Will The Global NSA Backlash Break The Internet?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Is backlash over NSA spying breaking the internet? What backlash? I hear a lot of talk but I don't see any action being taken to stop it. Do you?

In September, Brazil announced plans to build a fiber-optic cable that would route internet traffic away from US servers, theoretically keeping its citizens’ data away from the NSA. The policy has yet to be implemented, and many question whether it will actually be effective, but others appear to be following Brazil’s lead.
 
Pretty sure the network technology on which the internet is based was designed for exactly this, quite the opposite of breaking it.
 
In September, Brazil announced plans to build a fiber-optic cable that would route internet traffic away from US servers, theoretically keeping its citizens’ data away from the NSA, and putting it in the hands of the Brazilian government directly. The policy has yet to be implemented, and many question whether it will actually be effective, but others appear to be following Brazil’s lead.

FTFY.

Because like the countries that are throwing a bitch fit (You too, Germany) are not spying on their citizens just like the U.S. Rule one - throw a loud ass public bitch fit about shit that you yourself are doing.

It is a good thing that I don't have access to the "football"...I feel humanity is in dire need of a fucking reboot. :)
 
Because like the countries that are throwing a bitch fit (You too, Germany) are not spying on their citizens just like the U.S. Rule one - throw a loud ass public bitch fit about shit that you yourself are doing.

Uh, these countries aren't trying to keep their own eyes off their own population, they're trying to keep the U.S. from having their eyes on them as well. What those countries do in their own houses is their own business, that has nothing to do with the U.S., yet the U.S. seems to think it's their business.
 
FTFY.

Because like the countries that are throwing a bitch fit (You too, Germany) are not spying on their citizens just like the U.S. Rule one - throw a loud ass public bitch fit about shit that you yourself are doing.

It is a good thing that I don't have access to the "football"...I feel humanity is in dire need of a fucking reboot. :)

I don't know about Brazil, but I'd be shocked if Germany isn't doing things similar to the NSA. We know the Russians and Chinese do it.

But here's the thing, we wanted control over the net to promote all these American ideals, and we got caught doing things that are very much like the things we say the Chinese and Russians do, but should not.

If all email becomes encrypted, such that nobody can read it unless they're the intended recipient (e.g. PGP), that'd be a good thing.

Problem is I don't think that'll happen. Web email providers want to mine your email, so they won't implement it and if they don't implement it, then only the paranoid and those involved in something where privacy is an absolute must (e.g. crime, spies, some business communications) will bother.

As for private nets, the cure sounds worse than the disease. Once you're walled off, you may be safe from the U.S., but what's your government preventing you from reading? Honestly, I think I'd be less concerned about Germany spying on me that the NSA....but if I lived in Germany, I'd be more concerned about the German government spying on me.
 
One of the major problem is that, while laws prevent nations from spying on their own citizens (such as in the US), laws allow US to receive information concerning their citizens from other nations' spy agencies.

So US spies on British citizens and give the information to UK (who can't spy on British citizens without cause), and UK intelligence spice on Americans and give the information to US (who, likewise, can't legally spy on Americans without a cause).
 
Is backlash over NSA spying breaking the internet? What backlash? I hear a lot of talk but I don't see any action being taken to stop it. Do you?

There won't be any backlash. There won't be any revolt. People will eventually shut themselves up and go back to watching Dancing with the Stars, American Idol, reading Reddit/[H], Youtubing, Facebooking, Tweeting, etc and continuing on with their meaningless consumer-driven lives.

At most you will get regular jokes cracked by comedians, techvloggers, and IT bloggers alike. Beyond that it will be business as usual.
 
There won't be any backlash. There won't be any revolt. People will eventually shut themselves up and go back to watching Dancing with the Stars, American Idol, reading Reddit/[H], Youtubing, Facebooking, Tweeting, etc and continuing on with their meaningless consumer-driven lives.

At most you will get regular jokes cracked by comedians, techvloggers, and IT bloggers alike. Beyond that it will be business as usual.
I laughed pretty good at this post.
Though, he is spot in in regards to the original question.
 
