Windows 8.1: New Features, Same Problems

3. over reliance on kb shortcuts. Again since I use this in a HTPC environment, with a dinivo mini, kb shortcuts are often a pain. When you think about-nontech users it is just crazy.

There is no more reliance on kb shortcuts in 8.x than previous versions. Some things are faster using kb shortcuts in 8.x but that's true of any version of Windows.
 
1. Non-unified "running" apps. Before you had the taskbar and everything was there, now you have metro apps on the side bar, and desktop apps WITHIN the "desktop" instance on the side bar, so there is no quick way to go from start screen to an open MS word doc. It was so simple to hit the taskbar.
Alt + Tab actually shows all appilications (desktop and metro) in one switcher

Ctrl + Alt + Tab will open the switcher and leave it open so it can be operated with a mouse.


4.the haphazard nature of it all. You go to the left corner to get a menu to slide in from the left (running apps) but ANY part of the right side to get the "charms" bar, why not make them both corners?
Not sure what you're talking about there. Charms can only be activated by touching the top-right or bottom-right hot-corner. The edge of the screen does nothing...
 
personally where i take issue is that I have to modify the operating system before it becomes usable in a production environment.
That basically defines my experience with every OS... ever...

All the way back to Amiga Workbench, there were piles of customization tools. Docks, skins, enhanced animations, replacement file managers, etc. (and back then, most of it was closed-source commercial software too!)

But we all loved our Amiga's, and loved what we could turn them into :D

My experience with every version of Windows and every distro of Linux has been no different. Install and customize. Windows XP was one of the worst offenders, I found using it to be a pain in the ass without Launchy and RocketDock installed. And if you're wondering where OSX fits in...I don't like its default behavior (as expected) but there's very little you can do to fix it, so I haven't really been able to use it.

Customization using 3rd party software is par for the course. Move along, nothing to see here :p
 
Microsoft has a known history for kitten abuse. Please think of the kittens, and don't use Windows 8.

save-the-kittens.jpg

mg]
 
Two and ONLY two things left for me to gripe about:

1. advertisements in my paid operating system
2. please bring back the instant search functionality to the start menu. Win8 is a small step back, but a step back nonetheless.

I hate how the instant search that does exist separates programs and setting into two sections. So if I want to uninstall a program, I use to be able to hit the start button, type "uninstall" and click the option that shows up. Now I have to do the same thing, but click the "Settings" option to filter my results to the appropriate section. An extra click that is not needed, and feels really clunky.
 
People are always going to complain. The biggest WTF I've seen so far is someone saying (paraphrasing) "Skydrive is the default save location? So I only have 7 gigs to store everything? Good thing I have my 2tb hard drive! Microsoft is so stupid!"

Wait...are you trying to say cloud storage is better than local storage?

If so, LOL.
 
Meh. Wake me up when there is at least an option to completely remove the metro UI. Bring on all of the "you're just afraid of change" and "you're too dumb to learn new things" arguments. Just remember, not all change is inherently good, and there's a difference between not being able to learn something, and not wanting to learn something stupid.
 
Windows key + S, or just pressing start and typing what you are looking for doesn't have the functionality you want? For me, Win8 search functionality is far more useful than Win7 search ever was.

Um no... I want e-mail+files + control panel objects and administrator tools all included in my searches.

Like the way it used to work in windows 7 :rolleyes:
 
Because they could have stayed with Windows 7 and not moved anything. That's the point. Windows 8 was intended to be completely different and tile-based. If you're using Windows 8 like you're using Windows 7, then you're not trying to learn anything, like those "folks who moan" are.

Why should people learn Win8 when it doesn't do anything better? I feel the biggest issue with Win8 is the fact MS too out the customization that people always had with Windows. They could have just had the damn start menu and option to turn off that stupid tiled desktop. Tablet and laptop users would have kept it and those who actually use their computer and folks stuck up on the old interface would have had their way. Everyone wins and instead MS is feeding the tablet crap onto everyone. If I wanted a Start menu for whatever reason, I shouldn't need to install a 3rd party software. Most of these I love Win8 users still installed start menu or classic UI and got rid of the metro desktop.
 
Two and ONLY two things left for me to gripe about:

1. advertisements in my paid operating system
2. please bring back the instant search functionality to the start menu. Win8 is a small step back, but a step back nonetheless.

So really just one....because the start menu still has instant search, it just has no visible box.

Steps match those in the prior version of windows
1. Click to bring up the new UI OR press the windows key.
2. Start typing and search just happens.
 
Why should people learn Win8 when it doesn't do anything better?

It does do things better for tablet users.

It just doesn't do things better for the rest of us.

Microsoft is oblivious and indignant about the latter.
 
Alt + Tab actually shows all appilications (desktop and metro) in one switcher

Hmm, will have to try that, still not as easy as just clicking the taskbar, but at least it is workable. (again my use as an HTPC with mini kb/mouse combo)

As to my mention of conveyance, this video does a thorough job explaining what I mean.
 
