Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad?

I think things need to go one step further and I think Valve is the company to help do it.

Valve/Linux.

A custom distro tailored to gaming. What scares most game companies about Linux is that its a fractured platform. (same problem with Android) I think Valve needs to partner with Canonical or the Linux Mint guys and work this out. Both Ubuntu and Mint I feel are consumer friendly enough to pull this off.
 
No, I believe it's a simple fact that the GPL is more restrictive (to users) than BSD/MIT/etc. You have fewer permissions = you have more restrictions. I don't see how this can be evaluated in any other way.

Who are the "users"? Developers are also users. The developers are what matters here. No development, no software for the users. Some devs want to ensure code freedom for themselves also. I hate the ambiguity that's in the GPL, and it isn't only for the "users". That's just pure BS imo.

No. For a person to claim that they've been "screwed over" as a result of using the BSD license is a bit like handing someone an apple, telling them they can do whatever they want with it (including, but not limited to, eating it) and saying that they've been screwed over when the person they gave it to threw it in the trash. It doesn't hold water.


I'm not saying using the BSD license will definitely result of someone getting screwed over. I'm saying due to the nature of the license and lack of enforcement allows others to restrict the use of your software, or the modifications using the original as leverage It allows derivatives to be licensed under any other type of license, including a close source one. That lack of redistributive responsibility is what allows third parties to exploit code freedom for their own advantages. (Apple?)

Now some devs don't really care, and would rather retain their freedom of choice. Some do care. GPL advocates wants to ensure freedom of the code for both the end user and developers, at the cost of restricting the developers freedom of choice. But some devs don't see that responsibility as a restriction for themselves. It's subjective. When I said "compensated" i was referring to being able to use their modifications to your original source code they've linked to. Or both.

An example of a good compromise between a copyleft and permissive license would be the LGPL, for example.
 
Who are the "users"? Developers are also users.
That's what I'm referring to. Users of the code. People have who have been granted a license to use the code in a given set of ways with a given set of restrictions.

That's just pure BS imo.
What specifically are you referring to with this comment?

GPL advocates wants to ensure freedom of the code for both the end user and developers, at the cost of restricting the developers freedom of choice. But some devs don't see that responsibility as a restriction for themselves. It's subjective.
No, it's quantifiable, thus objective. Suppose I give you a list of three things you can do with an apple: eat it; throw it away; juice it. I then give you a list of two things you can do with an orange: eat it; juice it. Which list of allowances is more restrictive? How many more things can a person do with an apple than they can with an orange?

Your argument appears to be that because some people don't care that they won't be able to throw the orange away, the list of allowances is subjectively no more restrictive than the allowances you have with the apple. That doesn't make sense to me.
 
wonderfield and n0rVow seem to be getting tangled in strange semantic distinctions.

It might be useful to establish a baseline.

First off, developers are not "end-users" in this discussion. End users are not content creators. To fold those two categories into one another without distinction blurs the lines between the two audiences of code and makes discussion unwieldy.

Secondly, the BSD license does not preclude one from profiting from one's content creation. The BSD license is specifically intended to allow both open-source code as well as proprietary code.

Arguing that the GPL is more restrictive because it requires that all code licensed under its terms remain free as in speech is a strange way of viewing the situation. The BSD license can not, does not intend, and will never require that code remain free for all users. It may be more permissive for content creators to do what they want but it results in less code being open and free for end-users. Creators *may* freely release their content if they so choose but under the GPL they must.

Wonderfield has reversed a critical point in one of his earlier posts. Users do *not* get to decide how they want to release code. It's not theirs to release. Under the BSD licensing terms a content creator can refuse to simply release any code at all. There is no lever other than the GPL that forces opening of code.

Also, it's simply not true that "You have fewer permissions = you have more restrictions". That argument is too simple and misses the nuances of the relationship between copyright and copyleft.

I have to jet to a movie now but if I have time later tonight I'll expound on these points further. It's very important to understand the theories of law underlying these positions and not simply apply lay person comprehension to the points at issue. It won't work cleanly and the conclusions will be contradictory to what is already established.
 
