GoDaddy Pulls Lavabit's Security Creds

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
You remember Lavabit, right? It’s the secure email infamously used by Edward Snowden of NSA notoriety. It was shut down rather than turn over encryption keys to the FBI, but eventually lost the court case.

A court battle took place. Levison lost. In an epic trolling of the FBI, he handed over the keys but in the least convenient form possible: 11 pages of tiny font.
 
Some OCR and a few late nights for some interns with magnifying glasses and they won't notice.
 
This is actually really good for Levison. It proves without a doubt that the FBI did irreversible and unconstitutional harm to his business. He should thank them for making him very (soon to be) wealthy.

2016 ftw.
 
The FBI complained. Levison got hit with a $5,000/day contempt of court charge, and handed over the keys in digital form two days later after being charged $10,000. He also shuttered his site, making the keys useless for future communication interception.

FBI still had their way with him
 
It's ridiculous that a provider would be forced to do this kind of thing. It just shows how corrupted the US government is.

I think it's coming soon where the US is just going to make encryption illegal altogether. It's really sad how much the US is turning more and more into a dictatorship. They've essentially already made it illegal by forcing people to hand over keys.
 
It's been a long time since I've felt genuinely angry; even if it was for the briefest moment. These asshats in D.C... I'm trying to decide which terrible thing to wish upon them right now.
 
So the government doesn't like being coerced into typing something into a computer?
 
Well, your other option is just allow anyone to take data from others with impunity.

I think the uproar is because Snowden took US Gov't classified docs.

If he had been working for a bank, and released customer data, would you feel the same?

Or is stealing something that goes on a case-by-case basis?
 
It's ridiculous that a provider would be forced to do this kind of thing. It just shows how corrupted the US government is.

I'm not sure if enough people care enough to make changes come the next few elections. But, there is a good number of vocal people that are definitely not reelecting anyone. They are just flushing everyone out and starting new. Maybe things will change, maybe they won't.

Oops. Don't have the keys anymore. The HDD's crashed. Odd timing. Oh well....
 
ie - I think you are evil, hence I should be able to distribute your private data that I stole.
 
So, I can stop by a base and test out an M1 tank?

Or are some things owned by the government to be used only for specific purposes, not general consumption?
 
So, I can stop by a base and test out an M1 tank?

Or are some things owned by the government to be used only for specific purposes, not general consumption?

If the government were to start using those M1A1 tanks against US Citizens, you can bet your ass I would be stopping by a base and "borrowing" one.
 
This is actually really good for Levison. It proves without a doubt that the FBI did irreversible and unconstitutional harm to his business. He should thank them for making him very (soon to be) wealthy.

2016 ftw.

Unfortunately it's not likely to be seen that way by the courts. They will say Levison chose to shut down his business. It was his choice to not comply with the FBI/NSA, and the court obviously agrees with the FBI since it ordered Levison to turn over the keys, which he did.

Now, if he'd kept his business open and all his paying users had left because he put up a huge banner saying that he'd been forced to share his keys with the FBI...then he would probably have a case. But by shutting it down himself, he damaged his argument for tortious interference.
 
Well, your other option is just allow anyone to take data from others with impunity.

I think the uproar is because Snowden took US Gov't classified docs.

If he had been working for a bank, and released customer data, would you feel the same?

Or is stealing something that goes on a case-by-case basis?

If said bank was laundering money and doctoring the records to hide it then yes I woukd expect an employee who caught the bank doing so to come forward.

Not sure how you equate that to stealing.
 
If said bank was laundering money and doctoring the records to hide it then yes I woukd expect an employee who caught the bank doing so to come forward.

Not sure how you equate that to stealing.

Except money laundering is illegal.What is amazing is that what the NSA has been doing is not illegal.
 
I wonder if GoDaddy would be hit with something, since it could be seen as obstructing "justice" by shutting down a site used in an "investigation."

Good on GoDaddy though. Usually, all I hear about them is that they suck.
 
I'm not sure if enough people care enough to make changes come the next few elections. But, there is a good number of vocal people that are definitely not reelecting anyone. They are just flushing everyone out and starting new. Maybe things will change, maybe they won't.

Oops. Don't have the keys anymore. The HDD's crashed. Odd timing. Oh well....

Its the bullshit like this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Illinois_District_4_2004.png

THAT is why they get reelected no matter what they do.

Short of video on the internet and TV of a congressman raping kids they will get reelected no matter what they do. They've all handpicked their constituents.

