Microsoft DMCA Takedown Requests Targeting OpenOffice

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Now what could possibly motivate Microsoft to request that Google to remove any reference to OpenOffice Suite? Just goes to prove that there’s always a little bit of rivalry in any Office. :D

Among the hundreds of thousands of sites Microsoft has recently asked Google not to index are requests to remove references to sites that in no way infringe Microsoft's rights but instead mention the free OpenOffice suite.
 
Bottom line Microsoft trying to bulk-erase anything with OFFICE in a torrent link
Honestly, with how much crap there is on torrent sites, that's actually a pretty decent way to go about it.

Just ask for everything with "office" in the name to be taken down, let the guys hosting the index deal with deciding what's legit and what's not. Takedown requests get ignored every day, so it's not like Microsoft putting extra effort into targeting their search term beyond "office" is worth their time.
 
They (Google and the feds) should start instituting a fine for false/illegitimate DMCA requests.
Something like they do for speeding fines. I.E.
$1 each for the first ten,
$5 each for the next 10
$100 each for the next ten,
Then $1000 for them after that....
With all the proceeds going to legal defense funds for victims of Copyright trolls.
 
Of course OpenOffice is still developed. LibreOffice forked in September 2010, latest OpenOffice release is from July 2013.

Oh, I read they recommend you stop using OO and move to Libre some time back. That is why I thought it is no longer in development. I have OO installed but an older portable version. Did dload Libre though.
 
Wow that is sad. Is there not some kind of anti competitive law that would stop this? Then again when you are a mega corporation you MAKE the law. We all know damn well they are hiding behind the piracy banner and it's quite obvious they don't want people to be able to download an open source alternative.
 
They (Google and the feds) should start instituting a fine for false/illegitimate DMCA requests.
Something like they do for speeding fines. I.E.
$1 each for the first ten,
$5 each for the next 10
$100 each for the next ten,
Then $1000 for them after that....
With all the proceeds going to legal defense funds for victims of Copyright trolls.

no no no no, that won't work.... 50%-100% goes to fund government projects and you got yourself a bill on the president's table ready to sign. :p
 
Microsoft's stuff is so top notched they're worried about a project that is essentially an open source hobby.
 
Oh, I read they recommend you stop using OO and move to Libre some time back. That is why I thought it is no longer in development. I have OO installed but an older portable version. Did dload Libre though.

Yeah I cant remember all of the details, but I believe Oracle cut funding and development for OpenOffice. So some of the developers created a community project fork called LibreOffice. A year later, Oracle gave OpenOffice to Apache because they were interested in continuing development on the original project.
 
I have the full Office 2013 suite and Libre Office. I actually like Libre more. I'd be worried if I was Microsoft too.
 
the funny thing is if you use bing to search for "office torrent" they are almost all for MS office lol
 
Wow that is sad. Is there not some kind of anti competitive law that would stop this? Then again when you are a mega corporation you MAKE the law. We all know damn well they are hiding behind the piracy banner and it's quite obvious they don't want people to be able to download an open source alternative.

Its not so much hiding behind piracy banner as it is abusing legal grey area. Because of the volume of DMCA takedowns sent by companies, they tend to use automated programs and scripts to deal with the volume. In turn, search engines like Google don't have enough manpower for oversight, there isn't a human checking every request, so naturally where there's margin for people to cheat so they cheat, then claim "oh sorry, processing error we use automated means and that was a mistake, sorry won't happen again" and its business as usual without a f*cking change.
 
The more I think, the less sense it makes.

I have to agree. Even if it was an Ironic comment (Which I presume it is) it still doesn't make sense. If it was not an ironic comment and actually sincere, I cant make sense of where it fits into the topic.:confused:
 
Honestly, with how much crap there is on torrent sites, that's actually a pretty decent way to go about it.

Just ask for everything with "office" in the name to be taken down, let the guys hosting the index deal with deciding what's legit and what's not. Takedown requests get ignored every day, so it's not like Microsoft putting extra effort into targeting their search term beyond "office" is worth their time.

Great, make them lose their safe harbor because you think it would be too inconvenient for Microsoft to actually have to do some due diligence before censoring the web.

How about no?
 
Its not so much hiding behind piracy banner as it is abusing legal grey area. Because of the volume of DMCA takedowns sent by companies, they tend to use automated programs and scripts to deal with the volume. In turn, search engines like Google don't have enough manpower for oversight, there isn't a human checking every request, so naturally where there's margin for people to cheat so they cheat, then claim "oh sorry, processing error we use automated means and that was a mistake, sorry won't happen again" and its business as usual without a f*cking change.

Yeah it's quite sad. If they want to fight for this anti piracy BS they should HAVE to do it manually. Need to work for your money. This goes for all anti piracy companies like the RIAA and MPAA. All these automated things need to stop, they should have to work for it.
 
I read the article, so pardon any on topic discussion below. ;)

The links MS asked to be removed were torrents to "open_office_2010 ... full", which if anything point to bad filtering for "Office 2010 full" type links. I'm not letting MS out of blame for this, but MS has said it will make sure the links are more accurate in the future. If MS wanted to target OOo, it likely wouldn't nibble at such insignificant sources of downloads. But hysterical panic is the usual on the internets so whatever.
 
The Bing reference (and I can't believe this needs to be explained) is because the OP said MS is targeting GOOGLE. So by using BING, you bypass the restriction that MS is attempting to create. Get it now?
 
The Bing reference (and I can't believe this needs to be explained) is because the OP said MS is targeting GOOGLE. So by using BING, you bypass the restriction that MS is attempting to create. Get it now?
Microsoft itself is reportedly the largest originator of takedown requests on Bing. Microsoft issues DMCA requests to both Google and Bing.
 
Back
Top