Pretty sure the network technology on which the internet is based was designed for exactly this, quite the opposite of breaking it.

Yeah... I don't think anybody has proposed an internet firewall, just trying to keep traffic within their country if the end points are both within the same country; maybe a push to move servers there too... but really why should email from user A to user B, both in Brazil, go through the US? My understanding is that for a lot of Brazil to Brazil traffic, packets will go through Miami, because there's not a lot of interconnection in Brazil... which is crazy.
 
I hear a lot of talk but I don't see any action being taken to stop it. Do you?

Despite the noise, did anyone really think this wasn't happening?

Does anyone really think that *everyone* hasn't been spying on each other, friend or foe, forever?

I literally laugh when politicians get all outraged about it and make pronouncements, they are either super naive, or the outrage is totally a PR decision, and I don't think you get to be chancellor of Germany or whatever if you are naive :p

And most importantly, does anyone actually think any heads of state anywhere actually really want it to stop?

I'm sure everyone would love to not have people listening in on their stuff, but not enough that they are going to stop listening in on other peoples stuff :p

Nothing will change, I suspect the NSA won't even take meaningful steps to tighten their internal security to stop another snowden, I'm sure there's emails and meetings and audits flying around like crazy right now, but it'll be business as usual, inside and out, before very long, if it isn't already.
 
I don't quite get it. If each country had their own internet backbone along with the cabling that links it to the backbones of other countries, wouldn't that mean the internet will be completely decentralized? As it is now, if the US got nuked, several continents would actually lose their internet as a lot of them are piggybacking on the US infrastructure.
 
As it is now, if the US got nuked, several continents would actually lose their internet as a lot of them are piggybacking on the US infrastructure.

So does Brazil know something we don't?
 
As it is now, if the US got nuked, several continents would actually lose their internet as a lot of them are piggybacking on the US infrastructure.
Leaving aside the fact that if the US got "nuked" people would probablly be worrying about much bigger problems than lack of internet.

Connectivity wise south america would probably be hardest hit. There are very few cables from south america going to anywhere other than north america. Connectivity between europe and east asia/australasia would certainly be impacted but there are a significant number of links going "round the other way"
 
Let's get real here. I'm pretty sure every country spies on their own citizens and the internet activity of citizens outside of their country. If you honestly think otherwise, I'm guessing your head is in a cool, sandy location.

I remember getting laughed out of a chat room years ago for suggesting the USA had covert ops scattered across the globe; then lo and behold months later those covert ops' identities got revealed by the US media along with some info about their deployment. Everyone spies on everyone, it's in every country's national security's best interests.
 
Leaving aside the fact that if the US got "nuked" people would probablly be worrying about much bigger problems than lack of internet.

Connectivity wise south america would probably be hardest hit. There are very few cables from south america going to anywhere other than north america. Connectivity between europe and east asia/australasia would certainly be impacted but there are a significant number of links going "round the other way"

Original description of the internet was "able to survive a nuclear fallout". Which is technically true, but it's going to be crippled.

A lot of our connections really do pass through the US as that's where a lot of our service providers for the servers are located. Several years ago, I wondered why my countrys internet was so slow so I traced a connection to my neighbor. The many of the IP's it passed through were in the US, this was when I was in college. Several years later while I was working as IT full time and part time for several international companies, I found that a lot of our servers were located in the US.

Just "Go the other way" doesn't quite cut it. When I say, other countries are piggybacking on the US internet infrastructure, I mean it. Over the years a few other countries upgraded their infrastructure as well and able to host our servers now. But it's still only maybe three or four. Not to mention the older companies are still hosted in the US. If the US gets nuked, it'll take down a huge chunk of the internet with it.

If this pushes through and every country starts upgrading their infrastructures, private companies will appear in those countries to provide hosting and other internet services, then the internet will truly become a web instead of the massive chokepoints we have now.
 
I don't know about Brazil, but I'd be shocked if Germany isn't doing things similar to the NSA. We know the Russians and Chinese do it.

