Internet Whining Didn't Force Microsoft's Hand

Even so, he represents "a regular guy" asking unscripted questions, and the video shows the absolutely typical marketer response of a company like MS. As awkward as it was, you got to see all of Joe's body language as he gets shutdown by Nelson's handlers; you get to Nelson trying to steer around questions with hilarious crap like "But, It's the future!"; you get to see Joe begging "please don't blacklist me".

That video should be renamed "the state of gaming journalism" or "why every major website rates games 9/10 regardless of quality".

That's a good point.
 
But that was always an option for them. If you really think about it, if the "always online" 24hr check-in was *that* important to overall functionality of the system, it would be hard coded into so much of the software that Microsoft would have had to basically redesign the majority of the system to get rid of it.

So I stand by my belief that both Sony and Microsoft always planned to go full DRM, but also had backup plans in place... so in the end, the internet outrage and gamers speaking with their pre-orders DID ultimately force Microsoft's hand...

Exactly!! Remember that bit of the Angry Joe interview where the MSFT PR guy was like "ARE YOU A DEVELOPER!? THEN YOU DON"T KNOW HOW HARD IT IS"
 
When is MS going to drop their price by $100? Then we have a race...

The price is higher cause the xbox1 is more than a game console, you're paying for all the TV stuff it can do. Least thats my guess.
 
Even so, he represents "a regular guy" asking unscripted questions, and the video shows the absolutely typical marketer response of a company like MS. As awkward as it was, you got to see all of Joe's body language as he gets shutdown by Nelson's handlers; you get to Nelson trying to steer around questions with hilarious crap like "But, It's the future!"; you get to see Joe begging "please don't blacklist me".

That video should be renamed "the state of gaming journalism" or "why every major website rates games 9/10 regardless of quality".

Yes, I'd rather listen to Joe than Nelson.
 
I think that Microsoft will phase in the digital download the generation so the next one is fully digital. It was just too soon right now. Give the digital copy a $10 price break, and people will start moving over. If they can play it right, they can move the majority of their customers to the digital model and it won't be so extreme next generation. The way it is now is too much, too soon, and too restrictive (or at least it sounded that way, as so many didn't have the answers. It was always 'the future!').
.

I've seen quite a few people coming out with this kind of statement lately. Have you never owned an xbox360 or PS3?

As far as I'm aware you can already buy and download digital versions of games straight from the marketplace so what on earth are you referring to when you say they will phase in digital downloads later on? :confused:
 
I've seen quite a few people coming out with this kind of statement lately. Have you never owned an xbox360 or PS3?

As far as I'm aware you can already buy and download digital versions of games straight from the marketplace so what on earth are you referring to when you say they will phase in digital downloads later on? :confused:

As he stated...fully digital. Meaning no physical media copies of games available in any store ever again.
 
I am yet to read anything this guy said and agree with it. 15 yeas and counting...
 
The answer to 99 out of 100 questions in business in MONEY. Microsoft saw the money going to Sony, so they changed their tune. END OF STORY.

"Internet whiners" are the customers.

They gave their money to Sony. M$ doesn't operate in a vacuum like it wishes it still did.
 
M$ doesn't operate in a vacuum like it wishes it still did.

Microsoft has never operated in a vacuum in the console business. It was late to party as usual in a very competitive market when it got into gaming consoles.
 
Cliffy B is such an idiot now. He's probably the worst Xbox/Microsoft fanboy alive.

I wish that idiot would just give someone worthy the Unreal IP and let someone else who cares about who got them where they are now, continue to make great games for that same group of people.

Yes I said give, they don't deserve to make a single dime off it.
 
I've seen quite a few people coming out with this kind of statement lately. Have you never owned an xbox360 or PS3?

As far as I'm aware you can already buy and download digital versions of games straight from the marketplace so what on earth are you referring to when you say they will phase in digital downloads later on? :confused:

I own both, as well as a 3DS. I've done a few digital downloads, but they were also available as physical versions. If they were to start bringing in digital download only games, it would kind of 'prime' the market and set a transitional period. It would be phase out the used game market. It would be slow instead of the fast transition that MS had wanted. The goal would be the same, it would just be obtained slower. The whole frog and boiling water thing.
 
Cliff B is not important to the industry any more. He is at the moment unemployed and searching attention from MS so they can give him a job - with several ridiculous posts from him latelly he reminds me the Donkey from Shrek - "I'm here!, I'm here!".
IMO what caused MS to drop previous DRM was pre-order values - money is what any company needs / wants. There is a negative side to Sony - at this moment will earn less money than before (xbone more competitive) even if has the technologically and price advantage.
 
The price is higher cause the xbox1 is more than a game console, you're paying for all the TV stuff it can do. Least thats my guess.

