So whats good out there?

  • Thread starter Deleted member 184142
  • Start date
D

Deleted member 184142

Guest
Been a while since I have been PSU hunting, had my current one for gosh, 3-4 years, and runs 24/7. And I think it is time to move on, it has been through 3 builds and has been rock solid, but as of late, I will find the system will hang at random times or be off when I get up/back from work.

Looking for something with really stable power that will push the system in sig, while that could be done with a 5-600W PSU, I would like to keep it 650-700W range at least for upgrades I will probably be doing later, modular is a must, I was looking at the Seasonic SS-760XP2, seems to be a solid unit, but wanted to get some input before I place an order, like to keep it under $200 as well.
 
Seasonic XP platinum, Corsair AX platinum.

Those are the only two companies I've bought from for the past 8+ years, before that Antec.

Some of their upper end models are pretty decent.

PCP&C were great until OCZ bought them, ruined them and went belly up. I still have a 360W silencer kicking.
 
Your suggestion is nice, but giong for 760 watts is overkill :)

I'm not going to try and sell you another model, but how much power do you think your current system pulls from the wall?
 
I suppose you might come close to utilizing a 760W PSU with SLI 670s and some overclocking, so if that is your intention down the road, then go for it. I have never had a problem with a Seasonic PSU. I know occasionally they will have a QC slip-up where some PSUs experience coil-whine or the fan makes a bit of noise, but this is actually rather rare considering the volume of PSUs they ship (which includes a lot of other companies that they manufacture for) so I wouldn't worry about it.

Corsair and Antec are typically good brands as well, though just like most companies they will have some bad models in their lineup. Cougar and XFX have some particularly good models from time to time. Lastly, PSUs manufactured by SuperFlower are arguably as good as Seasonic units. I have a Kingwin at home that was made by SuperFlower and it is right there with Seasonic in terms of performance (voltage regulation, ripple, over-current protection, etc).

Hardware Secrets and Jonny Guru both do excellent in-depth PSU reviews. [H] of course does as well, but like Tom's and Anandtech, they do not seem to review them as often as the first two sites I mentioned.

TL;DR - You can't go wrong with Seasonic, but you can often save a few bucks by buying a Seasonic-based PSU from another company that is almost as good or another company that utilizes quality designs from other PSU manufacturers (Delta, SuperFlower, etc.).
 
Your suggestion is nice, but giong for 760 watts is overkill :)

I'm not going to try and sell you another model, but how much power do you think your current system pulls from the wall?

It will pull 420-480 through my UPS, like I said, 5-600w would be enough but I do plan on a full new build in the not to far future, so I want to have a bit extra just in case.

I suppose you might come close to utilizing a 760W PSU with SLI 670s and some overclocking, so if that is your intention down the road, then go for it. I have never had a problem with a Seasonic PSU. I know occasionally they will have a QC slip-up where some PSUs experience coil-whine or the fan makes a bit of noise, but this is actually rather rare considering the volume of PSUs they ship (which includes a lot of other companies that they manufacture for) so I wouldn't worry about it.

Corsair and Antec are typically good brands as well, though just like most companies they will have some bad models in their lineup. Cougar and XFX have some particularly good models from time to time. Lastly, PSUs manufactured by SuperFlower are arguably as good as Seasonic units. I have a Kingwin at home that was made by SuperFlower and it is right there with Seasonic in terms of performance (voltage regulation, ripple, over-current protection, etc).

Hardware Secrets and Jonny Guru both do excellent in-depth PSU reviews. [H] of course does as well, but like Tom's and Anandtech, they do not seem to review them as often as the first two sites I mentioned.

TL;DR - You can't go wrong with Seasonic, but you can often save a few bucks by buying a Seasonic-based PSU from another company that is almost as good or another company that utilizes quality designs from other PSU manufacturers (Delta, SuperFlower, etc.).

I know who makes good PSUs, I just wanted to make sure there was not that "one" out there, as every now and again something will pop up that just does so much better than everything else, and since I have not kept up with everything I wanted to see what people had to say. Saving a few bucks it not that big of a deal so long as it is under $200, and seeing my power requirements, I don't think there will be any PSU in that range much over $200 unless it is a passive one.
 
Really? Gabe has not posted a review at Hardware Secrets in almost a year and no longer does reviews.

