Haswell: adaptive voltage and OS processor power management

PHeeNIxx

n00b
Joined
Oct 19, 2004
Messages
52
I spent some time playing around with overclocking my i5-4670k and found what feels like a stable number (4.4 @ 1.235V manual override voltage).

I then read about Haswell's adaptive voltage settings and enabled adaptive voltage with a 1.235V cap.

Once I've achieved a stable overclock, is there any 'performance' reason not to enable the OS power management that allows the CPU multiplier (and with adaptive voltage enabled, the CPU voltage) to be dropped when the CPU is not under load?

Just as a note, because it wasn't 100% clear to me during testing, you must enable the OS CPU power management in order to see the benefits of adaptive voltage. If the CPU stays clocked at maximum it will always draw the voltage set by the adaptive voltage cap (in my case 1.235V) - at least in my experience ... is that consistent with what other people are seeing?
 
no, not reason to not enable OS power management.. in fact... not matter if you use haswell or not.. at least with my sandy bridge i7 2600 when I use "balanced" profile under energy options in the OS, it auto control the CPU multiplier and Voltage, so while on idle or low power it remains on 1600mhz, passing for 1800, 2000, 2400, 2800, 3000, 3400, 3800, 4200mhz.. depending on the needs.. also when idling or low requirement apps it downvolt to 0.912v and go throught all the way up to 1.208 which its the max voltage I reach under full load using auto voltage on bios and offset - 0.060v... and all the system work perfectly this way while playing games or any other thing....
 
I spent some time playing around with overclocking my i5-4670k and found what feels like a stable number (4.4 @ 1.235V manual override voltage).

I then read about Haswell's adaptive voltage settings and enabled adaptive voltage with a 1.235V cap.

which motherboard do you have? i have the same cpu on an asus z87-plus motherboard, and the default 'auto' voltage setting is actually adaptive/1.250v. it doesn't tell you in the bios, but it does in the ai suite iii software. and under prime95 stress testing, the actual voltage ends up at around 1.3v, i.e. .05v above the specified adaptive voltage.

with the default voltage settings, i also ended up at 4.4. 4.5 would throttle in prime95. i'm sure better cooling would take care of that (currently using hyper 212 evo). 4.4 is stable for me at adaptive/1.225 (lower than default).

Just as a note, because it wasn't 100% clear to me during testing, you must enable the OS CPU power management in order to see the benefits of adaptive voltage. If the CPU stays clocked at maximum it will always draw the voltage set by the adaptive voltage cap (in my case 1.235V) - at least in my experience ... is that consistent with what other people are seeing?

i've found that it depends on which power plan you set and what settings the min/max processor states are set to.

by default, the 'high performance' power plan has 100%/100% min/max processor states. this locks the cpu in turbo mode - maximum speed and specified adaptive voltage. lowering the minimum processor state allows the multiplier to drop, but voltage stays locked. lowering the maximum, even by 1%, disables turbo completely (both multiplier and adaptive voltage).

the 'balanced' power plan by default is 5%/100%. this allows the full range of dynamic multiplier and voltage adjustment. setting it to 100/100 sets the minimum frequency to the cpu's nominal frequency (in our case, 3.4) and the voltage to whatever the cpu demands. the cpu can still turbo up. but as with 'high performance', lowering the max processor state from 100% disables turbo.

tl;dr - just leave it on 'balanced', and if you don't like the cpu clocking down to 800mhz for whatever reason, you can change that default 5% minimum processor state to a higher number for a faster minimum processor speed.
 
Last edited:
I too am using a hyper 212 evo CPU cooler. My motherboard is an ASRock Z87M Extreme 4.
 
Can you stress the CPU using AIDA64 when adaptive voltage is set? Wasn't sure if that is how you find where its peaking. I was reading to be careful stressing with adaptive voltage turned on.
 
Ok, should the peak be any higher than what was found to be stable?

I found that 1.205 gave me 1.296V when stressing and 1.200 gave me 1.291V when stressing. So now should I drop the voltage more until I get closer to 1.255 when stressing?

I found 1.190 gives me 2.81V..... I also figured 1.175 would be close to giving me the correct (stressed) voltage but I got blue screens in the OS... probably to low in certain places?


Double Edit: 1.200V still did not give me stability when doing regular things. It's as the voltages aren't enough for part load duty yet the 1.296V it gives me under full load is well above what I found to be stable. I need a setting that gives me more voltage throughout the speed/load curve without having to push my peak voltage so high. I remember using Offset voltage on my last board and that worked like a champ. Throttled my voltage with no problems. I guess I am failing to see what Adaptive really does for me. I saw while gaming I was at 4.5ghz 1.203V... full speed but obviously not full load. I do love the cooler temps tho! I just bumped up to 1.210 Adaptive but this is going to give me 1.3V under full load... way to much.
 
