Dishonored Developer Talks About Video Game Violence

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I know all of you are going to have an opinion on this article so I'm just going to post it and let you discuss it in the forums.

I don’t believe that game violence causes real world violence, but I do believe that it does little to prevent it. And games with meaningful (and potentially distasteful) choice just might do better because they stand a chance of making the player think about what they’re doing on screen. And there are others that think so too: Dishonored is one of the few violent video games that has not been censored by the German government. One could argue this is largely because the game can be played without killing anyone. This doesn’t change all the things you might do in the game, but simply by knowing that it allows non-violence you find that every violent act you choose in cast in a sobering light.
 
I do think that violent games benefit when there are moral choices in the game ... I liked the choice of whether to rescue or harvest Little Sisters in Bioshock ... not just because it was a stark choice and affected the ending but because it actually affected the game play ... rescuing the Little Sisters made leveling your plasmids a little tougher but provided an excellent end game reward that wouldn't be available otherwise ... harvesting the Little Sisters might have provided an easier go at the beginning but you were trading off the end game to do it

Most games don't really differentiate between "good" and "bad" choices or the difference between them is mostly cosmetic ... I don't think that all games should present the moral choices or that games should be forced to do it ... but I think companies that find creative ways to do it should be commended and I do like games that provide more than one solution to a problem (even the shooters) ;)
 
Better example is Spec Ops The Line. The game makes you think about the random killing you do in shooters.
 
I just want to stab and shoot things in games. I think it KEEPS me from wanting to do it IRL.. Kind of cathartic.

All the mental problems I've had to go through, and for some reason video game violence doesn't desensitize me to real violence. No matter how much blood splattering I see in games, doesn't bother me.. I see a little bit of blood on the floor IRL, and I want to puke.

We need to learn to keep our violence in fantasy, and keep peace in the real world.
 
Violence in games is rewarding, therefore strongly desired. You wouldn't like a game you can't win. And there is always an enemy to be fought.

Truth is, I wouldn't give a fuck if my character were a single-colored cube fighting for liberty against the evil balls empire. It's the gameplay that counts.
 
Moral choices don't mean a thing in games any more than they train you how to shoot a real gun. Anyone who believes they do needs to check why they struggle to separate reality from fantasy. Sometimes I play a game and make the good choices, sometimes I play the game and slaughter everything in sight. There is no rhyme nor reason behind my actions other than it suited my whim at that particular moment. Idiots who perpetuate this nonsense are why this insipid discussion keeps coming up.
 
If violent video games had anything to do with real world violence then we would have a fucking epidemic of violent kids out there shooting and stabbing anything and everything. But we don't have an epidemic, just the occasional violent psycho who would still be a psycho regardless of the games he plays or movies he watches.
 
Grew up completely immersed in games like Doom and Quake; would never intentionally bring harm to another animal or human being unless in self defense.

I'm no outlier, either.
 
Something must be done!

Doesn't matter if it works or not. Doesn't matter is it intrudes on people's rights. Someone did something wrong, so those who did nothing wrong must be punished.
 
Grew up completely immersed in games like Doom and Quake; would never intentionally bring harm to another animal or human being unless in self defense.

I'm no outlier, either.

Only a lunatic would bring harm to someone because of something a movie showed them or a video game virtually simulated.

That's the simple disconnect that allows sociopaths to do what they do with absolutely no moral guard.

Its also the same reason no matter how many studies you do about simulated violence in various forms of entertainment , it will always result in no connection between the too and rational behavior.

Its a waste of time to debate it. Parents are perfectly capable of governing their children's choices if they feel otherwise but it provides them no legal grounds to inflict there viewpoints on others.
 
I still think Dragon Age Origins did the best "Moral choices", although many of them aren't cut and dry "good" and "bad" choices.
 
Better example is Spec Ops The Line. The game makes you think about the random killing you do in shooters.

That game really got me. One of the few that when I was done I just sat their in awe of everything that had happened and the choices I had made. Fantastic!

