TechLarry
RIP [H] Brother - June 1, 2022
- Joined
- Aug 9, 2005
- Messages
- 30,481
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Best simulator out there. Warning: may cause additional expenses in wheels, pedals, monitors, and other hardware.
I've always said no and I will continue to say no to their horrendously greedy pricing model. I love sim racing a great deal, but fuck iRacing. The subscription is just another "fuck you" on top of the ridiculous prices they charge for every shred of content. Completely, totally, absurdly unacceptable.
I've always said no and I will continue to say no to their horrendously greedy pricing model. I love sim racing a great deal, but fuck iRacing. The subscription is just another "fuck you" on top of the ridiculous prices they charge for every shred of content. Completely, totally, absurdly unacceptable.
iRacing is crap. Terrible.
For hundreds+ of dollars, you get a game with 8 yr old console graphics, highly restricted play, and the pleasure to spend more on cars and tracks. Don't even have nurburgring.
What would you recommend then?
After reading a few reviews and seeing how the admins/owners treat racers, NO WAY would I invest any money into this Nascar sim. Too many stories of the elite racers getting other users suspended for crashing on accident, winning, or a number of other stupid reasons all while they wreck havoc on the track with no repercussions.
F that noise
On the protest front: my experience is actually that iRacing is *more* lenient than I'd be. I don't know T2K's experiences, but I've been punted, shunted, and other verbs by lots of people, and the only ones who appeared to get any negative effect from the protests I've logged are the ones who actually tried deliberately to take people out (aiming for them, weaving back and forth to wipe out an oval field). Compare to pickup racing in some other sims where people wreck everyone and ragequit, or where a clean pass is responded to by GTA-style 'driving.'
I disagree. The idea is great. The application is crap. Instead of banning the drivers, they should allow the users to put those drivers on a "blacklist". Have the server refuse to pair you with anyone on your blacklist. Race against a guy who thinks he bought GTA6? Blacklist him. You no longer have to deal with him. It was a bad situation for a single race.The entire idea that the game allows you to "protest" the driving of other players is one of its worst problems.
I disagree. The idea is great. The application is crap. Instead of banning the drivers, they should allow the users to put those drivers on a "blacklist". Have the server refuse to pair you with anyone on your blacklist. Race against a guy who thinks he bought GTA6? Blacklist him. You no longer have to deal with him. It was a bad situation for a single race.
Then iRacing would decide to charge for the blacklist...
This is most of what keeps me away. I'm not a very good racer, so the VAST majority of my time is spent offline. I don't want to drop the ridiculous cash required to enter the game, buy the cars that interest me, and THEN pay a monthly fee on top.
If iRacing adopted a model where I could buy the base game and the cars I'm interested in without the monthly fee and no online access, I'd buy it in a heartbeat, even with a higher than average price tag. But I'm not interested in PvP racing. The only way I think they could get me to be competitive is if they introduced autocross.
If you want not only correct-to-the-millimeter tracks as well as a simulation of >racing< (as opposed to just driving racecars) then iRacing should be at the top of your list.
That's the thing about iRacing though, it isn't targeted for offline racers or people who are only looking to race cars they like around interesting tracks. The sole purpose of iRacing is about competitive online racing.
I know other people and this thread have crapped on the game for various reasons, but complaining about the lack of content and/or the price of content isn't quite fair since it's not like Forza or GT or even the Simbin games (Race 07, GTR2 etc) where a large part of the enjoyment comes from the cars themselves and pretty tracks. In iRacing, you aren't really meant to buy every car and play them all regularly like you might in Forza. If you want to be competitive online (and like I said... that's the heart and soul of iRacing) you have to spend many hours and hundreds of laps in each car to learn it, because they're all REALLY different. Believe me (for those who have never tried iRacing yet) you can spend weeks or months getting the hang of the freebie Mazda Miata Cups and Roadsters and becoming competitive. Again, I hate to sound repetitive, but it's absolutely nothing like "simcade" games where you can just hop from one car to the next and still be fairly competitive.
Oh yeah, one other important thing about iRacing is that the tracks are WAY above and beyond any other sim in terms of accuracy. Each track is laser scanned so even the tiniest bumps are replicated, even ones that aren't easily visible. In addition, iRacing (as an extension of the old Papyrus engine) uses a "splined" system for the track surface, so your car is actually driving on a "smooth" surface, not the actual polygons that make up the visual track model, which is how it's done in every single other racing sim out there. It doesn't sound like much but it's quite something when you get used to it, and going back to the other sims where you drive "on" the polygons really sucks.