Review sites are always hit or miss anyway. Most places like to only review the highend, 1000W+ PSU's as I am sure it gets allot of clicks, while most people buy in the 5-800W range I am sure, it seems like the lower wattage but still highend line take a while to get a review unless it is a new product line altogether or the lower wattage and higher wattage PSUs are based on the same design/parts and you are able to use the higher wattage review as a guide.
 
It will pull 420-480 through my UPS, like I said, 5-600w would be enough but I do plan on a full new build in the not to far future, so I want to have a bit extra just in case.

Makes sense :)

Your numbers put your current build around 400 watts maximum on the DC side, I can see why you want to go so high, if you should put in another GPU in the future.
 
Makes sense :)

Your numbers put your current build around 400 watts maximum on the DC side, I can see why you want to go so high, if you should put in another GPU in the future.

Ran the numbers for all the new HW that is out now and best guess on stuff that is not, and while it will be more powerful, it will be pretty close to the current setup, so I went ahead and ordered the SS-660XP2 last night.
 
Ran the numbers for all the new HW that is out now and best guess on stuff that is not, and while it will be more powerful, it will be pretty close to the current setup, so I went ahead and ordered the SS-660XP2 last night.

OK, good luck with it, depending on the amount of fan noise you will accept, it should hold up to a lot and Seasonic generally has a high level of quality.
 
Been using a Seasonic SS-660XP2 for over a year without issue, strong rails dead on volt wise.
I have it set to hybrid fan and since I only can max it at 170W while gaming the fan has yet to come on.

It should work well, the cables are damn stiff though so if you want to do some routing it has been suggested to take a hair dryer and warm them up so you can bend/mold them easier.
 
Been using a Seasonic SS-660XP2 for over a year without issue, strong rails dead on volt wise.
I have it set to hybrid fan and since I only can max it at 170W while gaming the fan has yet to come on.

It should work well, the cables are damn stiff though so if you want to do some routing it has been suggested to take a hair dryer and warm them up so you can bend/mold them easier.

Thanks for the info, but I will probably end up making my own cables this time around, even routing cables can be messy with how some of them are made.
 
Review sites are always hit or miss anyway. Most places like to only review the highend, 1000W+ PSU's as I am sure it gets allot of clicks, while most people buy in the 5-800W range I am sure, it seems like the lower wattage but still highend line take a while to get a review unless it is a new product line altogether or the lower wattage and higher wattage PSUs are based on the same design/parts and you are able to use the higher wattage review as a guide.

The last 6 reviews we have run have been less than 1000W's and just 3 of the last 20 have been 1000W or greater. Would you like to try again?
 
The last 6 reviews we have run have been less than 1000W's and just 3 of the last 20 have been 1000W or greater. Would you like to try again?

No, I still stand by my post.

You can not have just one or two review sites you look at, as it is always hit or miss, I have yet to see a single site review every PSU out there, and as such you are best off searching Google for reviews on the PSU in question, as your favorite review site might not have the review of that given model, unless the higher/lower models of the same line was reviewed and is based off of the same build/parts. Also, the last set of reviews of sub 1k PSUs have been on the market for at least a year and many past that, while the likes of the Antec 1300W is brand new but has reviews all over the place.

It is the nature of the beast (and I don't think you would deny), part because of the mfg and them wanting allot of press, so what do they do? Send out the new highend part to review sites, and the review sites are not going to put it off because it is a loss of money for them, they are a business after all. Which just means at times it can be hard to find solid reviews from trusted sites of a given PSU you are looking at.
 
"be quiet!" makes good PSUs, but they don't get much attention. Newegg and Amazon sell them.
 
No, I still stand by my post.

Well, you shouldn't stand by it because it was an incorrect assessment as I just proved to you. Standing by such an invalid assessment in the face of the truth is somewhat odd.

Also, the last set of reviews of sub 1k PSUs have been on the market for at least a year and many past that, while the likes of the Antec 1300W is brand new but has reviews all over the place.

So clearly YOU aren't reading what is being reviewed. Of the last 10 sub 1000W power supplies, 8 of them were launch products.

It is the nature of the beast (and I don't think you would deny), part because of the mfg and them wanting allot of press, so what do they do? Send out the new highend part to review sites, and the review sites are not going to put it off because it is a loss of money for them, they are a business after all. Which just means at times it can be hard to find solid reviews from trusted sites of a given PSU you are looking at.

