Bill Would Require Kill Switch For Cellphones

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
So what would stop someone from reporting your phone stolen as a "prank" if this passes? Imagine how fun that would be to have your phone "rendered useless" by your ex or some smart ass kid. :eek:

In the last year, officials in San Francisco and New York have pressured cellphone companies to adopt a so-called “kill switch” that would render a smartphone unusable after it was stolen, which would make it difficult for a thief to sell the device. On Friday, State Senator Mark Leno of California, a Democrat, is expected to introduce legislation requiring all smartphones and tablets sold in the state to include this kind of feature.
 
We have bigger problems and this is what the government is worried about?

Oh wait.. Its California, nevermind.
 
What's with these morons?

They want to use the tech to twart crime and the best they can think of to do is turn the damn thing off? Why in hell didn't they think of making it cry like a bitch instead?

"Help I'm stolen, someone come get this asshole whole took me,.. Hhheeelllppp!"
 
Can we have a kill switch for incompetent politicians?
 
Imagine how fun that would be to have your phone "rendered useless" by ... some smart ass kid. :eek:

I'm a teacher, one F on a test, or an argued detention, and it'd be new phone time.

Also, the idea is stupid in general. Allow me to have my own remote wiper/killer. That way, when my phone is stolen, I have all the keys to deactivate it and any social engineering attempts have to go through me.
 
LOL, typical california legislation... from guns to electronics, they MUST conform to California demands "because they say so"

I wonder when manufacturers / designers of all things will just say it's not worth selling in California because of the over-abundance of useless laws.
 
The priorities in this state are just amazing.
 
Can we get a kill switch implanted in the heads of our politicians and other high level gov'ment officials?
 
I cant wait to find out how long until either one of these phone companies screws up or some hacker is just a bit smarter than they expect (again) and we'll all know how to remote kill phones without going through the phone company.
 
That phone has everything it needs to make arrest and conviction a pretty easy thing.

It can be remotely controlled.
It has a microphone.
It has a camera.
It knows right where it's at.
And it can tell someone all of this.

And the best these idiots can come up with is to turn the damn thing off :rolleyes:
 
If they do this, then they'd better have some sort of authentication to prove it's the owner who's requesting the switch be flipped...oh wait, it would be unfair of them to burden the owner with the need to retain that kind of information. :(
 
They can have my flip phone when they pry it from my shaking, mildly annoyed hand!
 
The irony is that people who really steal phones will know how to circumvent the kill switch. But those of us who just want to say move to a different carrier will not.
 
The irony is that people who really steal phones will know how to circumvent the kill switch.

Really? I guess you missed all the videos of cell phone thieves being caught because they did stupid shit like posting pics of themselves and tales of daring on youtube.

Butt dialing the cops in the middle of a robbery maybe.

Man the list is long.
 
I thought blocking a nicked phone based on the IMEI was normal? Or is this only Europe?

No stupid apps needed, just the account holder phoning their phone company. Generally part of the call that orders a replacement phone...

How do idiots like this get to make laws? And why is it that no matter what country you live in on this planet, it is these *same* idiots who rise to a position to make these laws?


Surely the bigger story in that news item is the bit about trying to block second hand sales without proof of ownership. No more selling phones on ebay. Or even giving a phone to a mate. Even giving a phone as a present becomes complicated by that daft idea.
 
Imei blocking is a thing. At least through tmobile.
 
LOL, typical california legislation... from guns to electronics, they MUST conform to California demands "because they say so"

I wonder when manufacturers / designers of all things will just say it's not worth selling in California because of the over-abundance of useless laws.

I believe Smith and Wesson (S&W) and Ruger, both firearms manufacturers, recently announced they will no longer manufacture guns for California since they are the only ones who have specific requirements for firearms that can be sold there. Heck, there's 49 other states they can sell to.
 
So what would stop someone from reporting your phone stolen as a "prank" if this passes? Imagine how fun that would be to have your phone "rendered useless" by your ex or some smart ass kid. :eek:

The only thing stopping them is the phone service provider verifiying the caller when they call in. If its an authorized person on the account. They are good to go.

However, this service is already covered by 3rd parties with certain phones/brands. Its also pointless to kill a phone since if it remains on since police can still track it if its being used. There is also no point in putting the killswitch into the phone if the phone company can just shot off the serial number/IMEI that was registered to the account. I know Sprint has this capability in the USA (albeit rarely used), and I'm sure the others do also.

Unnecessary legislation from the nanny state itself.
 
I believe Smith and Wesson (S&W) and Ruger, both firearms manufacturers, recently announced they will no longer manufacture guns for California since they are the only ones who have specific requirements for firearms that can be sold there. Heck, there's 49 other states they can sell to.

I thought that was because they have to do something specific with the bullets. When one is fired it has to imprint it with the guns make, serial number and some other stuff.
 
I thought that was because they have to do something specific with the bullets. When one is fired it has to imprint it with the guns make, serial number and some other stuff.

Nope, it's because they do stupid shit like pass laws that a pistol can't have more then a 10 round magazine so then manufacturers have to make their usual 13 or more round guns able to accept both a 10 rounder and the larger capacity mag just to sell to one state. It just makes things tougher then they have to be for no good reason, increases costs, and makes competition more difficult if the other guy gives up on Cali and quits trying to build for them.
 
It can allow hacker groups to cut the Govt's cell phone off. For example, president, Congress men and women. Save the rest of us some money.
 
California can't figure out how to stop rolling brown outs, massive forest fires or illegal immigration BUT...
They sure can micromanage the living shit out of every industry in existence to the point it packs up and moves its shit elsewhere.
 
There is also no point in putting the killswitch into the phone if the phone company can just shot off the serial number/IMEI that was registered to the account.

Yeah I remember back when I worked for Comcast and we would be in charge of turning dude's cable modems off when they didn't pay. It was like ONE click and it turned off until they contacted us back and payed. I'm sure its exactly the same the cell phone companies. A kill switch would be like a tiny program (made by a programmer in like an hour) to make it easier for dumb people to click ONE button, and I'm sure the government will spend a billion dollars to have that program made.:rolleyes:
 
LOL what idiots so they are basically going to allow a hacker the ability to turn off every new phone in the world that has this feature ! These people are complete morons
 
Oh and better yet how about a tyranical government takeover shutting down all communication via cell phones.
 
California can't figure out how to stop rolling brown outs, massive forest fires or illegal immigration BUT...
They sure can micromanage the living shit out of every industry in existence to the point it packs up and moves its shit elsewhere.

They also can't fix public things like roads. Honestly, I have no idea where the fuck all the taxes and money go in this state.
 
Funny, you have a story about stolen cell phones being re-sold, etc, then you get everyone here with a story or something about why providers just don't give a shit and do nothing. Yet here's shits being given and the typical "oooh it's California, don't they have something liberal to do" type of rhetoric.
 
Back
Top