NSA Phone Data Program Is Illegal And Should End

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
But, but, but...didn't our government just say this wasn't illegal and it would change stuff to make things all better? ;)

An independent executive branch board has concluded that the National Security Agency’s long-running program to collect billions of Americans’ phone records is illegal and should end. In a strongly worded report to be issued Thursday, the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board (PCLOB) said that the statute upon which the program was based, Section 215 of the USA Patriot Act, “does not provide an adequate basis to support this program.”
 
Translation: Things will continue as normal, making sure Snowden doesn't happen again.
 
Blah blah blah

National Security

Argle Bargle

Blah blah blah
 
Yeah it sucks.

But the way I see it, they HAVE to collect multitudes and multitudes of information to be able to sort and use the stuff that is ACTUALLY used for national security/stop crime/kill bad guys. All this information HAS to be collected one way or the other.

What should be in the limelight is what they are doing with the information. Laws and regulations should be placed on what CAN be done with the info - not the matter of collecting it.
 
Yeah it sucks.

But the way I see it, they HAVE to collect multitudes and multitudes of information to be able to sort and use the stuff that is ACTUALLY used for national security/stop crime/kill bad guys. All this information HAS to be collected one way or the other.

What should be in the limelight is what they are doing with the information. Laws and regulations should be placed on what CAN be done with the info - not the matter of collecting it.

Because everyone always follows regulations...IRS targeting non-profits, LOVEINT, Snowden walking off with millions of documents. Yep, regulations will keep us safe from those who would do us harm with the catalog they've assembled of everything you've communicated to anyone anywhere ever.

The problem with this data is that it exists at all. It's very collection and existence will entice people to do bad things with it, as they already have. It is too great a potential threat to personal privacy and constitutionally protected freedoms to be allowed to continue.
 
Yeah it sucks.

But the way I see it, they HAVE to collect multitudes and multitudes of information to be able to sort and use the stuff that is ACTUALLY used for national security/stop crime/kill bad guys. All this information HAS to be collected one way or the other.

What should be in the limelight is what they are doing with the information. Laws and regulations should be placed on what CAN be done with the info - not the matter of collecting it.

No they don't and no it doesn't have to be.

This sounds like an argument that would come from one of the "waaa,our job is hard" people.
 
.....people to do bad things with it, as they already have.

Wait up, no one has shown this at all. You can't point to one case where someone used the meta data to do anything to anyone.

The LOVINT article is the only article that showed any wrong doing by NSA employees. In it they covered 12 cases, most never even got received of the data they did wrongful searches on, the systems blocked them. Of the few that did get data, all were on foreign nationals and the searches were not against the meta data but against other data bases unique to collections against foreign targets.

The one and only case where a US Person, who may or may not have been a Citizen, but US Person's status is supposed to protect him as if he were. That one case this woman was investigating a foreign national who was a target and she did a search for data on his relatives and one of his brothers had US Person Status. Auditors caught the mistake, and she was punished. But this was an honest mistake made in the proper course of her work, not willful misuse of the Agency's power.

All this aside, this article doesn't say that the panel has any power behind it, and it almost sound's like members of the panel believe that other members went beyond the scope of the panel's purpose by trying to make this determination. So it's like, this wasn't the purpose for the panel, some wanted to use it for another purpose and the others are calling them on it.

Defenders of the program reacted sharply to the report’s findings on Thursday. Rep. Mike Rogers (R-Mich.), chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, said he agreed with the two dissenters “that the board should ... not partake in unwarranted legal analysis.”
I wonder what those three dots replaced?

The two dissenters where Rachel L. Brand and Elisebeth Collins Cook former Justice Department.

Now this was the 9/11 Commission's purpose.

The National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States, also known as the 9/11 Commission, was set up on November 27, 2002, "to prepare a full and complete account of the circumstances surrounding the September 11 attacks", including preparedness for and the immediate response to the attacks.

The commission was also mandated to provide recommendations designed to guard against future attacks.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9/11_Commission

The purpose of this Board:

The Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board (PCLOB) is an independent agency within the executive branch of the United States government, established by Congress in 2004 to advise the President and other senior executive branch officials to ensure that concerns with respect to privacy and civil liberties are appropriately considered in the development and implementation of all laws, regulations, and executive branch policies related to terrorism.