I always wanted to have Linux on my PC. I'm now building a new one and Steam coming to Linux made me realize its time to dual boot my new rig.(waiting for parts atm) So to me this is a good thing.

I'm more curious if all PC/Steam software will run on Linux.
This

If all my steam games could work on Linux my next PC build might not have Windows on it at all, I could live with out Origin/EA bs, if popular the market could force many more developers to Linux. Ubuntu is almost idiot proof. In my case the money saved on an os license could purchase better hardware.
 
BSD has less restrictions on code. Period. The fact GPL that has requirements for usage as you explicitly say by definition means it has more restrictions and is less free.

The choosing a license like GPL is entirely a political maneuver. It has nothing to do with freedom, only agenda.

wonderfield and n0rVow seem to be getting tangled in strange semantic distinctions.

It might be useful to establish a baseline.

First off, developers are not "end-users" in this discussion. End users are not content creators. To fold those two categories into one another without distinction blurs the lines between the two audiences of code and makes discussion unwieldy.

Secondly, the BSD license does not preclude one from profiting from one's content creation. The BSD license is specifically intended to allow both open-source code as well as proprietary code.

Arguing that the GPL is more restrictive because it requires that all code licensed under its terms remain free as in speech is a strange way of viewing the situation. The BSD license can not, does not intend, and will never require that code remain free for all users. It may be more permissive for content creators to do what they want but it results in less code being open and free for end-users. Creators *may* freely release their content if they so choose but under the GPL they must.

Wonderfield has reversed a critical point in one of his earlier posts. Users do *not* get to decide how they want to release code. It's not theirs to release. Under the BSD licensing terms a content creator can refuse to simply release any code at all. There is no lever other than the GPL that forces opening of code.

Also, it's simply not true that "You have fewer permissions = you have more restrictions". That argument is too simple and misses the nuances of the relationship between copyright and copyleft.

I have to jet to a movie now but if I have time later tonight I'll expound on these points further. It's very important to understand the theories of law underlying these positions and not simply apply lay person comprehension to the points at issue. It won't work cleanly and the conclusions will be contradictory to what is already established.
 
Arguing that the GPL is more restrictive because it requires that all code licensed under its terms remain free as in speech is a strange way of viewing the situation.
In my estimation, arguing that the GPL is more restrictive because it places more restrictions upon users of the code is perfectly rational and sensible. It's also my estimation that the above quote is little more than spin.

It may be more permissive for content creators to do what they want but it results in less code being open and free for end-users.
I'm not debating that. What it "results in" is well beside the point.

Wonderfield has reversed a critical point in one of his earlier posts.
I have not.

Also, it's simply not true that "You have fewer permissions = you have more restrictions".
It's true as a simple matter of fact. You have fewer permissions; you have more restrictions. You have more hair; you have less baldness. You have more color; you have less grey.

The choosing a license like GPL is entirely a political maneuver. It has nothing to do with freedom, only agenda.
Bingo. It'd do people well to see through Stallman's smokescreen of faux freedom and understand what the GPL is designed to do. That's not to say that everything about the GPL is poisonous and wrong, or that the idea of everything being open to everyone isn't a very neat-sounding and idealistic thing, but we're dealing with the reality of people being allowed to do more things with their apples than they can with their oranges.
 
...we're dealing with the reality of people being allowed to do more things with their apples than they can with their oranges.

I can agree with everything in your above post under the condition you add making and eating apple pie to the list of things that I'm allowed to do with my apples.
 
In my estimation, arguing that the GPL is more restrictive because it places more restrictions upon users of the code is perfectly rational and sensible. It's also my estimation that the above quote is little more than spin.


I'm not debating that. What it "results in" is well beside the point.


I have not.


It's true as a simple matter of fact. You have fewer permissions; you have more restrictions. You have more hair; you have less baldness. You have more color; you have less grey.


