Kevin Smith Blasts YouTube's Content ID

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It looks like Kevin Smith isn't a fan of YouTube's Content ID system.

Clerks and Jay and Silent Bob director Kevin Smith has spoken out to voice his support for gaming video creators in the ongoing controversy over YouTube's recently expanded copyright policy. Speaking on George Stroumboulopoulos Tonight in Canada, Smith said YouTube's policy is negatively impacting creators' freedom of expression.
 
I still don't understand why these people simply don't host their own videos.... If more people pull their content then youtube and all these other copyright holders (who would have a much harder time finding their content and filing a take down then they do now) will get the message.
 
But that is the whole point the youtube generation is just not that great at marketing their own content and it is easier for them this way.

You would say that this would be an excellent time for some other big players to welcome them but you guessed it no one wants them :) .
 
I still don't understand why these people simply don't host their own videos.... If more people pull their content then youtube and all these other copyright holders (who would have a much harder time finding their content and filing a take down then they do now) will get the message.

Because in most cases the bandwidth costs for hosting those videos is well beyond the means of a small group (economy of scale and all that).
 
If critiques of games are removed at the request of the publisher, i think the ads for the publisher's games should also be removed.

but i also think lets play videos, are stealing money from content creators, when the plot is the highlight of the game.
 
If critiques of games are removed at the request of the publisher, i think the ads for the publisher's games should also be removed.

but i also think lets play videos, are stealing money from content creators, when the plot is the highlight of the game.

I dunno .. If someone is willing to sit through 6 hours of video from someone playing a game, I doubt they had any interest in playing it to begin with.
 
A lot of times Let's Plays will make people want to go out and buy the game. Many people keep telling me they have started playing Star Trek Online because of my Let's Play videos on the game. So I know it as fact that Let's Play videos can get people to play the game in question, bringing more people to that game. Sometimes people just want to see what the game is like, before they spend their money on it, and often time, it can encourage them to buy it and play it.
 
A lot of times Let's Plays will make people want to go out and buy the game. Many people keep telling me they have started playing Star Trek Online because of my Let's Play videos on the game. So I know it as fact that Let's Play videos can get people to play the game in question, bringing more people to that game. Sometimes people just want to see what the game is like, before they spend their money on it, and often time, it can encourage them to buy it and play it.

This is exactly what I use lets play videos for. I look them up all the time to get a better feel for games and help me decide if I want to buy a game or not. Hell there has even been a case where I saw a lets play of a game I had no intention of buying until I watched it and was instantly hooked and went and purchased the game. I will occasionally use a lets play video to help me look up how to get past certain parts of games too. For the most part though I mainly use them to help me decide if I want to buy said game or not.
 
I still don't understand why these people simply don't host their own videos.... If more people pull their content then youtube and all these other copyright holders (who would have a much harder time finding their content and filing a take down then they do now) will get the message.

Youtube is a centralized place to go for content that is very popular. If content creators split off to create their own distribution it involves far more work in exchange for way less viewers. Many would lose viewerships entirely by moving from Youtube to some place like Blip or their own personal hosting.

There are outliers like South Park Studios, but they have a colossal brand and the financial means to host videos themselves. For most people this is not an option, Youtube has them by the nuts.
 
I wish Google/Youtuber would protect its users better. After all, we make it what it is, and if it does get real bad, people will leave. Google is making money off the users as well, so it would be beneficial to them to protect us. However, they are taking the easy way out, protect themselves first, and let us fend for ourselves.
 
but i also think lets play videos, are stealing money from content creators, when the plot is the highlight of the game.

If the plot is the main reason to play the game, then that's one fucking terrible game. It's not our fault that spectacles are getting bigger, and gameplay has to shrink to make room for development.

The highlight of the game has and will always be gameplay. Besides, if I really wanna know the plot of a game, I will find out. Nothing they will do will stop that. In most cases, I want to know before I buy a game. Cause bad plot can also ruin the game, but no or little plot is OK if the gameplay is there.

