PC Shipments Down Again This Quarter

How does overall PC Shipments compare to individual component sales; excluding display and accessories? May or may not see a trend when the two are compared.
 
True though. My mom (70 years old, took every programming class the community college offered while being a stay at home mom in her 40s and 50s, so not an idiot with computers) got an Win8 laptop and basically told all her friends not to upgrade until something else comes. It really is having an effect

So then why did Mac sales decline even more this quarter? I'm not saying that Windows 8 is having no effect on new PCs but I think it's pretty minimal and that there are much bigger factors involved.

People have a really hard time with the way metro is not at all linked to desktop apps. My mom, for example, took screenshots of certain applications settings tabs so she could mimic them on her new laptop and opened the screenshot from a network drive to see it. Win8 opened it via a metro app and she couldn't overlay the settings window since it was a metro app. She could figure out how to get the metro app to the side, but then it shrunk the picture to about 1/16th normal size instead of moving it. Eventually I was able to talk her through how to get it to open in a window, and then she could layer things so she could see the old settings in the background with the new settings box on top.

This situation is much improved in 8.1 with modem apps having free horizontal sizing. Side-by-side apps even with the desktop work pretty well.

Word of mouth is keeping people from upgrading. Is it a significant amount in terms of the overall market? I have no idea, all I know is that I know a couple people who would have upgraded were it not for Win8.

We're not talking about upgrades here though but new hardware. PC hardware is making some nice advances in battery life, weight, baseline performance, screen resolution, etc. The OS has little to do with these things and while old PCs might be fast enough, that 4 and 5 year old laptop probably gets crap battery life now compared to new hardware.
 
4 and 5 year old laptop probably gets crap battery life now compared to new hardware.

Actually not to bad I get about 5 hours when using a new battery on my 2007 notebook still. I was going to replace it, but ultrabooks messed up the market.
 
Just in case it wasn't clear:

If you already don't need a gaming PC in your living room to play PC games in your living room, then that being a "major" feature of the Steam Box is pretty... well... "meh"
 
i blame windows 8 for the most part, besides all the user complaints, win8 was pushing more tablet/surface machines instead of desktop pc's.
As i remember, Vista with all its bad PR baggage caused a PC sales decline also.

also blame windows 8, windows 8 had very negative impact.

could have been fixed very easilly just by having choice.

let the user choose if he/she wants the new proven functional desktop and start menu and if they have a touchscreen let them choose the square metro window interface.
 
let the user choose if he/she wants the new proven functional desktop and start menu and if they have a touchscreen let them choose the square metro window interface.
It has been proven, time and time again, that giving normal users choices is a bad idea. They can't handle it.

If you set a default, almost ALL users stick with the default (making the option nearly pointless).
If you FORCE the user to make a decision, they complain heavily (UAC prompt as an example).

Users can barely handle picking between iPad versions as it is... seriously, I've watched an Apple Store employee try for over an hour to determine which iPad was the right choice for their customer. It's sad, but it's true.
 
According to IDC Apple had an 11% drop........must be Windows 8 related as well.

Apple declines are likely a combination of factors. They tend to release a new designs infrequently. We are at the end of that cycle. The other factor would be Apple PC users willingness to embrace other devices.(likely iOS devices) Tablets/smartphones can replace notebooks and desktops for minor communication tasks easily. Combine that with more home users likely sharing a personal computers while each having their own tablet/smartphone.

Data hints to me that Windows 8 is slowing sales and consumers are buying to replace hardware only when required. How much so depends on ones best guess as we have so many other factors. Data also shows that consumers are looking for solid value when buying computer hence the large uptick in Lenovo. The largest shock to me over the last year is how much Asus has fallen. Lenovo is just out performing them.
 
It has been proven, time and time again, that giving normal users choices is a bad idea. They can't handle it.

Users decided to upgrade to Windows(from dos) and purchased new hardware. People decided to upgrade tp windows 7 over XP. People who have used metro if given a positive reason to, but that was not the cause. They put the cart before the horse.

Make a useful tool and people will use it.
 
Data hints to me that Windows 8 is slowing sales and consumers are buying to replace hardware only when required.

But this would be the case regardless of Windows 8 because of the forces you noted, tablets and smartphones. There's simply a reduction in the demand for new PCs. A 20 UI year won't change that.
 
People decided to upgrade tp windows 7 over XP.
Uh... have you seen how many XP boxes are still out in the wild? That share isn't changing quickly at all...

My guess is that most people upgrading from XP these days are due to hardware failure, not due to specifically choosing Windows 7 or 8.
 
But this would be the case regardless of Windows 8 because of the forces you noted, tablets and smartphones. There's simply a reduction in the demand for new PCs. A 20 UI year won't change that.