Bingo. It'd do people well to see through Stallman's smokescreen of faux freedom and understand what the GPL is designed to do. That's not to say that everything about the GPL is poisonous and wrong, or that the idea of everything being open to everyone isn't a very neat-sounding and idealistic thing, but we're dealing with the reality of people being allowed to do more things with their apples than they can with their oranges.
What the GPL is designed to do is take content automatically created under the most restrictive license, copyright, and transpose it into the public domain.

The idea that the result does not matter is insane. As far as content creators are concerned they have all rights and benefits under copyright. They do not need BSD licensing to have full control over their content. Copyleft is designed to protect end-users' freedom.

There is no smokescreen, no faux freedom. The only way you can make the argument you are making here is by continuing to conflate content creators with end-users. As long as you continue to incorrectly conflate the two then you'll remain confused about these issues.
 
What the GPL is designed to do is take content automatically created under the most restrictive license, copyright, and transpose it into the public domain.
The GPL has absolutely nothing to do with the public domain, and it does not subvert copyright. Following the template, the second line in the GPL license is a copyright declaration. A work cannot be both A) under copyright and B) in the public domain. There is no "transposition".

They do not need BSD licensing to have full control over their content.
You've astutely determined that the BSD license is not about control. Very good. I consider this forward progress. Am I to assume that, given the omission of a similar statement regarding the GPL, that it's your feeling that the GPL is about control?

The only way you can make the argument you are making here is by continuing to conflate content creators with end-users. As long as you continue to incorrectly conflate the two then you'll remain confused about these issues.
I've made the distinction quite clear. "Users of code" is not ambiguous. In this discussion, "content creators" is, since it does not indicate whether we're referring to the original author of the software to which the license was applied (the licensor) or the licensees using that code for derivative works. This is important to the discussion. You merely believe that it will aid your agenda to portray me as being confused, despite that not being the truth. This won't work. You don't need to keep trying.
 
Perhaps this portion from one of your earlier posts contains errors you didn't catch then.

The GPL enforces source code availability by imposing restrictions. The BSD allows source code availability by granting users the ability to make that decision for themselves. In this respect, it is the users who make the decision as to whether the final product remains more open and free to users, not Richard Stallman's.

Clearly users do not make decisions about whether the code they are using is proprietary or not--developers make that decision.

Developers do not need BSD to have full control over their content because Copyright laws already automatically grants full protection and control for developers over their content. It should be obvious from my posts that I do not consider the GPL to be about control over users and if it wasn't apparent to you already then consider it explicitly stated now.

Freedom for users is all Stallman cares about and what the article (and this thread) is concerned with. If you want to argue for protection or freedom of developers over their content I suggest you do so in an appropriate thread instead of continuing to derail this conversation with doublespeak. Double speak is the only way I can describe your assertion that a license requiring that code remain non-proprietary for its users somehow means they end up with less freedoms. It's beyond ridiculous at this point so I'll just leave it at that.
 
The discussion regarding the GPL was always about developers. It was not defined as well as it could have been by myself and others, admittedly, but context establishes the meaning sufficiently enough (it otherwise makes absolutely no sense). In the quote above, I was referring to users, not as people who simply use software, but as "users of code". Which I already elaborated upon.

Just as a final note: coming from you, the accusation that I'm derailing the thread is something I take as a compliment.
 
LMAO. You think he will tell me who his drug dealer is?

if you ask him nicely, he answered a lot of my programing questions like time i emailed him
334hhmg.jpg
 
The discussion regarding the GPL was always about developers. It was not defined as well as it could have been by myself and others, admittedly, but context establishes the meaning sufficiently enough (it otherwise makes absolutely no sense). In the quote above, I was referring to users, not as people who simply use software, but as "users of code". Which I already elaborated upon.

Just as a final note: coming from you, the accusation that I'm derailing the thread is something I take as a compliment.
How does it make sense to state that, "The BSD allows source code availability by granting users the ability to make that decision for themselves." when referring to developers? They already have the ability to make source code available under any license.

The BSD license doesn't "allow" source code availability for developers. That's what your'e trying to argue?
 
What is this guy smoking?