As others have stated, I don't think playing or seeing violence makes people more violent. There are usually other factors at play with the person such as abuse or mental illness.
 
I think hotline Miami really made you think "why am i doing this". with its cut scenes and the between lvls as well as The ending.
 
I threw fireballs at turtles and mushrooms but I have no desire to hurt them in real life.
 
It should be a question to the medical organizations of how are these people that are obviously unstable or ready to snap, are slipping through and avoiding more serious mental care, are the parents sheltering them from being sent to an institution because little Timmy is innocent, he just likes to kill small animals sometimes...and draw some scary s#!t on the walls, or is it the fault of the psychiatric care not doing their job?

We had a perfect example of a paperwork cock up in San Francisco, allowed a transient to make his way to Santa Cruz, and stab to death an innocent woman in broad daylight, he was supposed to be sent from jail to an institution as he had a massive history of mental problems and violent behavior.

There is a massive difference between real and video game violence, if you cannot differentiate between the two and your not repulsed by real violence, then you should seek some help.
 
I love games that reward for different moral choices or has alternate endings for said choices. I also agree with neither choices having any affect on how one is raised or the mental state of said player to seperate fantasy from fiction.
 
How about this: we make video games with choices now, as you guys were talking about. You chose to be a raving lunatic and mow everything down and chose the dark side, so to speak, or you chose the path of goodness.

Except now a code should be added to the video game where the game phones home to the FBI when you make the violent choices.

Yes? :D
 
Video game violence in the real world shouldn't be that big of a problem. Some people agree that it is a problem and give out various reasons and scenarios, that’s all fine. I don’t believe it’s that big of an issue but it should be discussed as such. When I play a violent video game, it doesn't make me aggressive in any way, shape, or form. I think that it all depends on how your mind works, varying from person to person. The parents although should really watch what they buy their kids for their Xbox or PlayStation. It’s mostly up to them to teach their kid that it’s simply a game and should be just for fun, nothing serious. Also, the game rating on the cover is there for a reason. If it’s rated M for mature (17+), maybe the parent shouldn't buy it for say a 12 year old for example. An alternative would be a rated E for everyone game.
 
If violent video games had anything to do with real world violence then we would have a fucking epidemic of violent kids out there shooting and stabbing anything and everything. But we don't have an epidemic, just the occasional violent psycho who would still be a psycho regardless of the games he plays or movies he watches.
Without commenting on whether video game violence is linked to real world violence the fact of the matter is that the US is experiencing a violence epidemic.
 
Without commenting on whether video game violence is linked to real world violence the fact of the matter is that the US is experiencing a violence epidemic.

The murder rate is about half of what it was 20 years ago.

Any notion that there's a recent violence epidemic is pure propaganda to influence politics.
 
The murder rate is about half of what it was 20 years ago.

Any notion that there's a recent violence epidemic is pure propaganda to influence politics.

Not that I agree with there being more violence now than in the past, however, one thing we do need to be careful with about crime statistics is the source of the data ... police started using tracking software back in the 90's so that they could "reduce crime" ... however, one of the unfortunate side effects of that type of system is it encourages people to downgrade crimes ...

murder wouldn't be downgraded obviously but other violent crimes often are (rapes downgraded to assaults, attempted murder downgraded to assault, etc) ... to fully understand the true level of violence you have to look at all levels of violence and also factor in unreported crimes

that said, I think violence is a function of environment (income, opportunity, etc) and is not really a function of external factors like games or other forms of media ;)
 
The national rate has been dropping since the late 90's but if you look in the data for local cities with high levels of impoverishment, such as Compton, Detroit, and especially the south like St. Louis and New Orleans, then the data is more startling. The murder rates in those cities are upwards of 5x the national average. The national average is currently around 5% (and it's important to note that even that figure is high by international standards) and a place like Detroit with 5x the national average has a murder rate of 25%.

That's massive no matter what side of the political aisle anyone sane claims to be on.