Mass Effect is mostly Plot, and has little value past that.
Serious Sam has nearly no plot, but the game is good.
Half Life 2 has moderate plot, but has excellent gameplay. It's considered one of the best games ever.
 
Because in most cases the bandwidth costs for hosting those videos is well beyond the means of a small group (economy of scale and all that).
Not only that, but there is NOTHING out there that is identical to YouTube -- whether free or paid, and open source. I'm talking about the control panel and user interface; the workflow of browsing, searching for, and watching videos; video editor; video management; video transcoding; annotation editor; etcetera. The whole wazoo. There is no software out there that comes even close to the same functionality, interface-friendliness, and features and familiarity as 'YouTube'.

If there were something like that out there that would be as easy of installing and configuring like Wordpress, I'm sure that YouTube would lose some traffic. But right now, all you can do is attempt to run an awful site using Wordpress and plugins and FAIL at doing so; or use Vimeo or other similar providers (whether free or paid).
 
its more of a TheyTube now.

i_know_what_you_did_there_clean.jpg
 
I wish Google/Youtuber would protect its users better. After all, we make it what it is, and if it does get real bad, people will leave. Google is making money off the users as well, so it would be beneficial to them to protect us. However, they are taking the easy way out, protect themselves first, and let us fend for ourselves.

Historically Google / Youtube has fought to protected it's content creators pretty well. Look up them vs the RIAA, and Viacom. It's been lawyers, lawyers, lawyers for YEARS.

Fan cut videos, and real talent discovered on youtube would have NEVER had been possible without them fighting off the lawsuits.

It is good thing that Youtube drew a line in the sand, because I would want to know what company is being douche bag about game videos so I can avoid products by them, and support the companies encourage feedback (good or bad) about their games.
 
As mentioned above, content creators should not be pissed at youtube. These companies will go after them because of their deep pockets (because of the money they make off youtube and their search results).

It's not youtubes fault. Everyone should be mad at the companies that file these stupid take downs.
 
If critiques of games are removed at the request of the publisher, i think the ads for the publisher's games should also be removed.

but i also think lets play videos, are stealing money from content creators, when the plot is the highlight of the game.

If that's the case, then why call it a game? These content creators are simply cheating the system as Sony did with PS3 - they imported the console as a computer device to lower the tax, then eliminated that functionality via software update. They should not be allowed to have it both ways.
 
I still don't understand why these people simply don't host their own videos.... If more people pull their content then youtube and all these other copyright holders (who would have a much harder time finding their content and filing a take down then they do now) will get the message.
Because the host is completely irrelevant.

Its the subscribers that matter, and building a subscriber base of a million viewers is not something you do overnight.

It would be like saying if you don't like America, just GET OUT, there are plenty of other countries. American soil doesn't matter, but if you can't get the rest of America to move with you to Thailand, then you're going to be very lonely at your new location.
 
I still don't understand why these people simply don't host their own videos.... If more people pull their content then youtube and all these other copyright holders (who would have a much harder time finding their content and filing a take down then they do now) will get the message.

Imagine you ride the bus to work everyday, you put on your headphones to cancel out any distractions, whip out your smart phone to play a little Candy Crush because it's a long fucking ride to work, but because you're so cool the bus lets you ride for free because other bus riders want to get on your bus because you're there, it's a win win situation you get a free ride out of it, the bus company makes lots of money from all the extra rides it's a great symbiotic deal.

Then one day the bus company tells you that you can't use your smart phone anymore while on the bus, and you have to take off the headphones too. If you don't they'll kick you off the bus. So you have two choices, comply with what they say, or go out and buy a car for yourself and drive to work.
 
Then one day the DOT tells bus company that riders can't use their smart phone anymore while on the bus, and they have to take off the headphones too. If you don't they'll kick you off the bus. So you have two choices, comply with what they say, or go out and buy a car for yourself and drive to work.

Fixed it for you. Again if you want to use your smart phone with your headphones, then take a cab at full price.

It's not google/youtube's fault. They are just complying with the law. You don't like it change the laws but don't blame youtube or google.
 
