Rebuilding The Internet From Scratch

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Good luck trying to rebuild the internet from scratch. Having said that, I sure wouldn't mind an "us" and "theirs" internet where we could leave all the undesirables (spammers, scammers, the NSA, etc.) behind. :)

The internet is neither neutral nor private, in case you were in any doubt. The US National Security Agency can reportedly collect nearly everything a user does on the net, while internet service providers (ISPs) move traffic according to business agreements, rather than what is best for its customers. So some people have decided to take matters into their own hands, and are building their own net from scratch.
 

What's wrong with this? Do you honestly think that something like this won't be possible at some point in time? We already know the government has (very basic to public knowledge) way's to control weather (HAARP, etc).

On topic:

I'm down for this and it needs to happen if we want our information to be kept from prying eyes. Only issue with this is the massive scale that it would have to be done at. I think that if something like this started it would VERY quickly be stopped. Either by force or by "laws and regulations". So though this is a good idea in THEORY the actual DOING it part will be impossible.
 
I assume US can only collect data about a users in US or a foreign user goes to US website. I can't imagine a foreign government would allow US agency to do such thing.
 
I assume US can only collect data about a users in US or a foreign user goes to US website. I can't imagine a foreign government would allow US agency to do such thing.

Money and power bro. You bet your ass the US has access to out of country servers.
 
The NSA just taps into undersea phone and internet cables:

http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2013...-main-undersea-phone-and-internet-cables.html

Newly-Leaked NSA Slide Shows that NSA Is Tapping All Data from Main Undersea Phone and Internet Cables

Much of the information the agency once gleaned from the airwaves now travels in the form of light beams through fiber-optic cables crisscrossing continents and ocean floors. That shift has forced the NSA to seek new ways to gather intelligence–including tapping undersea cables, a technologically daunting, physically dangerous and potentially illegal task.

In the mid-1990s, the NSA installed one such tap, say former intelligence officials familiar with the covert project. Using a special spy submarine, they say, agency personnel descended hundreds of feet into one of the oceans and sliced into a fiber-optic cable.

------------------

The problem seems to be that no matter what gets built the NSA will find a way in.
 
So we don't have enough radio interference people want to have meshes of wifi networks creating even more :eek:

Also, given the anti-business tendencies of the people who would want to create these networks it would have virtually no high profile applications so you could IM, email, exchange torrents and play bootleg MMOs maybe ... I think they are better off fixing the existing internet or reducing a few of its flaws rather than turning over the internet to a crowd of paranoid neck beard types ;)
 
Agile crypto and privacy BUILT IN, explicit controls to opt out.
 
We need two things on a new Internet for it to be worthwhile: positive identification (no anonymity) and privacy (data collection) rules.

First off, we need the privacy/ data collection rules in place before it goes up. The government (without a warrant) and corporations (ever!) should not be allowed to track our movement on the internet. Without this, we're screwed from the get go.

Second, we need to remove the anonymity from the internet right from the start to stop the really harmful things people can do over the internet. Hacking, spamming, scamming, copyright violations, and spying need to be able to be tracked down when the government finds a violation, and not before. No "fishing expeditions" allowed, but we need to find and remove the evil people who are out to steal money and cause trouble. (I'm sure many hackers would consider themselves harmless, but I have yet to see a harmless hack. Even those who have no ill will intended have caused massive damage to companies, affecting people's ability to do their jobs. Also, people who go around copying movies and music are causing no end of pain to those of us who would like to pay for ours legitimately.) Above all, I want to be able to track down any bastard who makes a nearly unremovable fake anti-virus program so I can carve his heart out with a rusty spoon.
 
We need two things on a new Internet for it to be worthwhile: positive identification (no anonymity) and privacy (data collection) rules.

First off, we need the privacy/ data collection rules in place before it goes up. The government (without a warrant) and corporations (ever!) should not be allowed to track our movement on the internet. Without this, we're screwed from the get go.

Second, we need to remove the anonymity from the internet right from the start to stop the really harmful things people can do over the internet. Hacking, spamming, scamming, copyright violations, and spying need to be able to be tracked down when the government finds a violation, and not before. No "fishing expeditions" allowed, but we need to find and remove the evil people who are out to steal money and cause trouble. (I'm sure many hackers would consider themselves harmless, but I have yet to see a harmless hack. Even those who have no ill will intended have caused massive damage to companies, affecting people's ability to do their jobs. Also, people who go around copying movies and music are causing no end of pain to those of us who would like to pay for ours legitimately.) Above all, I want to be able to track down any bastard who makes a nearly unremovable fake anti-virus program so I can carve his heart out with a rusty spoon.