There was a recent study by Harvard medical pointing out that our last twenty years of excellent medical advancements account for a significant drop in the homicide rate. If we look at admissions to hospitals as a more accurate figure for violence in the US (because even if people don't want to report when they are victimized they tend to want to get patched up) Harvard medical estimated that our murder rate would be much higher than it currently is.
 
The murder rate is about half of what it was 20 years ago.

Any notion that there's a recent violence epidemic is pure propaganda to influence politics.
It's certainly not recent. We've had a violence epidemic in the US since around the late-60's.
We had sharp spikes in the late 80's and through the 90's and now the *national* rate has been declining for the past twenty years.

But our pre-spike period was already high by international standards over thirty years ago. Our incarceration rate was already exceptionally high by international standards, too, and now it's seven times what it was.


Like I said, I wasn't commenting on video games as a cause for violence. But I do think there's merit to the concern that US culture has normalized violence. That's a real problem regardless of one's political ideological underpinnings.
 
The bigger the gap between the rich and the poor, the bigger the crime rate. No, it's not about getting enough money to survive, it's the gap. The fact that someone has it a LOT better than you seems to anger some, especially when it's not justified at all (as in: got bailed out by government).

See: Brazil.
 
The bigger the gap between the rich and the poor, the bigger the crime rate. No, it's not about getting enough money to survive, it's the gap. The fact that someone has it a LOT better than you seems to anger some, especially when it's not justified at all (as in: got bailed out by government).

See: Brazil.
I agree completely and the data tends to back this up.
The way we typically measure inequality is through what we call the "GINI coefficient (or GINI index)" The US ranks among the highest relative to other advanced industrial nations. Here's an article I found on the topic that seems to be easily consumable:
http://www.economist.com/node/17957381

And here's the raw data is people want to compare GINI coefficients of various countries:
http://data.un.org/DocumentData.aspx?q=HDI&id=271

From that chart you can see that we are the highest among our peers and only surpassed by places like Latin America, Russia, China, and the Middle East.
 
The national rate has been dropping since the late 90's but if you look in the data for local cities with high levels of impoverishment, such as Compton, Detroit, and especially the south like St. Louis and New Orleans, then the data is more startling. The murder rates in those cities are upwards of 5x the national average. The national average is currently around 5% (and it's important to note that even that figure is high by international standards) and a place like Detroit with 5x the national average has a murder rate of 25%.

That's massive no matter what side of the political aisle anyone sane claims to be on.

There was a recent study by Harvard medical pointing out that our last twenty years of excellent medical advancements account for a significant drop in the homicide rate. If we look at admissions to hospitals as a more accurate figure for violence in the US (because even if people don't want to report when they are victimized they tend to want to get patched up) Harvard medical estimated that our murder rate would be much higher than it currently is.

We just have to be careful of what we attribute a change in something to so we can avoid the "post hoc ergo propter hoc" (after this therefore because of this) effect ... in the 50's comic books were considered the cause of violence since they performed studies of prison populations and juvenile delinquents and found that most of them read comic books (they didn't consider how much of the general comic reading population was not in prison or a delinquent)

With societal violence you have to consider a wide range of factors (income, employment, access to drugs, alcohol, age of population, etc). Another consideration in the studies on games and violence is they don't require someone to commit actual violence ... they usually use some sort of surrogate for violence ... it is one thing to say that games desensitize you to violence and then take someone to a slaughterhouse or something where you see real blood (and smell it) ...

With all things, whether it is games or music or movies or books or magazines or whatever, if you are healthy and unstressed you will likely experience no significant impacts ... if you are unhealthy or highly stressed then LOTS of things can impact you, not just those ;)
 
i would be surprised if a video game has ever changed someone's view on violence, one way or the other. and these "moral choices" in video games always feel a bit obvious. more likely views are shaped by the context (people, news, family) you live in. that said, i can't deny there's probably some glamorization effect of war, with FPSs like CoD, but i doubt playing it would make a pacifist change his mind.
 
