according to that.
Looking at a particular set of data doesn't preclude you from looking at others. Companies look at adoption rates, fragmentation, within the context of the marketplace. I am telling you this is how it is done; I know because I have witnessed it *many* times. Do you think I'm lying about this?


Why would OS X adoption rates matter to companies that have little or no investment in OS X products? And likewise why would Windows adoption rates matter to companies that have little or no investment in Windows products?
I didn't claim either of the things you are asking me to explain. I'm not going to defend a position I didn't take.


You'd still probably need far more resources dedicated to Windows 8.x simply because that sky high OS X adoption rate is only 1/10th the actual number of Windows 8.x users.
No. It seems like you've never been involved in planning a cross-platform development (surprise!). Development resourcing is hugely proportional to the amount of fragmentation rather than the absolute number of users.
 
No. It seems like you've never been involved in planning a cross-platform development (surprise!). Development resourcing is hugely proportional to the amount of fragmentation rather than the absolute number of users.

So if you are developing a native cross-platform application and Windows is more fragmented than OS X are you saying that the increased fragmentation of Windows would require more resources dedicated to the Windows versions?
 
So if you are developing a native cross-platform application and Windows is more fragmented than OS X are you saying that the increased fragmentation of Windows would require more resources dedicated to the Windows versions?

No I'm not saying that.
 
So if you are developing a native cross-platform application and Windows is more fragmented than OS X are you saying that the increased fragmentation of Windows would require more resources dedicated to the Windows versions?
that's my understanding of how it works
 
Back
Top