^This^

Privacy is important. However, you don't have the right to anonymously damage people's stuff or steal their data. What we have today is Anti-Privacy on the internet. Anyone can invade your privacy without repercussion. Companies can collect data on you without your knowledge. The Government can spy on you.

All because the internet is "anonymous". It's like wearing a mask and peaking in your window. That's not privacy. Privacy is only supported by removing the mask.
 
So we don't have enough radio interference people want to have meshes of wifi networks creating even more :eek:

Also, given the anti-business tendencies of the people who would want to create these networks it would have virtually no high profile applications so you could IM, email, exchange torrents and play bootleg MMOs maybe ... I think they are better off fixing the existing internet or reducing a few of its flaws rather than turning over the internet to a crowd of paranoid neck beard types ;)

There would only be two mechanisms that would trigger a rebuild of such a network as the internet: social revolution and business.

In a social revolution, there would likely be anti-business tendencies, and things might be as you say. I'm sure there would be ways to encapsulate any necessary mechanisms for higher level functions in low lever functions to get what we would need out of it, though. We could encapsulate VPN type data in IM format packets to get such a business function to work.

In a business push to build a new network, whatever the business wanted could be built into it. Even a "socially minded" business would be in it to make money. Let's face it, everyone needs to make a living, and all humans want more and are generally willing to work for it. The best and most successful businesses are the ones that enable others to do more. They smooth the road for others to do what they do. This also happens to be the most likely scenario of how it would happen in the US.

Sure, Russia or China, or even Iran or Syria or Egypt, could make their own internet with the social revolution type protections in it.

Your argument is a little lacking, as it wouldn't be the only way it could happen.
 
This has been true since the 1960's. It's not just the US doing it either.

Yeah, every time I hear an undersea cable has been accidentally "cut" by a ship's anchor or by activists, I wonder which government has just tapped into the line.
 
Good luck trying to rebuild the internet from scratch. Having said that, I sure wouldn't mind an "us" and "theirs" internet where we could leave all the undesirables (spammers, scammers, the NSA, etc.) behind. :)

That thought has crossed my mind for awhile now. I just want to connect with my friends and family at broadband speeds and leave everyone else out (invitation only to join my network). This has to be the evolution of the Internet.
 
I may not be as active in some respects as others on the internet. I play my games, stream some movies from Netflix, occasional catch some Youtube, and try and keep my inbox somewhat free of spam while occasionally I get some time to hit a few forums favoite to my interests.

A privately owned web mess of wireless, no thanx, ping time, streaming and downloading would suck. And how are you going to keep Flash up to date? Someone going to cross load and host the files? Legally right? So their sites aren't always being attacked, shut down, admins going to prison or getting fined?

BTW, all those private citizens who are now complicent in assisting in criminal activities, no fucking thank you morons. I am not going to be held responsible because I have volunteered the use of my equipment to any screwhead jerk that want's to commit a crime and their packets just happen to travel through my equipment.

All this concern over privacy. Like these guys said, the feds have had the capability to collect all overseas calls since the 60s and in fact any domestic call they wanted to as well. But that is capability which is not the same as authority. To have the authority they must go through proceedures, the proceedures have been approved, they are not illegal. When it comes to the NSA their targets are foreign persons or when approved, US Persons who apparently have done something and perhaps said things that make them appear to be a threat.

When the recent changes came following the Patriot Act the new laws allowing greater flexability in domestic collection and monitoring were done becuase it was too difficult to do under the previous rules, they weren't flexible enough nor did they take into acount the actualy phsical nature of modern communications. The rules needed an update.

At least one of those rules was found to be too lax and had actually led to the abuse of several peoples rights, the courts ruled and tightened those rules up to prevent future occurances of those abuses.

I have a question for you, since Snowden's release of information, his revelations, anyone made a true and specific complaint of abuse? Is there even one case where someone can actually say "My rights to privacy were violated" and they actually have a case? Proof, evidence, snything at all beyond a general complaint that what is going on is wrong?

Cite one if you have it, I don't recall anything specific or individual in nature.
 
And BTW, just for your info, a US Person is not by definition a US Citizen. Even foreign nationals who are not US Citizens may be considered US Persons and be avorded those protects if the qualify. Let's say a Doctor from India working in the US for a US Company, or even a native Frenchman working for Amazon.Com in France would still gain US Persons Protection.

But the average Joe from any other country that we have not made special agreements with, all bets are off and we can and will collect anything and everything we think is of use on anyone we thing has something worth knowing.
 
Back
Top