Hence why consumers will go with PS4. It's a game console, and paying $100 extra for non gaming functionality makes no sense. It makes sense to add features like DVD Blu-Ray playback and YouTube Netflix functionality, cause it's just software. Adding a TV tuner to a game console costs much more.

Not to forget that Microsoft was planning to store your games on a 500GB hard drive. Add the DVR functionality and that drive will quickly shrink in size. Without anyway to replace the internal drive, you'll be stuck with limited space.

If Microsoft wanted to be different then Sony, they have Windows for fuck sakes. They could make Xbox One games compatible with Windows PC's. God forbid since it's an x86 machine now.
 
Hence why consumers will go with PS4. It's a game console, and paying $100 extra for non gaming functionality makes no sense. It makes sense to add features like DVD Blu-Ray playback and YouTube Netflix functionality, cause it's just software. Adding a TV tuner to a game console costs much more.

Not to forget that Microsoft was planning to store your games on a 500GB hard drive. Add the DVR functionality and that drive will quickly shrink in size. Without anyway to replace the internal drive, you'll be stuck with limited space.

If Microsoft wanted to be different then Sony, they have Windows for fuck sakes. They could make Xbox One games compatible with Windows PC's. God forbid since it's an x86 machine now.

They won't make them compatible, the whole point of a console is that it's one piece of hardware to develop for. With PCs, it's many pieces. They'd receive too many support calls for Xbox games not playing correctly on the PC.
 
As he stated...fully digital. Meaning no physical media copies of games available in any store ever again.

There ARE fully digital games available on both consoles. Sony calls them PSN Exclusives. I'm not sure if MS has as specific term though...
 
I'm sure that Microsoft and Sony must have made an agreement that they'll both impose these DRM restrictions on their consoles. Sony let Microsoft announce it first, and then did a 180 and claimed to not have any DRM on their machine. Don't think the game publishers had nothing to do with it as well.
I was just going to say he same thing but seen your post, I agree with you. Sony seen the backlash MS was getting and decided to change their mind and use it against MS, even though they most likely agreed with it initially.
 
Okay so yea--this is funny as shit:

MSFT rep: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RtSGFryKwo#t=11m30s

@ 11:30

Then MSFT blog today:

An internet connection will not be required to play offline Xbox One games – After a one-time system set-up with a new Xbox One, you can play any disc based game without ever connecting online again. There is no 24 hour connection requirement and you can take your Xbox One anywhere you want and play your games, just like on Xbox 360.

Man they're so full of shit.
 
The price is higher cause the xbox1 is more than a game console, you're paying for all the TV stuff it can do. Least thats my guess.

You have to explain things through hardware, no one ever says console X has great software so its worth $100 more. The Kinect is the reason for the price difference if it is explainable.


Hence why consumers will go with PS4. It's a game console, and paying $100 extra for non gaming functionality makes no sense. It makes sense to add features like DVD Blu-Ray playback and YouTube Netflix functionality, cause it's just software. Adding a TV tuner to a game console costs much more.

Not to forget that Microsoft was planning to store your games on a 500GB hard drive. Add the DVR functionality and that drive will quickly shrink in size. Without anyway to replace the internal drive, you'll be stuck with limited space.

If Microsoft wanted to be different then Sony, they have Windows for fuck sakes. They could make Xbox One games compatible with Windows PC's. God forbid since it's an x86 machine now.

Kinect is exactly $100 more than an XBOX 360, and 24 million of them were sold with 75 million in xbox sales, that's over 1/3 of the market for an item that came years late. I don't think it was much of a stretch at all to try to push it to all users.
 
Kinect is exactly $100 more than an XBOX 360, and 24 million of them were sold with 75 million in xbox sales, that's over 1/3 of the market for an item that came years late. I don't think it was much of a stretch at all to try to push it to all users.

Yea, but that makes it $100 more than the competition. But, it comes with a Kinect? That's fine, but I don't use the Kinect, nor do I want it. It's like including a VCR with your TV and charging more.... I don't want a VCR, can't I just buy it without? Nope. Package deal.

I'm comparing the two with the Kinect out of the picture. Do they compete well that way? Is there a $100 difference? Not sure yet. I need to see more games before I decide.
 
Kinect came with my sons 360. We hate it. Unless it gets massively better, then it is junk. Slow, inaccurate, and more of a pain in the ass than a benefit. Nothing like having to scream at your Xbox multiple times to get it to recognize the command. It's like yelling at your smartphone.
 
There ARE fully digital games available on both consoles. Sony calls them PSN Exclusives. I'm not sure if MS has as specific term though...

Fully digital console...meaning the owner will have no choice other than downloading any and all games. Further meaning that no more games can be purchased in a brick and mortar store, ever. You shop for any game title from your couch, because the virtual store is the only place to buy them from.
 