Two and ONLY two things left for me to gripe about:

1. advertisements in my paid operating system
2. please bring back the instant search functionality to the start menu. Win8 is a small step back, but a step back nonetheless.

And these are two of several reasons I am avoiding 8.1 and stating putting on 8.0 with the Win7 shell (Ex7ForW8, which disables Metro completely from ever running).
 
I hate how the instant search that does exist separates programs and setting into two sections. So if I want to uninstall a program, I use to be able to hit the start button, type "uninstall" and click the option that shows up. Now I have to do the same thing, but click the "Settings" option to filter my results to the appropriate section. An extra click that is not needed, and feels really clunky.

hit WinKey + W, then type uninstall.
 
Wait...are you trying to say cloud storage is better than local storage?

If so, LOL.

No, you still didn't get the point. They aren't forcing you to save files there, it's just integrated into the OS so you don't have to install the software and there's some advantages such as creating stubs to save space. He's assuming that it's forcing you to use it, just like you are assuming that I'm saying that cloud storage is better than local.
 
Windows key + S, or just pressing start and typing what you are looking for doesn't have the functionality you want? For me, Win8 search functionality is far more useful than Win7 search ever was.

Its close.

You click the start menu and start typing.... Display for instance. It defaults to the Apps category. Requires Extra click.

In win 7 hit windows key or open the start menu and type "display" and hit enter and you're right where you want to be. It also searches my outlook for emails containing the word display, and documents. Anything that is found all appears in the start menu with no additional clicks.

(I havent tested the email search functionality on Win8 yet)

Like I said.... its a small step back for me, but a step back nonetheless.

Plus as I mentioned, ads are retarded in an OS that I payed for.
 
there is ads in windows 8? whereabouts and whatabouts? Is this something that is displayed on the metro start screen (I installed Start8 about 1 day into my Windows 8 experience and then soon forgot it was a different OS)

If you use the Travel and News section there are ads. I also have not been able to change the "top story" in the default News app even though I can configure my own sources.

A small gripe, but a gripe nonetheless. The fact that they tried to sneak in ads at all really irks me.
 
Problem is too much change. People are used to the mouse/windows/desktop since ~20 some years ago of using the same thing. As far as GUI appearance, since after Windows 3.1, the OS has looked quite similar and differed appearance-wise by "themes" per say. And now in 8, things looked totally different. All of a sudden MS wants to prop up touch tiles and change the way the OS operates by user usage. It's kind of hard to push this much change to the majority of the market, when some are just getting acquainted with Windows XP/7 and others have been using the "same thing" for years. If anything, MS should have gradually changed the GUI and at least give options, or find a way to segregate the style of the OS.

But as of now, I don't really see a personal reason to switch to 8.1, when 7 has been working pretty well over the past few years.

All Windows 8 needs is:

- Boot to desktop. 8.1 does this.

- GUI to shut down the PC without opening a full screen window. Looks like 8.1 does this, though it looks visually ugly compared to Vista/7. Why bother changing it?

- Ability to auto default to desktop programs if applicable by default. Right now it auto defaults file associations with Modern apps even if you have desktop apps installed. If I am in the desktop and have a desktop program to use please don't boot me into a full screen app.

- Drop down menus are quicker to use than the ribbon and require one less click. I don't, and never will use a touch screen on my desktop or laptop. My arm blocks my screen (inefficient) and dirties the screen up quicker. This requires me to clean my screen more.

- Make the UI more like 7/Vista. The lack of borders makes it confusing to know where a button ends or starts. Decreases efficiency. Bring back aero; it simply looks nicer.


Also, my 1 month old Win 8 install bricked itself recently for no reason. Was not a fan of that.
 
There......fixed that for you. :)

Some people 'think' or 'know' they are techs......but they're not. lol.

I used the word "arent". It was speficicaly for people who know that they are not computer savvy. As the poster I quoted said something to the effect of "you're no tech if you cant customize Win8 in an hour". Thats mostly irrelevant for the majority of users.
 
Its close.

You click the start menu and start typing.... Display for instance. It defaults to the Apps category. Requires Extra click.

In win 7 hit windows key or open the start menu and type "display" and hit enter and you're right where you want to be. It also searches my outlook for emails containing the word display, and documents. Anything that is found all appears in the start menu with no additional clicks.

(I havent tested the email search functionality on Win8 yet)

Like I said.... its a small step back for me, but a step back nonetheless.

Plus as I mentioned, ads are retarded in an OS that I payed for.

Winkey + W for Settings
Winkey + F for files
Winkey + Q for apps
 
Step 1: Press the windows key
Step 2: Start typing your search term.
Step 3: Search UI instantly appears and starts working.

This might sound familiar... because it's the same way you use start-search in Windows 7 :p

Its close, but not quite. See my above description.
 
