Xbox One and PC Cross-Platform Possibility Discussed

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
While talk of cross-platform play is cool and all, I think most of us like the fact that console gamers are currently separated from those of us on the PC. ;)

Talk of a cross-platform play reality between the Xbox and the PC has been brought up many times over the years, not the least of which was last week when Ausgamers posed a question on the topic to Microsoft’s Phil Spencer. Among several other questions, Spencer was asked if Xbox One and PC cross-platform play could be a reality in the future, and Spencer indicates the answer is yes.
 
Ah yes just want i want to hear over my pc headphones is some kid screaming hacks cause my response time with a keyboard/mouse is less than his controller.
 
I'd support it on a strictly-filtered (read: friends only, not matchmaking) basis. I have a bunch of console friends who I can't play with right now, and as long as I know I'm ONLY playing with them, I'd even be willing to pay a small amount (not a full XBL subscription) to do it.
 
Agreed Sovereign. I'd love to be able to rope in console only friends, and would pay a pittance to be able to do so.
 
That would be a HUGE negative for the Xbox One if there are no checks and balances in place. If there are a list of options to filter the playerbase like Sovereign said it wouldn't be a bad deal at all.

If not and it is unregulated wow lol
 
I'd prefer it if the unwashed savages remained on the other side of the Rubicon.

And no, that wasn't entirely tongue-and-cheek.
 
I'd love some cross platform gaming. I still have some friends who refuse to give up their consoles and it would be nice to play stupid games with those idiots.
 
That would be a HUGE negative for the Xbox One if there are no checks and balances in place. If there are a list of options to filter the playerbase like Sovereign said it wouldn't be a bad deal at all.
If cross-platform play is predicated on all users using the same or similar controller, I wouldn't see any issue. PC gamers get to crank up resolution, but that doesn't afford a substantial competitive advantage. From a technical feasibility perspective, this is all completely doable, particularly given a client/server networking model.
 
Could be? Sure!
WILL be? Not in your lifetime!

There were discussions about this during the last generation of games too. And the same thing was said.

The fact is, it's not going to happen. EVER.
 
maybe microsoft is doing drm in their controllers.

so you can use xbox one controller on pc and will be detected as a certain controller.

people must use that controller when playing against consoles.


however people might try to figure out the drm and make other things work. this in when microsoft will do a controller firmware update and ban everyone that is using a modded driver.

that is what i believe microsoft will do
 
Cross platform play has always been a "possibility". A few games on the PS3 cross over with PC games and there have been a few on the XBox 360 that were playable with PC gamers as well. The problem comes down to execution. Obviously anyone playing a FPS on PC has a great advantage over someone playing on a console. Moreover if you're a third party publisher/developer it's conceivable that you could do a game that would allow PC gamers to play with players on the Playstation or PC gamers to play with people on the XBox but you wouldn't be able to allow players on the XBox to play against players on the Playstation thanks to the walled garden approach that Microsoft has implemented for the XBox (and apparently Sony will do for the Playstation 4). So the question is why would any developer bother with the time and expense of doing a cross platform game if they can't make sure all their customers can play together?
 
If cross-platform play is predicated on all users using the same or similar controller, I wouldn't see any issue. PC gamers get to crank up resolution, but that doesn't afford a substantial competitive advantage. From a technical feasibility perspective, this is all completely doable, particularly given a client/server networking model.

Sure if you forced PC users to use the Xbone controller but that would be hacked within probably 10 mins. It's doable, always has been. The issue is always going to be console players getting absolutely destroyed due to a handicap.

I would be cool if they have options in place on the Xbox One side to prevent them from joining games with PC players.
 
Could be? Sure!
WILL be? Not in your lifetime!

There were discussions about this during the last generation of games too. And the same thing was said.

The fact is, it's not going to happen. EVER.

It already has happened in some games and you are completely wrong. Why so closed minded? I for one welcome it and everyone automatically goes to FPS and the keyboard/mouse is better so it won't work crap. Fact is there are plenty of other games out there to play where keyboard/mouse precision means absolutely squat. It would be cool to play those games cross platform if need be where my friends don't have a PC and only a console.
 
