Class Action Suit Filed Against Microsoft Over Surface RT

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Well, it's not like this class action lawsuit will come as a shock to anyone. The Surface RT has been a thorn in Microsoft's side since it launched.

The lawsuit claims that Microsoft failed to state how bad sales of the Surface RT have been and that the company's inventory of the tablet "experienced a material decline in value during the quarter ended March 31, 2013." The lawsuit also alleges that Microsoft's financial statements for that same quarter were "materially false and misleading" and violated both general accounting practices along with Microsoft's own "policy of accounting for inventories."
 
Yeah, wait until the lawsuit over their claims about how many Win8 licenses are being sold.
 
Yeah, wait until the lawsuit over their claims about how many Win8 licenses are being sold.

Not sold................activated. :p

Doubt there will be any fall out from 8 as it's not quite the same animal as RT was. And, it might not go anywhere if MS decides to defend and not settle. If it does succeed then I'd have to make one of the conditions that Ballmer resign. If they can prove it then it's flat-out misleading investors, and he should be immediately removed.
 
This is interesting. I would like to follow the fallout of this one. I hope groklaw.net follows this one.
 
I hate these kinds of lawsuits.... Sur/RT sales, inventory, and value is MS's business and nobody else's, imo.
 
I hate these kinds of lawsuits.... Sur/RT sales, inventory, and value is MS's business and nobody else's, imo.

I'd normally agree with you on this except it's a publicy traded company so folks throw money at them from their own pockets in stocks. Because of that, they need to be careful about misleading reports. I'm sure every public company fudges numbers. The question is how far can you fudge before you get caught?
 
So the lawsuit is about people thinking surface RT can run x86 software when it cant?
 
Well, it's not like this class action lawsuit will come as a shock to anyone. The Surface RT has been a thorn in Microsoft's side since it launched.

I've said it before, I'll say it again: if you buy a stock and intend to sell it in less than 3 years, you're not investing. The current price is higher than any time this year prior to May. If your investing window is 3 months, go to Vegas.
 
I've said it before, I'll say it again: if you buy a stock and intend to sell it in less than 3 years, you're not investing. The current price is higher than any time this year prior to May. If your investing window is 3 months, go to Vegas.

This has nothing to do with holding a stock long term or short. The lawsuit alleges ms financially mislead their investors. Personally Balmer needs to resign. The stock price has historically stagnated for years.
 
MS shipped 200,000 Windows RT tablets last quarter, according to IDC. The much more expensive Windows 8 tablets shipped 9x as many units. lol elasticity fail, or just a poor concept of a new product.

Related:
Microsoft's bet on touch PCs fails to pay off
Buyers reject touchscreen notebooks, spooked by higher prices and concerns about value of Windows 8's touch UI


Oh, snap CW went there!

"Frankly, the supply was too short," said Tami Reller, at the time the CFO of the Windows division, in January. "I mean, there was more demand than there was supply in the types of devices that our customers had the most demand for."

Microsoft's message was clear: If touch PCs had been more prevalent, Windows 8 would have gotten out of the gate faster. And once touch was more widely available, the new operating system would power a rebound in PC sales.

But half a year after Reller's finger-pointing and nine months after Windows 8's debut, most customers are taking a pass on touch, said O'Donnell.
​

tl;dr Users don't care about touch apps on Windows 8 (no surprise to anyone but you-know-who), and aren't willing to pay hefty price premiums for touch enabled models. ed (me): no duh on either one of those. A blind person could have seen that coming.
 
WTF why can you sue for that, and why would you? How is that affecting people that the product did not sell as well as MS thought it did?

If this is about stocks, then this is still stupid. By buying stocks you are risking that something out of your or the company's control occurs that makes those stocks go down. It's part of the game. Stocks are not GICs.

I'm usually a Microsoft hater, but this is just retarded. I hope they win.
 
shipped
sold
returned
kept but 'downgraded' to prior OS
kept & activated W's 8

Ballmer knows the numbers but is loathe to share
 
WTF why can you sue for that, and why would you? How is that affecting people that the product did not sell as well as MS thought it did?

If this is about stocks, then this is still stupid. By buying stocks you are risking that something out of your or the company's control occurs that makes those stocks go down. It's part of the game. Stocks are not GICs.

I'm usually a Microsoft hater, but this is just retarded. I hope they win.

The suit alleges that Microsoft broke not only their own accounting practices, but of those that they are obligated to follow as a publicly traded entity (GAAP). That's a very big deal if the accusations prove accurate. I'd never invest in a company that cooks its books to mislead both investors and the authorities. Such a company would be a very poor choice to invest in as the risk would go through the roof and the payoff through the floor.