It depends on how you translate the data as it is rough to simply compare it to every previous OS release and model it after the good and bad releases because you have such strong alternatives.(tablets phones)

You and I agree on most things so no reason to debate the matter. I think Microsoft is hamstring the market by making poor choices, you think it is going through a transition and having a rough spot. In the end we want the same thing. Better integration between Microsoft products and more of a focus on Consumer needs. The results is the same. Decline in PC sales which will not be fixed unless Microsoft and Intel focus on the end users.

This should eventually happen. To me it is just frustrating that they are making things take longer by their poor choices.
 
Uh... have you seen how many XP boxes are still out in the wild? That share isn't changing quickly at all...

My guess is that most people upgrading from XP these days are due to hardware failure, not due to specifically choosing Windows 7 or 8.

Talking about adoption rates during a similar period after release. The point was people will switch if you give them a reason ... people refuse to switch when they do not see a reason. They are busy doing other things. It would be very easy to get users to try metro without having forced the change. It would have cost Microsoft nothing and reduced the loss of Goodwill.

Forcing needless change on users is one way to lose their trust.
 
The point was people will switch if you give them a reason ...people refuse to switch when they do not see a reason.
Right... so how does giving users the option of making it exactly like Windows 7 give them a reason to upgrade?

"I guess it's fine because it's exactly like Windows 7"
"Wait... why would I upgrade if it's exactly the same?"
"This is a total rip off! It's the same as the last version!"
 
Right... so how does giving users the option of making it exactly like Windows 7 give them a reason to upgrade?

What they did right was increase performance and make the os a little leaner.
What they did wrong was force a UI change on desktop users versus giving them an incentive to switch UI.

Windows 8 would be a hit if they had not done the later. I would have added more incentive to the OS. I would have focused on the Windows Store. I would have made sure you could buy apps once and run them everywhere.(also tools to sell to developers for said purporse) I would have used metro as a way for users to access the windows store. SO you could buy apps and run them on your pc for example. This encourages adoption.... look at this fun game! It also increases backend revenue. It helps users learn how to use a windows tablet so when they are considering a tablet Microsoft has the inside track. I would have focused on improving media delivery. Metro is fine for a touch pc/htpc default, but there should still be an option to switch. Users will switch if they see the advantage, you just have to make them feel it is to their advantage.

Just interesting that after all the data since even before release we have been debating the same points. Even with all the data some just will not believe it was a costly blunder which really should not have been.
 
If you already don't need a gaming PC in your living room to play PC games in your living room, then that being a "major" feature of the Steam Box is pretty... well... "meh"
The ability to read books on an iPad is a major selling point of the iPad despite the fact that you don't need an iPad to read books.

Do you see where I'm going with this?
 
I would have made sure you could buy apps once and run them everywhere.(also tools to sell to developers for said purporse) I would have used metro as a way for users to access the windows store. SO you could buy apps and run them on your pc for example. This encourages adoption.... look at this fun game! It also increases backend revenue. It helps users learn how to use a windows tablet so when they are considering a tablet Microsoft has the inside track. I would have focused on improving media delivery.
This is exactly what Microsoft is angling to do, as far as I can tell...

The ability to read books on an iPad is a major selling point of the iPad despite the fact that you don't need an iPad to read books.

Do you see where I'm going with this?
I don't see how that's relevant, no...

The only way to read books on an iPad is to read books on an iPad.
The only way to play PC games on your livingroom TV is NOT the Steam box.
 
The results is the same. Decline in PC sales which will not be fixed unless Microsoft and Intel focus on the end users.

This should eventually happen. To me it is just frustrating that they are making things take longer by their poor choices.

I'm not saying that Microsoft has made mistakes with Windows 8 but there's simply less demand for new desktops and laptops, Microsoft's mistakes notwithstanding.
 
What they did right was increase performance and make the os a little leaner.
What they did wrong was force a UI change on desktop users versus giving them an incentive to switch UI.

The concept of incentive has been mentioned many times and is there under many circumstances. If you want a device that works as both a laptop and a tablet or if you want apps that you can buy once and run on many devices and even have those apps tracked in the cloud without having to find an install disk or executable. Even on a desktop with multiple monitors and desktop apps there are incentives to use Windows 8.1.
 
PC shipments being down means they did their job... at least computers are not turning into insect exoskeleton environments...

Where is the groundbreaking software that necessitates the hardware? What strange creatures grow from the potential of technology?

Looking at ourselves we might find problems in society. People are not as much a part of computers as the technology has potential for... but are people as much a part of people as people have to the potential to be?
 
It comes down to need and what you gain for the $$$ spent. I was talking to my dad the other day and he asked if I though he should get a new PC since his was "older". He has a Phenom II x4 940BE with 4 GB RAM and a 500 GB HD that I built him in early 2009. I told him if anything the only item I'd suggest is a SSD, everything else is still more than adequate for his email, mass session web browsing, online shopping, etc.

Ten years ago a 4 year old PC was ready to be retired, that's just not the case today. I can see him realistically getting another 3 years out of the PC, if not more.
 
Back
Top