ICANN Planning to Close Domain Database Open Access

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) regulators have proposed a change in how the system public information database can be accessed. The proposal would restrict access except by specific permission from ICANN.

Critics of the working group's proposal agree that the system is broken, but disagree with the recommendation that the openness of today be replaced with a system that is closed by default.
 
Now, you can't tell who's the government!

Love the comment about pirates loving this, as if this would impede on MPAA's or the RIAA's way into finding out something about a suspected pirate.
 
This would also eliminate domain squatters, correct? If a potential buyer can't communicate with a squatter, there's no reason to squat.

Nice....
 
People who use domain anonymizing services often don't realize that they are paying a third party to become the registrant-of-record for their domain. This means the purchaser (technically) doesn't own the domain. There are numerous legal ramifications from this, none in the customer's favor. And then there's the fact that the biggest anonymizing service (you figure it out) are a bunch of push-overs and hand customer data to practically anyone who sends a strongly-worded letter with no notice to the original registrant.

I personally would love to a) knock GoDaddy down a notch by removing their $5 add-on, and b) have domain anonymity be enabled by default and c) have an organization like ICANN set rules and standards for when and how domain information is released, and how the owner will be notified in such cases.
 
This would also eliminate domain squatters, correct? If a potential buyer can't communicate with a squatter, there's no reason to squat.

Nice....

A squatter could/would still opt-in to listing his squatted upon domain for sale on a domain auction/marketplace type site like sedo.com, so this proposed change really wouldn't have any impact on that sort of activity.
 
Of all of the stupid things that come from ICANN, this one takes the cake.

This is a spammer's wet dream.
 
Of all of the stupid things that come from ICANN, this one takes the cake.

This is a spammer's wet dream.

Spammers and other nefarious types just lie on their registration info anyhow don't they? The last dubious domain I remember looking up had an address in China that turned out to be an empty field in street-view.
 
People who use domain anonymizing services often don't realize that they are paying a third party to become the registrant-of-record for their domain. This means the purchaser (technically) doesn't own the domain. There are numerous legal ramifications from this, none in the customer's favor.

I bought my new domain from Gandi a few weeks ago because of this. They mask all of your personal information except your name, so you retain ownership as well as most of the privacy benefits.
 
Spammers and other nefarious types just lie on their registration info anyhow don't they? The last dubious domain I remember looking up had an address in China that turned out to be an empty field in street-view.

It is more about going after the computers that they have compromised to send spam.

If I can't get information to report abuse in the future, I will simply start nuking the IPs that send spam to my e-mail servers.
 
This would also eliminate domain squatters, correct? If a potential buyer can't communicate with a squatter, there's no reason to squat.

Nice....

You mean the squatter cant just post his email at the domain lol? This will do nothing to squatting. At worst they will create databases for their info.
 
Back
Top