Any attention you can get to Linux is a good thing so it doesn't become an obscure O/S strictly for power users and fall behind. More interest means more development, and everyone from the consumers, developers, and merchants will benefit.

Stallman is the extreme end of Free Software. Its ok that he sounds liek a nutter becasue he adds weight to that end of the argument, which allows a greater bandwidth of discussion.
 
The biggest reason I don't use Linux is games. The next biggest reason I don't use Linux is because Linux nerds want Linux to suck too much to be a viable choice for home users.
 
How about splitting the difference and having affordable and functional/user friendly for the masses software available? Isn't the latter really what keeps Linux off the desktop (that and games)? And a chance to be compensated your efforts tends to stimulate software innovation.
 
Keep in mind that "Free" does not just mean "doesn't cost any money". It also means that the source code is available and can be changed and re-distributed by anyone.

Too much non-free software on Linux kind of works against the whole purpose of using the OS in the first place. There's absolutely nothing wrong with Windows 7 except that the OS itself and most software are closed-source and cost money.
 
As a long time Linux user and supporter I always feel embarrassed for the community when Stallman opens his mouth. The man is worse than a religious fanatic, he constantly makes an ass of himself and refuses to bend. If you argue with him you just hate freedom. Well as a user what about my freedom to use what ever software I want? What about the developers freedom to protect his work? The man truly believes if you create something you have no rights to it at all.

It sounds harsh but the Linux community as a whole will be better off when he croaks.
 
I can tell you right now. If/When Valve pulls this off. I will never buy another copy of Windows. I expect to pay for games. I'm not really sure how this is different than using a Linux PC to navigate to Amazon and buying an MP3? I'm sure that has been done plenty. Is all the music on Amazon free if you use Linux?

Linux video card drivers will have to improve. Whether Valve does it or they pressure Nvidia and AMD to do it.

AMD will have to actually write an OGL driver that works. Not just patch holes in the current crappy one so that one game on the market can work half ass.

These are all good things.
 
As a long time Linux user and supporter I always feel embarrassed for the community when Stallman opens his mouth. The man is worse than a religious fanatic, he constantly makes an ass of himself and refuses to bend. If you argue with him you just hate freedom. Well as a user what about my freedom to use what ever software I want? What about the developers freedom to protect his work? The man truly believes if you create something you have no rights to it at all.

It sounds harsh but the Linux community as a whole will be better off when he croaks.

Agreed. I just had to read the bit about "non free programs being unethical" to think he's a wanker. Steam on Linux will bring me one step closer to freedom. The freedom to choose between linux and windows. Right now I don't "practically" have that choice. That meaning that I really am over multiboot. I just want to stick with one thing for a period of time.
 
Am I misunderstanding? When he talks about free I though he was less concerned about money being paid for software (many Linux distros are free in that you don't pay to install and use, but you have to pay for service and support, if you want it) Rather Stillman means free from restrictive and unfairly imposed terms e.g. you want this game or delivery system (Steam) therefore you must also agree that:

  • we can collect all of your personal data
  • you can't use other specific software (because of DRM or whatever,)
  • you must accept updates whether you want them or not
  • you can't play your games at all until you get the latest update
  • you can't play the game if you lose your internet connection
  • updates will be automatic at out time of choosing (you can't schedule downloads to be off peak and play in the meantime)
  • you must accept changes in the terms whenever we feel like or lose the right to use the software you already paid for etc.
He's against all the despicable EULA bullshit that MS, Apple, EA, Adobe, Ubisoft et al impose on users and which we all hate.

I accept that Stallman has a somewhat black and white viewpoint of this and wants absolute freedom to do anything, whereas most of us just want fair EULAs that don't trample on our rights and let us use the software we paid for without further interference from the seller.
 
I think the key point is that games are art (as a few other posters have mentioned) ... an OS is not art, a word processor is not art, a game is (it might be really crappy art but it is still art) ... as such it is entitled to protections unless the "artist" chooses to allow others to tweak their art ... since some PC games have been successfully modded in Windows there is no reason to expect that Linux versions wouldn't be similarly moddable (if the programmer makes that possible) ... since games are strictly a voluntary purchase then they wouldn't restrict the users freedom because the user doesn't have to buy them :)
 
Dont hate on Stallman. He is asking proper questions. You must be careful you dont turn Linux into a DRM infested/backdoor having/rootkit installed, bad EULA's Windows look-alike.
 