Kinect came with my sons 360. We hate it. Unless it gets massively better, then it is junk. Slow, inaccurate, and more of a pain in the ass than a benefit. Nothing like having to scream at your Xbox multiple times to get it to recognize the command. It's like yelling at your smartphone.

This has been my experience with it.

Not to mention the games are all gimmicky and have the worst latency imaginable... it's like you're playing on servers located in NZ
 
Yea, but that makes it $100 more than the competition. But, it comes with a Kinect? That's fine, but I don't use the Kinect, nor do I want it. It's like including a VCR with your TV and charging more.... I don't want a VCR, can't I just buy it without? Nope. Package deal.

I'm comparing the two with the Kinect out of the picture. Do they compete well that way? Is there a $100 difference? Not sure yet. I need to see more games before I decide.

You are discounting all the advantages of shipping with it. Its expected to get much better and have better support if everyone has one. Second actually your TV is loaded with shit many people never use or don't need like 80% of the ports on the back, the speakers that no one should ever use, smart functions etc... On my TV there are exactly 2 wires, the power and a single HDMI cable.

If you take the Kinect out of the picture MS can't win this one because the PS4 has better core hardware, the only wild card is exclusive games. So IMO they have to play off Kinect. And they should because the features of Kinect are going to become an important part of computing interfaces.
 
In the Titanic captain's defense, the iceberg wasn't there, then it was there. No amount of wisdom would have saved the ship. Nobody saw it until inches from collision.

The iceberg was there the entire time. The captain was full steam ahead despite warnings of other ships; and his crew didn't have the right equipment to spot it in time.

In the Microsoft equivalent the head of Xbox development was pressing ahead with Microsoft's plans for DRM and cloud only despite what his industry peers (Nintendo and Sony) were doing. His Crew (public relations and game insiders) weren't listening to what the public was saying. Effectively not seeing the uproar until the last moment. It was too late to port around the iceberg of public outcry.
 
You are discounting all the advantages of shipping with it. Its expected to get much better and have better support if everyone has one. Second actually your TV is loaded with shit many people never use or don't need like 80% of the ports on the back, the speakers that no one should ever use, smart functions etc... On my TV there are exactly 2 wires, the power and a single HDMI cable.

If you take the Kinect out of the picture MS can't win this one because the PS4 has better core hardware, the only wild card is exclusive games. So IMO they have to play off Kinect. And they should because the features of Kinect are going to become an important part of computing interfaces.

As of right now - I have zero interest in the new Kinect, regardless of how much better it is technically. If they were to announce some really kick ass games for it that really utilize it, sure, I'll definitely look into it. But, as a selling point right now, nope.

My TV has power and HDMI. That's it. It can do Netflix, Hulu and stuff, but I don't use those, so they were not a deciding factor in the purchase.

The PS4 is a better console with specs in mind. So, am I paying $100 for an inferior product? I don't know. If I want to play Halo (I don't, I don't care for the Halo series), and I buy a PS4 - It's definitely NOT worth it. So, it comes down to the games and if they are worth the extra $100 investment to play those exclusive games.

Now that Microsoft turned around on that, I am having a difficult decision deciding, which is good. It's back to the games and not on the policies. Xbox does have a lot of other features. We'll definitely see more as they get closer to release, and it's becoming an exciting battle so far, even before they are released. I do know I'll eventually own both consoles, but I'll wait until the other one goes down to $200-$250 to buy, which may be a few years. Just need to decide which is first! :) Before it was 99% PS4. Now, it's more around 50/50. I just don't know. They are both amazing machines with a good initial game lineup.
 
Come on guys the hardware does not matter, Wii hardware , they ruled.

Cliff BleszinskiVerified account
@therealcliffyb

*Sony* forced Microsoft's hand, not the internet whining.

Yeah Sony are such an influential and inspiring company which can dictate to MS their "vision for the future" (yes I got to admit that this future really is something I would rather not encounter not even in a parallel universe) and just bail on it.

There are prolly a few bean counters at MS which were screaming murder after E3 because of the sad situation of reporting on their policies instead of the games.

So what did Sony do , nothing they let MS bungle their half wit policies and just ended up ROFLMAO they prolly still are doing this at Sony.

Now did the Sony stampede of ROFLMAO cause this, no , Sony are just happy people at the moment.

What more then likely happened is that the hollow policies which were bound to not work anyway "Always on" was more of a headache then something which would work smoothly. The family plan was nothing more then 10 people might be able to play a demo. And DRM which is something Ubisoft failed badly at so MS could proof itself at the cost of the consumer, good idea to introduce that at the beginning of a new start.

And Sony being Sony of course allows DRM on their console and so on, they really don't give anything about their customers anyway.
 