My biggest question is how this would work in a game like battlefield where individual guilds (clans?) can set up their own servers for others to play on. Will those just stay PC Exclusive? or will Xbox players now get access to privately owned servers like PC players do? This is a no brainer in certain genres where keyboard and mouse isnt an advantage such as racing or other sims, MMOs, fighting, but shooting not so much
 
Sure if you forced PC users to use the Xbone controller but that would be hacked within probably 10 mins.
That seems to me like a cheating/exploiting issue. Those are already abound. Why would this be any different?
 
Could be? Sure!
WILL be? Not in your lifetime!

There were discussions about this during the last generation of games too. And the same thing was said.

The fact is, it's not going to happen. EVER.

Just like there was major discussions about remote play with the PS Vita and PS3?

The thing your missing is Microsoft is moving in this direction as a whole with a more unified OS model in windows 8, windows TR, and the mobile OS. I wouldnt say its far fetched at all for Microsoft to be planning this when their entire focus of the XBox is an integrated experience
 
Well, if MSFT does the programming, it'll be a POS.

Take your hate to a different thread, face it, Microsoft continues to be one of the most if not the most software dominant companies on the planet. And it IS NOT because they have a near monopoly on windows. Its because Companies use their server and corporate level software because it is one of if not the best most stable platforms out there. Microsoft does a hell of a lot on the corporate scale than most windows realize and its because they are the best at it
 
This could be great with the right games. Co-op in Diablo 3 for example. Co-op in Portal 2 was fine between PS3 and PC.
 
Take your hate to a different thread, face it, Microsoft continues to be one of the most if not the most software dominant companies on the planet. And it IS NOT because they have a near monopoly on windows. Its because Companies use their server and corporate level software because it is one of if not the best most stable platforms out there. Microsoft does a hell of a lot on the corporate scale than most windows realize and its because they are the best at it

I like his hate. He can keep it in this thread, hombre.
 
I was going to ask "to which thread shall he take the hate?" but Vlad would probably demand it be in yet another thread.
 
Vlad does have a point: Microsoft struggles with everything but engineering, but on the engineering front, they do pretty well.
 
In most cases, cross-platform is fine... but in cases like competitive FPS, the PC gamer will most likely ruin the console kiddies' day.
 
The problem with cross-platform gaming between an Xbox console and PC is Microsoft's own artificial limitation to it. They only intend multiplayer gameplay between Xbox consoles, and nothing more than that. To hear them possibly change their mind on it feels like I have to take it a huge grain of salt because knowing Microsoft, they'd rather be selling Microsoft consoles and get a better return on them than having multiplayer console games spread to PCs (and Sony consoles).

Back in the early years of the Xbox 360 and after Final Fantasy XI was released, MSDN even stated that cross-platform play would only be limited to Xbox Live Gold subscribers on both Xbox 360 and Windows. There would be no cross-platform play between non-Microsoft consoles such as the PS3. These were the old requirements on MSDN. I checked them out myself because I was curious, and it looks like Microsoft is changing their restrictions again.

Other silly things about the multiplayer requirements at that time several years ago:
  • Multiplayer games are to be hosted on Xbox Live servers, or if they aren't, matchmaking MUST GO through the Xbox Live servers.
  • Game updates, patches, and DLCs are to be hosted on the Xbox Live servers and be pre-approved.

I honestly would like several things changed:
  • Silver level subscription is the only barrier, not the pay wall called Xbox Live Gold.
  • Filters in matchmaking-- friends-only versus a bunch a bratty CoD twelve-year olds.
  • No restrictions on what Windows OS is used to play multiplayer games with the Xbox ONE.
  • Zero restrictions between platforms.
Another issue that a lot of console gamers complain about is that PC users have the better hardware and control-- keyboard and mouse versus gamepad-- and are more responsive. I highly doubt we'll have a multiplayer game anytime soon between the Xbox ONE and PC unless the fucktards in Microsoft be more open with their platform, which will never happen.

Look at Elder Scrolls Online, another good example. It's why there will NEVER be Final Fantasy XIV for the Xbox ONE. Blame Microsoft. When Elder Scrolls Online is released for the Xbox ONE. NO ONE ON THE Xbox ONE will be able to play with someone on the PS4, OSX and PC versions. NO ONE. The only players you will be limited to are Xbox ONE console users. If the PC, PS4 and OSX versions have hundreds of thousands of players combined and the Xbox ONE-only servers only have tens of thousands, then you'll understand the reason.