Gerrymandering: The #1 problem with the US Federal Government.
 
Except money laundering is illegal.What is amazing is that what the NSA has been doing is not illegal.

According to the NSA. According to the Constitution of the United States, it's very illegal. And my country was founded on that Constitution, not their bullshit opinion.
 
Except money laundering is illegal.What is amazing is that what the NSA has been doing is not illegal.

Incorrect. The NSA has already stated they have violated their oversight numerous times. From spying on spouses and girlfriends to cyber-stalking to completely ignoring the secret courts decisions or bypassing them completely.
 
According to the NSA. According to the Constitution of the United States, it's very illegal. And my country was founded on that Constitution, not their bullshit opinion.

Where in the Constitution or the Bill of Rights (or any of the Amendments) is the word "privacy" ever used? Where does it say in the Constitution that domestic espionage is forbidden from the federal government? Where does the Constitution limit the federal government from reading other people's mail? Your country was indeed founded on the Constitution....you should study it sometime, because you are quite wrong.

I'm not saying what the NSA has been doing is ethically right nor am I saying it is good thing...I'm saying that it is not illegal based on the laws we have, and that includes the Constitution, the Declaration of Independence, and the Amendments.

Incorrect. The NSA has already stated they have violated their oversight numerous times. From spying on spouses and girlfriends to cyber-stalking to completely ignoring the secret courts decisions or bypassing them completely.

I was speaking WRT programs like PRISM generally.
 
If the government were to start using those M1A1 tanks against US Citizens, you can bet your ass I would be stopping by a base and "borrowing" one.

Sure you would.They don't just leave the key's to the tanks laying around. I spent enough time guarding the damn things.

Oh, btw, we shoot people that attempt to "borrow" tanks. just so you know.


Funny how no one complains when the FBI wiretaps or reads the emails of drug lords and terrorists, only when it's a cause they care about.
 
Sure you would.They don't just leave the key's to the tanks laying around. I spent enough time guarding the damn things.

Oh, btw, we shoot people that attempt to "borrow" tanks. just so you know.


Funny how no one complains when the FBI wiretaps or reads the emails of drug lords and terrorists, only when it's a cause they care about.
A cause we care about? You mean our freedom? The freedom that you're sworn to uphold?

If I rolled my eyes any harder, I'd go blind.
 
Where in the Constitution or the Bill of Rights (or any of the Amendments) is the word "privacy" ever used? Where does it say in the Constitution that domestic espionage is forbidden from the federal government? Where does the Constitution limit the federal government from reading other people's mail? Your country was indeed founded on the Constitution....you should study it sometime, because you are quite wrong.

I'm not saying what the NSA has been doing is ethically right nor am I saying it is good thing...I'm saying that it is not illegal based on the laws we have, and that includes the Constitution, the Declaration of Independence, and the Amendments.



I was speaking WRT programs like PRISM generally.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution
 
Sure you would.They don't just leave the key's to the tanks laying around. I spent enough time guarding the damn things.

Oh, btw, we shoot people that attempt to "borrow" tanks. just so you know.


Funny how no one complains when the FBI wiretaps or reads the emails of drug lords and terrorists, only when it's a cause they care about.
If that happened under the circumstance described, do you think the shooter could live the rest of their life on base because they could never leave. Even at that they'd have to sleep with one eye open.
 
Unfortunately it's not likely to be seen that way by the courts. They will say Levison chose to shut down his business. It was his choice to not comply with the FBI/NSA, and the court obviously agrees with the FBI since it ordered Levison to turn over the keys, which he did.

Now, if he'd kept his business open and all his paying users had left because he put up a huge banner saying that he'd been forced to share his keys with the FBI...then he would probably have a case. But by shutting it down himself, he damaged his argument for tortious interference.

Thought about this a bit. Due to the secrecy involved, I think it could be argued in favor of Levison. In this case, as soon as it was revealed that his SSL security was compromised, his credentials were pulled immediately. If he'd been allowed to discuss it and make it know that he was indeed forced to hand the information over, GoDaddy would have pulled it that day. Since he was under a gag order, he had no choice but to shut down. Otherwise, he'd have been civilly liable for the loss of security had he allowed those using his service to continue using it without knowing that said security had been compromised. Due to that civil liability, he had no other choice but to shut his doors, as the federal government had removed his ability to continue running his business without lying outright to his customers.

If he had told them that he was forced to give his SSL information to the FBI, he would have been held in contempt of court for breaking the Gag order.
 