They won't make them compatible, the whole point of a console is that it's one piece of hardware to develop for. With PCs, it's many pieces. They'd receive too many support calls for Xbox games not playing correctly on the PC.
There's a very high likelihood that those games will be on PC anyway. Very few games never make it to PC that make it to Xbox 360. At least by allowing Xbox One games to run on a Windows PC, would actually reduce development costs. Microsoft could create a test program to check your PC specs, and if it doesn't pass then you can't play Xbox One games. You know like Windows Experience Index, except with a meaningful value.

Mind you not that I would want game developers to produce games like this. Though I would hope that if Microsoft did allow Xbox One games to work on PC, that hopefully developers would have control as to how that game would install and function on a PC. I would still rather have developers port games to Linux.
 
You have to explain things through hardware, no one ever says console X has great software so its worth $100 more. The Kinect is the reason for the price difference if it is explainable.

That part of your post doesn't make sense. Even if this camera tech costs $100 more, PS4 still has considerably better hardware. Why do you ignore that in your calculation?
 
Internet whining didn't force their hand, durr, of course. However internet whining played a part in spreading the word which led to reduced money, and internet whining gave MS a clue as to which direction their hand should be forced in.

The money is what forced them to change not the internet whining... but the internet whining and the money are linked and the changes MS made and the internet whining are linked.
 
That part of your post doesn't make sense. Even if this camera tech costs $100 more, PS4 still has considerably better hardware. Why do you ignore that in your calculation?

The hardware is not that much better. It has more memory because it has to have more to deal with the latency GDDR5 has. To shorten it up, the 4 is going to be CPU bound, and the One GPU bound, which is going to end up with similar results. Almost no one mentions the latency and gets caught up in specs, or get caught up in other marketing, like the AMD video which is specifically talking about GDDR5 is better for video, not general performance.

Any decent programmer should be able to get similar performance out of both. The people expecting it to be mostly one sided like it was this generation is going to be disappointed, But then again, most of the people got the reasons why wrong there too, so no wonder they all thing the PS4 is 'drastically better'
 
Cliffy B is a moron. Sony forced Microsoft's hand because they chose to respond to "internet whining" by giving customers what they wanted and making a public show out of it, playing the PR to their advantage. If there was no internet whining, Sony would have probably done the same crap to the PS4 that Microsoft wanted to do to the xbone.

bingo. this guy gets it. there is an interconnectedness between consumer feedback.. microsofts initial annoumcement and sony seizing an opportumity like a hundred dollar on the sidewalk

and if 'internet whining' had not been a fact there would be no need for him to snark against it. obviously it was a factor or why brimg it up
 
The hardware is not that much better. It has more memory because it has to have more to deal with the latency GDDR5 has. To shorten it up, the 4 is going to be CPU bound, and the One GPU bound, which is going to end up with similar results. Almost no one mentions the latency and gets caught up in specs, or get caught up in other marketing, like the AMD video which is specifically talking about GDDR5 is better for video, not general performance.

Any decent programmer should be able to get similar performance out of both. The people expecting it to be mostly one sided like it was this generation is going to be disappointed, But then again, most of the people got the reasons why wrong there too, so no wonder they all thing the PS4 is 'drastically better'

I hope you're not putting words in my mouth. I didn't say of the things you accused people of saying. I don't play on consoles, and I am not a fan of either company or product. They both suck.

Generally I agree with pretty much everything except one thing - these days games are GPU bound, and almost never starve for more CPU cycles. PS4 is better equipped for the current reality, even though GDDR5 has much higher latency. Memory is unified which mitigates the effect and you know it.
 
CliffyB is the head up Totalbuscuit's ass.
Anytime either of them say anything it starts to stink round here...
 
The lack of pre-orders force Microsoft's hand.

That would be my guess. In the Amazon survey, it was 18 to 1 in favor of the PS4. If the sales difference was even half of that, it would explain Microsoft's quick reversal in policy. I think that's a better explanation than MS was listening to their fans. If they were ever listening to their fans they wouldn't have planned all that DRM in the first place.
 
You are discounting all the advantages of shipping with it. Its expected to get much better and have better support if everyone has one. Second actually your TV is loaded with shit many people never use or don't need like 80% of the ports on the back, the speakers that no one should ever use, smart functions etc... On my TV there are exactly 2 wires, the power and a single HDMI cable.

If you take the Kinect out of the picture MS can't win this one because the PS4 has better core hardware, the only wild card is exclusive games. So IMO they have to play off Kinect. And they should because the features of Kinect are going to become an important part of computing interfaces.


There are zero advantages to forcing kinect. At best it is a novelty that only supports shit games and only found real value on the PC. At worst it is still an unfathomable piece of spyware that anyone would have to be crazy to want to allow.

Back OT.

Yea, sorry but internet "whining" did indeed force MS to change their stance. Now we just need to keep up the furor and force them to lose the mandatory kinect bs.
 
Back
Top