Winkey + W for Settings
Winkey + F for files
Winkey + Q for apps

How is this easier than pressing the windows key and ONLY the windows key for EVERYTHING?

A small step back, but a step back nonetheless.
 
If you use the Travel and News section there are ads. I also have not been able to change the "top story" in the default News app even though I can configure my own sources.

A small gripe, but a gripe nonetheless. The fact that they tried to sneak in ads at all really irks me.

But half the people complaining are the same ones who had no intention of using modern in the first place. I can see if it's like Bonzi Buddy and it's everywhere, but if you don't like it, then disable modern.
 
But half the people complaining are the same ones who had no intention of using modern in the first place. I can see if it's like Bonzi Buddy and it's everywhere, but if you don't like it, then disable modern.

I for one think Win8 is FAN-F'N-TASTIC on my tablet. So I use the Modern UI alot.

Its just shady to use ads in something you pay for no matter how small they might be. Ads is something I've become accustom to for free services. Not an OS that I've payed for.
 
How is this easier than pressing the windows key and ONLY the windows key for EVERYTHING?

A small step back, but a step back nonetheless.

Once upon a time nobody knew about Winkey + L for sleep, CTRL ESC for start menu (supplemented with the Winkey now), CTRL C for copy, CTRL X for cut, CTRL V for paste, ALT+TAB for app switching, and so on and so forth.

People evolve. We remember new things as we keep using it. It's not that hard.

First world problem.
 
Once upon a time nobody knew about Winkey + L for sleep, CTRL ESC for start menu (supplemented with the Winkey now), CTRL C for copy, CTRL X for cut, CTRL V for paste, ALT+TAB for app switching, and so on and so forth.

People evolve. We remember new things as we keep using it. It's not that hard.

First world problem.

All of the keyboard shortcuts you mention actually made doing a task faster.

As it stands, the Win7 start menu search has more flexibility.

I'd like to see something similar done with the Win8 search... currently when you search in Win8 you might only get 2 or 3 icons per "category" that requires extra clicks to switch between. How bout you just line those categories up in columns on the start screen? I'd love that.
 
^that would bring back the glorious functionality of the Win7 search and might even improve upon it as there is more space to display more results.
 
But half the people complaining are the same ones who had no intention of using modern in the first place. I can see if it's like Bonzi Buddy and it's everywhere, but if you don't like it, then disable modern.

Speaking of Modern UI. Default programs are linked to it. Click a link and it opens in IE in the Modern UI. Open up a pdf and it opens in the Moder UI reader. I know how to change these types of things, but does your average user?
 
All the stuff that folks moan about in Windows 8 is mostly the stuff those of us that like 8 just ignore or don't use. I don't get why they can't just move into Desktop and stay there like most of us do. It's like watching people punching themselves in the balls over and over. Bizarre.

Not exactly a ringing endorsement, but a helluva tagline: Windows 8: "Oh, that. Just ignore it."™

Do you realize how silly that sounds? You say you like Windows 8 but ignore the main features Microsoft wants you to use and "just adapt" to. You are moaning, only in your own, head-in-sand, passive way. The point is, when the day comes in a future version of Windows that that "ignoring it" is no longer an option, think back and realize maybe you should have moaned about it when you had the chance.
 
Not exactly a ringing endorsement, but a helluva tagline: Windows 8: "Oh, that. Just ignore it."™

Do you realize how silly that sounds? You say you like Windows 8 but ignore the main features Microsoft wants you to use and "just adapt" to. You are moaning, only in your own, head-in-sand, passive way. The point is, when the day comes in a future version of Windows that that "ignoring it" is no longer an option, think back and realize maybe you should have moaned about it when you had the chance.

Or realize it didn't make a difference whether you moaned about it or not and regret the time you spent moaning that you could have instead used for more productive things.
 
You really should read up on the network effect. Regardless, if I've saved even one friend from the Playskool UI fiasco (and I passed that milestone a long time ago), then a difference was made.
 
Not exactly a ringing endorsement, but a helluva tagline: Windows 8: "Oh, that. Just ignore it."™

Do you realize how silly that sounds? You say you like Windows 8 but ignore the main features Microsoft wants you to use and "just adapt" to. You are moaning, only in your own, head-in-sand, passive way. The point is, when the day comes in a future version of Windows that that "ignoring it" is no longer an option, think back and realize maybe you should have moaned about it when you had the chance.

Now you're grasping straws. All he's saying is if you don't want to use a feature in Windows, then DON'T USE IT. There are features in every single versions of Windows that people don't use if they don't like it. For the longest time it was the integrated Internet Explorer. By god, I thought people will never shut up about it.

Don't like the modern UI? Get classic shell. Don't like full screen apps and prefer them windowed? Get ModernMix. Install them and be done with it. Windows 7 with the extras, snappiness and security of Windows 8. Boom, done.
 
Back
Top