It's one thing to invest and have a product fail to take off. That's a gamble that is standard to investments. But, to have the company cover up the failure, or to conjure up false numbers in an attempt to retain stock value through falsifying or at the least omitting records is outright fraud. That said, I'm not claiming Microsoft did this or did not, just that to claim that an investigation into such allegations is most assuredly warranted.
 
tl;dr Users don't care about touch apps on Windows 8 (no surprise to anyone but you-know-who), and aren't willing to pay hefty price premiums for touch enabled models. ed (me): no duh on either one of those. A blind person could have seen that coming.

One thing to keep in mind, many, if not most of the apps in Windows Store don't actually require touch. I've said this a million times, if Windows 8 is to succeed it's going to need well priced tablets and hybrids, touchscreen notebooks really don't factor into that much. That said, even this report estimates 12% of notebooks this year will ship with touch. While it would obviously be better for Microsoft and OEMs for that number to be higher, that's still over a tenth of the market that until last year you didn't have much in the way of a solution with Windows 7 to sell to. So 88% of the laptop market should be non-touch but 12% won't. So I don't know exactly what this report is trying to say. Sure, make Windows 8 more keyboard and mouse friendly which 8.1 does, but does it really make sense to just forget about that 12% that you just picked up this year?
 
WTF why can you sue for that, and why would you? How is that affecting people that the product did not sell as well as MS thought it did?

If this is about stocks, then this is still stupid. By buying stocks you are risking that something out of your or the company's control occurs that makes those stocks go down. It's part of the game. Stocks are not GICs.

I'm usually a Microsoft hater, but this is just retarded. I hope they win.

RTFA
 
Uh, its called shareholders.

Yeah, so? The stock market is nothing more than a casino. Fuck whiny shareholders that have an entitlement complex.

Now, if MS did in fact fail to follow proceedures, then that is another thing.
 
Yeah, so? The stock market is nothing more than a casino. Fuck whiny shareholders that have an entitlement complex.

Now, if MS did in fact fail to follow proceedures, then that is another thing.

The thing is, the stock market is only incidentally about buying, selling, trading, and making/losing money based on the market's valuation of a company. On a more fundamental level, it's about investing in a company to obtain ownership, so you can share in the company's profits through dividends. For this reason, if a company violates Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, it boils down to the management literally defrauding the owners.
 
I've said this a million times, if Windows 8 is to succeed it's going to need well priced tablets and hybrids, touchscreen notebooks really don't factor into that much.

You have hit upon the Achilles heel of Microsoft and tablets.

No one can make a cost competitive touch tablet for WIN8. The only way you can get a price competitive tablet out there, that runs WIN8, is to take a fairly massive loss on it. There is no price comparison, from a hardware point of view, in the cost for an Android vs a Windows tablet. Windows is a resource hog compared to Android, and the hardware needed to run it costs more. Hardware costs, battery life, weight, are all detriments to WIN tablets. Maybe Intel can pull a rabbit out of its ass and help, likely not though.
 
I was going to edit my post above regarding the original topic of this thread, but alas no edit.

Told you so. I said previously there were some shenanigans going on with Microsoft financials. What else will....surface?
 
This has nothing to do with holding a stock long term or short. The lawsuit alleges ms financially mislead their investors. Personally Balmer needs to resign. The stock price has historically stagnated for years.

perhaps, but their div has increased making it a great long term stock.
 
No one can make a cost competitive touch tablet for WIN8. The only way you can get a price competitive tablet out there, that runs WIN8, is to take a fairly massive loss on it. There is no price comparison, from a hardware point of view, in the cost for an Android vs a Windows tablet. Windows is a resource hog compared to Android, and the hardware needed to run it costs more. Hardware costs, battery life, weight, are all detriments to WIN tablets. Maybe Intel can pull a rabbit out of its ass and help, likely not though.

The hardware situation for Windows 8 should improve dramatically with Bay Trail at the low end. You need about 2GB of RAM and 32 GB of storage to run 8 well but that's in with Android except at the low end. The proposition is that for $50 to $100 more from the low one can get a Windows 8 tablet that can serve as work computer.

In time though hardware is going to get cheaper and people are going to want more powerful tablets anyway, so Windows as long at it can stay in the foot print it is at now and go down a bit should be able to fit on even the cheapest devices in the not to distant future anyway.
 
Back
Top