iFixit Mac Pro Teardown

For as much engineering as went into that system, shame it has to be the fugliest computer hardware to come around since the old Apple Hockey Puck mouse.
 
This may well be the first apple product I'm liking, seems well put together & quality components. I wouldn't buy one as a workstation though, but a consumer version could be interesting.

That PSU is tiny for those GPUs, highly binned I's guess.
 
It looks really cool... but I like my big, loud rigs. Just something magical about having a powerful, loud box.

But the engineering, as other have said, is really cool.

No temp issues at all with this?
 
I'll hand it to Apple on the engineering side here. Packing that much tech into the coffee can is impressive. That being said.....

This thing looks like an overheat nightmare. Better keep it dust free, and I bet it shortens the life span of the unit.

There's pretty much zero cost effective upgrade options there. Except the CPU and RAM, but refer back to the heat comment, not to mention the extra draw on the power supply.


Add 50% to the size and I think they could have used more standard parts, had a better heat solution, and had more standard upgrade options like a platter hard drive. I suppose then you wouldn't HAVE to go to Apple for everything then, typical.
 
Dammit apple...... I like it.

Now. What is the price without ram, processor, ssd or OS. Get it under $1k and I bet sales would be pretty high. If needed to get the costs down only offer 30 day warranty on bare bones system. Maybe $1300 for barebones and dual D700??

Yes I realize that's not how apple does business.... But that's about the only way I'll every own a Mac.
 
Meh. Seen better DIYs. Also, proprietary case and video cards mean the those cards have no resale value and it's a throw away trash computer if it doesn't sell well and get dropped. And, four memory slot and 64GB limitation make it more like a desktop class.
 
For as much engineering as went into that system, shame it has to be the fugliest computer hardware to come around since the old Apple Hockey Puck mouse.
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. IMO it looks far nicer than a giant rectangular cuboid.
This thing looks like an overheat nightmare. Better keep it dust free, and I bet it shortens the life span of the unit.
I don't think it will get all that hot as long as the fan spools up appropriately when loads get high. The heatsink is pretty big and the fan draws air straight from outside, over the cooler, then straight out the case, further aided by natural convection.

Add 50% to the size and I think they could have used more standard parts, had a better heat solution, and had more standard upgrade options like a platter hard drive. I suppose then you wouldn't HAVE to go to Apple for everything then, typical.
Yeah, I would have liked to have seen it be able to use standard video cards at least, however that brings about it's own problems as not all graphics cards have their GPU in the same place and on the same size mounting, so they'd have to design the cooler for a specific card and then you'd have very little upgrade options, if any.

I think you'd have to be significantly larger than just 50% larger to use many more standard parts.

Meh. Seen better DIYs.
Such as?
 
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. IMO it looks far nicer than a giant rectangular cuboid.
I don't think it will get all that hot as long as the fan spools up appropriately when loads get high. The heatsink is pretty big and the fan draws air straight from outside, over the cooler, then straight out the case, further aided by natural convection.


Yeah, I would have liked to have seen it be able to use standard video cards at least, however that brings about it's own problems as not all graphics cards have their GPU in the same place and on the same size mounting, so they'd have to design the cooler for a specific card and then you'd have very little upgrade options, if any.

I think you'd have to be significantly larger than just 50% larger to use many more standard parts.


Such as?

"Giant rectangular cuboids"...at least don't look like cheap pieces of plastic. Hell even the old Mac Pro tower was a hella classy tower that got many enthusiasts modding them for PC use.

As to the rest...that tiny heatsink probably barely has comparable effective area to a high end PC CPU cooler and worse is cooling everything....2xGPUs, LGA2011 CPU, *and* a PSU with no spare wattage. And the heatsink isn't even made out of copper but aluminum.
 

Anything that requires imagination and doesn't look like a trash can.

http://www.geek.com/chips/man-builds-the-ultimate-pc-casedesk-hybrid-1533146/

final8.jpg



http://www.damngeeky.com/2013/02/27...computer-case-mod-for-classic-car-lovers.html

Christine-DIY-Hotrod-car-computer-case-mod.jpg



http://lifehacker.com/5874600/build-a-computer-into-your-desk-for-easy-upgrades-hidden-cables

ku-xlarge.jpg



http://hackedgadgets.com/2008/10/24/computer-cooled-using-a-mineral-oil-filled-fish-tank/

_Mineral_Oil_Submerged_Computer_3.JPG
 
nice engineering, i liked the gpu die being on the back side.

Now , here's a thought. Design looks scalable.... why not make a 6 feet tall version. :eek:
 
"Giant rectangular cuboids"...at least don't look like cheap pieces of plastic. Hell even the old Mac Pro tower was a hella classy tower that got many enthusiasts modding them for PC use.

As to the rest...that tiny heatsink probably barely has comparable effective area to a high end PC CPU cooler and worse is cooling everything....2xGPUs, LGA2011 CPU, *and* a PSU with no spare wattage. And the heatsink isn't even made out of copper but aluminum.

Again, beauty in the eye of the beholder. The thing is aluminium, if you think it looks like a cheap piece of plastic, that's your perception, to me it looks like a space efficient cylinder, that is all. Giant rectangular cuboids, to me, look like inefficient boxes that serve no purpose that couldn't be achieved with a cardboard box with a few holes cut in it. I've never understood why people get hard ons for computer cases in the first place. Almost all standard computer cases my first thought is "well that's a fucking expensive box", not "ooo, such sexy lines on that box" (which I don't think about the Mac Pro either, but what I think of the Mac Pro is still a step above "expensive box" :p).