Like I said, I wasn't commenting on video games as a cause for violence. But I do think there's merit to the concern that US culture has normalized violence. That's a real problem regardless of one's political ideological underpinnings.

Violence has always been normalized, and it isn't just America or its culture. Look at the Italian crime waves in the 80's and 90's, the shining path and other central American guerrillas, Castro and Che Guevara, the American West, the rise of the Russian Mafia, fundamentalist countries, etc...etc...Violence is a tool to spread fear or to make a name for yourself. The spread of information makes it seem more than it has been in the past. The simple fact is violence is down as education has gone up. When you make a comparison in the data to education the less educated areas have a higher rate of violence. This tends to also correlate to areas of poverty and the culture that poverty brings is a subject of another debate.

So it just isn't America or our culture and video games have little to do with violence just as heavy metal and D & D wasn't responsible for turning everyone into satanists with bloodthirsty tendencies. However, with that said there are some games that even make me uneasy and I won't play and if my son was older I wouldn't let him play either until he understood what the message behind his choices meant.
 
No, the US is unique among all other first world nations in its violence and incarceration and poverty rates. It's leading the developed nations in infant mortality and child abuse.

Those examples you listed are not examples of "normalized violence." That's not what we mean when we talk about normative behavior or a culture of violence. Normative behavior is what comes to be acceptable behavior.

The fact that you claim in your statement that violence is normal and that it's always been with us and acceptable to a point is what we social scientist mean when we claim US citizens exist in a culture of violence and that it's normative. That claim you made, that it's just a natural part of life, is a fairly unique US perspective. Other country's citizens don't tend to see the world that way. They don't tend to accept violence as a natural state of social interaction and that's what we mean when we say it's a big problem and a uniquely US problem.
 
Violent video games or games with "moral choices" have no more baring on real life than watching Silence of the Lambs turned me on to cannibalism.

Pretty sure a generation grew up fine watching Jerry brutalize Tom without any consequences whatsoever and didn't go around dropping anvils on each other's heads for fun.
 
No, the US is unique among all other first world nations in its violence and incarceration and poverty rates. It's leading the developed nations in infant mortality and child abuse.[

Those examples you listed are not examples of "normalized violence." That's not what we mean when we talk about normative behavior or a culture of violence. Normative behavior is what comes to be acceptable behavior.

Violence isn't an acceptable behavior in America nor has it ever been. You can't change the definition to fit the pattern. The rest of the first world nations are considerably more homogenized than American which leads to fewer outbreaks of violence.

The fact that you claim in your statement that violence is normal and that it's always been with us and acceptable to a point is what we social scientist mean when we claim US citizens exist in a culture of violence and that it's normative. That claim you made, that it's just a natural part of life, is a fairly unique US perspective.

It isn't an American perspective it is a historical one. I can spend the rest of the weekend describing, listing examples, and what not.
Other country's citizens don't tend to see the world that way. They don't tend to accept violence as a natural state of social interaction and that's what we mean when we say it's a big problem and a uniquely US problem.

Other countries tend not to see their own problems as clearly as they should. America is by no means perfect and we do have too much violence but it isn't unique to America; however, our diversity which can be our greatest strength is at times also our greatest weakness. Again our culture of poverty which we have bred and somewhat responsible for is a topic for general mayhem.
 
Better example is Spec Ops The Line. The game makes you think about the random killing you do in shooters.

That game was a mind fuck. One of the few good games I've played in a while.

As far as violence goes...I've been playing games for as long as I can remember...violent whore killing ones, you know the type...yet I still can't bring myself to play someone evil or be mean in a game. I'm always a good guy, a Jedi, all blue and white.

This whole debate is pointless. The only way I see violent video games causing harm is with those that are already mentally unstable. Plus, if it isn't video games that gets them it'll be movies, or T.V., or music...anything other stimulating form of entertainment.

Video games aren't the problem...society is the problem. People that need help who aren't or can't get it is the problem.

Of course I feel that in the end none of this matters. Politicians have some end game in this. They want people disarmed...but for what...
 
Back
Top