It would be like saying if you don't like America, just GET OUT, there are plenty of other countries. American soil doesn't matter, but if you can't get the rest of America to move with you to Thailand, then you're going to be very lonely at your new location.

Imagine you ride the bus to work everyday, you put on your headphones to cancel out any distractions, whip out your smart phone to play a little Candy Crush because it's a long fucking ride to work, but because you're so cool the bus lets you ride for free because other bus riders want to get on your bus because you're there, it's a win win situation you get a free ride out of it, the bus company makes lots of money from all the extra rides it's a great symbiotic deal.

Then one day the bus company tells you that you can't use your smart phone anymore while on the bus, and you have to take off the headphones too. If you don't they'll kick you off the bus. So you have two choices, comply with what they say, or go out and buy a car for yourself and drive to work.

Ahh, terribly poor and simultaneously unnecessary analogies, no forum discussion is complete without them. As if making up a story that is kinda but not quite the same serve to improve understanding instead of just making the discussion weaker and muddier.
 
It's not google/youtube's fault. They are just complying with the law. You don't like it change the laws but don't blame youtube or google.

Google/YouTube is acting as if they're exempt from the situation that they facilitated, in favor of companies over individuals. They simple washed their hands on the matter, and gave total power over to big game and video companies. Not doing anything is just as bad as doing something about the situation.

The problem is that YouTube's automated flagging system is detecting copyright material with great accuracy, and allowing anyone who claims it to be theirs, to have total control over it. A lot of these claims are not even the company who makes the material in question. This wouldn't be such a big deal if Disney was actually the one to report on the copyright material, and not some small company hidden in India.

So lets recap.

#1 Google flags way too much material that clearly falls under fair use. A 16 second sound clip should not be flagged, as it falls under fair use. As long as it's under a certain amount of time, it falls under fair use.

#2 Google/YouTube needs to verify that the company who claims the material to be there's is really their material. Way too many false claims. It's facilitating YouTube copyright trolls.
 
1. Form LLC
2. Make a bunch of content that is similar to some extremely popular songs/videos
3. Upload your copyrighted material to YT's content recognition system
4. Rake in the ad dollars while the videos sit waiting to be reviewed.

Spam system with as many as possible, force YT to reconsider their policies.
 
I do think what youtube is doing is a bit excessive. However they are in the business to make money, so I can only assume they are currently paying more in legal fees and manpower to deal with copyright issues than they are making from ad revenue on such videos.
1. Form LLC
2. Make a bunch of content that is similar to some extremely popular songs/videos
3. Upload your copyrighted material to YT's content recognition system
4. Rake in the ad dollars while the videos sit waiting to be reviewed.

Spam system with as many as possible, force YT to reconsider their policies.

Yeah, I'm sure it would almost pay for the lawyers required to defend the shaky copyrights.
 
Because the host is completely irrelevant.

Its the subscribers that matter, and building a subscriber base of a million viewers is not something you do overnight.

It would be like saying if you don't like America, just GET OUT, there are plenty of other countries. American soil doesn't matter, but if you can't get the rest of America to move with you to Thailand, then you're going to be very lonely at your new location.

I totally agree. You got the point across. You cant just simply move your channel. You'll lose your fanbase and the platform which you acquire income.

youtube has screwed up this year with the whole forced real name thing, now this? Honestly 80% of my time consumed on Youtube is because of these small talented brocasters/players. If they are gone because of this policy, then i'll stop watching youtube as a whole as well.
 
A lot of times Let's Plays will make people want to go out and buy the game. Many people keep telling me they have started playing Star Trek Online because of my Let's Play videos on the game. So I know it as fact that Let's Play videos can get people to play the game in question, bringing more people to that game. Sometimes people just want to see what the game is like, before they spend their money on it, and often time, it can encourage them to buy it and play it.

I definitely check out real gameplay through twitch.tv when trying to decide to spend my money on a new game. I found Let's Play videos for games I couldn't find on youtube so there's that too.
 
Back
Top