The heatsink doesn't look all that tiny to me. It takes up most of the space in the cylinder. Several reviews have said it's quiet, so unless it's burning up it seems like a good design. Haven't seen any mention of actual temperatures as of yet, but I could totally believe it keeps it all equally cool as any other high end case. If it doesn't then Apple are in a world of shit because I'm sure many people buying it will be putting it through it's paces. It might not have the net airflow of a bigger case with 3 or 4 case fans, but in a traditional case so much of the air passing through the fans is wasted. In this, all the air passing through the fan comes from the outside, goes straight through the heatsink and out again. We'll have to see some actual tests to know what the temperature is like, personally I'm optimistic.
 
It looks like a trash can, with a gloss finish.

I do like some of the thought that went into it though, the engineering is nice. That doesn't mean it isn't ugly. The concorde was ugly too.
 
so the only thing you MIGHT be a be able to upgrade is the memory huh?

Fuck you apple -- I don't care how small or sleek it is, every thing in that device is proprietary, and for 3K it better come with a year supply of hookers.

Sadly there is some hipster out there whos masturbating to those pictures, scheming how to get the money to buy one so he can have it on his desk at work and feel superior.

For 3K I'd expect the service life of that thing to be at least 5 to 7 years. So if you buy one, just hope for ZERO advancements in HDD/GPU/CPU technology and you should be golden.
 
so the only thing you MIGHT be a be able to upgrade is the memory huh?

Fuck you apple -- I don't care how small or sleek it is, every thing in that device is proprietary, and for 3K it better come with a year supply of hookers.

Sadly there is some hipster out there whos masturbating to those pictures, scheming how to get the money to buy one so he can have it on his desk at work and feel superior.

For 3K I'd expect the service life of that thing to be at least 5 to 7 years. So if you buy one, just hope for ZERO advancements in HDD/GPU/CPU technology and you should be golden.

???

The only part that not upgradable are the GPUs. But it's better to pay for the upgrade at the time of purchase from Apple.
 
???

The only part that not upgradable are the GPUs. But it's better to pay for the upgrade at the time of purchase from Apple.

Either way -- when my car needs an oil filter or new tires, I prefer to get them at standard prices from whoever gives the best deal. You can't pop down to Fry's or order a GPU online and upgrade it yourself without voiding whatever warranty you have. Plus I don't like the message apple sends with the whole "its cheaper to upgrade NOW" crap. Basically saying "spend more money than you planned to now, because if you don't we are going to REALLY rape you later, just because we can"

I won't even point out the historic cost of BASIC parts for apple computers.

I realize it's targeted towards professional workstation people who generally don't care about a budget, but it's about $1000 overpriced across the line.

It's a cool looking little toy - but at the end of the day you are spending more than you need to, that's been the theme of all apple products since the beginning of time.
 
I realize it's targeted towards professional workstation people who generally don't care about a budget, but it's about $1000 overpriced across the line.

Haven't we already shown in the plethora of other threads that, part for part, it's actually a pretty good deal?
 
If it doesn't overheat I'm impressed with the engineering.
But that being said...
I don't care for the look of it, to me, it looks like something I keep next to my toilet, not my desk.
 
Either way -- when my car needs an oil filter or new tires, I prefer to get them at standard prices from whoever gives the best deal. You can't pop down to Fry's or order a GPU online and upgrade it yourself without voiding whatever warranty you have. Plus I don't like the message apple sends with the whole "its cheaper to upgrade NOW" crap. Basically saying "spend more money than you planned to now, because if you don't we are going to REALLY rape you later, just because we can"

I won't even point out the historic cost of BASIC parts for apple computers.

I realize it's targeted towards professional workstation people who generally don't care about a budget, but it's about $1000 overpriced across the line.

It's a cool looking little toy - but at the end of the day you are spending more than you need to, that's been the theme of all apple products since the beginning of time.

But you're looking at it from a individual point of view.

The target market are studios that need 2-10 of these at the time of purchase.
They're not going to buy a base spec MP and then budget money in the future for upgrades. Now is now, period.

If an individual isn't bringing in enough money to afford spending $4K at once, stick with PC. Easy.
I wouldn't recommend something like this for a singular creative unless that person is well established and the ROI will been seen in 90 days or less.
 
That really is 20 pounds of stuff in a 10 pound bag.
 
"Giant rectangular cuboids"...at least don't look like cheap pieces of plastic. Hell even the old Mac Pro tower was a hella classy tower that got many enthusiasts modding them for PC use.

As to the rest...that tiny heatsink probably barely has comparable effective area to a high end PC CPU cooler and worse is cooling everything....2xGPUs, LGA2011 CPU, *and* a PSU with no spare wattage. And the heatsink isn't even made out of copper but aluminum.

Right. Apple doesn't have a fucking clue... :rolleyes:
 
Seriously?

And none of those will be used in a creative studio.
This is not a casual desktop PC to loop your Heaven Benchmark on.

Meh. Nothing more than your typical commodity PC and work that can be done out of a home office. My commodity PC has eight slots and supports 256GB. Not that four slot 64GB garbage.
 
Meh. Nothing more than your typical commodity PC and work that can be done out of a home office. My commodity PC has eight slots and supports 256GB. Not that four slot 64GB garbage.

Yeah, because 200GB+ usage is common in a home office.

Let's keep the comparisons within scope.
 
Back
Top