That, actually, is very far off from how scheduling and production actually works. If you actually watch what goes live when, you would notice how very far off you are.
 
Well, you shouldn't stand by it because it was an incorrect assessment as I just proved to you. Standing by such an invalid assessment in the face of the truth is somewhat odd.



So clearly YOU aren't reading what is being reviewed. Of the last 10 sub 1000W power supplies, 8 of them were launch products.



That, actually, is very far off from how scheduling and production actually works. If you actually watch what goes live when, you would notice how very far off you are.

So, you are claiming you have reviewed all PSUs at launch? And you are also claiming you reviewed the PSU I was researching? Neither of which is the case and proves my point. I also never said reviews are never done at launch or that all the reviews are of older products. And if you have insight onto how release of products and reviews differ from my suggestion of mfgs wanting press and sending out highend products for review and is why the higher end tend to have far more online reviews than others, please do explain, I am always willing to hear someones input on the matter.

I am not really even sure how this started as I was more or less agreeing with your post about review sites and how you can not depend on a single one for all products as you might be waiting sometime for the review of the given product you are researching. Such as HS lack of updates and hit or miss on JG reviewing the PSU you are researching. As well, JG and a few choice others are not "most review sites", like I said, there are a choice few trusted review sites out there, outside of that most reviews are click bait, JG probably being one of the biggest exceptions to this as far as PSU reviews go.

So, my statement I still stand by, which is that you can look at only one or two review sites and possibly wait a long time if ever for a product you are researching now, or rummage through all sorts of marketing reviews you will find all over Google. I really don't see a problem with this statement. :confused:

I think you misunderstood my first quote, as I was not referring to the H or your reviews. But how having a single review site is hit or miss on the product at hand, and searching Google is the only way sometimes, but most reviews you come across are click bait sites and you have to spend time filtering the more trusted sites from that, which is why I come here to ask as someone else might have already done this or people who have kept up with the PSU world might know of a hidden gem you would have just passed on over other wise.
 
So, you are claiming you have reviewed all PSUs at launch? And you are also claiming you reviewed the PSU I was researching?

Nope, read what I wrote again and see what was written not what you want to be written. I addressed VERY specific complaints that you made using broad generalizations that were wholly incorrect.
 
Nope, read what I wrote again and see what was written not what you want to be written. I addressed VERY specific complaints that you made using broad generalizations that were wholly incorrect.

Such as? I still do not see anything that you said that even really relates to what I stated, and everything you are saying you keep referring back to H reviews which were never a topic that I even brought up, but you did. I really am trying to grasp what you are saying, but don't see how any of it changes or makes the first statement I made wrong in anyway as it was not directed at any one site, but an overall view of review sites. The specific point you made referred to some H reviews and then how I am wrong about how most reviews are done but without any clarification, but would be willing to bet you would be explaining the process here and not in general.
 
Any good review site has a methodology for testing loads and such and it's available on the website. If you don't like [H], there's JonnyGuru, PC Perspective, and more recently--Hardware Secrets. There's probably a few more, but as far as sites that don't just plug it in and turn it on and score based on how pretty it is and didn't blow up, the selection is pretty slim.
 
Such as? I still do not see anything that you said that even really relates to what I stated, and everything you are saying you keep referring back to H reviews which were never a topic that I even brought up, but you did. I really am trying to grasp what you are saying, but don't see how any of it changes or makes the first statement I made wrong in anyway as it was not directed at any one site, but an overall view of review sites. The specific point you made referred to some H reviews and then how I am wrong about how most reviews are done but without any clarification, but would be willing to bet you would be explaining the process here and not in general.

http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1040822158&postcount=13

Or, you could look at at JG...of the last 20 units 15 were less than 1000W's. Etc. My point was and still is, your complaint is not founded when you actually look at the numbers. You may only notice certain reviews but that doesn't mean that is all or predominately what runs.
 
Last edited:
Master [H];1040826490 said:
Any good review site has a methodology for testing loads and such and it's available on the website. If you don't like [H], there's JonnyGuru, PC Perspective, and more recently--Hardware Secrets. There's probably a few more, but as far as sites that don't just plug it in and turn it on and score based on how pretty it is and didn't blow up, the selection is pretty slim.

A few years ago I watched a video "review" of a power supply at 3DGameMan that was exactly that. Funny and sad at the same time.

.
 
I would say corsair has some quality products, depending on the series and good customer support
 
Back
Top