But here's the thing, we wanted control over the net to promote all these American ideals, and we got caught doing things that are very much like the things we say the Chinese and Russians do, but should not. .
We wanted control because other countries would fuck it up. Apart from incompetence you would have Nigeria double issuing IP's and urls like www.google.com. North Korea would fuck with it just to fuck with it. And depending who controlled domain names you would domains llike .jewseatbabies
 
Nuclear war is another FUCKING JOKE.

Governments spend great effort telling you that nuclear war and the resulting fallout would be catastrophic for human life.

YET, anyone want to guess the number of warheads that HAVE been detonated by the US government? By the Soviet Government? By the UK? France? China? India? Pakistan? North Korea? Israel?

Well, here's you answer. And it's one that the average person would never fucking believe, because the answer is evil and irrational.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LLCF7vPanrY

Than cannot say that they were unaware of the effects of radiation, I'm sure there were pockets of ignorance in that era, but key actors in the program knew without a doubt what they were releasing.
 
Sure, 500 atmospheric tests over decades is the same as thousands of weapons used in a few hours.
 
This is precept to the United Nations construction of 'Internet 2' deployment. *tin foil hat off*
 
more the reason to support Darknets

This. I've been toying with the idea of starting a meshnet/hyperboria node. I don't have any means for physical connectivity (this town is not really tech savvy so nobody to link with) but if people can at least start nodes and offer various web services it's a start.

Sadly the majority of people just don't care about the NSA/CSEC issue and will just cry "tin foil hat" when people talk about it. What's CSEC? That's basically Canada's NSA and they are just as guilty. Pretty sad, seems you can't go anywhere without being spied on. I used to feel safe in this country till I found out about CSEC.
 
This. I've been toying with the idea of starting a meshnet/hyperboria node. I don't have any means for physical connectivity (this town is not really tech savvy so nobody to link with) but if people can at least start nodes and offer various web services it's a start.

Sadly the majority of people just don't care about the NSA/CSEC issue and will just cry "tin foil hat" when people talk about it. What's CSEC? That's basically Canada's NSA and they are just as guilty. Pretty sad, seems you can't go anywhere without being spied on. I used to feel safe in this country till I found out about CSEC.

Canada just spent over 1 billion dollars on a shiny new spy palace for the building alone.
CSEC is just as guilty and effective as the NSA.

Next election the Canuck current Government is out anyway its become so corrupted and a total farce. CSEC spying, Government corruption and and drug De-criminlization and legalization are going to be major election topics.
 
This is just the saber of Fear being rattled. To instill fear into those who know that what is being done is wrong, and keep them silent. If the final outcome from this is that Businesses can not collect/store data on the public, I am perfectly fine with that as it was an unsustainable business model anyway. The sooner the general public learns to detect Fear monger arguments as BS the sooner we can get real problems fixed.
 
Let's get real here. I'm pretty sure every country spies on their own citizens and the internet activity of citizens outside of their country. If you honestly think otherwise, I'm guessing your head is in a cool, sandy location.

I remember getting laughed out of a chat room years ago for suggesting the USA had covert ops scattered across the globe; then lo and behold months later those covert ops' identities got revealed by the US media along with some info about their deployment. Everyone spies on everyone, it's in every country's national security's best interests.

It's not in my best interest that the NSA spies on me or any other U.S. citizen. I'm unconvinced that notifying Germany that we spy on them was a patriotic decision (it's more likely he's hoping it will lead to asylum in a country not called Russia), but the NSA has been out of control for decades, and it's good to let the PEOPLE know what they do. If we decide that's acceptable, then so be it, but this seems to be an issue that's actually resonating with the left, right and center. With each passing month, it's clear that no matter how bad we thought it was, it's worse. When the NSA says we don't do that, they did it. The way he's released info to catch them in lies has been awesome. Now if Snowden can avoid releasing things like "the nsa spies on <insert allied country>," I'd be a totally behind him.
 
Back
Top