Ohhh, making a new post, this one is priceless.........
 
Many people view PCLOB as a propaganda arm of the US government. The board was convened to protect the American public against privacy intrusions by their own government, such as the NSA electronic surveillance program and PRISM (surveillance program). In the wake of the Edward Snowden security breach, it has been discovered that PCLOB, while being establish in 2004, had never held a substantive hearing until 11/4/2013.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privacy_and_Civil_Liberties_Oversight_Board

So these five members were part of an independent panel, temporary in nature. All Board members were sworn in and had their first meeting on March 14, 2006. This panel was made into it's own Agency with permanent status August 3, 2007.

But it seems "they had never held a substantive hearing until 11/4/2013". So like for 7 years they never ever really did anything. At least we know some of the people who weren't looking out for you even when that was expressly their job.

So just a few months ago we find out these yahoos never held a meeting or did anything and today they want to release a report and do their job. Oh, and two out of five don't even think this was their job to do to begin with.

These guys and girls are real champions, we should all be proud to have them in our corner.
 
Translation: Things will continue as normal, making sure Snowden doesn't happen again.

One thing I've learned about people is that when they get caught, they don't stop what they were doing. They just find a better way not to get caught again. The NSA will be no different.
 
The problem with this data is that it exists at all. It's very collection and existence will entice people to do bad things with it

But it does exist, and the government isn't the only people who have it. The phone companies keep it to start with, the NSA collects it, and if they can get it then so can others outside of our government.

Then again, there is a limit to just how useful "— in this case phone numbers dialed, call times and durations, but not call content " can actually be.

Now in all truth it can't be hard to find out someone's name if you have their phone number. And if you have a name and a number, you can usually get an address easy enough. So who the person is becomes a no-brainer unless you are specifically restricted from connecting those dots, I don't know if they are or not. This might be why they have to take stuff they already have and go back to the Carriers to request additional information, maybe they have to be able to tie a target to a number before they can request data on who these people are from the phone carriers. If that's the case, I see why this commission says the data gained on the target themselves was already available, the meta data is used to find associates, whiting or unwitting.

Anyway, this is what it's shaping up to look like.
 
This might be why they have to take stuff they already have and go back to the Carriers to request additional information, maybe they have to be able to tie a target to a number before they can request data on who these people are from the phone carriers.

You guys remember those 2,700 violations that one report tried to make look like privacy violations that were actually security violations, that's what this was. The NSA taking information from the meta data program and passing it to phone carriers to get additional data, but they passed data that was classified and wasn't supposed to be released along with the minimal stuff on the request and this was the security violations.
 
How did "Snowden happen" anyway?

I find it very interesting that, when he went public there was no real chatter about foreign powers influencing him. He was a conscientious objector, and whether they liked his methods or not, no one really questioned his access to the documents he had. When public opinion started to swing his way as the scope of the illegal activity by the NSA became apparent, he was suddenly being helped by the North Ko-rusk-uba-iran-eans.

Some times I think our "security" infrastructure in the west is so corrupted, so used to lying about everything they do, that they're no longer capable of distinguishing their own lies from their truths. They can't distinguish their allies from their enemies or remember the job they were supposed to do in the first place.
 
Yeah it sucks.

But the way I see it, they HAVE to collect multitudes and multitudes of information to be able to sort and use the stuff that is ACTUALLY used for national security/stop crime/kill bad guys. All this information HAS to be collected one way or the other.

What should be in the limelight is what they are doing with the information. Laws and regulations should be placed on what CAN be done with the info - not the matter of collecting it.

Which info showed that basically of everything they have collected, %0 of it lead to anything useful protecting Americans and their rights on U.S soil.
 
Some times I think our "security" infrastructure in the west is so corrupted, so used to lying about everything they do, that they're no longer capable of distinguishing their own lies from their truths. They can't distinguish their allies from their enemies or remember the job they were supposed to do in the first place.

I'm sorry man, but you got it wrong. What do you think that whole Five Eyes classification marking is all about. The US, Britain, Canada, New Zealand, and Australia have no problems at the "security level" knowing who our friends are, and to them everyone else is suspect because everyone else has earned it.

I can't watch those Bezos-CIA links from work, but I'll try and get to them later.
 
Back
Top