Unreasonable Search and Seizure...

Both of you should read the link that one of you posted. Nowhere in the 4th Amendment is "Privacy" every mentioned. Like I just said, and you both apparently felt some need to argue with me by agreeing with me. Thank you for proving my point for me.

Further what the NSA is doing is not reading your papers, or breaking into your homes, nor are your effects getting disturbed. What the NSA is doing is not really at all different than what companies and corporations do every day on the internet of tracking users browsing histories. What the NSA is doing is in fact SO unreasonable that if it wasn't for cmployee/contractor-leakers like Snowden who is now permanently banished from returning to the USA, we never would have heard about it.

PRISM and all the rest of their normal programs are not illegal, like it or not. The courts say as much. You can claim otherwise, but you have precisely zero lawyers with any authority (and quite frankly a better knowledge of the law) agreeing with you regarding legality.
 

Indeed.
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
Seems pretty clear to me. It is written in English. I'm pretty sure there is no way to logically interpret that what the NSA is doing is legal.
 
To the government's eyes, the constitution is just a piece of paper, do you really think they care about following it? If anything they do is illegal, they'll just make it legal. Anything we do to get around it, they'll just make that illegal.
 
Indeed.

Seems pretty clear to me. It is written in English. I'm pretty sure there is no way to logically interpret that what the NSA is doing is legal.

It is pretty clear indeed. The 4th amendment in no way mentions communications digital or otherwise whether they are person-to-person direct or if they are conducted through 3rd and 4th party hardware/software. Especially where the 3rd and 4th parties are known to snoop your communications by themselves.

And the courts agree with me. So if you're "pretty sure" about your conclusion...well you should think it through again.
 
It is pretty clear indeed. The 4th amendment in no way mentions communications digital or otherwise whether they are person-to-person direct or if they are conducted through 3rd and 4th party hardware/software. Especially where the 3rd and 4th parties are known to snoop your communications by themselves.

And the courts agree with me. So if you're "pretty sure" about your conclusion...well you should think it through again.

For someone who is agreeing with a gov't that constantly say that laws should be adapted to the times, you aren't adapting it to the times. Gov't, either, for that matter.
 
Further what the NSA is doing is not reading your papers, or breaking into your homes, nor are your effects getting disturbed. What the NSA is doing is not really at all different than what companies and corporations do every day on the internet of tracking users browsing histories.
This is where we disagree. The NSA is in fact reading my papers (email meta-data and in some cases content), breaking into homes (computer viruses uploaded to computers using the TOR browser), and plainly distributing it between government agencies and other governments.

The difference between this and other companies doing the same is that when other companies do it, it's solicited (because we agree to the terms of service by using their services). When the NSA does this it is entirely unsolicited and up until recently, completely unknown to those who pay them to do what they're doing.
 
This is where we disagree. The NSA is in fact reading my papers (email meta-data and in some cases content), breaking into homes (computer viruses uploaded to computers using the TOR browser), and plainly distributing it between government agencies and other governments.

The difference between this and other companies doing the same is that when other companies do it, it's solicited (because we agree to the terms of service by using their services). When the NSA does this it is entirely unsolicited and up until recently, completely unknown to those who pay them to do what they're doing.
Exactly, thank you.
there is no comparison whatsoever, I pay for say cloud storage a contract between a private person and a private company.. comparison would be snail mail which has proper protections.. Electronic data should be ruled in the same manner, but its not, what is being done is the same as government opening everyones mail.
its wrong.. There is little real argument about it. The arguments in favor here cant fit inside my brain anymore, they seem so absurd to me.
 
It is pretty clear indeed. The 4th amendment in no way mentions communications digital or otherwise whether they are person-to-person direct or if they are conducted through 3rd and 4th party hardware/software. Especially where the 3rd and 4th parties are known to snoop your communications by themselves.

And the courts agree with me. So if you're "pretty sure" about your conclusion...well you should think it through again.

you should really think profundly about the absurdity you are saying.. The idea of interpreting the constitution is to keep its soul alive alive.. Its very clear what it says.. Govt is not to look into your business without reason, period. All the other convoluted shit you mention is that shit,.. Of course the courts agree and crap the push for planting the seeds of repressive goverment have been going for a long time, its not unprecedented for countries to do clearly wrong moves that are 'legal' .. And clearly we are not above moving towards crappy govt. As we see it in 'other' countries... Sure we can tell ourselfs oooh no we are soooo different, all the while goin down the same we point out as wrong in other countries
 
Back
Top