Last edited:
Ok, should the peak be any higher than what was found to be stable?

sounds like it will end up up being that way due to the 0.090v jump which you can't really control. is your cpu an i7?

1.175 is too low, thus the blue screens. try 1.180 and 1.185. it'll mean you'll end up running at 1.270v or higher when stressing, but there's not much you can do about that.

keep in mind though that stress tests are designed to torture the cpu. so unless your usual workload is unusually stressful, your cpu will not be spending most of its life running at 1.270 volts.
 
Double Edit: 1.200V still did not give me stability when doing regular things. It's as the voltages aren't enough for part load duty yet the 1.296V it gives me under full load is well above what I found to be stable.

it's possible you may have hit a voltage wall at the multiplier you're trying to run. try dropping the multiplier a step and see if that gets you stable at 1.2 volts or lower.

on my cpu, i had to push 1.255 volts (adaptive) to get it stable at 4.4, but it will run all day at 4.3 with only 1.185v.
 
Wow, so adaptive is kinda blah. I mean why not just run Offset voltage? This worked fine on my Sandy Bridge. My temps aren't bad leaving it full voltage all the time to be honest. I am debating a de-lid job. I can't leave things alone...
 
offset isn't going to help. setting a positive offset will just increase voltage everywhere. the only way to prevent that .090v jump when stress testing is to use manual voltage.
 
offset isn't going to help. setting a positive offset will just increase voltage everywhere. the only way to prevent that .090v jump when stress testing is to use manual voltage.

or negative offset.. that help... I use on my sandy 2600 and my brothers 3570k too use offset and work perfect keeping autovoltage with negative offset..
 
or negative offset.. that help... I use on my sandy 2600 and my brothers 3570k too use offset and work perfect keeping autovoltage with negative offset..

I can tell you right now.. Haswell does not function like those chips. For me its been a HUGE pain trying to get it right on mine but I think I finally found it.
 
Copyright - I just wanted to understand you. Are you saying that when using adaptive you get instabilities during 'regular' system operation that you don't necessarily see during stress testing?

I think I'm seeing something similar. I currently get random blue screen and bootup issues and I'm not sure if it's related to having adaptive voltage set. I guess I'll revert to override until I am sure my system is 100% stable and keep on the lookout for instabilities. I was able to run prime for an hour no problem on override. Then I reboot the machine and set adaptive with the same 'cap' voltage and power down. Next morning I turn on my PC and it blue screens on me.

Not really sure what is going on or if my massive overclock (only trying 4.2GHz at 1.15v ...) is simply too aggressive :)
 
Copyright - I just wanted to understand you. Are you saying that when using adaptive you get instabilities during 'regular' system operation that you don't necessarily see during stress testing?

this is possible, since when using adaptive voltage, the cpu will even more voltage when stress testing with a program that uses avx instructions. that means that if you run regular apps that don't use avx, the cpu is using the adaptive voltage you specified, which may not be stable at your target clock speed even though it is when running, say, prime95. this tends to happen if you set your adaptive voltage such that you end up with the lowest stable stress test voltage.

for example, say you find your cpu is prime95 stable at 4.5ghz with a manual voltage of 1.25. so you set your adaptive voltage to 1.25, but then when stressing with prime95, you see that the cpu is actually running at 1.35, not 1.25. that additional .1v is what your cpu pulls when running avx instructions. so you reduce your adaptive to 1.15 resulting in your cpu then running at 1.25v when stressing, and it's stable.

but then you find your cpu is unstable at the desktop, or running an older non-avx version of prime95, because 1.15v isn't actually enough for non-avx stability.

in this case you'll need to slowly bump up the adaptive voltage and stress test with non-avx until it's stable. but it means that it will be running at higher voltage than is necessary for stability when it executes avx instructions.

or you can simply use manual or offset voltage and avoid this problem.
 
How is everyone setting their cache ratio when using adaptive mode and C states?

I believe x8 for min and x45 for max (for a 4.5Ghz OC) would be logically correct since the CPU idles at 800Mhz. Or leaving both on AUTO or x45? I don't know how to set it right for adaptive mode.

The more I read about it the less benefits I see using adaptive or offset, especially on a desktop. Would permanently feeding 1.170v degrade the CPU faster?
 
Back
Top