I've been using Linux in one form or another since the mid to late 90s. I still have one of the books around here, but whatever.

Games are the reason I have never fully adopted it for my home use. That's it. I've relied on a windows operating system to give me what I want. And no, I don't wanna deal with tweaking something endlessly so I can get it working in Linux. The point of the game is to play it, not fiddle with it trying to get it to work.

I've been a Steam user for 8 years now. This has bubbled up once or twice before, but MS has finally pushed this to happen and I'm pretty happy about it.

Just think. If this had happened a decade ago, I never would have been on XP, at all.

Will this be bad for Linux? Ya know, I really don't care. I'm just an average user and I just want access to some of my favorite games on Linux, and new recently released stuff, too. This has always been too much to ask for. I really truly do NOT care about about 'restrictions'. As I said, I've been using Steam for 8 years already. All that will change for me if this goes through is the icons I click to open stuff up.
 
The most interesting point in the above quote raises an implicit analogy: How is the "Mona Lisa" considered ethical to have a dollar value, but software doesn't?

It's not free as in "value," it's free as in "doing whatever you want with it."


The Mona Lisa is a bad example anyhow as digital copies of it are all over the internet for free. The original also doesn't have a license that prevents the owners from modifying it or copying it.
 
Dont hate on Stallman. He is asking proper questions. You must be careful you dont turn Linux into a DRM infested/backdoor having/rootkit installed, bad EULA's Windows look-alike.
THAT is the choice of the user. Stallman does not dictate MY FREEDOM. I do with it as I please. If I want to install Far Cry 2 (hypothetically if it had a Linux release) that comes with its DRM, then I will.
 
I've heard that this post by him isn't, "Give it to us for free" but more so, "Linux is built on the idea of freedom to do what we wish, having closed software harms that."

I think he's making the point that valve making games for linux without the users able to modify with source code like nearly everything on linux would change expectations. I think he's saying that he wishes to keep Linus the place of modders and coders.

Though, I'm sure it's easier to yell out that he wants free shit.

This is honestly, how I read it. It was more about principles from the way I read it.
 
Talk about biting the hands that feed you. Valve doesn't HAVE to do this.

And isn't DRM acronym for Digital RIGHTS Management, not restrictions? Is he being facetious?
 
EULA's are pure BS and the part about we can change it at any time if you don't like it GTF out is the worst part.
DRM is just crazy and the always connected part on a single player game is BEYOND STUPID.

BUT I do like the idea of linux because so many can tell MS to go F themselves BIG TIME
I would like to see them go out of business....overall their heavy handed crap with office and the millions they make in spyware they install is crazy.
 
20 years later, and Stallman still doesn't understand that "increased market share" and "pure open-source" are literally 100% at odds with each other.

Linux has to choose. Are they going to be totally free and open, forever relegated to tweakers? Or are they going to accept some closed components in exchange for market acceptance?
 
Dont hate on Stallman. He is asking proper questions. You must be careful you dont turn Linux into a DRM infested/backdoor having/rootkit installed, bad EULA's Windows look-alike.

You see that's the issue. What about my freedom to do just that? Stallman talks a lot about freedom yet wants to take away our ability to install what we want drm or not. Just like a religious fanatic he's trying to force HIS idea of freedom on the users and that in itself it's taking away one freedom to protect another.

If the freedom of Linux users was really what his agenda was ask about he would support it but warn the users what they are looking at nothing more. That would be freedom for the users.
 
If the freedom of Linux users was really what his agenda was ask about he would support it but warn the users what they are looking at nothing more. That would be freedom for the users.
When you have time to read the linked article this thread is discussing you'll see that's exactly what he does. Or if you did click through to it make sure to read or skip to the last couple paragraphs where he clarifies his position.
 
Back
Top