The Desktop PC Needs A Makeover

Get rid of 5.25" bays. Just get rid of 'em. Optical media is dead.

Don't tell the military cause they don't even allow flash drives except in the most special of exceptions. I would love to kick Bradly Manning in the balls for that one. Jerk !
 
Don't tell the military cause they don't even allow flash drives except in the most special of exceptions. I would love to kick Bradly Manning in the balls for that one. Jerk !

And that ban was lifted in 2010. Nice to stay current. Then again we have 2.5 pages of people shit talking a guy's BLOG post who has done more in/for the tech community than everyone else here combined (except for Steve, obviously).
 
If I ever rebuild my mediaPC I would definitely go mATX at this point.

That said......I have a butt load of movies on disc that need a drive.

and for gaming......sorry I happen to like my 800D and sometimes it looks too small.
But that's just me.;)
 
His idea is ok if you are a casual PC user but for a gamer you won't find a very powerful video card that will fit in a small case. When AMD 5870 came out I had to buy a new larger case so it would fit and the previous case was a mid-tower and not small.
The Fractal Design Node 304 is a Mini ITX case that can handle the GTX 780, GTX Titan, GTX 690, HD 7970, or HD 7990.

It can also take full-size ATX power supplies and has enough room for 6 hard disks and either a tower-style CPU heatsink or an integrated water cooling kit like the Corsair H90.

Very easy to put a Core i7, 16GB of RAM, and a GTX 690 in there... Mini-ITX SLI system :D
 
And that ban was lifted in 2010. Nice to stay current. Then again we have 2.5 pages of people shit talking a guy's BLOG post who has done more in/for the tech community than everyone else here combined (except for Steve, obviously).

the agency I work for still doesn't allow them.
 
And that ban was lifted in 2010. Nice to stay current. Then again we have 2.5 pages of people shit talking a guy's BLOG post who has done more in/for the tech community than everyone else here combined (except for Steve, obviously).

But I agree with your second statement.
 
And that ban was lifted in 2010. Nice to stay current. Then again we have 2.5 pages of people shit talking a guy's BLOG post who has done more in/for the tech community than everyone else here combined (except for Steve, obviously).

Well I don't really think it matters what he has done, his post was moronic.

If people want SFF PCs they are free to buy them, but rarely do. His post makes me think of someone who doesn't need a truck themselves complaining that some people choose to drive pickups or SUVs.
 
This is dumb, why wouldn't you want a blu-ray drive in your PC?
 
And that ban was lifted in 2010. Nice to stay current. Then again we have 2.5 pages of people shit talking a guy's BLOG post who has done more in/for the tech community than everyone else here combined (except for Steve, obviously).

Your blog post was OK, but it still wasn't very good. Why call for the industry to move to more SFF layouts when it already is? Case manufacturers and mobo manufacturers are doing more and more to accomodate exactly what the article is about. Sure, some unified cable layouts might be nice, but the post is still mostly fluff. It came across as more, "Look at me being relevant" than actually discussing an indepth ideas.
 
This is dumb, why wouldn't you want a blu-ray drive in your PC?

Some people can get away with ripping hundreds of discs and making a media library, but not everyone has time for it. Optical media is here to stay for the next several years.
 
This is dumb, why wouldn't you want a blu-ray drive in your PC?

Because the article author didn't think about all tangents of PC hardware before hammering out that drivel. ...or he has a stretched anus from Netflix and Hulu.
 
This is dumb, why wouldn't you want a blu-ray drive in your PC?
Optical media is pretty unpleasant compared to solid state media ,or even mechanical hard drives. The only reason Blu-ray drives offer any value at all is due to the relatively high cost of solid state storage and due to the fact that the infrastructure for digital distribution (including consumer broadband in the U.S. and many other countries) is still largely inadequate for delivering extremely high quality video content.

If these were solved problems, hardly anyone could keep a straight face when someone around them claimed to own an optical disc drive. We only accept the relative grotesqueness and ridiculousness of optical media because it fills a certain niche for consumers at the moment.
 
micro ATX should be the new standard. ATX could live on for high end enthusiasts.

I disagree about optical drives though. I think most people still want an optical drive.

I personally run a mini-ITX board, but with full size optical drive and full size ATX power supply and a Radeon 7870 Myst Edition.

Most users don't even need the kind of power I'm fitting onto a mini-ITX board and would be much happier with their PC taking up less room, so yes, I think micro ATX is more appropriate for the masses, which is what standards are for. And when going up or down in size from the micro ATX standard I think there are a greater number of people who would want mini-ITX than full ATX among the general populace.
 
The Fractal Design Node 304 is a Mini ITX case that can handle the GTX 780, GTX Titan, GTX 690, HD 7970, or HD 7990.

It can also take full-size ATX power supplies and has enough room for 6 hard disks and either a tower-style CPU heatsink or an integrated water cooling kit like the Corsair H90.