Why?

Microsoft.

Microsoft is not going to open their console up to players on other platforms. Believe me, it won't happen.

They'll make more money forcing people to Xbox Live Gold to play multiplayer and buy Xbox ONE consoles than trying to get people to move to Windows 8.1 and allow cross-platform play between the two.
 
Just like there was major discussions about remote play with the PS Vita and PS3?

Hey Vlad!

Nice to see you again, you mentioned that a few weeks ago and never provided additional information. Could you please provide some links where every PS3 game would work with Vita or that it was going to be a driving factor?

I know I remember seeing it being an option for developers but
 
I'd love some cross platform gaming. I still have some friends who refuse to give up their consoles and it would be nice to play stupid games with those idiots.

Likewise I have a bunch of retard buddies who refuse to game on anything other than what they perceive as God's gaming device, the PC.

This would be pretty sweet so long as the same filters and regulations apply that will be governing the new XBL when the XB1 comes out. It would give me a chance to show people that controllers are not a handicap once you master their use in shooters.
 
Hey Vlad!

Nice to see you again, you mentioned that a few weeks ago and never provided additional information. Could you please provide some links where every PS3 game would work with Vita or that it was going to be a driving factor?

I know I remember seeing it being an option for developers but

It was optional. My point was simply that Sony began discussions about the possibility that wasnt realized until hopefully the PS4. But the overarching point is that the discussion was initiated by microsoft, which suggests that it will likely come to realization in the future as Remote play (hopefully) does. A major company like microsoft just acknowledging that it has entered their though process means its a fairly high priority or their PR wouldnt even mention it
 
Likewise I have a bunch of retard buddies who refuse to game on anything other than what they perceive as God's gaming device, the PC.

This would be pretty sweet so long as the same filters and regulations apply that will be governing the new XBL when the XB1 comes out. It would give me a chance to show people that controllers are not a handicap once you master their use in shooters.

No.
 
Why should PC gamers be handicapped just because MS is too stubborn to provide keyboard/mouse support on their consoles? If they limit cross platform play to gamepads only,it's a farce.
 
Why should PC gamers be handicapped just because MS is too stubborn to provide keyboard/mouse support on their consoles? If they limit cross platform play to gamepads only,it's a farce.

What does one have to do with the other??????
 
It would give me a chance to show people that controllers are not a handicap once you master their use in shooters.
One can perform maneuvers with a mouse that are simply impossible to achieve with a joypad or a pair of joypads. I like using a controller on a PC on occasion, but I don't delude myself into thinking that it affords the same level of speed or accuracy as a mouse. It's a simple technical infeasibility.
 
Take your hate to a different thread, face it, Microsoft continues to be one of the most if not the most software dominant companies on the planet. And it IS NOT because they have a near monopoly on windows. Its because Companies use their server and corporate level software because it is one of if not the best most stable platforms out there. Microsoft does a hell of a lot on the corporate scale than most windows realize and its because they are the best at it

It's not hate, it's an observation. They can't even release decent patches for their O/S anymore ... so put a sock in yours.
 
I don't see the problem for coop games, but most of the fun playing on a console is the level playing field and limited number of exploiters.
 
It's not hate, it's an observation. They can't even release decent patches for their O/S anymore ... so put a sock in yours.

Really? your telling me Microsoft didnt just release a win 7 patch to completely remove obsolete updates? The fact that your even stating this proves the fact that you dont have a clue when it comes to software
 
They can't even release decent patches for their O/S anymore ....

Personally I quite enjoyed having my PC continually reboot over and over and not being able to use any of my Office 2013 programs :p They've definitely had a couple of atypically bad months when it comes to updates, hopefully it'll clear up though.
 
On one hand, it would be good if the dirty console peasants were allowed to experience their fair share of humiliating losses while fighting members of the glorious PC gaming master race. That way at least some of time will apply and at try to be one of us.

One the other hand, however, I don't want to end up in a team with a bunch of clueless noobs. It's very hard to play with good players as it is. Unless you play some obscure goodness such as Quake :(
 
Back
Top