Apple Gets Patent for 5D Technology

Looks like an old virtual reality simulator to me, can only hope someone already has a patent on the tech they scribbled on this piece of toilet paper (the motion detection system looks like the same tech used for character animation for a start).
 
Looks like an old virtual reality simulator to me, can only hope someone already has a patent on the tech they scribbled on this piece of toilet paper (the motion detection system looks like the same tech used for character animation for a start).

You just jogged my memory! I knew I'd see that someplace before!

640px-NES-Power-Glove.jpg
 
Im not sure exactly how people are calling apple patent trolls? They are a leader in a few industries and the only people they have sued HAVE come out with arguably similar products potentially violating patents that apple has implemented into products, and they have not sued any companies for violating patents they own, but have not produced anything from/with. (unless there's some other big case I've been missing.)

If they are being called patent trolls because of the Samsung cases, then I lol and :rolleyes:
 
Im not sure exactly how people are calling apple patent trolls? They are a leader in a few industries and the only people they have sued HAVE come out with arguably similar products potentially violating patents that apple has implemented into products, and they have not sued any companies for violating patents they own, but have not produced anything from/with. (unless there's some other big case I've been missing.)

If they are being called patent trolls because of the Samsung cases, then I lol and :rolleyes:

Matalim pretty much called them out on it already from this:

Apple bought the patent from someone else.

What he implies isn't overt trolling, but the potential to go there. Patent trolling is pretty much buying patents and then suing someone else over it. The first part, the buying, is already done. The second part is still something we don't know about yet until we see if Apple will take other companies to court over the patent or simply use it to protect something they're developing that isn't yet released to market.
 
Matalim pretty much called them out on it already from this:



What he implies isn't overt trolling, but the potential to go there. Patent trolling is pretty much buying patents and then suing someone else over it. The first part, the buying, is already done. The second part is still something we don't know about yet until we see if Apple will take other companies to court over the patent or simply use it to protect something they're developing that isn't yet released to market.

So exactly. There isn't any patent trolling here, they bought a patent, so what? I'd be right there by you if they started suing companies over patents they haven't implemented themselves because I think the patent system is screwed up, but that hasn't happened. So it's funny to see the senseless apple bashing because they bought a patent.

It's not like apple is hard up for cash and suing everyone they can like some other real patent trolls :p


I still want to know what figure 500 refers to in the posted illustration.
 
Im not sure exactly how people are calling apple patent trolls? They are a leader in a few industries and the only people they have sued HAVE come out with arguably similar products potentially violating patents that apple has implemented into products, and they have not sued any companies for violating patents they own, but have not produced anything from/with. (unless there's some other big case I've been missing.)

If they are being called patent trolls because of the Samsung cases, then I lol and :rolleyes:


I LOL'd at your whole post. It's patent trolling when you steal ("inovate" as apple calls it) an idea then patent it and sue other companies for using it. You also realize samsung is countersuing apple for patent infringment right as well right?
 
So exactly. There isn't any patent trolling here, they bought a patent, so what? I'd be right there by you if they started suing companies over patents they haven't implemented themselves because I think the patent system is screwed up, but that hasn't happened. So it's funny to see the senseless apple bashing because they bought a patent.

It's not like apple is hard up for cash and suing everyone they can like some other real patent trolls :p


I still want to know what figure 500 refers to in the posted illustration.

And I forgot to add: and when apple sues someone, Samsung namely, they want the offending product removed from the shelves, not a settlement, they aren't out to profit off of the patents, they are using them in the exact way they were intended, to protect their IP and prevent others from using it. Which is why again, it is laughable to me that people are calling them patent trolls for using the system as it was intended, not as another source of revenue through litigation.
 
I LOL'd at your whole post. It's patent trolling when you steal ("inovate" as apple calls it) an idea then patent it and sue other companies for using it. You also realize samsung is countersuing apple for patent infringment right as well right?

Damn I wish I saw this before posting my last reply so I have didn't have to add yet another post.

So are Samsung patent trolls for suing? And where exactly did they steal these ideas from and get patents on them? It sounds like you think the patent system should just be abolished and everyone can take everyone's ideas. I've also noticed the courts have sided with apple on some parts, and simply said that Samsung didn't infringe on other parts, I haven't heard anything about Samsung being very successful in their suits against apple, but maybe you can link me to something that says otherwise?

If apple truly did steal any ideas and patent them, then whoever they stole those ideas from should be able to prove it, and if they could, they would get a massive settlement, but so far I've only heard about Samsung, who sued in response to apples lawsuit.
 
Damn I wish I saw this before posting my last reply so I have didn't have to add yet another post.

So are Samsung patent trolls for suing? And where exactly did they steal these ideas from and get patents on them? It sounds like you think the patent system should just be abolished and everyone can take everyone's ideas. I've also noticed the courts have sided with apple on some parts, and simply said that Samsung didn't infringe on other parts, I haven't heard anything about Samsung being very successful in their suits against apple, but maybe you can link me to something that says otherwise?

If apple truly did steal any ideas and patent them, then whoever they stole those ideas from should be able to prove it, and if they could, they would get a massive settlement, but so far I've only heard about Samsung, who sued in response to apples lawsuit.

Well just off the top of my head, how about the slide unlock? Also, there is a very recent article about the current battle between samsung/apple and which patents each ones are infringing on etc, but I'm not gonna go search for it.

The patent office doesn't need to be removed, it needs to be fixed. They need to stop handing out all these patents to apple for vague/broad categories, and do some research. Not just rubber stamp it and collect a fee.
 
I was curious as to what the patent approval process is, at least for the US. One write up has:

The job of the individual that is assigned to your application will include a number of important tasks. One of those tasks is taking the time to fully examine and understand your patent request.
http://www.patentgenius.com/patentapproval.html

From the pic in this thread, how does any of that make sense esp with regards to item "500" - the Willy reference?
 
Damn I wish I saw this before posting my last reply so I have didn't have to add yet another post.

So are Samsung patent trolls for suing? And where exactly did they steal these ideas from and get patents on them? It sounds like you think the patent system should just be abolished and everyone can take everyone's ideas. I've also noticed the courts have sided with apple on some parts, and simply said that Samsung didn't infringe on other parts, I haven't heard anything about Samsung being very successful in their suits against apple, but maybe you can link me to something that says otherwise?

If apple truly did steal any ideas and patent them, then whoever they stole those ideas from should be able to prove it, and if they could, they would get a massive settlement, but so far I've only heard about Samsung, who sued in response to apples lawsuit.

I thought that we had done this one before. Anyway, here it is again, for the youngsters to learn from: -

A “patent troll” is normally a small organisation who is trying to extort money out of a large wealthy one.

Apple’s philosophy is to dominate the market by killing the competition. They use patents, or even a design copyright, in order to achieve this.
 
I hope this is a sick joke. Wtf is this shit. Apple has to be taken out in the future. First we behing with hipsters.
 
Back
Top