Very easy to put a Core i7, 16GB of RAM, and a GTX 690 in there... Mini-ITX SLI system :D

Looks good but no air vents on the top. I read an article on best case design for cooling and front intake with open vents/fan on the top for exhaust is best. My current case has top ventilation and in long gaming sessions I can feel heat venting out the top.
 
Totally agree. The PC is dying in the consumer space and it needs some major changes to stay relevant. It's not 1999 anymore.
 
The article was obviously troll bait to reel in site hits.

Fun how it not only reeled in everyone who was pissed at the drivel, but even some white knights of it, even here!
 
There's a mini ITX case that vents exclusively from the top (Silverstone FT03-Mini), but it isn't actually all that fantastic for cooling due to its relatively cramped quarters. It also doesn't support PCIe cards longer than 10", which means no 780/Titan and some AMD cards.
 
If these were solved problems, hardly anyone could keep a straight face when someone around them claimed to own an optical disc drive. We only accept the relative grotesqueness and ridiculousness of optical media because it fills a certain niche for consumers at the moment.

If optical media went the way of the dodo bird how would I be able to install my vast library of games/apps that are on optical media? Would I be expected to just suck it up and discard thousands of dollars in invested software?
 
There's a mini ITX case that vents exclusively from the top (Silverstone FT03-Mini), but it isn't actually all that fantastic for cooling due to its relatively cramped quarters. It also doesn't support PCIe cards longer than 10", which means no 780/Titan and some AMD cards.

OK, thanks. That Fractal Design case could be fixed with a drill.
 
Looks good but no air vents on the top. I read an article on best case design for cooling and front intake with open vents/fan on the top for exhaust is best. My current case has top ventilation and in long gaming sessions I can feel heat venting out the top.
I just ordered one to build a new micro-server in, so I'll have some first-hand experience with it.

Still... I don't think the Node 304 will have much of a problem with cooling. Dual 92mm intake fans + one 140mm exhaust fan at the rear basically make this thing a wind tunnel.

If you use a Corsair H90 to cool the processor, it'll bolt directly to the back of the case, sending all hot air outside immediately. If you pick a graphics card with a blower-style cooler it'll draw cool air from the side vent and blow hot air directly out the back of the case as well. The venting for the PSU means that it also blows all its exhaust heat right out the side of the case.

Basically... the only heat actually being radiated directly into the case itself is from drives and maybe a bit from the back of the graphics card.
 
If optical media went the way of the dodo bird how would I be able to install my vast library of games/apps that are on optical media?
How much space would all the data on your discs occupy on a hard disk? If you're dealing mainly with legacy stuff, then it's totally feasible that you could get away with having all of that data on a single relatively low capacity hard drive. Pulling data from discs into a disc images is certainly no big deal at all: you just need toe storage space for it.
 
PC's are like Linux in that we are free to roll our own. He can build a mATX box if he wants sans optical media.
 
Optical media is dead ? WOW ! then why do I need on average about 5 50gb blue-rays per month to store data on ? Sure as hell am not going to use some bs cloud service.
 
As a PC enthusiast I prefer having options and being able to build my version of the "dream machine" but the idea of standardizing connectors and integrating power delivery and I/O ports into the case makes a lot of sense to me.
The use of SFF in enthusiast components leaves a lot to be desired IMHO.
Here are my thoughts on changes to the existing form factors and standards that would have significant impact on SFF builds:
I would love to see a mobo that supports a way to mount a 2.5" drive to the bottom (solder side) so that there is no wiring to the drive. Another take on it would be to sacrifice a slot and have 2.5" drive mounts built into it.
Why are there no mini-ITX boards that use laptop-sized memory sticks?
What happened to he MXM video card form factor?
A mini-ITX board that combined both features would have room for a discrete video card and still have an available PCIe slot.
I guess what I am trying to say is that we already have small components that are designed for laptops with no performance penalty, why can't we use these on the desktop?

Regarding bottom mount 2.5" drives...they don't have those, but they do have mSATA ports. I have a 256 GB SSD plugged into the bottom of my mobo with no wires. The drive is about the size of a quarter. Slightly longer one direction.
 
His idea is ok if you are a casual PC user but for a gamer you won't find a very powerful video card that will fit in a small case. When AMD 5870 came out I had to buy a new larger case so it would fit and the previous case was a mid-tower and not small.

The Fractal Design Node 304 is a Mini ITX case that can handle the GTX 780, GTX Titan, GTX 690, HD 7970, or HD 7990.

It can also take full-size ATX power supplies and has enough room for 6 hard disks and either a tower-style CPU heatsink or an integrated water cooling kit like the Corsair H90.

Very easy to put a Core i7, 16GB of RAM, and a GTX 690 in there... Mini-ITX SLI system :D

I have a $40 uATX case that has space and slots for 2 Titans. As Unknown-One has pointed out, a smaller form factor does not have to be inhibiting and sometimes can be just as capable as its larger brethren, depending on the amount of hardware being crammed into a chassis.
 