Anyway, I'm not out to prove anything or submit that iRacing is the best racing sim out there.. I'm just trying to point out that when you look at it for what it is (organized competition) it's actually very good. Other sims like rfactor or the Simbin Race 07 series offer lots of cars and tracks and you can race offline to your heart's content and offer multiplayer, but to get into consistent online competition it requires a lot of effort on your part (finding appropriate forums and setting up your own competitions.) iRacing organizes it all, with an official licensing, scoring and ranking system, and that's really what it's all about.
No.6 really summed it perfectly in one sentence:
Except doing it that way makes it extraordinarily intimidating to a newcomer. You've said it yourself "you have to spend many hours and hundreds of laps in each car to learn it." That's great if I'm someone with a racing background, but I don't.
The easiest (and ridiculously obvious) solution would be what I said earlier. Sell me the base game for the same or maybe even more than you do now, and make the monthly fee for competitive play and/or access to more advanced leagues. This way I spend "many hours and hundreds of laps" without spending months paying for competitive play I'll never engage in. Or keep it the way it is now and include autocross; an event where if I screw it up, I'm not screwing up an entire field.
Maybe 6 months after I start playing I'll graduate to the paid competitive play. Its like saying I'll pay for a year of XBox Live along with my Halo 5 purchase. I'll eventually play online, but like any other FPS, I'm going to do it after playing single player and getting my skill level up enough to be remotely competitive.
The bottom line is that iRacing does accurately simulate the need for all of your time, an unrealistically massive pile of cash, and dealing with the most obnoxious assholes on earth on a daily basis if you want to even dream of being a racing driver. In these respects it is exactly like real life.
Yup, and I respect your opinion and your argument.
There's plenty of information in this short thread for any bystanders to make an informed decision. I simply want to point out that No.6 referred to his past history at iRacing as "every year of my tenure" and Bluesun said "It becomes more work than play and you forget why you are even doing it" and these two quotes are mild Freudians compared to some that have been dropped by iRacers over the years. Be warned of what you are getting into. The people of iRacing are worse than the pay model, which will be difficult to believe.
rFactor is old but with ENB and mods is still one of the best around for serious simming and for 20 bucks you get more content than every other PC racing game put together including iRacing, rFactor2 is coming along well but is a pain in the ass to deal with (their mod packaging system is a fucking war crime), Assetto Corsa looks promising but is still early in development, Project CARS is coming along nicely but is more Forza/GT than a real deal simulator and you can't actually buy that one yet unless you already own it from early days... there aren't many more PC options, which is a big reason iRacing is as popular as it is. "It sucks, but what else is there?" is what people say. I just listed what else there is.
Oh and can't forget Game Stock Car aka GSC -- I haven't bought it myself but it is regarded highly by sim gamers.
I wish they were more enthusiastic about putting Gran Turismo releases on PC. That is the only arcade style racing simulator I ever got into, but this was back with a handheld controller so... Pretty much from 2003 until iRacing got big(ger) and was being advertised on Indy races I was strictly a Papyrus racer. I ran races in a nice small league and struggled to keep on track in hardcore mode with my 50dollar wheel and pedals. It was a lot of fun and quite a bit of frustration, which is a weird combination that has always drawn me to difficult activities.
I did a good bit of rally type racing on the rural roads of the Texas hillcountry and somehow survived with enough sense not to go looking for a GT ride when I could have had a shot (was fitter and younger) so for people like me... who have been in a collision at 100mph and jumped out of the car ready to go again but don't have a ride or a deathwish anymore iRacing is the next best thing. Take a look at Pablo Lopez or Shupop's videos on Youtube. They are better than live races most of the time, unless you like constant color commentary. Me, without characters like James Hunt in the booth, I'd rather just hear the sounds from in the cockpit. Pretty much everyone I've ever shown one of Shupop's videos to takes about 5 minutes before they realize it's a simulator and not an actual onboard camera.
iRacing is not raking it in, either, as I understand it. This is a company run by racing enthusiasts who have their own agenda and it doesn't reflect a "passive and fun" game style in any way shape or form. Still, I spend most of my time on iRacing offline, and I enjoy myself immensely. My 4 year old knows how to heal-and-toe; his feet just aren't big enough. The time we've spent together running around smacking into walls or me showing him how to put fast laps down is precious and a lot of other "games" I used to play would be impossible for me to share with him. He's getting better at MarioKart all the time!![]()
But is there any other options with such a large base of consumers?
iRacing is crap. Terrible.
For hundreds+ of dollars, you get a game with 8 yr old console graphics, highly restricted play, and the pleasure to spend more on cars and tracks. Don't even have nurburgring.