I've had all my slots taken before. I have 2 x16 slots, 2 PCI, and 3 x8(?) slots.

The graphics cards take both x16s, and 2 x8s. This alone would max out a mATX motherboard.

Add to that a WiFi card (the last x8 slot) and the sound card (1 PCI slot), I'm left with one PCI slot remaining. I then put my LED controller down there.

Am I a fringe case? Sure. But I don't think I'm that unusual among enthusiasts. For me to get the same level of functionality out of a motherboard (integrating WiFi and sound), I'd be looking at a $200+ board. That's damn hard to justify when my motherboard, WiFi card, and sound card cost me all of $130.
 
If we're just talking about DVD movies here... once you rip them and compress to h.264, it's very easy to fit thousands onto a single 2TB drive.

depends on the quality -- a "good" 1080p rip is minimum 8GB all the way up to 15GB. Using an average sampling -- you could only get about 200-250 movies on a 2TB drive.

If you are encoding a 720P standard -- maybe around 500. Only way you are going to get thousands is if you go down to a iphone screen resolution standard.

I'm a bit of an HD media whore snob -- i feel dirty watching movies in standard resolution, 720p minimum for me, 1080p to be super happy. My 11TB worth of space is always evolving :)
 
IAdd to that a WiFi card (the last x8 slot)
Can get that built-in to the motherboard. Many smaller motherboards include a mini-PCIe slot pre-loaded with a wifi card that doesn't use up any of the regular expansion slots.

USB is also a highly popular option for WiFi adapters, since it lets you move a MASSIVE source of RF far away from your computer. It also allows you to keep the antennas closer to the actual transmitter (reduced pigtail length = less loss).

the sound card (1 PCI slot)
Again, quite possible to get decent built-in sound these days. USB is an option here too.

Am I a fringe case?
Yes. :p

Seriously though, as more stuff has been integrated into motherboards over the years, expansion slots have become less and less useful. Used to be you needed a parallel-port card for your printer, serial-controller for your mouse, video card for 2D, video card for 3D, sound card, network card, etc.

Now you'd get funny looks for using cards for most of that instead of the built-in motherboard variant.
 
depends on the quality -- a "good" 1080p rip is minimum 8GB all the way up to 15GB.
8.5GB is a good target to aim for. You can burn the resulting rip onto an AVC-HDDVD (basically burns a BluRay folder structure onto a regular dual-layer DVD)

Your standard set-top BluRay player will pick it up like any other BluRay and play it in all its 1080p glory :D
 
I think he has good points, but the overhaul should happen naturally, not be cause he said so.

5.25 bays are annoying and I wouldn't want them in a new case I buy

I'm targeting 450W - 500W for my next high end gaming build (haswell + 9970 + 2 SSD's + 2 WD Green drives)

I can live without an optical drive
 
Reading the comments to that article is hurting my brain because of one single commenter. That person "pardigmshift" really has a bug up his ass. He basically reeks of feeling personally offended that anyone dares oppose the thought of the article. And he's really offensive too. In normal discussion forums he would have been moderated out after his third or so comment.

Otherwise, The article as such isn't really wrong. Most PC's really isn't used like most users at [H] use it. For the most cases the PC could probably be reduced to an expendable little Raspberry pi type of deal. I think a lot of power-users forget that.

What makes the article silly is that the choice is already out there. If he insists on building his own, and still want a case with all the cables prefitted, then it is really already reduced to a Dell-by-IKEA. Like you order a prebuilt with options and have to put the options in yourself.
 
depends on the quality -- a "good" 1080p rip is minimum 8GB all the way up to 15GB. Using an average sampling -- you could only get about 200-250 movies on a 2TB drive.
He did specifically say "DVDs". A perceptually transparent DVD rip — and I hate putting any kind of average file size on these — can be had for less than a gig in some cases.
 
Seriously though, as more stuff has been integrated into motherboards over the years, expansion slots have become less and less useful. Used to be you needed a parallel-port card for your printer, serial-controller for your mouse, video card for 2D, video card for 3D, sound card, network card, etc.

Now you'd get funny looks for using cards for most of that instead of the built-in motherboard variant.

Like I said before, getting those motherboards takes far more money than just getting the equivalent add-in cards. And if I want to upgrade a specific portion, it doesn't take another $200 investment.

And I've had terrible experiences with USB WiFi. Dropped connections, even worse latency, and range so short I may as well run wire. I was getting 2/5 signal strength when the AP was like 20-30 feet away. While I could be convinced to use onboard or USB sound, I'm NEVER using USB WiFi again.

All this being said, I'm going to build a watercooled SFF PC as my next gaming build. It will just take an upgrade I feel is worth upgrading from my current build for. I'm perfectly content with my graphics card and processor for the time being; nothing's come out that's raised the bar so significantly that I feel dropping $900 is worth it.
 
I'd also like to point out that the vast majority of entry-level prebuilt machines are mid-tower sized and smaller. They already are the form factor the author is trying to move to.
 
Back
Top